DPQT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

DPQT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 2603 (23 July 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/9443

Re:DPQT

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndZXDS

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member P Ranson 

Date:23 July 2024

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is varied such that an interim care period of 26 weeks applies from 10 April 2022.

................................[SGD]...................................

Member P Ranson

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care determination – change in care – whether a child can self-select which parent to live with – whether care has been withheld - whether special circumstances apply – whether reasonable action was taken to enforce care orders - interim period applied – decision under review varied

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999 (Cth),
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Social Services Legislation Amendment (Child Support and Family Assistance Technical Amendments) Bill 2024 (Cth)

Cases

Child Support Registrar v CMU23 [2024] FCA 109

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Oldfather and Fountaine (Child support) 2023 AATA 3301 (14 September 2023)

Secondary Materials

Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member P Ranson

23 July 2024

BACKGROUND

  1. DPQT is the father and ZXDS is the mother of their son (Master R) who was born in 2008. They have other children together who are not a part of this case. The child support case for Master R began in 2013 and was confirmed in 2014 by consent orders from the court, which gave each parent equal shared care of him.

  2. The father states that in March 2022, when Master R was 14 years of age, he self-selected to live with him. Master R would be 15 years of age within the next four months. In April 2022, both parents advised the Child Support Agency (Agency) of the change. However, both parents were of contradictory views as to Master R's living arrangements. The father stated that it was Master R's decision, whereas the mother stated that Master R had been taken against his will by the father. In any event, the Agency decided to do two things. First, they changed the care percentages from 51% to 100% for the father and from 49% to 0% for the mother. Second, they granted the mother an interim care period of 26 weeks from the changeover date in March 2022.

  3. Interim care periods can be granted when care of a child changes, despite the child being made available and the parent with reduced care takes reasonable action to enforce the care…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DPQT and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2603
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review before the General Division of the Tribunal, brought by the father, concerning a child support percentage of care determination. The dispute arose after the child, Master R, who was approaching 15 years of age, chose to live full-time with his father from 10 April 2022, rather than return to the mother's care as per existing court orders. The father argued that the child had self-selected to stay with him and that previous decisions had not correctly applied court orders.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether a child could legally self-select their primary caregiver for child support purposes, whether care had been withheld by either parent, and if special circumstances applied to alter the usual assessment of care. Specifically, the Tribunal needed to consider if the mother had taken reasonable action to enforce the court-ordered care arrangements and whether an interim period should apply.

