DTS Succession Pty Ltd v Survco Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

DTS Succession Pty Ltd v Survco Pty Ltd [2021] QSC 283

PARTIES:

DTS SUCCESSION PTY LTD ACN 614 803 235
(and others)

(applicants)

v

SURVCO PTY LTD ACN 119 449 008

(first respondent)

AND

MMJ DEVELOPMENT CONSULTING PTY LTD

ACN 119 564 073

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

8993 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Civil

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

4 November 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 November 2021

JUDGE:

Freeburn J

ORDERS:

1.   A declaration that the valuation of Brian McDonald of Pilot Partners dated 26 May 2021 was prepared in accordance with clause 4 of the Deed of Separation and Release dated 1 March 2021 (the deed);

2.   An order that the deed ought to be specifically performed and carried into execution;

3.   The parties be heard on the form of the orders and on costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACT – VALUATION – FINAL AND BINDING – HONESTY AND IMPARTIALITY OF PROCEDURE – Where parties resolved their dispute through a mechanism whereby the applicants bought the respondents’ shares in the company – Where the compromise was recorded in a Deed of Separation and Release – Where Deed set out how valuation of the shares was to be undertaken – Where Deed appointed a valuer - Whether there is an error in the discretionary judgement of the valuer – Whether the valuation was carried out honestly and impartially. 

COUNSEL:

Mr L Copley
(Applicants)

Mr G Sheahan

(Respondent)

SOLICITORS:

Talbot Sayer
(Applicants)

ESJ Law
(Respondent)

REASONS

Introduction/Background

  1. The applicants and the respondents are shareholders in a group of companies that operate a surveying, town planning and urban design business in Brisbane.

  2. The parties fell into dispute.  They agreed to resolve their dispute through a mechanism that involved the applicants, who are the continuing shareholders, buying out the outgoing shareholders – the respondents.  The compromise agreement they reached is documented in a Deed of Separation and Release (the ‘deed’).

  3. That deed provided that the purchase price for the shares was to be the value of the shares as determined in accordance with clause 4.  Clause 4 comprises what is commonly described as an expert determination clause.  The parties agreed that, within two business days of the execution of the deed, they would appoint Brian McDonald of Pilot Partners as the valuer to value the shares.

  4. Mr McDonald completed the valuation on 26 May 2021 and assessed the shares as having a value of $125.32 each.  The respondents have refused to complete the sale of the shares at that price in accordance with the deed.  The applicants seek specific performance, that is to compel the respondents, the outgoing shareholders, to transfer their shares at the price determined by Mr McDonald.

  5. The substantive issues in this case turn on two propositions advanced by the respondent which I will summarise and then deal with in more detail.  The first broad proposition is that Mr McDonald’s valuation does not qualify as a valuation under clause 4.3 of the deed.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DTS Succession Pty Ltd v Survco Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 283
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DTS Succession Pty Ltd brought an action against Survco Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Victoria seeking a declaration that the valuation of the respondent’s shares in the company was correctly carried out. The parties had settled their dispute through a mechanism whereby the applicants bought the respondents’ shares in the company, which was recorded in a Deed of Separation and Release. The deed set out how the valuation of the shares was to be undertaken, including appointing a valuer. The respondents argued that the valuation was incorrect, and the court should set it aside. The applicants argued that the deed provided that the valuation was to be final and binding on the parties and the respondents were bound by the valuer’s decision.

The court was required to determine whether the valuation complied with the terms of the contract and if it was made honestly and impartially. The court held that a valuation obtained by fraud or collusion could be disregarded, and it is easy to imply a term that a valuation must be made honestly and impartially. However, it is difficult to imply a term that a valuation can be set aside on the ground of the valuer’s mistake or because the valuation is unreasonable. The critical question is whether the valuation complies with the terms of the contract. The court found that the valuation complied with the terms of the contract, and the applicants were entitled to the declarations sought.

The Supreme Court of Victoria declared that the valuation of Brian McDonald of Pilot Partners dated 26 May 2021 was prepared in accordance with clause 4 of the Deed of Separation and Release dated 1 March 2021. The court ordered that the deed ought to be specifically performed and carried into execution. The parties were to be heard on the form of the orders and on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. A declaration that the valuation of Brian McDonald of Pilot Partners dated 26 May 2021 was prepared in accordance with clause 4 of the Deed of Separation and Release dated 1 March 2021 (the deed);

2. An order that the deed ought to be specifically performed and carried into execution;

3. The parties be heard on the form of the orders and on costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The words ‘conclusive and binding’ in the deed here are similar to the words ‘final and binding’ used in a number of cases. The frequent starting point for cases discussing the extent to which such an expert determination can be challenged is the reasons of McHugh JA in Legal and General Life of Australia Ltd v A Hudson Pty Ltd:[4]In my opinion the question whether a valuation is binding upon the parties depends in the first instance upon the terms of the contract, express or implied. This was pointed out by Sir David Cairns in the Court of Appeal in Baber v Kenwood Manufacturing Co Ltd (at 181). A valuation obtained by fraud or collusion can usually be disregarded even in an action at law. For in a case of fraud or collusion the correct conclusion to be drawn will almost certainly be that there has been no valuation in accordance with the terms of the contract. As Sir David Cairns pointed out, it is easy to imply a term that a valuation must be made honestly and impartially. It will be difficult, and usually impossible, however, to imply a term that a valuation can be set aside on the ground of the valuer's mistake or because the valuation is unreasonable. The terms of the contract usually provide, as the lease in the present case does, that the decision of the valuer is ‘final and binding on the parties’. By referring the decision to a valuer, the parties agree to accept his honest and impartial decision as to the appropriate amount of the valuation. They rely on his skill and judgment and agree to be bound by his decision. It is now settled that an action for damages for negligence will lie against a valuer to whom the parties have referred the question of valuation if one of them suffers loss as the result of his negligent valuation: Sutcliffe v Thackrah [1974] AC 727; Arenson v Arenson [1977] AC 405. But as between the parties to the main agreement the valuation can stand even though it was made negligently. While mistake or error on the part of the valuer is not by itself sufficient to invalidate the decision or the certificate of valuation, nevertheless, the mistake may be of a kind which shows that the valuation is not in accordance with the contract. A mistake concerning the identity of the premises to be valued could seldom, if ever, comply with the terms of the agreement between the parties. But a valuation which is the result of the mistaken application of the principles of valuation may still be made in accordance with the terms of the agreement. In each case the critical question must always be: Was the valuation made in accordance with the terms of a contract? If it is, it is nothing to the point that the valuation may have proceeded on the basis of error or that it constitutes a gross over or under value. Nor is it relevant that the valuer has taken into consideration matters which he should not have taken into account or has failed to take into account matters which he should have taken into account. The question is not whether there is an error in the discretionary judgment of the valuer. It is whether the valuation complies with the terms of the contract. [emphasis added][4](1985) 1 NSWLR 314 at 335.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.