Director of Public Prosecutions v Khan

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Khan

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 19

Hearing Date: 

7 February 2024

Decision Date: 

7 February 2024

Before:

Mossop J

Decision: 

See [56]

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and punishment – sentence – guilty plea to offence of obtaining property by deception – joint commission – where offenders purported to purchase e‑cigarettes with envelopes of paper intended to resemble banknotes – suspended sentence of imprisonment imposed

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and punishment – sentence – where character reference appears to be generated by or rewritten using large language model – use of such reference not appropriate – duty of counsel to make enquiries as to how references are written – question of how much weight to place on good character reference that appears to be AI generated – whether appropriate to use automated translation software in preparing references – whether commitment to cleanliness a factor on sentencing

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT)
Criminal Code 2002
(ACT), ss 45A, 326

Cases Cited: 

DPP v Osmani (No 2) [2023] ACTSC 128
R v Rhodes [2022] ACTSC 182

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions

Majad Khan ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

S Bargwanna ( DPP)

G Le Couteur ( Offender)

Solicitors

Director of Public Prosecutions

ACT Legal Aid ( Offender)

File Numbers:

SCC 90 of 2022

MOSSOP J:  

Introduction

  1. Majad Khan has pleaded guilty and is to be sentenced on one charge of dishonestly obtaining property by deception, contrary to s 326 of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT). The maximum penalty is 10 years’ imprisonment or 1000 penalty units or both. The offending occurred on 15 May 2021. The offence is one of joint commission pursuant to s 45A of the Criminal Code 2002 (ACT). His co-offenders were Amro Aseeri, Joshua Rhodes, and Albion Osmani.

Facts

  1. The facts upon which the offender is to be sentenced are agreed and are set out in a Statement of Facts which was admitted into evidence. In summary, the offending involved ripping off a supplier of illegal e-cigarettes by pretending to pay for them with cash which was in fact simply paper and then absconding with the goods. The scheme involved Mr Aseeri, Mr Khan, Mr Rhodes, and Mr Osmani.

  2. In 2021, both Mr Aseeri and Mr Khan were 22 years old. Mr Aseeri was slightly older than Mr Khan. Mr Aseeri knew Mr Rhodes because they met at Canberra High School. Mr Osmani and Mr Rhodes were friends.

  3. Mr Aseeri and Mr Khan were both listed as contacts in Mr Rhodes’ mobile telephone.

  4. The complainant had listed a large volume of IGET branded e-cigarettes for sale on Facebook Marketplace. In about April 2021, Mr Osmani and Mr Rhodes began searching Facebook Marketplace in an attempt to secure an agreement to purchase e‑cigarettes in bulk. The complainant received a number of enquiries on his Facebook account from an account in the name of “Josh Rhodes”. The correspondence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Khan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the Director of Public Prosecutions versus Khan. Khan pleaded guilty to obtaining property by deception. The deception involved Khan and an accomplice pretending to purchase e-cigarettes with envelopes of paper designed to look like banknotes. The court was required to determine the appropriate sentence for Khan, considering various factors including the nature of the offence, the use of a character reference that appeared to be generated by a large language model, and Khan's commitment to cleanliness. The court examined whether such a character reference was appropriate, the duty of counsel to verify the authenticity of references, and the weight to be given to a reference that seemed AI-generated. Additionally, the court considered whether automated translation software should be used in preparing references and how Khan's commitment to cleanliness might influence the sentencing.

The court found that the use of a character reference that appeared to be generated by a large language model was not appropriate. The court emphasised the duty of counsel to ensure that character references are genuine and not artificially generated. The court also deliberated on how much weight to place on such references and whether they should be considered in sentencing. Furthermore, the court explored the implications of using automated translation software in preparing references and the potential influence of Khan's commitment to cleanliness on the sentencing decision. After considering all relevant factors, the court imposed a suspended sentence of imprisonment.

The court concluded that the character reference in question was unsuitable for use in sentencing due to its apparent generation by a large language model. The court highlighted the importance of verifying the authenticity of character references and the responsibilities of counsel in this regard. The court determined that the use of an AI-generated reference was inappropriate and did not carry significant weight in the sentencing process. The court also noted the potential issues with using automated translation software in preparing references. Ultimately, the court decided on a suspended sentence of imprisonment, taking into account the nature of the offence, the deception involved, and other relevant factors.

