Reported Decision: (1999) NSW ConvR 55-906
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: Dorothy Jonns & Anor v Kim Seong Tan & 2 Ors [1999] NSWSC 648 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity FILE NUMBER(S): 2531/99 HEARING DATE(S): 11/06/99 JUDGMENT DATE:
11 June 1999PARTIES :
Dorothy Jonns & Nick Savvas (Ps)
Kim Seong Tan (D1)
Cenijade Pty Limited (D2)
Felderri Pty Limited (D3)JUDGMENT OF: Santow J
COUNSEL : P P O'Loughlin (P)
M T Bonnell (Sol) (D2)SOLICITORS: Peter Townsend (P)
Mallesons Stephen Jaques (D2)CATCHWORDS: EQUITY — Right of first refusal or pre-emption to tenant under lease — Right fructifies — Option then granted to third party or nominee on constructive or actual notice of right — Does tenant’s right of pre-emption as either a mere equity or as an equitable interest prevail over nominee at least on a prima facie basis to maintain injunction — Is the fructified right then still a mere equity or has it become an equitable interest in property — Unconscionable for holder of option on notice of right of pre-emption to prevail — Specific performance versus damages as an adequate remedy CASES CITED: Bahr v Nicolay No. 2 (1988) 164 CLR 604
Beneficial Finane Corporation Ltd v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd (1995) 36 NSWLR 510
Breskvar v Wall (1971) 126 CLR 367
Fraser v Walker [1967] 1 AC 569
Garcia v National Australia Bank Limited (1998) 155 ALR 614
Mackay v Wilson (1947) 47 SR(NSW) 315
Sterns Trading Pty Limited v Shteinman (1988) NSW Conv R 55-414
Tanzone v Westpac [1999] NSWSC 478
Transfield Properties v Amos Aked Swift Pty Ltd (1994) 36 NSWLR 321
Walker Corporation Limited v Pateman Pty Ltd (1990) 20 NSWLR 624DECISION: Injunction continued
Jonns.11June99 — 30 June, 1999: Dorothy Jonn & Anor v Kim Seong Tan & 2 Ors 811 June 1999
REVISED — 30 June, 1999
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
IN EQUITYSANTOW J
No. 2531/99
DOROTHY JONNS & NICK SAVVAS
PlaintiffJUDGMENT — ex tempore
KIM SEONG TAN
First Defendant
CENIJADE PTY LIMITED
Second Defendant
FELDERRI PTY LIMITED
Third DefendantINTRODUCTION
1 The Plaintiffs as holders of a right of first refusal seek a continuance of the injunction restraining the Second and Third Defendants from exercising the option, granted to the Third Defendant or its nominees, to purchase certain land consisting of Shop 11 in a shopping centre in Neutral Bay. The injunction was granted on an ex parte basis against the Second and Third Defendants. This was on the basis that the Third Defendant had nominated the Second Defendant as entitled to exercise the option. Though they were both on notice of to-day’s proceedings, only the Second Defendant attended to-day’s proceedings.
2 The Plaintiff is the lessee of the relevant shop and the First Defendant the lessor and registered proprietor. The lease was granted on 25 August 1995 and was subsequently extended on 20 May 1998. It gives the Plaintiffs a first right of refusal (“right of pre-emption”) in…
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dorothy Jonns v Kim Seong Tan and 2 Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 648
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Dorothy Jonns commenced proceedings against Kim Seong Tan, as well as two other defendants, in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute revolves around the interpretation and enforcement of a right of first refusal clause in a lease agreement. The lease in question contained a clause granting Jonns the right to match any offer received by the landlords for the property, effectively giving her a pre-emption right. The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the tenant's right of pre-emption, once it had "fructified", could be enforced against a third party who was on notice of the right, and whether the right transitioned from being a mere equity to an equitable interest upon fructification.
The court considered the nature of the pre-emption right and its status as either a mere equity or an equitable interest. It examined whether the right could be enforced against a third party who was aware of the pre-emption clause, as well as the circumstances under which it might be unconscionable for the third party to exercise their option. The court also weighed the adequacy of specific performance against damages as a remedy. Ultimately, the court found that the pre-emption right, once fructified, did indeed transform into an equitable interest, providing Jonns with a stronger claim against the third party. The court held that it would be unconscionable for the third party to proceed with the sale without respecting Jonns' pre-emption right, and thus granted an interlocutory injunction to prevent the sale from proceeding until the matter was finally determined.
The court's decision emphasised the importance of protecting equitable interests in property, particularly in situations where a tenant's right of first refusal has been triggered. The outcome reinforces the principle that it is unconscionable for a party with notice of such rights to proceed with a transaction that would otherwise infringe upon those rights. The final orders of the court included an interlocutory injunction preventing the sale of the property to the third party, pending the outcome of the proceedings.
The court considered the nature of the pre-emption right and its status as either a mere equity or an equitable interest. It examined whether the right could be enforced against a third party who was aware of the pre-emption clause, as well as the circumstances under which it might be unconscionable for the third party to exercise their option. The court also weighed the adequacy of specific performance against damages as a remedy. Ultimately, the court found that the pre-emption right, once fructified, did indeed transform into an equitable interest, providing Jonns with a stronger claim against the third party. The court held that it would be unconscionable for the third party to proceed with the sale without respecting Jonns' pre-emption right, and thus granted an interlocutory injunction to prevent the sale from proceeding until the matter was finally determined.
The court's decision emphasised the importance of protecting equitable interests in property, particularly in situations where a tenant's right of first refusal has been triggered. The outcome reinforces the principle that it is unconscionable for a party with notice of such rights to proceed with a transaction that would otherwise infringe upon those rights. The final orders of the court included an interlocutory injunction preventing the sale of the property to the third party, pending the outcome of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi