-
Thornton v The Queen
[2021] VSCA 325
Citation 1
…n v The Queen (2014) VR 308; Worboyes v The Queen [2021] VSCA 169 , R v Merrett and others (2007) 14 VR 392; Col Thornton v The Queen [2021] VSCA 325; Re Diab [2020] VSC 196; DPP (Cth) v Stanley (a pseudonym) 2020 VCC 898 Sentence: WILSON – 18 month CCO with conditions (s.6AAA 3 years with non-parole period of 2 y…
-
Chenhall v The Queen
[2021] VSCA 175
Citation 2
(Para 32)
…erceptible amelioration of sentence. [20] [2021] VSCA 169, [39]. See also DPP v Bourke [2020] VSC 130 at [32]; Chenhall v The Queen [2021] VSCA 175, at [34]–[35]. 72Each plea in my view warrants a significant moderation of the sentence to be imposed, though I repeat I do not value the pleas in quite the same way.…
-
Worboyes v The Queen
[2021] VSCA 169
Citation 3
…parity. Legislation Cited: Crimes Act 1958; Sentencing Act 1991 Cases Cited: Boulton v The Queen (2014) VR 308; Worboyes v The Queen [2021] VSCA 169 , R v Merrett and others (2007) 14 VR 392; Col Thornton v The Queen [2021] VSCA 325; Re Diab [2020] VSC 196; DPP (Cth) v Stanley (a pseudonym) 2020 VCC 898 Sentence:…
-
R v Merrett
[2007] VSCA 1
Citation 4
…58; Sentencing Act 1991 Cases Cited: Boulton v The Queen (2014) VR 308; Worboyes v The Queen [2021] VSCA 169 , R v Merrett and others (2007) 14 VR 392; Col Thornton v The Queen [2021] VSCA 325; Re Diab [2020] VSC 196; DPP (Cth) v Stanley (a pseudonym) 2020 VCC 898 Sentence: WILSON – 18 month CCO with conditions (s.…
-
Singh v Lugondela (Costs)
[2020] VSC 799
Citation 5
…i , [59]–[67]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]. [30] DPP v Osman [2020] VCC 638, [87]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]; DPP v McInnes [2020] VSC 799, [35]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]. [31] Teplin , [43]; DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [41]. 75Specifically, Wilson was unbale to receive visits from his family for most of the time on…
-
Re Diab
[2020] VSC 196
Citation 6
…08; Worboyes v The Queen [2021] VSCA 169 , R v Merrett and others (2007) 14 VR 392; Col Thornton v The Queen [2021] VSCA 325; Re Diab [2020] VSC 196; DPP (Cth) v Stanley (a pseudonym) 2020 VCC 898 Sentence: WILSON – 18 month CCO with conditions (s.6AAA 3 years with non-parole period of 2 years) SCOTT – combinatio…
-
DPP v Bourke
[2020] VSC 130
Citation 7
(Para 32)
…ensure that the plea of guilty results in a perceptible amelioration of sentence. [20] [2021] VSCA 169, [39]. See also DPP v Bourke [2020] VSC 130 at [32]; Chenhall v The Queen [2021] VSCA 175, at [34]–[35]. 72Each plea in my view warrants a significant moderation of the sentence to be imposed, though I repeat I…
-
DPP v Bietman
[2020] VCC 894
Citation 8
…DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]; Hoblos , [121]. [24] DPP v Zampatti [2020] VCC 628, [59]-[67] ( Zampatti ); DPP v Bietman [2020] VCC 894, [63]; Teplin , [44]; Williams , [75]. [25] Stanley , [63]; DPP v Danci [2020] VCC 575, [55]. [26] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Teplin , [44]. [27] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; DPP v Noble [2…
-
DPP v Teplin
[2020] VCC 846
Citation 9
…efit.[31] [22] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; DPP v Sulieman & Mahmoud [2020] VCC 454, [81]–[88] ( Sulieman ); DPP v Teplin [2020] VCC 846, [44] ( Teplin ); DPP v Williams & Anor [2020] VCC 739, [75] ( Williams ); DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [42]; DPP v Hoblos [2020] VCC 720, [121] ( Hoblos ). [23] Diab , [38];…
-
DPP v Lang
[2020] VCC 759
Citation 10
…Teplin , [44]. [27] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; DPP v Noble [2020] VCC 600, [50] ( Noble ); Hoblos , [121]. [28] DPP v Lang [2020] VCC 759, [117]; Noble , [51]. [29] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]. [30] DPP v Osman [2020] VCC 638, [87]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]; DPP v McInnes [2020] VSC 799, [35]; DPP v Vu [202…
