Draper v Body Corporate for Winchcombe Place CTS 15441

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Draper v Body Corporate for Winchcombe Place CTS 15441 & Ors  [2025] QCATA 66

PARTIES:

KATHRYN DRAPER

(appellant)

v

BODY CORPORATE FOR WINCHCOMBE PLACE CTS 15441

(RESPONDENT)

SUSAN COLLARO

(RESPONDENT)

STEVEN WEEKS

(RESPONDENT)

LEX MCQUEEN

(RESPONDENT)

WENDY MCQUEEN

(RESPONDENT)

PENNY HALL

(RESPONDENT)

LAUREN BARNABY

(RESPONDENT)

GREGORY SOUSTER

(RESPONDENT)

JOANNE SOUSTER

(RESPONDENT)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL112-23

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:


[2023] QBCCCmr 139

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

26 June 2025

HEARING DATE:

23 January 2025

Further submissions filed 14 May 2025

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Richard Oliver

ORDERS:

1.     The name of the respondent body corporate be amended to Body Corporate for Winchcombe Place CTS 15441.

2.     The adjudication decision dated 29 March 2023 is set aside.

3.     It is declared that Motion 2 is deemed to have passed without dissent.

4.     The parties are to file an agreed draft order to  include consequential orders as necessary to give effect to these reasons by 4:00pm on 18 July 2025.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – STRATA AND RELATED TITLES – MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL – BODY CORPORATE: POWERS, DUTIES AND LIABILITIES – EXCLUSIVE USE – DISPOSITION OF COMMON PROPERTY – RESOLUTION WITHOUT DISSENT – OBJECTION TO RESOLUTION – OBJECTION MUST BE REASONABLE – where appellant is the owner of Lot 4 in the Scheme which is a ground floor unit – where Lot 4 has exclusive use of part of the ground floor terraced area adjacent and contiguous to Lot 4 – where renovation work carried out to Lot 4 and on the exclusive use area without the approval of the Body Corporate – where by resolution the Body Corporate retrospectively approved the renovation work to Lot 4 but not to the exclusive use area – where the appellant sought by Motion 2 at an extraordinary general meeting to amalgamate part of the exclusive use area into Lot 4 – where a Motion for the disposition of common property by a lot owner required to be passed without dissent – where Motion failed to pass without dissent – where appellant sought an adjudication on the grounds that the objections of the dissenting votes were unreasonable – where adjudicator held the objections to Motion 2 were reasonable and the Motion failed to pass  – whether the grounds for objection to Motion 2 were reasonable in the circumstances – whether grounds for objection were relevant to and related to the disposition of the exclusive use area.

Body Corporate and Community Management Act1997 (Qld), s 3, s 4, s 94, s 271, s 272, s 289

Ainsworth v Albrecht (Viridian Residences, Noosa) (2016) 261 CLR 167

Allen v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2024] QCA 24
Body Corporate for Viridian; Kjerulf Ainsworth & Ors v Martin Albrecht & Anor [2014] QCATA 294

Pivovarova v Michelsen [2019] QCA 256

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Appellant:

Mr Strangman of counsel instructed by Grace Lawyers

Respondents: Mr Walker of counsel instructed by LawSolve

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The appellant is the registered owner of Lot…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Draper v Body Corporate for Winchcombe Place CTS 15441 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCATA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal, Draper v Body Corporate for Winchcombe Place CTS 15441, involves a dispute over the renovation of Lot 4 and part of the exclusive use area, a ground floor terraced space adjacent to Lot 4. The appellant, the owner of Lot 4, undertook renovations without obtaining the necessary approvals from the Body Corporate. These renovations included remodelling the kitchen and living area, which involved removing part of the exclusive use area and amalgamating it into the living space of Lot 4. Despite retrospective approval for the works carried out on Lot 4, the Body Corporate did not approve the changes to the exclusive use area. The appellant subsequently sought to amalgamate part of the exclusive use area into Lot 4 through a resolution passed at an extraordinary general meeting. This resolution, however, failed to pass without dissent.

