Dostal v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Dostal v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited [2006] NSWWCCPD 272

APPELLANT:  Zdenka Dostal

RESPONDENT:              Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited

INSURERS:1.        Allianz Australia Workers

Compensation (NSW) Limited on risk from 31 July 1987 to 31 January 2002.

2.Coles Myer Pty Limited as Self Insurer on risk from 31 January 2002 to date.

FILE NUMBER:  WCC221-06

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          18 April 2006

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  16 October 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Determination of issues outside the identified ‘preliminary issues’; procedural fairness.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Holman Webb

Respondent:    (i)        In the interests of

Allianz: Hicksons Lawyers

(ii)In the interests of the

Self Insurer Lander & Rogers, Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  1.   The decision of the Arbitrator dated 18 April 2006 is revoked and the following decision is substituted:

“That the Applicant Ms Dostal suffered from two separate injuries pursuant to section 4(b)(ii) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, the first one on 15 December 2001 and a second injury on 19 April 2003.”

2.   The matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination of Ms Dostal’s entitlements to compensation in accordance with the reasons stated in this decision.

3.   The Respondent, Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited, is to pay the costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. Zdenka Dostal (‘Ms Dostal’) was employed by Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited (‘Coles’) at its Hurstville store in the dairy department. She claimed that on 15 December 2001 whilst unloading a shipment of dairy she developed pain in her lower back, and that in April 2003 whilst lifting heavy stock she again suffered pain in her back. She further claimed that in June 2003 the pain in her lower back became worse and that in addition, the nature and conditions of her employment with Coles from December 2001 “to date and continuing” caused and/or contributed to the “injuries” to her back.

  1. In her statement dated 21 May 2005, Ms Dostal claimed that she was still employed by Coles on reduced hours and selected duties.

  1. Coles was insured by Allianz Australia Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘Allianz’) from 31 July 1987 to 31 January 2002, and thereafter by Coles Myer Pty Limited as Self Insurer (‘the Self Insurer’).

  1. Ms Dostal notified Coles of her injuries in December 2001, April 2003 and June 2003.

  1. On 14 November 2003 the Self Insurer wrote to Ms Dostal advising that “… liability for on going benefits has been declined effective from the date of this letter.”

  1. On 10 January 2006 Ms Dostal filed an ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in the Commission seeking weekly benefits compensation, medical, hospital or related expenses and permanent impairment/pain and suffering compensation pursuant to the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’) and the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the 1998 Act’).

  1. In its ‘Reply’ filed on 2 February…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dostal v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 272
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Dostal v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited was heard by the Commission, where the appeal concerned the decision of an arbitrator regarding the nature and extent of an injury sustained by Ms Dostal. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the arbitrator’s finding that Ms Dostal suffered from two separate injuries was within the scope of the dispute as agreed upon by the parties. Specifically, the court had to determine if the arbitrator exceeded her authority by considering an issue outside the agreed scope of the arbitration, which was limited to whether Ms Dostal had suffered from a disease process or frank injury.

In considering the matter, the court examined the evidence and submissions presented to the arbitrator, including medical reports and testimonies, as well as the agreed terms of the dispute. The court noted that the submissions made by the parties during the arbitration focused solely on whether Ms Dostal suffered from an aggravation of a disease or a frank injury, and not on the issue of recovery from the injury. The court found that the arbitrator’s conclusion that Ms Dostal suffered from two separate injuries fell within the scope of the agreed dispute, as it related directly to the aggravation of a disease or injury, which was the agreed topic of the arbitration.

The court concluded that the arbitrator’s decision was within the ambit of the agreed dispute, and thus the appeal was not justified. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. The court determined that it had sufficient information to proceed with the appeal based on the papers and the transcript of the arbitration proceedings. The court did not find any basis to interfere with the arbitrator’s decision, thereby upholding the original determination.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Ms Dostal, who was employed by Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited, claiming workers' compensation for injuries she sustained during her employment. The specific dispute centres on whether Ms Dostal suffered from a disease process or a frank injury, and whether the Arbitrator's findings were within the scope of the dispute. The Arbitrator had conducted a teleconference on 24 March 2006 and subsequently issued a 'Statement of Reasons'. The parties had agreed that the primary issue to be determined was whether Ms Dostal had suffered from a disease process or frank injury, as outlined in section 4(b)(ii) of the 1987 Act. The Arbitrator analysed medical evidence and concluded that Ms Dostal suffered from two separate injuries, which included the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation, or deterioration of a disease due to her employment. Submissions from the legal representatives for Allianz and the Self Insurer focused on the issue of disease or injury, but no submissions were made regarding recovery from injury.

