JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CIVIL
CITATION: DUCKWORTH -v- WATER CORPORATION [No 2] [2015] WASC 411
CORAM: MITCHELL J
HEARD: 15 OCTOBER 2015
DELIVERED : 5 NOVEMBER 2015
FILE NO/S: CIV 1795 of 2013
BETWEEN: KARL JAMES DUCKWORTH
RACHEL ALICE DUCKWORTH
ANDREW DANIEL DUCKWORTH
CLARE LEONORA DUCKWORTH
PlaintiffsAND
WATER CORPORATION
Defendant
Catchwords:
Contract - Trusts - Whether contract entered into as trustee or in personal capacity - Trustee's subsequent bankruptcy - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Trustees Act 1962 (WA), s 10
Result:
Preliminary questions determined
Contracts entered into as trustee
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiffs: Mr J M Healy
Defendant: Mr M C Goldblatt
Solicitors:
Plaintiffs: Nova Legal
Defendant: Lavan Legal
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Bechara v Sotrip Pty Limited [2011] NSWSC 252
Birla Nifty Pty Ltd v International Mining Industry Underwriters Ltd [2014] WASCA 180; (2014) 47 WAR 522
Duckworth v Water Corporation [2012] WASC 30
Duckworth v Water Corporation [No 2] [2012] WASC 163
Gebauer Nominees Pty Ltd v Cole [No 2] [2008] WASCA 41
Octavo Investments Pty Ltd v Knight (1979) 144 CLR 360
Re Interwest Hotels Pty Ltd (In Liq) (1993) 12 ACSR 78
MITCHELL J:
Summary
In these proceedings, the plaintiffs seek relief in relation to the drawdown by the Water Corporation of a $3 million Banker's Undertaking. The undertaking secured the performance of obligations of Neil Duckworth under agreements for the construction of water headworks for a subdivisional development. The headworks have never been constructed, and the plaintiffs claim to be entitled to enforce a contractual provision for repayment as assignees of Mr Duckworth's trustee in bankruptcy.
The Water Corporation challenges the plaintiffs' standing to enforce any rights which Mr Duckworth had under the agreements. First, it says that the rights were held by Mr Duckworth as trustee, and so never vested in Mr Duckworth's trustee in bankruptcy so as to be available for assignment by the trustee in bankruptcy. Secondly, the Water Corporation says that, even if the rights were held by Mr Duckworth in his personal capacity, they could not be assigned by the trustee in Bankruptcy without the Water Corporation's consent, which was never obtained.
I ordered that these questions relating to the plaintiffs' standing to enforce the alleged rights be tried as preliminary issues.
I have concluded that, at the time of his bankruptcy, Neil Duckworth held the claimed rights under the agreements on trust. Those rights did not vest in, and so could not have been assigned to the plaintiffs by, Mr Duckworth's trustee in bankruptcy.
My reasons for that conclusion follow.
Facts
There was no dispute as to the primary facts in these proceedings, which were recited in a statement of agreed facts filed by the parties. The following summarises the effect of the agreed statement and attached documents.
Parties
The plaintiffs are the children of Neil James Duckworth and the beneficiaries under the Ocean Farms Trust which Neil Duckworth established. The defendant is a corporation established by the Water…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Duckworth v Water Corporation [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] WASC 411
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the court were whether Duckworth acted as a trustee when he entered into the contract with the Water Corporation and, if so, whether the rights under the contract could be assigned by his trustee in bankruptcy. Additionally, the court needed to determine the validity of the assignment of Duckworth's rights to the plaintiffs and the extent to which the Water Corporation was liable to account for the use of funds drawn under a Banker's Undertaking.
The court held that the determination of whether Duckworth was acting as a trustee or in his personal capacity turned on the specific facts of the case and was not resolved. However, the court did address the implications of the Assignment Deed and the non-assignment clause in the Guarantee. The court found that if Duckworth was acting as a trustee, the rights could not vest in his trustee in bankruptcy and thus could not be assigned. The court also held that the non-assignment clause in the Guarantee precluded the assignment of Duckworth's rights to the plaintiffs. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' claims and ordered Duckworth to pay the Water Corporation's costs.
The court's final orders were that the plaintiffs' claims be dismissed and that Duckworth pay the Water Corporation's costs of the action. The court did not need to resolve the specific question of whether Duckworth was acting as a trustee, as the outcome regarding the assignment and non-assignment clauses was dispositive.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On 18 May 2012, Edelman J refused an application by Mr Duckworth to reinstate the First Proceedings, and ordered Mr Duckworth to pay the Water Corporation's costs of the action.[2][2] Duckworth v Water Corporation [No 2] [2012] WASC 163. In making his decisions Edelman J noted, but did not need to resolve, a dispute between Neil Duckworth and the Water Corporation as to whether Mr Duckworth was in fact acting as a trustee. Neil Duckworth ceased to be bankrupt on 19 October 2012, when his bankruptcy administration was annulled. On 16 May 2013, the plaintiffs commenced these proceedings by writ. The writ was indorsed with a statement of claim[3] which pleaded that the plaintiffs were assigned all of the causes of action that Neil Duckworth's trustee in bankruptcy held against the Water Corporation. [3] At the hearing on 15 October 2015, I ordered that a minute of proposed amended statement of claim dated 5 March 2015 stand as the statement of claim. The amendments clarified the circumstances in which the Assignment Deed was entered into and do not materially affect what follows. The plaintiffs plead the express term of the CCWA that the unused portion of the Financial Security would be returned to Neil Duckworth. There is also pleaded an implied term in the CCWA and the Bond Agreement that the Water Corporation would commence and complete construction of the Works within a reasonable time, in the circumstances not being more than two years from the drawdown of the Financial Security. It is pleaded that:The defendant is obliged to account to the plaintiffs with respect to how the $3,000,000 Banker's Undertaking drawn down by the defendant has been used to complete the works described in the CCWA and Bond Agreement.The plaintiffs ask that the defendant account, and that an inquiry be undertaken in respect thereto. The plaintiffs then sought in the prayer for relief:An account for all monies received by the defendant upon drawn down of the $3,000,000 Banker's Undertaking.An inquiry into how and to what extent the defendant has used the $3,000,000 drawn down under the Banker's Undertaking to complete the works described in the CCWA and the Bond Agreement.An order that the defendant is liable and a declaration and order that the defendant make payment to the plaintiffs of any sum found to be due and payable to the plaintiffs upon taking such an account and inquiry. It appeared that the plaintiffs' claimed right to relief was based on rights held by Neil Duckworth against the Water Corporation being assigned to them by the Assignment Deed. However, it is common ground that, if the rights were held by Neil Duckworth as trustee, they did not vest in, and so could not have been assigned by, the trustee in bankruptcy. The Water Corporation also asserted that, even if the rights were held by Neil Duckworth in his personal capacity, they could not have been assigned to the plaintiffs by reason of the non-assignment clause in the Guarantee. I considered it appropriate to try the question of whether Neil Duckworth held the rights under the CCWA and the Bond Agreement as trustee for the Ocean Farms Trust or only in his personal capacity, and the effect of the Assignment Deed, as preliminary issues in the proceedings.