The legal issues before the court were whether the objections to the resolution were reasonable and whether the grounds for the objections were relevant to and related to the disposition of the exclusive use area. The court had to determine if the objections were reasonable, considering the facts and circumstances of the case, and if the grounds for objection were relevant to the disposition of the exclusive use area.

The court found that the grounds for objection were reasonable as they were based on the failure of the appellant to obtain the necessary approvals and agreements for the works carried out on the exclusive use area. The court held that the objections were reasonable and related to the disposition of the exclusive use area. Consequently, the adjudication decision that the objections were reasonable was set aside, and it was declared that the resolution to amalgamate the disputed area into Lot 4 was deemed to have passed without dissent. The parties were required to file an agreed draft order to include necessary consequential orders by a specified date.

The court's decision highlights the importance of obtaining necessary approvals and agreements before undertaking renovations on common property, even if it is designated for exclusive use by a particular lot owner. The court's ruling ensures that the rights of all lot owners in a strata scheme are protected and that any changes to common property must be properly approved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The name of the respondent body corporate be amended to Body Corporate for Winchcombe Place CTS 15441.

2. The adjudication decision dated 29 March 2023 is set aside.

3. It is declared that Motion 2 is deemed to have passed without dissent.

4. The parties are to file an agreed draft order to include consequential orders as necessary to give effect to these reasons by 4:00pm on 18 July 2025.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a useful guide to assist in considering whether the objections by the dissenting lot owners are reasonable without having to make findings of fact which would necessarily go beyond that which is strictly a question of law in this appeal. This appeal then involves a consideration of the basis of opposition by the lot owners, as expressed in their written objections and whether, objectively viewed, the objections were reasonable.Further Background The renovation work to Lot 4 involved remodelling the kitchen and living area. To enlarge the living space the appellant sought to include part of her exclusive use area, about 3.8m2, by extending the living space into that exclusive use area (“the disputed area”). It is best described by reference to the exclusive use floor plan which shows the wall between the lot and the exclusive use area as a “L” section of the eastern masonry wall. Access to the exclusive use area from the living area of Lot 4 is through sliding glass doors. The change was to remove the existing sliding doors and masonry, and replacing them with new doors, so that the “L” shape goes, and the eastern wall becomes a straight wall.[5] By making this change the appellant amalgamates the disputed area into the living space of her lot. [5]Annexure “A” to these reasons is a copy of the exclusive use floor plan with the disputed area marked up in red. The appellant has in fact partially undertaken structural work by the removal of the L shaped wall (which incorporated a sliding glass door) adjacent to the kitchen and replaced it with a sliding glass door as can be seen at page 166 of the hearing book. The floor plan on page 156 of the hearing book shows the original configuration of the lot,[6] the subject area being that adjacent to the notation “Patio 13.5m2”. By reference to the plan showing exclusive use areas on Level A (ground floor) only lots 1 – 4 inclusive have a similar configuration, with lot 1 being the same as lot 4. Lots 3 and 4 have different floor plan but have similar exclusive use areas. Lots 11 and 12 do have the same floor plan and those lots have already been re-configured so that there is a straight wall from the living space to the patio. This work was carried out before approval of the disposition of the exclusive use area. This was retrospectively approved on 3 August 2021.[6]Hearing book page 194. However, before embarking on the renovation work in the lot and the disputed area, the appellant failed to obtain the consent of the Body Corporate of the scheme, not only to carry out the works within her own lot but more importantly, the disputed area (being common property, albeit exclusive use). She also failed to obtain agreement, without dissent, to amalgamate the disputed area into lot 4. At an extraordinary general meeting of the Body Corporate on 3 August 2021, the meeting, by resolution, retrospectively approved the renovation works carried out by the appellant to her lot and in the disputed area (acknowledging it is common property) in accordance with plans and specifications produced by her. That is the removal of the “L” shaped wall and replace it with a straight wall. The motion passed with a majority of 17 votes in favour and 10 against.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established