Duarte v IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Duarte v IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd [2024] NSWPIC 723
APPLICANT: Charmaine Duarte
RESPONDENT: IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd
MEMBER: Jill Toohey
DATE OF DECISION: 31 December 2024
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for reasonably necessary treatment expenses for the applicant’s left shoulder; applicant suffered serious fracture to her left ankle in a fall on 5 April 2022; whether she also injured her left shoulder in that fall and/or in a consequential fall on 28 April 2022; absence of any contemporaneous evidence of injury to the left shoulder; no evidence in hospital records over several weeks or in treating doctor’s records; first evidence of injury appeared in worker’s Doctor’s report in March 2024; Held – award for the respondent.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     Award for the respondent in the claim for reasonably necessary treatment expenses as a result of injury to the applicant’s left shoulder on 5 April 2022 and/or 28 April 2022.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant, Charmaine Duarte, was working from home on 5 April 2022, the day after she had had a COVID-19 vaccination. She became unwell and fell, fracturing her left ankle. She was taken by ambulance to St Vincent's Hospital where she underwent surgery.

  2. Ms Duarte underwent further surgery on 11 April 2022 when metal plates and screws were inserted into her left ankle. She remained in hospital until 4 May 2022 when she was moved to Elizabeth Bay Lodge for respite care. She was there until 3 June 2022 when she was transferred to another hospital for rehabilitation. She was discharged to home in August 2022.

  3. The respondent, IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd, accepted liability for injury to Ms Duarte’s left ankle.

  4. On 28 April 2022, while still in St Vincent's Hospital, Ms Duarte fell off the knee scooter that she was using for rehabilitation and on to her left side. She claims compensation for the cost of treatment for her left shoulder which she says she injured in the fall.

  5. The respondent disputes Ms Duarte’s claim that she injured her left shoulder in the fall on 28 April 2022.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  1. When these proceedings commenced, Ms Duarte claimed compensation for a consequential condition in her right hip as a result of the fall at home on 5 April 2022. She discontinued that claim at the conciliation conference and arbitration hearing on 18 November 2024.

  2. The parties agree that the issue remaining in dispute is whether Ms Duarte suffered injury to her left shoulder in the fall from the knee scooter on 28 April 2022 and whether she is entitled to the cost of medical treatment for that injury.

PROCEDURE BEFORE THE PERSONAL INJURY COMMISSION

  1. The parties attended a conciliation conference and arbitration hearing on 18 November 2024. Ms Duarte was represented by Mr Necovski of counsel, instructed by Mr O’Malley. The respondent was represented by Mr Stiles of counsel, instructed by Ms Prichard. They were unable to reach agreement and the matter proceeded…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Duarte v IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 723
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Duarte v IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd, the applicant, Duarte, sought compensation for treatment expenses relating to her left shoulder. Duarte suffered a significant fracture to her left ankle following a fall on 5 April 2022. The dispute centred on whether she also injured her left shoulder during this initial fall or in a subsequent fall on 28 April 2022, and if such an injury was compensable under workers' compensation. The matter was heard and determined by the relevant tribunal, which was tasked with assessing the evidence and determining the validity of Duarte's claim for reasonably necessary treatment expenses.

The central legal issue before the tribunal was the causation and timing of any injury to Duarte's left shoulder, and whether this injury arose out of or in the course of her employment. The tribunal needed to consider the absence of any contemporaneous evidence of shoulder injury, the lack of mention in hospital records and treating doctor's notes, and the timing of the first reference to the shoulder injury in Duarte's Doctor’s report in March 2024. This timeline raised questions about the credibility and reliability of Duarte's claim.

The tribunal concluded that there was no credible evidence to support the assertion that Duarte's left shoulder injury occurred during the falls in April 2022 or that it arose from her employment. The absence of any contemporaneous documentation or evidence, combined with the delayed appearance of the injury in Duarte's Doctor’s report, led the tribunal to find that the applicant had not discharged the onus of proving her claim. The tribunal thus awarded the claim in favour of the respondent, IOOF Service Co Pty Ltd, rejecting Duarte's claim for compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established