-
Re Broes
[2020] VSC 128
Para 15
…nd [99]. [14] See the discussion in Huby at [74] and [75] referring to R v Tsiaris [1996] 1 VR 398 and R v Bullen [2005] VSCA 206. [15]Re Broes [2020] VSC 128 at [42].…
-
RC v R; R v RC
[2020] NSWCCA 76
Para 13
…tal consequences to him were he to be infected with the COVID 19 virus in prison, that would not be the case for a younger, fitter, prisoner. [12][2020] NSWCCA 76.…
-
DPP v Huby
[2019] VSCA 106
Para 15
…e acutely. The sentence imposed will reflect that fact. [13] See DPP v Avci (2008) 21 VR 310 at [53] – [54]; R v VZ (1998) 7 VR 693; DPP v Huby [2019] VSCA 106 at [70], [71] and [99]. [14] See the discussion in Huby at [74] and [75] referring to R v Tsiaris [1996] 1 VR 398 and R v Bullen [2005] VSCA 206. [15]Re Br…
-
Shiel v The Queen
[2017] VSCA 359
Para 20
…a and greater criminality involved will result in the continuing criminal enterprise offences attracting longer sentences. [17] See Shiel v The Queen [2017] VSCA 359 at [41].…
-
Poursanidis v The Queen
[2016] VSCA 164
Para 2
…stance; Poursanidis v The Queen[5], Porcaro v The Queen[6], R v Munt[7], Hoy v The Queen[8], Yusuf v The Queen[9] and The Queen v Fernandez[10] . [5] [2016] VSCA 164. [6] [2015] VSCA 244, (‘ Porcaro ’). [7] [2015] VSC 132, (‘ Munt ’). [8] [2012] VSCA 49, (‘ Hoy ’). [9] [2010] VSCA 266, (‘ Yusuf ’). [10] [2006] VSC…
-
Porcaro v The Queen
[2015] VSCA 244
Para 2
…The Queen[5], Porcaro v The Queen[6], R v Munt[7], Hoy v The Queen[8], Yusuf v The Queen[9] and The Queen v Fernandez[10] . [5] [2016] VSCA 164. [6] [2015] VSCA 244, (‘ Porcaro ’). [7] [2015] VSC 132, (‘ Munt ’). [8] [2012] VSCA 49, (‘ Hoy ’). [9] [2010] VSCA 266, (‘ Yusuf ’). [10] [2006] VSCA 38.…
-
R v Munt
[2015] VSC 132
Para 2
…v Munt[7], Hoy v The Queen[8], Yusuf v The Queen[9] and The Queen v Fernandez[10] . [5] [2016] VSCA 164. [6] [2015] VSCA 244, (‘ Porcaro ’). [7] [2015] VSC 132, (‘ Munt ’). [8] [2012] VSCA 49, (‘ Hoy ’). [9] [2010] VSCA 266, (‘ Yusuf ’). [10] [2006] VSCA 38.…
-
Hoy v The Queen
[2012] VSCA 49
Para 2
…f v The Queen[9] and The Queen v Fernandez[10] . [5] [2016] VSCA 164. [6] [2015] VSCA 244, (‘ Porcaro ’). [7] [2015] VSC 132, (‘ Munt ’). [8] [2012] VSCA 49, (‘ Hoy ’). [9] [2010] VSCA 266, (‘ Yusuf ’). [10] [2006] VSCA 38.…
-
Yusuf v The Queen
[2010] VSCA 266
Para 2
…rnandez[10] . [5] [2016] VSCA 164. [6] [2015] VSCA 244, (‘ Porcaro ’). [7] [2015] VSC 132, (‘ Munt ’). [8] [2012] VSCA 49, (‘ Hoy ’). [9] [2010] VSCA 266, (‘ Yusuf ’). [10] [2006] VSCA 38.…
-
R v Iles
[2009] VSCA 197
Para 7
…These contentions were derived from the decision of the Court of Appeal in R v Iles[4] per Lasry AJA at [19], [20] and [22]. [4] [2009] VSCA 197, (‘ Iles ’).…
-
RK v Mirik
[2009] VSC 14
…ic Prosecutions v Bulfin [1998] 4 VR 114; RC v R; R v RC [2020] NSWCCA 76; Re Broes [2020] VSC 128; R v Roussety [2008] VSCA 259; RK v Mirik [2009] 21 VR 623.…
-
R v Roussety
[2008] VSCA 259
Para 19
…nd 30, and the applicable maximum penalty is 20 years. On all other charges, the relevant maximum penalty is 10 years imprisonment. [16] R v Roussety [2008] VSCA 259 per Nettle JA at paragraphs [33] – [36].…
-
R v Fernandez
[2006] VSCA 38
Para 2
…[2015] VSCA 244, (‘ Porcaro ’). [7] [2015] VSC 132, (‘ Munt ’). [8] [2012] VSCA 49, (‘ Hoy ’). [9] [2010] VSCA 266, (‘ Yusuf ’). [10] [2006] VSCA 38.…
-
R v Bullen
[2005] VSCA 206
Para 15
…2019] VSCA 106 at [70], [71] and [99]. [14] See the discussion in Huby at [74] and [75] referring to R v Tsiaris [1996] 1 VR 398 and R v Bullen [2005] VSCA 206. [15]Re Broes [2020] VSC 128 at [42].…
-
Tsiadis v Patterson
[2001] VSCA 138
Para 4
…s and sentencing judges need to be cautious in not allowing that feature to distract attention from the importance of general deterrence. [11] [1998] 4 VR 114.…
-
R v Jiminez
[1999] NSWCCA 7
Para 15
…) 7 VR 693; DPP v Huby [2019] VSCA 106 at [70], [71] and [99]. [14] See the discussion in Huby at [74] and [75] referring to R v Tsiaris [1996] 1 VR 398 and R v Bullen [2005] VSCA 206. [15]Re Broes [2020] VSC 128 at [42].…
-
R v DJH
[1998] VSCA 108
Para 15
…endure imprisonment much more acutely. The sentence imposed will reflect that fact. [13] See DPP v Avci (2008) 21 VR 310 at [53] – [54]; R v VZ (1998) 7 VR 693; DPP v Huby [2019] VSCA 106 at [70], [71] and [99]. [14] See the discussion in Huby at [74] and [75] referring to R v Tsiaris [1996] 1 VR 398 and R v Bulle…