Coledale District Hospital v Harrison-Shaw

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Coledale District Hospital v Harrison-Shaw [2005] NSW WCC PD 139

APPELLANT:  Coledale District Hospital (Illawarra Area Health Service)

RESPONDENT:  Sharon Harrison-Shaw

INSURER:GIO Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd

FILE NUMBER:  WCC 20076-03

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          30 August 2004

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  23 November 2005

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Procedural fairness; determination of ‘preliminary issues’.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant: Turks Legal

Respondent: Lyons & Lyons, Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  1.         The decision of the Arbitrator is

revoked.

2.        The matter is referred to the Registrar

to remit to another Arbitrator to determine all issues in accordance with the reasons stated in this decision.

3.        No order as to the costs of the Appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. Sharon Harrison-Shaw (‘the Respondent Worker’), was employed by Coledale District Hospital, (‘the Appellant Employer’), as an enrolled nurse. She claims that on or about 22 April 1992 whilst lifting a patient with a wardsman, she sustained an injury to her lower back. She continued to work for the Appellant Employer and various other employers over subsequent years.

  1. She lodged a claim for compensation in respect of the alleged injury in April 1992 against the Appellant Employer’s insurer on 15 August 2001. The insurer denied liability for the claim.

  1. On 25 March 2002, the Respondent Worker lodged an Application for Determination in the former Compensation Court claiming weekly benefits, medical expenses and lump sum compensation as a result of that injury pursuant to the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’). The proceedings were transferred to the Workers Compensation Commission on 4 December 2003.

  1. On 9 February 2004, the Respondent Worker lodged an Application to Resolve a Dispute in the Commission seeking similar entitlements. The Appellant Employer lodged a reply on 1 March 2004. The Appellant Employer in its Reply, disputed whether the Respondent Worker was injured as alleged or at all and further, that the Respondent Worker was not entitled to recover compensation by reason of section 61(1) of the Work Place Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the 1998 Act’) and the former section 92 of the 1987 Act because she had failed to give notice of the alleged injury to the Appellant Employer, and failed to make a claim for compensation within six months after the injury.

  1. The matter was listed for a teleconference on 10 May 2004. The Arbitrator determined that the issues of failure to give notice and late making of the claim, should be decided as preliminary issues before any further determination of the Application, including referral of a medical dispute to an Approved Medical Specialist.

  1. At that teleconference, the parties agreed to the determination of these preliminary issues ‘on the papers’. Both parties, as directed, then filed written submissions on the issues noted by the Arbitrator.

  1. A Certificate of Determination issued on 30 August 2005. Due to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coledale District Hospital v Harrison-Shaw and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWWCCPD 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Coledale District Hospital (Illawarra Area Health Service), an appellant employer, appealed against a decision of the Workers Compensation Commission in relation to a claim made by Sharon Harrison-Shaw, a respondent worker who was an enrolled nurse. The respondent worker alleged that she sustained an injury to her lower back while lifting a patient at work on or about 22 April 1992. The insurer denied liability for the claim. The appellant employer disputed whether the respondent worker was injured as alleged or at all, and further that the respondent worker was not entitled to recover compensation under the Work Place Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 because she had failed to give notice of the alleged injury to the appellant employer, and failed to make a claim for compensation within six months after the injury. The appeal was brought against the decision of the arbitrator who determined that the respondent worker was not barred from recovering compensation by section 61 of the 1998 Act or section 92 of the 1987 Act. The appeal raised issues of law and fact, including whether the respondent worker suffered a frank injury arising out of or in the course of her employment on or about 22 April 1992, and whether the respondent worker had given notice of injury as required by section 61 of the 1998 Act. The court held that the arbitrator's decision was flawed as to his determination on the issue of 'injury', and that the nature of the error made by the arbitrator in this case was such that his decision cannot stand. The decision of the arbitrator was revoked and the matter was referred to the registrar to remit to another arbitrator to determine all issues in accordance with the reasons stated in this decision. No order was made as to the costs of the appeal.