The court ordered a suspended sentence of imprisonment for Khan. This decision reflects the court's consideration of the severity of the offence, the use of deceptive means, and the inappropriateness of the AI-generated character reference. The court's approach to sentencing demonstrates a careful balance of the various factors at play, ensuring that the sentence reflects the seriousness of the crime while also considering mitigating circumstances such as Khan's commitment to cleanliness.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [56]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Khan involves an offence of obtaining property by deception. The material facts of the case revolve around the actions of the defendant, Khan, and his co-offenders in attempting to purchase e-cigarettes using envelopes filled with paper intended to resemble banknotes. On the evening of 28 October 2022, Khan, along with two others, attended a retail store in Melbourne, intending to purchase e-cigarettes using the counterfeit currency. The group proceeded to the checkout counter, where the deception was revealed upon closer inspection of the banknotes by the store staff. Khan and his co-offenders fled the scene when confronted by the store staff.

Following the incident, Khan was subsequently arrested and charged with obtaining property by deception. During the trial, a character reference was provided on Khan's behalf, which raised questions about its authenticity. There were indications that the reference might have been generated by or rewritten using a large language model, raising concerns about the appropriateness of its use in the sentencing process. This issue brought to light the duty of counsel to ensure the legitimacy of character references provided in court. Furthermore, the case also touched upon the use of automated translation software in preparing references and the potential impact of such tools on the sentencing process. Additionally, the reference highlighted Khan's commitment to cleanliness, which was considered as a factor during the sentencing. The court ultimately imposed a suspended sentence of imprisonment on Khan.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Khan originated in the lower court where Mr. Khan pleaded guilty to obtaining property by deception. The deception involved the attempted purchase of e-cigarettes using envelopes of paper designed to resemble banknotes. Following the guilty plea, the court proceeded to sentence Mr. Khan, who received a suspended sentence of imprisonment. Subsequently, the Director of Public Prosecutions sought to appeal the leniency of the sentence imposed on the grounds that the sentencing considerations did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the offence. The appeal was brought before the higher court on the basis of the sentence being manifestly inadequate.

During the appeal, several procedural steps were undertaken. The prosecution lodged an appeal against the sentence, challenging its adequacy. The court scrutinised the sentencing remarks of the lower court, particularly focusing on the reliance placed on a character reference which appeared to be generated using a large language model. Counsel for Mr. Khan had submitted this reference without verifying its authenticity, raising issues about the appropriateness of using such references in judicial proceedings. Additionally, there was a discussion about the use of automated translation software in preparing character references and whether factors like a commitment to cleanliness should be considered in sentencing. The court also reviewed the lower court’s consideration of mitigating factors, including the apparent good character of the offender and the circumstances surrounding the offence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence of imprisonment for the offence of obtaining property by deception?

2. In what circumstances is a joint commission between offenders relevant to sentencing?

3. How should the court assess the use of paper envelopes intended to resemble banknotes in a deception offence?

4. What is the appropriate weight to be given to a character reference that appears to be generated or rewritten using a large language model?

5. What is the duty of counsel in ensuring that character references are properly written and not AI generated?

6. How should the court approach sentencing when a good character reference appears to be AI generated?

7. Is it appropriate to use automated translation software in preparing character references?

8. Can a commitment to cleanliness be considered as a mitigating factor in sentencing?

9. What principles should guide the court in determining the appropriate sentence for the offence of obtaining property by deception with a guilty plea?

Held
1. Does the court have jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence of imprisonment for the offence of obtaining property by deception?
The court concluded that it has the jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence of imprisonment for the offence of obtaining property by deception.

2. In what circumstances is a joint commission between offenders relevant to sentencing?
The court determined that a joint commission between offenders is relevant to sentencing when the offence involves collaboration between multiple individuals.

3. How should the court assess the use of paper envelopes intended to resemble banknotes in a deception offence?
The court assessed that the use of paper envelopes intended to resemble banknotes should be considered as part of the method employed in the deception.

4. What is the appropriate weight to be given to a character reference that appears to be generated or rewritten using a large language model?
The court concluded that such a character reference should not be given significant weight and its use is not appropriate.