The Tribunal found that there is no legal basis for a child to self-select their primary caregiver. However, it determined that the mother had taken reasonable steps to enforce the care orders, including contacting the police, seeking legal advice, and arranging family dispute resolution, which the father failed to attend. Despite the child's choice, the Tribunal found that the father had made the child available for care by the mother. The Tribunal concluded that the change of care date was 10 April 2022, revoking previous percentage of care determinations for both parents and establishing a new determination of 100% care for the father and 0% for the mother. An interim care period of 26 weeks was afforded to the mother under section 53(1)(c) of the Assessment Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The objection by the father was disallowed because the mother had taken reasonable action to enforce the court ordered care arrangement. The father then appealed the objection decision to the Social Security Division of this Tribunal, which upheld the interim care period and changed the start date to 28 March 2022.[3] Dissatisfied with that outcome, the father appealed to the General Division for a second review.[4] CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE[3] Section 37 T-Documents, T2, pages 7 to 16.[4] Section 37 T-Documents, T1, pages 1 to 6.What does the father say? In his application for review of the AAT1 decision, the father says:‘I believe the AAT decision is wrong. Member [redacted] based his decision solely on his interpretation of whether the court orders were still in force, a decision I do not believe he was qualified to make. He also refused to acknowledge key information and past history which is critical in the decision making process. Constantly he asked if the Court Orders were being followed to which I answered no and was the basis of my original application. [The mother] asserted that they were despite the fact that another child [redacted] who is still part of the child support system is not 50% in my care.Federal court orders are not a buffet which can be turned on and off by one parent at will. Child Support have also in every other instance not applied the court orders in the decision making process and have as a result set a precedent. All of this was ignored by Member [redacted] and I believe requires review. These decisions have had a significant financial impact to [Master R] and myself.’(Typographical errors in original) The father says Master R came into his care on 18 March 2022 (not disputed by the mother as that was a normal changeover day) and self-selected to stay full time in the care of the father.[5] Curiously, the father did not advise the mother of this change until 10 April 2022 when he sent her an e-mail to that effect.[6] As discussed below, there is no basis in law for a child to self-select which parent they will live with.[5] Section 37 T-Documents, T13, page 65.[6] Section 37 T-Documents, T14, page 66. On 6 June 2022, the father wrote to the Agency saying as of that date, he had not had any correspondence from anyone about mediation.[7] This is contradictory to a certificate provided by Family Relationship Centre dated 15 June 2022 which showed his non-attendance at family dispute resolution on 1 June 2022.[8] [7] Section 37 T-Documents, T43, page 133.[8] Section 37 T-Documents, T46, pages 138 to 139.What does the mother say? The mother provided copies of various e-mail exchanges from 17 April 2022 to 16 July 2022, and a one-page submission dated 29 June 2023 which sets out her position in relation to the change of care.[9] Her submission pre-dates the decision in CMU23, and she strongly maintains she took and will continue to take all reasonable steps to restore her care of Master R.[9] Other Party’s screenshots of emails.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Remembering Term 1 school holidays in 2022 were from Saturday, 2 April 2022 to Monday, 18 April 2022 and the father was due to have the first week from Saturday, 2 April 2022 to Saturday, 9 April 2022, the next scheduled changeover from the father to the mother was Sunday, 10 April 2022. Changeover did not happen that day, which was also the first time the father notified the mother Master R was staying with him and would not be returning to her care.CONCLUSION Whilst there is no basis in law which permits a child to self-select which parent they will live with, the Tribunal finds that the father made him available for care by the mother by not withholding care of him from her because Master R, who was approaching age 15 at the relevant time, chose to leave the care of his mother and live full-time with his father and she had agreed in 2019 he could decide where he lives once he was in Year 8. The Tribunal finds the change of care day was 10 April 2022 because:(i)changeover on 18 March 2022 was part of the normal week about care;(ii)the extension firstly to 25 March 2022 and then to 30 March 2022 was a minor one-off change to the pattern of care due to illness and was agreed upon between the parents;(iii)the suggestion by the mother to delay changeover a second time, which was due on 30 March 2022, given its proximity to the first day of the school holidays, is another minor one-off change in the pattern of care again agreed between the parents; and(iv)10 April 2022 was the first time the care arrangements were breached. The Tribunal finds revocation under s 54G applies in this case because the mother was to have equal shared care which ended when Master R chose to live with his father and not return to her care even though the father made him available by not withholding care. Further, the Tribunal finds the change of care day was 10 April 2022, as reported by the parents that day and that:(a)the father’s existing determination of percentage of care is revoked under s 54F of the Assessment Act, and a new determination of percentage of care for the father must be made under s 50(1)(b) of the Assessment Act because he had a pattern of care after the change of care date, that is, 100% care; and(b)the mother’s existing determination of percentage of care is also revoked under s 54F of the Assessment Act, and a new determination of percentage of care for the mother must be made under s 49(1)(b) of the Assessment Act because she had no pattern of care after the change of care date, that is, 0%. That being the case and following the determination in CMU23, s 53(1)(c) applies to afford the mother an interim care period of 26 weeks because:(i)the previous care determination for both parents was made under s 50 as they both had regular care of Master R;(ii)the mother took reasonable action to enforce the care orders; and(iii)the father made Master R available to her albeit Master R chose not to return to her care. The Tribunal finds, as have previous decision makers in this matter, the mother took reasonable action to restore the equal care arrangement because she contacted the Police, sought legal advice and importantly, arranged family dispute resolution with the Family Relationship Centre, which the father failed to attend.[20] [20] Section 37 T-Documents, T46, pages 138 to 139.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.