DPP v Osmani (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Osmani (No 2)

Citation:

[2023] ACTSC 128

Hearing Date:

30 March 2023; and 26 May 2023

DecisionDate:

26 May 2023

Before:

Mossop J

Decision:

See [24].

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and punishment – sentence – guilty plea to offence of obtaining property by deception – offence committed by joint commission – where offenders purported to purchase e‑cigarettes with an envelope of papers cut to resemble banknotes – offending in mid-range – offender's role included driving the getaway vehicle – offender did not comply with ICO assessment in circumstances where he requested an assessment – sentence of suspended imprisonment imposed

Legislation Cited:

Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT)

Criminal Code 2002 (ACT), ss 45A, 326

Parties:

Director of Public Prosecutions

Albion Osmani ( Offender)

Representation:

Counsel

N Deakes (DPP)

A Doig ( Offender)

Solicitors

Director of Public Prosecutions

Tim Sharman Solicitors ( Offender)

File Number:

SCC 259 of 2022

MOSSOP J:

Introduction

  1. On 17 October 2022 the offender, Albion Osmani, pleaded guilty to one count of obtaining property by deception contrary to s 326 of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) (CC2022/8428). The offence was an offence by joint commission by virtue of s 45A of the Criminal Code.

Facts

  1. The facts are set out in a Statement of Facts, which is agreed. It is not necessary to recite the facts in great detail. In summary, the offending was as follows. The offender was involved in a scheme to acquire e-cigarettes in bulk from a seller located via Facebook Marketplace. There were three co-offenders, Mr Aseeri, Mr Rhodes and Mr Khan who, along with the offender, participated in the scheme which involved a purported purchase of 12,000, IGET brand e-cigarettes. At the exchange of the merchandise Mr Khan departed with the e‑cigarettes in a vehicle while Mr Rhodes purported to made payment with envelopes full of cash totalling $63,600. Instead of containing cash, they only contained paper cut to the size of banknotes. Mr Rhodes then ran from the scene to a car which was driven by the offender and was driven away.

  1. The level of involvement on the part of the offender was the subject of some dispute. The agreed facts show that he was communicating with Mr Aseeri about the plan on 10 May 2021 where Mr Rhodes had found a potential seller. On 13 May 2021 the facts record communications between the seller and Mr Aseeri. These communications continued on 14 May 2021. There are some communications on the evening of 14 May 2021 between Mr Aseeri and the offender which indicate the offender had knowledge of the scheme but do not indicate him as a leader (rather than a follower) in the plan. The theft took place at about 3pm the next day. There is no evidence of involvement of the offender prior to him waiting in an adjacent street and driving the getaway car for Mr Rhodes. He…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DPP v Osmani (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, the Director of Public Prosecutions brought a case against Albion Osmani, charging him with obtaining property by deception under section 326 of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT). The court, presided over by Mossop J, heard the matter over two dates: 30 March 2023 and 26 May 2023, with the decision announced on the latter date. The primary legal issues before the court were the assessment of the objective seriousness of the offence, the subjective circumstances of the offender, and the appropriate sentence considering these factors.

The court determined that the offence, involving a scheme to purchase e-cigarettes with fake banknotes, was serious and premeditated, placing it in the mid-range of objective seriousness. The offender's role, although significant, was that of a subordinate who drove the getaway car. Despite his subordinate role in the actual commission of the offence, the court acknowledged the substantial value of the stolen property and the dishonesty involved. Regarding the offender's subjective circumstances, the court noted his lack of prior criminal history, his socially isolated state, and his family support, which provided a stable environment. However, the offender's request for an assessment for an Intensive Correction Order (ICO) was handled poorly by both the offender and his family, leading to the conclusion that an ICO was not a suitable option.

Considering the factors of general deterrence and the harm to the victim, the court imposed a sentence of 12 months imprisonment, suspended upon the offender entering into a good behaviour order for two years and completing 150 hours of community service within one year. The court emphasised the necessity of strict compliance with the conditions of the good behaviour order and the community service, warning of adverse consequences for any non-compliance.

The final orders of the court included the conviction of the offender on the charge of obtaining property by deception, with the sentence of 12 months imprisonment suspended, subject to the conditions of the good behaviour order and community service. The offender was also required to report to ACT Corrective Services by a specified date.

Background

Background to the litigation

Albion Osmani was involved in a scheme to acquire a large quantity of e-cigarettes through deception. Osmani and three co-offenders, Mr Aseeri, Mr Rhodes, and Mr Khan, conspired to purchase 12,000 IGET brand e-cigarettes from a seller located via Facebook Marketplace. The plan involved Mr Rhodes presenting envelopes filled with paper cut to resemble banknotes as payment, amounting to $63,600, instead of actual cash. After the exchange, Mr Khan took the e-cigarettes while Mr Rhodes fled the scene, with Osmani driving the getaway car to help Mr Rhodes escape. The theft occurred at around 3pm on 15 May 2021.

Communications between Osmani and Mr Aseeri leading up to the offence indicated Osmani's awareness of the scheme, though not as a leader. While Osmani played an important role by driving the getaway car, his involvement in planning the scheme was less clear. The stolen goods have not been returned or recovered. The offence, by joint commission, was in the mid-range of objective seriousness due to the significant value of the stolen property and the premeditated nature of the scheme.

