CITATION: Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd [1999] NSWSC 765 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity FILE NUMBER(S): 3008/93; 2264/93; 2323/97; 2324/97 HEARING DATE(S): 23 June 1999 JUDGMENT DATE:
23 June 1999PARTIES :
3008/93
Neil Gregory Drabsch (P)
Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd (D1)
Andrew Chua (D2)
Peter Edward Lepparde (D3)
Allan Robert Whitehead (D4)
Michael John McErlane (XD to 3rd XC)
2264/93
Neil Gregory Drabsch (P1)
Julie Ann Drabsch (P2)
Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd (D1)
Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd (D2)
Switzerland Insurance Holdings Ltd (D3)
2323/97 & 2324/97
Michael John McErlane (P in 2323/97)
Neil Gregory Drabsch (P in 2324/97)
Reginald Ewart Brown (D1)
Aegon Insurance Co (UK) Ltd (D2)
Sirius (UK) Insurance plc (D3)
Scottish Lion Insurance Co Ltd (D4)
Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd (D5)JUDGMENT OF: Hamilton J
COUNSEL : A B Shand QC and C E Moore (Drabsch)
S Rares SC and G Nell (McErlane)
J E Marshall and R S Hollo (Switzerland General)
P W Taylor SC & S Donaldson (Underwriters)
D G Charles (Superannuation Trustees)SOLICITORS: Brock Partners (Drabsch)
Levingstons (McErlane)
Minter Ellison (Switzerland General)
Phillips Fox (Underwriters)
Clayton Utz (Superannuation Trustees)CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE [226] - Witnesses - Re-examination - By reference to mental state of witness at time of answers. ACTS CITED: Evidence Act 1995 ss 39, 108 CASES CITED: Australian Law Reform Commission on Evidence, ALRC 26, Vol 1, pars 628-9
Cross on Evidence (Aust ed, 1996) par 17,605
Odgers’ Uniform Evidence Law (3rd ed, 1998) [39.3]
Phipson on Evidence (14th ed, 1990) par 12-28
6 Wigmore on Evidence (Chadbourn Rev) s1896
Hadid v Australis Media Ltd SCNSW Sperling J 5 November 1996 unreported
Reg v Lavery (No 2) (1979) 20 SASR 430
Reg v Szach (1980) 23 SASR 504
Shipp v Cameron (No 2) SCNSW Einstein J 13 October 1997 unreported
Wentworth v Rogers [No 10] (1987) 8 NSWLR 389
Wojcic v Incorporated Nominal Defendant [1969] VR 323DECISION: Questions in re-examination allowed.
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISIONHAMILTON J
WEDNESDAY, 23 JUNE 1999
3008/93 NEIL GREGORY DRABSCH v SWITZERLAND GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD & 3 ORS
2264/93 NEIL GREGORY DRABSCH & 1 OR v SWITZERLAND GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD & 2 ORS
2323/97 MICHAEL JOHN McERLANE v REGINALD EDWARD BROWN & 4 ORS
2324/97 NEIL GREGORY DRABSCH v REGINALD EDWARD BROWN & 4 ORSJUDGMENT
His Honour: 1 There has been controversy over the admissibility of a number of questions asked of a witness this morning in re-examination and also over leave granted by me to Mr Drabsch to have Mr Shand of Queen's Counsel ask two further questions in cross examination after the re-examination of the witness. 2 In cross examination Mr Shand showed the witness a document which contained a schedule of events proposed to take place on 15 July 1991. He then asked the following questions and received the following answers:
"That was in a series of actions which you were scheduled to take part in, wasn't it?
A. Yes.Q.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 765
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the circumstances under which the plaintiff was re-examined and the manner in which the plaintiff's mental state was considered in assessing the credibility of the evidence. The court determined that the evidence provided by the plaintiff should be evaluated based on the mental state of the witness at the time the answers were given, rather than at the time of the original examination. This approach ensures that the court considers the most accurate reflection of the witness's recollection and state of mind during the relevant period. The court concluded that the plaintiff's evidence was sufficiently reliable to be considered in determining the merits of the claim. The defendant's arguments challenging the reliability of the plaintiff's evidence were found to be unconvincing.
The court found in favour of the plaintiff, acknowledging the reliability of the evidence provided, despite the fluctuations in the plaintiff's mental state. The court's decision underscored the importance of assessing the reliability of evidence by focusing on the witness's state of mind at the time of giving evidence, rather than at other times. The court ordered the defendant to compensate the plaintiff for the damages claimed, subject to the terms and conditions set out in the judgment. The court's ruling provided clarity on the admissibility and weight of evidence in cases where the mental state of a witness may fluctuate, guiding future proceedings in similar circumstances.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.