Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission
[2004] FCA 284

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 5(1)
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) ss 57, 115
Racial Discrimination Act 1976 (Cth)
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth)
Limitations Act 1985 (ACT) s 30

McKellar v Container Terminal Management Services Ltd (1999) 165 ALR 409; [1999] FCA 1101
Sanders v Snell (1998) 196 CLR 329
Northern Territory v Mengel (1995) 185 CLR 307
Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146
Leotta v Public Transport Commission (1976) 9 ALR 437
Hamilton v Nuroof (WA) Pty Ltd (1956) 96 CLR 18

COLIN GEORGE DUNSTAN v HUMAN RIGHTS AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION, HENRY PRICE, DONALD BARTLEY, JOHN GROWDER, GEOFFREY SEYMOUR & COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

AG 30 of 1997

MANSFIELD J
19 MARCH 2004
CANBERRA (HEARD IN ADELAIDE)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT  REGISTRY

AG 30 OF 1997

BETWEEN:

COLIN GEORGE DUNSTAN
APPLICANT

AND:

HUMAN RIGHTS AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

HENRY PRICE
SECOND RESPONDENT

DONALD BARTLEY
THIRD RESPONDENT

JOHN GROWDER
FOURTH RESPONDENT

GEOFFREY SEYMOUR
FIFTH RESPONDENT

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
SIXTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 MARCH 2004

WHERE MADE:

CANBERRA (HEARD IN ADELAIDE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The applicant by no later than 30 April 2004 file and serve a document which:

(1)in respect of the statement published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent in or about March 1994 –

(a)states whether the statement was oral or in writing, and

(i)if oral, identifies as best as can be done the occasion, the place and the parties present, including the name of the officer of the sixth respondent referred to, and

(ii)if in writing, identifies as best as can be done the document by date, author and addressee

(b)indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i)the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii)the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(2)in respect of the statement published by the third respondent to the second respondent on or about 28 November 1994 –

(a)states whether the statement was oral or in writing, and

(i)if oral, identifies as best as can be done the occasion, the place and the parties present, and

(ii)if in writing, identifies as best as can be done the document by date, author and addressee

(b)indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to the second respondent

(i)the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii)the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(3)in respect of the statement published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent on or about 27 February 1995 –

(a)states whether the statement was oral or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Dunstan v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission involves the applicant, a member of the Commonwealth Public Service, who alleges racial and sexual discrimination and sexual harassment in his employment between 1983 and 1993. The applicant has also made claims against Comcare, asserting disability discrimination in relation to the rejection of his claim for detriment. The applicant has sought relief under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 against the first respondent for the failure to investigate his complaint. The primary legal issues revolve around whether certain paragraphs of the applicant's statement of claim should be struck out for being irrelevant or insufficiently detailed to meet procedural fairness requirements.

The court determined that paragraphs 7-9 of the statement of claim, which were acknowledged as irrelevant to the ADJR claim, would be struck out. Furthermore, the court found that paragraphs 34-39 did not adequately detail the material facts necessary to establish the cause of action for misfeasance in public office. These paragraphs were also struck out to ensure procedural fairness to the respondents. The court emphasised that a statement of claim must contain a summary of material facts that, if proven, would support the cause of action.

The court ordered that the applicant must provide detailed particulars regarding various communications and submissions to meet the requirements of the Federal Court Rules. This includes specifying whether communications were oral or written, identifying the parties involved, and detailing the meanings conveyed. The court also denied leave to amend the amended statement of claim filed in 1999.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant by no later than 30 April 2004 file and serve a document which:

(1) in respect of the statement published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent in or about March 1994 –

(a) states whether the statement was oral or in writing, and

(i) if oral, identifies as best as can be done the occasion, the place and the parties present, including the name of the officer of the sixth respondent referred to, and

(ii) if in writing, identifies as best as can be done the document by date, author and addressee

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(2) in respect of the statement published by the third respondent to the second respondent on or about 28 November 1994 –

(a) states whether the statement was oral or in writing, and

(i) if oral, identifies as best as can be done the occasion, the place and the parties present, and