The court found that the arbitrator had exceeded the limitations on the nature of his determination as notified and agreed to by the parties, and that this amounted to an error of law. The court also found that the arbitrator had failed to determine only the issue that was the subject of his earlier direction, and that this amounted to a denial of natural justice and procedural fairness in the conduct of the matter. The court held that the parties were entitled to rely upon the arbitrator's directions in relation to the ongoing conduct of this matter, and that there had been a denial of procedural fairness in the determination of the substantive matter by the arbitrator. The court concluded that the decision of the arbitrator was flawed and could not stand, and that it was not possible on the material before the court to substitute its own decision. The decision of the arbitrator was revoked and the matter was referred to the registrar to remit to another arbitrator to determine all issues in accordance with the reasons stated in this decision. No order was made as to the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sharon Harrison-Shaw, an enrolled nurse, claims she sustained a lower back injury on or about 22 April 1992 while lifting a patient at Coledale District Hospital, where she was employed. She continued working for various employers after the alleged injury. In April 1992, she lodged a claim for compensation against the hospital's insurer on 15 August 2001, which was denied. On 25 March 2002, she filed an Application for Determination in the former Compensation Court for weekly benefits, medical expenses, and lump sum compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The proceedings were transferred to the Workers Compensation Commission on 4 December 2003. The hospital, through its insurer, disputed the injury claim, alleging it was not reported or claimed within the statutory period. The matter was set for a teleconference on 10 May 2004, where it was agreed to determine the notice and late claim issues on the papers. Both parties submitted written arguments, and the Arbitrator issued a Certificate of Determination on 30 August 2004, finding that the worker was not barred from recovering compensation. The hospital appealed this decision on 3 March 2005.

The case began with Sharon Harrison-Shaw lodging a claim for workers' compensation against Coledale District Hospital's insurer on 15 August 2001, following an alleged injury in April 1992. The matter was transferred to the Workers Compensation Commission on 4 December 2003. On 9 February 2004, Harrison-Shaw filed an Application to Resolve a Dispute in the Commission, which the hospital contested. The Arbitrator, after a teleconference on 10 May 2004, decided to address preliminary issues—failure to give notice of injury and late claim—on the papers. Both parties submitted written arguments, and the Arbitrator issued a Certificate of Determination on 30 August 2004, finding that Harrison-Shaw was not barred from recovering compensation. The hospital appealed this decision on 3 March 2005. The appeal hearing took place on the papers, and the decision was handed down on 23 November 2005.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the worker suffered a frank injury arising out of or in the course of her employment on or about 22 April 1992.
2. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the worker had given notice of injury as required by section 61 of the Work Place Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.
3. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the worker's failure to make a claim within six months of the injury was occasioned by ignorance, mistake, or other reasonable excuse.
4. Whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the 'interests of justice' required that the worker be allowed to bring her claim out of time.

Held
1. The decision of the Arbitrator dated 30 August 2004 is revoked.
2. The matter is referred to the Registrar to remit to another Arbitrator to determine all issues in accordance with the reasons stated in this decision.
3. No order as to the costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal was lodged by the Coledale District Hospital against the decision of the Arbitrator, who had determined several 'preliminary issues' in the matter of Sharon Harrison-Shaw's claim for workers' compensation. The Acting Deputy President, Deborah Moore, found that the Arbitrator had erred in law by determining the issue of whether the worker suffered a frank injury arising out of or in the course of her employment, as this was outside the scope of the preliminary issues agreed to be determined by the parties. The determination of the issue of 'injury' was considered to be a denial of procedural fairness and an error of law. The Arbitrator had proceeded to determine that the Respondent Worker had suffered a frank injury on 22 April 1992, and that her employment with the Appellant Employer was a substantial contributing factor to this injury. This amounted to a denial of procedural fairness and constituted an error of law. As the nature of the error made by the Arbitrator was such that his decision could not stand, it was not possible to substitute the Acting Deputy President's own decision on the material before her. Consequently, the decision of the Arbitrator was revoked, and the matter was referred to the Registrar to remit to another Arbitrator to determine all issues in accordance with the reasons stated in this decision. The Acting Deputy President made no order as to the costs of the appeal.