-
DPP v Vu
[2020] VCC 775
Citation 11
…] VCC 631, [42]; DPP v Hoblos [2020] VCC 720, [121] ( Hoblos ). [23] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; Teplin , [44]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]; Hoblos , [121]. [24] DPP v Zampatti [2020] VCC 628, [59]-[67] ( Zampatti ); DPP v Bietman [2020] VCC 894, [63]; Teplin , [44]; Williams , [75]. [25] Stanley , [63]; DPP v…
-
DPP v Williams & Anor
[2020] VCC 739
Citation 12
…man & Mahmoud [2020] VCC 454, [81]–[88] ( Sulieman ); DPP v Teplin [2020] VCC 846, [44] ( Teplin ); DPP v Williams & Anor [2020] VCC 739, [75] ( Williams ); DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [42]; DPP v Hoblos [2020] VCC 720, [121] ( Hoblos ). [23] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; Teplin , [44]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775…
-
DPP v Hoblos
[2020] VCC 720
Citation 13
…] ( Teplin ); DPP v Williams & Anor [2020] VCC 739, [75] ( Williams ); DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [42]; DPP v Hoblos [2020] VCC 720, [121] ( Hoblos ). [23] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; Teplin , [44]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]; Hoblos , [121]. [24] DPP v Zampatti [2020] VCC 628, [59]-[67] ( Zampatti ); DP…
-
DPP v Barnfield
[2020] VCC 631
Citation 14
…); DPP v Teplin [2020] VCC 846, [44] ( Teplin ); DPP v Williams & Anor [2020] VCC 739, [75] ( Williams ); DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [42]; DPP v Hoblos [2020] VCC 720, [121] ( Hoblos ). [23] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; Teplin , [44]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]; Hoblos , [121]. [24] DPP v Zampatti [2020]…
-
DPP v Osman
[2020] VCC 638
Citation 15
…DPP v Lang [2020] VCC 759, [117]; Noble , [51]. [29] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]. [30] DPP v Osman [2020] VCC 638, [87]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]; DPP v McInnes [2020] VSC 799, [35]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]. [31] Teplin , [43]; DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [41]. 75Specifically, Wilson was unba…
-
DPP v Zampatti
[2020] VCC 628
Citation 16
…os ). [23] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; Teplin , [44]; DPP v Vu [2020] VCC 775, [27]; Hoblos , [121]. [24] DPP v Zampatti [2020] VCC 628, [59]-[67] ( Zampatti ); DPP v Bietman [2020] VCC 894, [63]; Teplin , [44]; Williams , [75]. [25] Stanley , [63]; DPP v Danci [2020] VCC 575, [55]. [26] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Te…
-
DPP v Noble
[2020] VCC 600
Citation 17
…]; DPP v Danci [2020] VCC 575, [55]. [26] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Teplin , [44]. [27] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; DPP v Noble [2020] VCC 600, [50] ( Noble ); Hoblos , [121]. [28] DPP v Lang [2020] VCC 759, [117]; Noble , [51]. [29] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Sulieman , [81]–[88]. [30] DPP v Osman [2020] VCC 638, [87]; Suliema…
-
DPP v Danci
[2020] VCC 575
Citation 18
…]-[67] ( Zampatti ); DPP v Bietman [2020] VCC 894, [63]; Teplin , [44]; Williams , [75]. [25] Stanley , [63]; DPP v Danci [2020] VCC 575, [55]. [26] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; Teplin , [44]. [27] Zampatti , [59]–[67]; DPP v Noble [2020] VCC 600, [50] ( Noble ); Hoblos , [121]. [28] DPP v Lang [2020] VCC 759, [117]; No…
-
Director of Public Prosecutions v Suleiman
[2020] VCC 454
Citation 19
…k) making the plea of guilty of greater utilitarian benefit.[31] [22] Diab , [38]; Stanley , [63]; DPP v Sulieman & Mahmoud [2020] VCC 454, [81]–[88] ( Sulieman ); DPP v Teplin [2020] VCC 846, [44] ( Teplin ); DPP v Williams & Anor [2020] VCC 739, [75] ( Williams ); DPP v Barnfield [2020] VCC 631, [42]; DPP v Hob…