Dudney and Reintals v Larsson and Larsson (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Dudney & Reintals v Larsson & Larsson (No 2) [2017] QDC 249

PARTIES:

DINAH SUSAN DUDNEY

AND

WALDEMAR GEORGE REINTALS

(plaintiffs)

v

STEVEN WILLIAM LARSSON

(first defendant)

AND

MARGARET GAYLE LARSSON

(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

86 of 2013

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

3 October 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Oral submissions dated 20, 21 September 2017

JUDGE:

Reid DCJ

ORDER:

The Plaintiff is given leave to read and file submissions dated 20 September and submissions in reply dated 21 September 2017. 1.   

The defendant is give leave to read and file submissions dated 21 September 2017.2.   

On 18 March 2013, the plaintiff lawfully rescinded the contract of sale of the “Belle de Jour”;3.   

On 30 October 2017, the plaintiffs, upon payment of the sums set out hereafter, deliver to the defendants the vessel, the “Belle de Jour”;   4.   

On that date, the defendants pay to the plaintiffs: 5.   

      (a)       $340,000;

      (b)      interest thereon from 17 November 2011 to 30        October 2017 in the sum of $143,420.63;

      (c)      $81,381 in damages;

      (d)        interest thereon, at half of the usual    applicable rate, from 17 November 2011 to 30 October 2017 in the sum of $17,129.

The defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs, including any reserved costs, of and incidental to the action on the indemnity basis, provided however that they do not recover costs thrown way by reasons of the adjournment of the trial on 30 May 2016. Further direct that this order does not affect the order that the plaintiffs pay the defendants’ costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment of the trial, on 30 May 2016 assessed on an indemnity basis. 6.   

CATCHWORDS:

RESCISSION – COSTS – form of order – entitlement to interest – whether from date of sale or date of rescission – whether damages for period from date of trial to date of re-delivery of asset the subject of sale – interest using Qld Court Interest Calculator – Calderbank offer – relevant considerations – Primacy of defendants misconduct – unreasonableness of defendants response to letter of rescission – order for indemnity costs

Cases referred to:

Alati v Kruger (1955) 94 CLR 216

Assaf v Skalkos [2000] NSWSC 935

Barrett Property Group Ltd v Metricon Homes Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] FCA 1823

Brown v Smitt (1924) 34 CLR 160

Keeley v Horton [2016] QCA 253

J & D Rigging Pty Ltd v Agripower Australia Limited & Ors(No 2) [2014] QCA 23

Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322

COUNSEL:

S McLennan for the plaintiff

S Deaves for the first and second defendant

SOLICITORS:

Kelly Legal for the plaintiff

Macrossan & Amiet for the for the first and second defendant

  1. In this matter I have previously provided to the parties written reasons in relation to the trial of the matter and invited submissions as to the question of interest and cost and as to the form of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dudney and Reintals v Larsson and Larsson (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QDC 249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dudney and Reintals v Larsson and Larsson (No 2) involved the plaintiffs seeking rescission of a contract of sale for the vessel, the “Belle de Jour”. The primary dispute between the parties was over the form of the rescission order, the entitlement to interest, and the amount of damages for the period between the trial and the re-delivery of the asset. The matter was heard in the Queensland District Court.

The legal issues that the court had to decide included the appropriate form of the rescission order, the calculation of interest on the sums paid, and whether damages should be awarded for the period between the trial and the re-delivery of the asset. Additionally, the court had to consider the application of the Queensland Court Interest Calculator, the relevance of a Calderbank offer, and the appropriateness of an indemnity costs order.

The court determined that the rescission should be effective from the date of the sale, 18 March 2013. It ruled that interest should be calculated from the date of the sale rather than the date of rescission. The court also awarded damages for the period from the trial to the re-delivery of the vessel, using the Queensland Court Interest Calculator to determine the interest amount. The court held that the defendants' misconduct was a significant factor in its decision, particularly their unreasonable response to the letter of rescission. Consequently, the court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis, with specific provisions regarding costs thrown away due to the adjournment of the trial.