The matter originated from a dispute between Ms Dostal and Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Limited concerning workers' compensation. The dispute was initially arbitrated, with an Arbitrator issuing a 'Statement of Reasons'. An appeal was filed by one of the parties within the prescribed time limits under section 352(4) of the 1998 Act. The appeal was deemed suitable for determination 'on the papers'. The Deputy President, having reviewed the material before the Arbitrator, the transcript, and the parties' submissions, decided to proceed with the appeal 'on the papers'. The central issue was whether the Arbitrator's finding in paragraph 35 of the 'Statement of Reasons' was beyond the scope of the agreed dispute.

Decision

Reasons for decision

No amount of compensation has been awarded in this matter however, as Deputy President Byron said in Mawson v Fletchers International Exports Pty Limited [2002] NSWWCCPD 5 “The ‘decision’ in each instance is not restricted to an ‘award’”. In section 352(8) of the 1998 Act, “… ‘decision’ includes an award, interim award, order, determination, ruling and direction” such that the Commission constituted by a Presidential Member has power to review the Arbitrator’s decision. The appeal was filed within the time limits prescribed by section 352(4) of the 1998 Act. Accordingly, leave to appeal is granted. All parties submit that the appeal is suitable for a determination ‘on the papers’. Having carefully read all the material before the Arbitrator, the transcript, and the parties’ submissions on appeal, I am satisfied that I have sufficient information within the meaning of section 354 of the 1998 Act and in accordance with Practice Direction No. 1 to proceed ‘on the papers’, and that this is the appropriate course in the circumstances. The only issue is whether the Arbitrator’s finding in paragraph 35 of the ‘Statement of Reasons’ to which I have previously referred was outside the ambit of the dispute to be determined between the parties. I have been unable to locate any notes made by the Arbitrator following the Teleconference on 24 March 2006 nonetheless, the transcript of 31 March 2006 at page 1 records the Arbitrator’s statement as follows: Again, at paragraph 14 of the ‘Statement of Reasons’ the Arbitrator noted “The parties have agreed that the only issue to be determined at this time is whether the Applicant has suffered from a disease process or frank injury/injuries.” In the ‘Statement of Reasons’ the Arbitrator then proceeded to identify the various documents before her and to analyse the medical evidence before reaching her conclusion, in paragraph 35, that Ms Dostal suffered from “… two separate injuries within the meaning of section 4(b)(ii) of the 1987 Act.” Section 4(b)(ii) of the 1987 Act provides that an injury includes “the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of any disease, where the employment was a contributing factor to the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration; …” The transcript records the legal representative for Allianz making submissions on this issue contained at pages 1, 2 and 4 of the transcript. Those submissions were entirely on the issue as to whether or not Ms Dostal suffered from an aggravation of a ‘disease’ or frank injury. Whilst submissions were made to the effect that Ms Dostal continues in “the same work that was causing her the problems previously …” nothing was put to the Arbitrator on the issue of ‘recovery’ from any ‘injury’. The legal representative for the Self Insurer made submissions contained at pages 4 to 6 of the transcript. A submission was made to the effect that Ms Dostal had been certified “fit for pre-injury duties” but in the context of a submission that “if it was a disease, a disease does not resolve.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the scope of the dispute as agreed upon by the parties, which was limited to whether Ms Dostal had suffered from a disease process or frank injury. The Arbitrator's finding in paragraph 35 that Ms Dostal suffered from two separate injuries was beyond the agreed scope of the dispute. The court noted that the submissions made by the legal representatives for Allianz and the Self Insurer were focused on the existence of an injury rather than addressing the issue of Ms Dostal's recovery from any injury. The court emphasised that the Arbitrator had not been presented with submissions on the issue of recovery, and therefore the finding on recovery was outside the scope of the dispute. The court relied on the agreed terms of the dispute and the submissions made to the Arbitrator to conclude that the Arbitrator's finding on recovery was not within the scope of the dispute. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that findings made by an arbitrator that go beyond the agreed scope of the dispute are outside the ambit of the dispute to be determined between the parties.