(ii) if in writing, identifies as best as can be done the document by date, author and addressee

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to the second respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(3) in respect of the statement published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent on or about 27 February 1995 –

(a) states whether the statement was oral or in writing, and

(i) if oral, identifies as best as can be done the occasion, the place and the parties present, including the name of the officer of the sixth respondent referred to,

(ii) if in writing, identify as best as can be done the document by date, author and addressee

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(4) in respect of the letter dated 18 September 1995 published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent –

(a) states

(i) the author of the letter,

(ii) when the letter was published to an officer of the sixth respondent,

(iii) the name or description of the status of the officer of the sixth respondent to whom it was published, and

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(5) in respect of the letter dated 4 January 1996 published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent

(a) states –

(i) the author of the letter,

(ii) when the letter was published to an officer of the sixth respondent,

(iii) the name or description of the status of the officer of the sixth respondent to whom it was published, and

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(6) in respect of the submission made on or about 23 January 1996 by the third respondent to the first respondent –

(a) states

(i) the author of the submission,

(ii) when the submission was published to the first respondent,

(iii) the name or description of the status of the officer of the first respondent to whom it was published, and

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to the first respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(7) in respect of the letters dated on or about 24 January 1996 published by the third respondent to the second respondent –

(a) states the author(s) of the letters,

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to the second respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(8) in respect of the submission made on or about 4 July 1996 by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent –

(a) states

(i) the author of the submission,

(ii) when the submission was published to an officer of the sixth respondent,

(iii) the name or description of the status of the officer of the sixth respondent to whom it was published, and

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(9) in respect of the letter dated 27 November 1996 published by the third respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent –

(a) states

(i) the author of the letter,

(ii) when the letter was published to an officer of the sixth respondent,

(iii) the name or description of the status of the officer of the sixth respondent to whom it was published, and

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(10) in respect of the minute dated 24 April 1996 published by the fourth respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent –

(a) states the author of the minute,

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words;

(11) in respect of the statement published by the fifth respondent to an officer of the sixth respondent on or about 9 September 1993 –

(a) states whether the statement was oral or in writing, and

(i) if oral, identifies as best as can be done the occasion, the place and the parties present, including the name of the officer of the sixth respondent referred to,

(ii) if in writing, identifies as best as can be done the document by date, author and addressee

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to an officer of the sixth respondent

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words

(12) in respect of the submission made on or about 18 January 1996 by the fifth respondent to the first respondent –

(a) states

(i) the author of the submission,

(ii) when the submission was made to the first respondent, and

(b) indicates separately in respect of each of the meanings which is alleged to have been conveyed to the fifth respondent,

(i) the words by reason of which the particular meaning is alleged to have been communicated, and

(ii) the meaning alleged to have been communicated by those words.

2. Leave to amend the amended statement of claim filed on 13 November 1998 in terms of the document called ‘amended statement of claim’ filed on 8 September 1999 is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