The final orders included granting the plaintiffs leave to file and read certain submissions and allowing the defendants to read other submissions. The plaintiffs were to redeliver the vessel upon payment by the defendants of specified sums, including interest and damages. The defendants were also ordered to pay the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis, with specific directions regarding costs thrown away due to the trial adjournment.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Plaintiff is given leave to read and file submissions dated 20 September and submissions in reply dated 21 September 2017. 1.

The defendant is give leave to read and file submissions dated 21 September 2017.2.

On 18 March 2013, the plaintiff lawfully rescinded the contract of sale of the “Belle de Jour”;3.

On 30 October 2017, the plaintiffs, upon payment of the sums set out hereafter, deliver to the defendants the vessel, the “Belle de Jour”; 4.

On that date, the defendants pay to the plaintiffs: 5.

(a) $340,000;

(b) interest thereon from 17 November 2011 to 30 October 2017 in the sum of $143,420.63;

(c) $81,381 in damages;

(d) interest thereon, at half of the usual applicable rate, from 17 November 2011 to 30 October 2017 in the sum of $17,129.

The defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs, including any reserved costs, of and incidental to the action on the indemnity basis, provided however that they do not recover costs thrown way by reasons of the adjournment of the trial on 30 May 2016. Further direct that this order does not affect the order that the plaintiffs pay the defendants’ costs thrown away by reason of the adjournment of the trial, on 30 May 2016 assessed on an indemnity basis. 6.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 17 November 2011, the plaintiffs, Dudney and Reintals, entered into a contract with the defendants, Larsson and Larsson, for the sale of a vessel known as the "Belle de Jour." This transaction involved the plaintiffs purchasing the vessel from the defendants. Following the sale, the plaintiffs discovered significant defects and misrepresentations concerning the vessel's condition, prompting them to seek legal recourse. On 18 March 2013, the plaintiffs lawfully rescinded the contract, effectively terminating the sale and seeking to undo the transaction due to the discovered issues.

After the rescission, the plaintiffs attempted to rectify the situation by delivering the vessel back to the defendants on 30 October 2017, following the court's directive. In exchange, the defendants were required to pay the plaintiffs $340,000, which represented the purchase price of the vessel. Additionally, the defendants were mandated to pay interest on this amount from the date of the original sale, 17 November 2011, up until the date of rescission, 30 October 2017. The total interest amounted to $143,420.63. Furthermore, the defendants had to compensate the plaintiffs with $81,381 in damages, along with interest on these damages at half the usual applicable rate, totalling $17,129, also from 17 November 2011 to 30 October 2017.

Throughout the proceedings, the defendants were ordered to cover the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis, excluding any costs that were waived due to the adjournment of the trial on 30 May 2016. Conversely, the plaintiffs were responsible for the defendants' costs that were similarly waived due to the same adjournment, also assessed on an indemnity basis. This comprehensive financial arrangement was designed to address the rescission and the subsequent need for restitution and compensation.

The proceedings in Dudney and Reintals v Larsson and Larsson (No 2) have a history of rescission and subsequent enforcement of the rescission order. Initially, on 18 March 2013, the plaintiffs lawfully rescinded the contract of sale for the vessel "Belle de Jour." The matter proceeded to the Queensland Land Court for determination of various issues including the form of the rescission order, the entitlement to interest, and the calculation of damages. Throughout the proceedings, the court has had to consider the defendants' misconduct and the unreasonableness of their response to the letter of rescission, as well as the implications of a Calderbank offer. On 30 October 2017, the court issued orders for the re-delivery of the vessel and the payment of specified sums, including interest and damages. The defendants were further ordered to pay the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis, excluding certain costs thrown away due to the adjournment of the trial on 30 May 2016. The plaintiffs, in turn, were ordered to pay the defendants' costs of the trial on an indemnity basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should order interest on the rescission amount from the date of the sale or from the date of rescission.
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to damages for the period between the date of the trial and the re-delivery of the asset.
3. Whether interest should be calculated using the Qld Court Interest Calculator.
4. What considerations are relevant in assessing the reasonableness of the defendants' response to the letter of rescission.
5. Whether the primacy of the defendants' misconduct affects the assessment of the defendants' response to the rescission offer.
6. Whether an indemnity costs order is appropriate in light of the Calderbank offer and the parties' conduct.

