Drive My Car Rentals Pty Ltd v Gabriel

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Drive My Car Rentals Pty Ltd v Gabriel [2021] NSWCA 73
Hearing dates: 23 February 2021
Date of orders: 29 April 2021
Decision date: 29 April 2021
Before: Macfarlan JA at [1]
Meagher JA at [2]
Gleeson JA at [3]
Decision:

2020/105960

(1)   Grant leave to appeal in relation to ground 1 of the draft amended notice of appeal contained in Tab 2 of the combined White Folder.

(2)   Direct the applicant to file the draft amended notice of appeal within 7 days.

(3)   Appeal allowed.

(4)   Set aside:

(a)   orders 1 and 2 made by Adamson J on 11 March 2020;

(b)   orders 1 to 5 made by Adamson J on 9 September 2020.

(5)   In lieu, make the following orders on the appeal from the Local Court to the Supreme Court:

(a)   grant leave to appeal in relation to ground 2 only of the amended summons filed 3 October 2017;

(b)   set aside order 4 made by Atkinson LCM in the Local Court on 11 August 2017, and make no order as to costs as between DMC and Joseph Gabriel;

(c)   order DMC to pay Joseph Gabriel’s costs of the following applications in the Supreme Court:

(i)   DMC’s application heard on 20 March 2018 and dismissed on 1 November 2018: Gabriel v Grech [2018] NSWSC 1652;

(ii) DMC’s application heard on 14 August 2019 and dismissed on 11 September 2019: Gabriel v Grech [2019] NSWSC 1163; and

(iii) DMC’s application for disqualification of Adamson J dealt with on the papers and dismissed on 11 June 2019: Gabriel v Grech (No 4) [2020] NSWSC 726;

(d)   otherwise there be no order for costs of the Supreme Court proceedings.

(6)   Joseph Gabriel to pay DMC’s costs of the appeal to this Court up to and including the hearing on 23 February 2021.

(7)   No order as to the costs in this Court after 23 February 2021.

2020/344453

(8)   Summons seeking leave to appeal filed 4 December 2020 dismissed with no order as to costs.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – third party proceedings – motor vehicle collision – where plaintiff’s son driving vehicle at time of collision – where defendant driving a rental car – where defendant cross-claimed against rental car company seeking indemnity – where admission by defendant on the pleadings that plaintiff owned the vehicle – where third party contested plaintiff’s ownership on the cross-claim – whether ownership issue foreclosed by defendant’s admission on the pleadings – whether the parties were bound by issue estoppels arising from the judgment in the proceedings – Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 22

APPEALS – finding of fact – where Magistrate found that plaintiff’s son owned the vehicle – where ownership finding informed by Magistrate’s assessment of the credibility and reliability of the plaintiff and his son – whether Magistrate’s decision was glaringly improbable or contrary to compelling inferences – where small amount in issue – whether leave to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Drive My Car Rentals Pty Ltd v Gabriel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWCA 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a motor vehicle collision where the defendant, driving a rental car, cross-claimed against the rental car company (the third party) seeking indemnity. The plaintiff’s son was driving the vehicle involved in the collision. The defendant had admitted on the pleadings that the plaintiff owned the vehicle, but the third party contested this ownership in the cross-claim. The central dispute before the Court of Appeal was whether the defendant's admission on the pleadings foreclosed the issue of ownership and whether issue estoppel applied. The appeal also concerned the Magistrate's finding of fact regarding the vehicle's ownership, which was based on an assessment of witness credibility, and whether this finding was so improbable as to warrant appellate intervention.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the Magistrate's finding of ownership was demonstrably wrong, considering the principles for interfering with findings of fact. Furthermore, the court had to consider the costs orders made by the Magistrate, particularly the order that the plaintiff pay 50% of the third party's costs, given that the Magistrate had implicitly found that half of the lengthy Local Court hearing related to allegations of fraud which were not established. The court also had to address the costs of the appeals to the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal, considering the mixed outcomes and the timing of concessions made by parties.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside certain orders made by the Supreme Court and the Local Court. The court granted leave to appeal in relation to a specific ground concerning the Magistrate's costs order. In lieu of the set-aside orders, the court made no order as to costs as between the third party and the defendant in the Local Court proceedings. The court also made specific orders regarding the costs of various applications in the Supreme Court, with the third party ordered to pay the defendant's costs of certain dismissed applications. The court ordered the defendant to pay the third party's costs of the appeal to the Court of Appeal up to a specific hearing date, with no order as to costs thereafter. A separate summons seeking leave to appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

2020/105960

(1) Grant leave to appeal in relation to ground 1 of the draft amended notice of appeal contained in Tab 2 of the combined White Folder.

(2) Direct the applicant to file the draft amended notice of appeal within 7 days.

(3) Appeal allowed.

(4) Set aside:

(a) orders 1 and 2 made by Adamson J on 11 March 2020;

(b) orders 1 to 5 made by Adamson J on 9 September 2020.

(5) In lieu, make the following orders on the appeal from the Local Court to the Supreme Court:

(a) grant leave to appeal in relation to ground 2 only of the amended summons filed 3 October 2017;

(b) set aside order 4 made by Atkinson LCM in the Local Court on 11 August 2017, and make no order as to costs as between DMC and Joseph Gabriel;

(c) order DMC to pay Joseph Gabriel’s costs of the following applications in the Supreme Court:

(i) DMC’s application heard on 20 March 2018 and dismissed on 1 November 2018: Gabriel v Grech [2018] NSWSC 1652;

(ii) DMC’s application heard on 14 August 2019 and dismissed on 11 September 2019: Gabriel v Grech [2019] NSWSC 1163; and

(iii) DMC’s application for disqualification of Adamson J dealt with on the papers and dismissed on 11 June 2019: Gabriel v Grech (No 4) [2020] NSWSC 726;

(d) otherwise there be no order for costs of the Supreme Court proceedings.

(6) Joseph Gabriel to pay DMC’s costs of the appeal to this Court up to and including the hearing on 23 February 2021.

(7) No order as to the costs in this Court after 23 February 2021.

2020/344453

(8) Summons seeking leave to appeal filed 4 December 2020 dismissed with no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.