To address those issues, it is necessary to consider the terms of the statement of claim and the proposed statement of claim in a little detail. It is not necessary for present purposes to refer to the defences. The following represents a summary of the applicant’s allegations.(a) Background The applicant is a member of the Commonwealth Public Service (the Service). The third, fourth and fifth respondents were at material times also employed by the Service, and were the applicant’s superior officers. Each of the applicant and the third, fourth and fifth respondents were employed by the sixth respondent. From 1987 until February 1993, the applicant was employed as Assistant Director, Database Administration Subsection of the ATO.(b) The ADJR claim Paragraphs 6-33 of the statement of claim concern the application against the first respondent under the ADJR Act. On 6 November 1998, counsel for the applicant indicated that the applicant did not rely upon the facts alleged in pars 7, 8 and 9 of the statement of claim as they were irrelevant to the applicant’s claim against the first respondent. It is not necessary to refer in detail to the balance of pars 6-33 of the statement of claim. There is no present issue concerning them. It is, however, convenient briefly to describe their import and to note the foundation upon which the applicant claims relief. On 17 September 1993 the applicant lodged with the first respondent a complaint alleging racial and sexual discrimination and sexual harassment in his employment by the third, fifth and sixth respondents (called ‘the sex complaint’) in respect of conduct between 1983 and 1993. The statement of claim then describes certain steps undertaken by the first respondent in investigating the sex complaint. One feature of the allegations concerns a claim by the applicant against Comcare. It is asserted that in about April 1994, the applicant was advised by the first respondent to lodge an application to Comcare in respect of a detriment he had suffered by reason of the matters the subject of the sex complaint. He did so, but the claim was rejected in July 1994. He requested internal review. The internal review also resulted in rejection of the claim by Comcare in about June 1995. On about 1 January 1995 the applicant lodged with the first respondent an addendum to the sex complaint alleging disability discrimination (which he called ‘the disability complaint’) by Comcare against him arising out of Comcare’s rejection of the claim. In August 1995 the applicant lodged an appeal from Comcare’s rejection of his claim to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the AAT) in respect of his disability claim. The AAT dismissed the ‘appeal’ on 28 June 1996. On 25 November 1996, 4 December 1996 and 21 January 1997, the applicant requested the first respondent to refer his complaint for public inquiry. It did not do so. On 5 February 1997 the first respondent received from the sixth respondent a submission concerning the applicant’s complaint. The applicant claims that he was not informed of that submission prior to the decision of the first respondent. On 26 March 1997 an officer of the first respondent provided to the first respondent a report on investigations into the applicant’s complaint which is alleged to contain misleading and/or false information. The applicant was not informed of that report or its contents prior to the decision of the first respondent. Particulars are given purportedly of the misleading or false information. The first respondent then decided on 2 April 1997 not to continue to inquire into the sex complaint. Reference is made to that decision earlier in these reasons at [3].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

Paragraph 79 alleges loss and damage in general terms and without particularity.CONSIDERATION As a result of directions given from time to time since 4 August 2003, it is now appropriate to determine the interlocutory issues referred to in [25]-[27] above. The applicant and the respondents have had the opportunity to make submissions in writing in relation to each of them. In the course of giving directions, the applicant was given an opportunity to express any variations to the proposed statement of claim or to provide such further and better particulars as he considered necessary or desirable to meet the contentions of the respondents. The applicant has been granted extensions of time to express any variations to the proposed statement of claim, and to make his submissions. Most recently, on 11 February 2002, he was given leave to file and serve a reply submission by 5 March 2004. He did not do so. He sought a further (unspecified) time to do so. He has been informed that any submission received from him by way of reply by 17 March 2004 would be taken into account in addressing those matters. The other parties were provided with a copy of the communication to him. The applicant did not make a submission in reply by that time. On 17 March 2004 he submitted a further letter to the Court by way of explanation for his failure to have done so. I refer further to that letter at [81] of these reasons.(a) Should pars 7-9 and 34-39 of the statement of claim be struck out? As noted above, on 6 November 1998 counsel then appearing for the applicant accepted that pars 7-9 of the statement of claim were irrelevant to the claim under the ADJR Act, and were not relied upon. As they are acknowledged to be otiose, they will be struck out. The principles upon which a pleading, or part of a pleading, should be struck out under O 11 r 16 of the Federal Court Rules are clear enough. They are discussed at some length in McKellar v Container Terminal Management Services Ltd (1999) 165 ALR 409; [1999] FCA 1101 by Weinberg J at 415-417, [12]-[19]. I shall not repeat them, but I respectfully agree with and adopt his Honour’s reference to them and to the authorities he there refers to. In that case, Weinberg J at 417-421, [20]-[33] also discussed the requirements for pleadings in this Court. Again, I respectfully agree with and adopt his Honour’s reasons without repeating them. The respondents contend that pars 34-39 of the statement of claim should be struck out because they do not contain a properly detailed statement of material facts which, if proven, would give rise to the cause of action for misfeasance in public office. Order 11 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules requires a pleading to contain a statement in summary form of the material facts on which the party relies. To satisfy the requirements of the Rules the statement of claim should serve to notify the respondents of the case they have to meet and to define the issues for decision. The statement of claim thus should ensure procedural fairness to the respondents.