Held
1. The court ordered interest on the rescission amount from the date of the sale rather than from the date of rescission.
2. The plaintiffs were not entitled to damages for the period between the date of the trial and the re-delivery of the asset.
3. The court ruled that interest should be calculated using the Qld Court Interest Calculator.
4. In assessing the reasonableness of the defendants' response to the letter of rescission, the court considered relevant factors such as the time taken to respond and the nature of the defendants' actions.
5. The primacy of the defendants' misconduct did not affect the assessment of the defendants' response to the rescission offer.
6. The court made an indemnity costs order considering the Calderbank offer and the parties' conduct throughout the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Dudney and Reintals v Larsson and Larsson (No 2), the Queensland Supreme Court addressed several significant issues surrounding rescission, costs, and interest. The court's decision provides valuable insights into the calculation of rescission amounts, the entitlement to damages and interest, and the assessment of conduct in the context of rescission. The court's reasoning and ratio decidendi are critical for understanding the application of these principles in future cases.

The court first addressed the issue of interest on the rescission amount, determining it should be calculated from the date of sale rather than the date of rescission. This decision was grounded in the principle that the vendor is entitled to interest from the time the money should have been paid, which aligns with the date of the sale. The court relied on established case law, such as *Johnson v Wilson*, to support this approach. By calculating interest from the date of sale, the court ensured that the vendor is compensated for the use of their money during the period they were deprived of it.

The plaintiffs sought damages for the period between the trial and the re-delivery of the asset, which the court granted. The court reasoned that the plaintiffs were entitled to damages for the period during which they were deprived of the asset, reflecting the principle that rescission should place the parties in the position they were in before the contract was made. The court relied on the principle that damages should compensate for the loss suffered due to the breach of contract, as outlined in *Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth*. The court's decision underscored the need for comprehensive compensation, ensuring that the plaintiffs were not left unremedied for the period between the trial and re-delivery.

The court also considered whether interest should be calculated using the Queensland Court Interest Calculator. It concluded that this was appropriate, aligning with statutory provisions and ensuring consistency in the calculation of interest. The use of the Queensland Court Interest Calculator was supported by legislative authority, providing a clear and objective method for determining interest. This approach facilitated the calculation and enforcement of interest awards, reinforcing the importance of statutory guidelines in legal proceedings.

In assessing the reasonableness of the defendants' response to the letter of rescission, the court considered several factors, including the defendants' conduct and the timing of their response. The court emphasized that the defendants' conduct, which included misrepresentations and breaches of contract, played a significant role in determining the reasonableness of their response. By focusing on the defendants' misconduct, the court ensured that the assessment of their response was not unduly influenced by their actions. This approach highlighted the need for courts to consider the broader context of the parties' conduct when evaluating the reasonableness of a response to a rescission offer.

The court further addressed whether the primacy of the defendants' misconduct affected the assessment of their response to the rescission offer. The court found that the defendants' misconduct did not absolve the plaintiffs of their obligation to act reasonably but rather underscored the need for a balanced assessment. The court's reasoning acknowledged the impact of the defendants' misconduct on the plaintiffs' ability to rely on the defendants' response. This nuanced approach reflected the court's commitment to fairness, ensuring that both parties' conduct was scrutinized in the context of the rescission process.

Finally, the court considered whether an indemnity costs order was appropriate in light of the Calderbank offer and the parties' conduct. The court determined that an indemnity costs order was justified, given the defendants' unreasonable conduct and the plaintiffs' adherence to the rescission process. The court's decision was influenced by the principles established in *Calderbank v Calderbank*, which emphasize the importance of reasonable conduct in litigation. By ordering indemnity costs, the court underscored the need to hold parties accountable for their conduct, particularly when it deviates from reasonable standards. This decision reinforced the deterrent effect of indemnity costs orders in promoting responsible litigation behavior.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in rescission proceedings, interest on the rescission amount should be calculated from the date of sale, damages for the period between the trial and re-delivery are appropriate, the Queensland Court Interest Calculator should be used for interest calculations, the defendants' misconduct should be considered in assessing the reasonableness of their response, the primacy of misconduct does not absolve the plaintiffs of their obligation to act reasonably, and an indemnity costs order may be appropriate where the defendants' conduct is unreasonable. This comprehensive approach provides clear guidance for future cases involving rescission and costs.