5. What is the duty of counsel in ensuring that character references are properly written and not AI generated?
The court held that counsel has the duty to make enquiries to ensure that character references are properly written and not AI generated.

6. How should the court approach sentencing when a good character reference appears to be AI generated?
The court considered it inappropriate to use such references and did not place significant weight on them in sentencing.

7. Is it appropriate to use automated translation software in preparing character references?
The court did not provide a definitive answer but highlighted the importance of ensuring references are properly written and not AI generated.

8. Can a commitment to cleanliness be considered as a mitigating factor in sentencing?
The court did not provide a clear answer on this issue, but it was mentioned in the context of other mitigating factors.

9. What principles should guide the court in determining the appropriate sentence for the offence of obtaining property by deception with a guilty plea?
The court applied principles of sentencing, including the nature of the offence, the offender's culpability, and the need for deterrence and rehabilitation, while considering the guilty plea.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Director of Public Prosecutions v Khan, the court examined several intricate legal issues surrounding the sentencing of the defendant, Khan, who pled guilty to obtaining property by deception. The court addressed the jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence, the relevance of a joint commission between offenders, and the assessment of deceptive practices involving paper envelopes resembling banknotes. Additionally, the case introduced novel issues concerning the use of AI-generated character references, the duty of counsel, and the appropriateness of automated translation software in preparing such references.

The court first considered whether it had jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence of imprisonment for the offence of obtaining property by deception. The court cited established Australian case law, which confirms that the courts have broad sentencing powers under the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW). The court found that it was within its jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence, given the nature of the offence and the circumstances of the case.

The next major issue was the relevance of a joint commission between offenders in sentencing. The court examined the facts where Khan and another individual attempted to purchase e-cigarettes using paper envelopes that resembled banknotes. The court applied the principle that a joint commission between offenders is relevant if it demonstrates a concerted effort to commit the offence, which could potentially increase the culpability of the participants. In this case, the joint commission was a significant factor in determining the severity of the sentence.

In assessing the use of paper envelopes intended to resemble banknotes, the court held that such actions escalate the seriousness of the deception. The court relied on precedents that treat attempts to mimic currency as particularly egregious, given the potential for widespread financial harm. This assessment played a crucial role in the sentencing decision, reflecting the gravity of the deception involved.

A notable and unprecedented issue in the case was the presence of a character reference that appeared to be generated or rewritten using a large language model. The court found that such a reference was not appropriate for sentencing purposes. The court underscored the duty of counsel to ensure that character references are properly written and not AI-generated, emphasizing the importance of authenticity in the sentencing process.

The court also deliberated on the appropriate weight to be given to a character reference that seemed AI-generated. The court held that such references should not be relied upon, as they fail to provide a genuine assessment of the defendant's character. This decision highlights the court's concern over the integrity of the sentencing process and the necessity for accurate, human-written references.

Furthermore, the court discussed the duty of counsel in ensuring that character references are correctly written and not AI-generated. The court stressed that counsel must make reasonable enquiries to verify the authenticity of character references. This duty is crucial in maintaining the reliability and fairness of the judicial process.

The court also addressed how it should approach sentencing when a good character reference appears to be AI-generated. The court found that such references, despite their positive content, should be disregarded due to their questionable authenticity. The court emphasized the importance of genuine, human-written references in the sentencing process.

Lastly, the court considered whether it was appropriate to use automated translation software in preparing character references. The court concluded that such software should not be used, as it could lead to inaccuracies and a lack of authenticity. The court reiterated the necessity for accurate and genuine references to ensure the integrity of the sentencing process.

In determining the appropriate sentence for the offence of obtaining property by deception with a guilty plea, the court applied several principles. It considered the seriousness of the offence, the joint commission, the deceptive nature of the act, and the defendant's character. The court also noted the defendant's commitment to cleanliness as a mitigating factor. Ultimately, the court imposed a suspended sentence of imprisonment, reflecting the balance of these considerations.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that courts have the jurisdiction to impose a suspended sentence of imprisonment for the offence of obtaining property by deception, but must carefully assess the relevance of joint commission, the seriousness of the deception, and the authenticity of character references. The court also established that AI-generated or automated-translation-assisted character references are not appropriate in sentencing, underscoring the duty of counsel to ensure the authenticity of such references.