Osmani's personal circumstances were also considered. He is 25 years old, socially isolated, and has difficulty making friends. His relationship with Mr Aseeri involved controlling behaviour and financial abuse, leading to an Adjustment Disorder with Mixed Anxiety and Depressed Mood. Despite a plea of guilty, Osmani and his family did not cooperate with an assessment for an Intensive Correction Order (ICO), deeming it unsuitable. Instead, the court imposed a suspended sentence of 12 months' imprisonment, to be served with a good behaviour order for two years and 150 hours of community service. The court emphasised the importance of compliance with these conditions, warning of adverse consequences for any breaches.

The case of DPP v Osmani (No 2) before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory came to the court following the offender, Albion Osmani, entering a guilty plea to one count of obtaining property by deception on 17 October 2022. The offence, which involved Osmani's participation in a scheme to acquire e-cigarettes through deception, was heard in the Magistrates Court before being transferred to the Supreme Court for sentencing. The procedural history of the case includes Osmani's initial plea of not guilty, which was subsequently changed to a guilty plea on the third mention of the case in the Magistrates Court. This early plea was recognised by the Supreme Court, which applied an approximate 25 percent discount to the sentencing. The matter was then transferred to the Supreme Court for consideration of the appropriate sentence. Throughout the proceedings, key procedural steps included the preparation and consideration of a pre-sentence report and a psychological assessment, which provided insights into Osmani's personal circumstances and risk of reoffending. Additionally, the court considered the submissions regarding Osmani's role in the offending and his cooperation with authorities, which informed the final sentencing decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate sentence for the offender who pleaded guilty to obtaining property by deception, considering his subordinate role and personal circumstances?
2. Should the offender's sentence be reduced due to his limited assistance to the authorities?
3. Is a period of full-time detention necessary for the offender's sentence, given his subordinate role and personal circumstances?
4. How should the court address the offender's and his family's apparent misunderstanding of the benefits of an Intensive Correction Order (ICO) in the sentencing process?
5. What are the most important sentencing considerations in this case, and how should they be balanced against each other?

Held
1. The court concluded that the appropriate sentence for the offender, considering his subordinate role and personal circumstances, was a suspended sentence of 12 months' imprisonment, with the sentence being suspended upon the offender entering into a good behaviour order and performing community service.
2. The court concluded that the offender's limited assistance to the authorities warranted a reduction in his sentence by a fixed period of one month, resulting in a sentence of 12 months' imprisonment, suspended for the aforementioned reasons.
3. The court concluded that a period of full-time detention was not necessary for the offender's sentence, given his subordinate role and personal circumstances. Instead, a suspended sentence with good behaviour and community service obligations was appropriate.
4. The court noted the offender's and his family's misunderstanding of the benefits of an ICO and emphasized the importance of compliance with the good behaviour order and community service obligations. The court warned that any non-compliance would result in adverse consequences for the offender.
5. The court determined that the most important sentencing considerations in this case were general deterrence and recognition of the harm done to the victim. These considerations were balanced against the offender's subordinate role and personal circumstances, resulting in a suspended sentence with good behaviour and community service obligations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in DPP v Osmani (No 2) addressed the sentencing of Albion Osmani for obtaining property by deception, balancing various legal principles and the offender's circumstances. Firstly, the court assessed the appropriate sentence considering Osmani's subordinate role and personal circumstances. The court found Osmani played a secondary role in the commission of the offence, driving the getaway vehicle, and considered his social isolation and family support as mitigating factors. The court applied the principle of proportionality, adjusting the sentence to reflect Osmani's lesser involvement and personal vulnerabilities, ultimately deciding on a suspended sentence of 12 months imprisonment, reduced from an initial 17 months.

Secondly, the court deliberated on whether Osmani's limited assistance to the authorities warranted a reduction in his sentence. While the prosecution argued for a fixed period of full-time detention, the court opted for a fixed reduction of one month, reflecting the lesser value of Osmani's assistance compared to that of his co-offender, Mr. Rhodes. The court applied the principle of just deserts, acknowledging Osmani's cooperation albeit limited, and concluded that a fixed reduction was more appropriate than a percentage discount.

Thirdly, the court considered whether a period of full-time detention was necessary, given Osmani's subordinate role and personal circumstances. The court rejected the prosecution's argument for full-time detention, emphasizing the importance of considering Osmani's role in the crime and his personal situation. The court applied the principle of individualization, tailoring the sentence to Osmani's specific circumstances, and decided on a suspended sentence with conditions, rather than immediate imprisonment.

Fourthly, the court addressed the misunderstanding exhibited by Osmani and his family regarding the benefits of an Intensive Correction Order (ICO). The court highlighted the necessity of clear obligations for compliance with the good behaviour order and community service, ensuring there was no ambiguity regarding the consequences of non-compliance. The court applied the principle of deterrence, making it explicit that any breach would result in adverse consequences for Osmani.

Lastly, the court identified the most important sentencing considerations in this case, focusing on general deterrence and recognition of the harm done to the victim. Balancing these considerations against Osmani's subordinate role and personal circumstances, the court decided on a suspended sentence with specific conditions to ensure compliance and address the offender's vulnerabilities. The court followed established sentencing principles, adjusting them to fit the unique aspects of this case, and departed from the prosecution's argument for full-time detention by opting for a more lenient disposition. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that in cases involving a subordinate offender with personal vulnerabilities, a balanced approach considering both the seriousness of the offence and the offender's circumstances can result in a suspended sentence with conditions, rather than immediate imprisonment.