SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Drake v PKF (Gold Coast) Pty Ltd & Anor (No 2) [2023] QSC 66
PARTIES:
PETER CHARLES DRAKE
(plaintiff/respondent)
v
PKF (GOLD COAST) PTY LTD
ACN 137 531 250(first defendant/applicant)
SCOTT JAMES McMURTRIE
(second defendant/applicant)FILE NO:
BS No 2822 of 2019
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at BrisbaneDELIVERED ON:
4 April 2023
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
Heard on the papers (defendants’ written submissions on costs filed 23 March 2023; plaintiff’s written submissions on costs filed 3 April 2023; defendants’ written submissions in reply on costs filed 3 April 2023)
JUDGE:
Cooper J
ORDER:
1. The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the application filed on 27 February 2023 assessed on the indemnity basis if not agreed.
2. To the extent that costs of the proceeding have not been awarded by existing orders (including paragraph 1 of these orders), the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs, assessed on the standard basis if not agreed.
CATCHWORDS:
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS GENERALLY – where the plaintiff commenced proceedings in 2019 arising from alleged negligence of the first and second defendants in 2013 – where the tenth amended statement of claim as relating to causation and loss was struck out without leave to replead – where the proceeding was dismissed for want of prosecution – whether indemnity costs should be awarded
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 681, r 703
AKS Investments Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank & Anor (No 2) [2012] QSC 282, considered
Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225, cited
Drake v PKF (Gold Coast) Pty Ltd & Anor [2022] QSC 197, related
Drake v PKF (Gold Coast) Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] QSC 45, relatedCOUNSEL:
The plaintiff/respondent appeared on his own behalf
M Jones for the defendants/applicantsSOLICITORS:
The plaintiff/respondent appeared on his own behalf
Hall & Wilcox for the defendants/applicants
On 16 March 2023, I ordered that parts of the plaintiff’s tenth statement of claim be struck out, without leave to replead, and that the proceeding be dismissed for want of prosecution.[1]
At the time I delivered judgment, I directed that the parties file and serve written submissions on costs so that question could be decided on the papers. Those submissions have been filed. This is my decision on the question of costs.
Parties’ submissions
The defendants have sought payment of their costs on three alternative bases:
(a)that the plaintiff pay their costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs, on the standard basis up to 25 July 2022 and on the indemnity basis thereafter, by reason of him having imprudently refused an offer to settle dated 11 July 2022,[2] which expired on 25 July 2022;
(b)alternatively, that the plaintiff pay their costs of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Drake v PKF (Gold Coast) Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QSC 66
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the defendants' reliance on an offer to compromise made on 11 July 2022, which the plaintiff refused. The offer proposed that the plaintiff discontinue his claim and pay 60% of the defendants' costs or a fixed sum of $65,000. The court found the offer to be a genuine compromise but concluded that the plaintiff's refusal was not imprudent. The court also noted that the plaintiff's proceeding had negligible prospects of success, as evidenced by the previous dismissal order. The court ultimately determined that the plaintiff should pay the defendants' costs incurred before the determination of the appeal on the standard basis, but the costs of the application filed on 27 February 2023 should be assessed on the indemnity basis.
The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants' costs of the application filed on 27 February 2023 assessed on the indemnity basis if not agreed. Additionally, the plaintiff was ordered to pay the defendants' costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs, assessed on the standard basis if not agreed, to the extent that costs had not been awarded by existing orders. This decision reflected the court's view that while the plaintiff's refusal of the offer to compromise was not imprudent, other factors warranted the imposition of indemnity costs for the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the application filed on 27 February 2023 assessed on the indemnity basis if not agreed.
2. To the extent that costs of the proceeding have not been awarded by existing orders (including paragraph 1 of these orders), the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs, assessed on the standard basis if not agreed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The plaintiff submitted that he should only be ordered to pay costs of the proceeding from 30 April 2021, on the basis that the Court of Appeal effectively set aside all costs orders made before that date. He further submitted that no grounds exist that warrant the award of indemnity costs.Consideration It is clear from the plaintiff’s written submissions that he accepts that the costs of the dismissal application and the proceeding should follow the event. This reflects the general position set out in r 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR) that the costs of a proceeding, including an application in a proceeding, are in the discretion of the court but follow the event, unless the court orders otherwise. The real question is whether any part of the costs the plaintiff is ordered to pay should be assessed on the indemnity basis and, if so, which part. Rule 703(1) of the UCPR confers a discretion to order that costs be assessed on the indemnity basis. While that discretion is unfettered, it is generally recognised that the discretion should not be exercised unless some feature of the case warrants a departure from the usual course of ordering that costs awarded against an unsuccessful party be assessed on the standard basis. The defendants rely on two features which have previously been recognised as warranting the exercise of the discretion to order indemnity costs:[4] an imprudent refusal of an offer to compromise and wilful disregard or known facts or clearly established law.[4]Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225, 233.Refusal of offer to compromise As Applegarth J stated in AKS Investments Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank & Anor (No 2):[5][5][2012] QSC 282, [11]. The letter dated 11 July 2022 set out what the defendants described as insurmountable issues with the plaintiff’s pleading of causation. The defendants offered to settle the proceeding on the basis that the plaintiff agreed to discontinue his claim and to pay 60% of the defendants’ costs of the proceeding assessed on the standard basis or, alternatively, a fixed agreed sum of $65,000 inclusive of GST. The letter clearly foreshadowed the defendants’ intention to rely upon the offer in support of a submission that the plaintiff pay their costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis. In my view, the discount offered on the costs that the plaintiff would pay if he accepted the offer was a genuine compromise compared with the costs the plaintiff would pay if his proceeding was dismissed. I do not accept the plaintiff’s submission that the offer was “disingenuous and not realistically capable of being accepted.” I also consider that the fourteen days which the defendants allowed the plaintiff to consider the offer was a reasonable period. Nevertheless, I am not persuaded that the plaintiff’s refusal of the offer to compromise was imprudent. The offer was made before the previous strike out and dismissal application was heard by Hindman J on 2 August 2022. Although her Honour struck out the plaintiff’s statement of claim, she granted leave to replead. The defendants applied for costs on the indemnity basis from 25 July 2022 on that occasion,[6] however the plaintiff was ordered to pay costs on the standard basis.[7] That seems to me to be consistent with Hindman J’s refusal to act on the basis that the plaintiff’s proceeding had negligible prospects of success.[8] [6]Amended application filed 2 August 2022 (Court document 71).[7]Orders of Hindman J dated 16 September 2002 (Court document 76).[8]Drake v PKF (Gold Coast) Pty Ltd & Anor [2022] QSC 197, [43].