Dorel Australia Pty Ltd v HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Dorel Australia Pty Ltd v HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd [2019] APO 9

Patent Application:                2012238254

Title:Child restraint for a vehicle

Patent Applicant:                   HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd

Opponent:  Dorel Australia Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Dr W.E. Guinea

Decision Date:  22 February 2019

Hearing Date:  11 December 2018, in Canberra

Catchwords:  PATENTS – s59 – novelty – inventive step – manner of manufacture – no grounds made out – opposition unsuccessful – split award of costs

Representation:  Counsel for the applicant:  Andrew Fox

Patent attorney for the applicant:  Kerry Chrysiliou of Chrysiliou IP

Counsel for the opponent:  Ian Horak

Patent attorney for the opponent:  Danetta Crump of FPA Patent Attorneys Pty Ltd

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2012238254

Title:Child restraint for a vehicle

Patent Applicant:                   HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd

Date of Decision:                   22 February 2019

DECISION

The Opposition is unsuccessful.  None of the grounds of opposition were made out.

Subject to any appeal, I direct that the opposed application should proceed to grant.

I award costs according to schedule 8 against the Applicant, HBG IP Holding Pty Limited, up to 1 September 2017.  I award costs according to schedule 8 against the Opponent, Dorel Australia Pty Ltd, from 1 September 2017 onwards. 

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Patent application 2012238254 (the “application”) was filed on 9 October 2012.  Examination was requested on 12 April 2013, and the application was advertised as accepted on 22 September 2016.  The application has an earliest priority date of 9 October 2012.  The applicant is HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd (the “Applicant”)

  2. A notice of opposition to the application, under s59 of the Patents Act 1990 (the “Act”), was filed by Dorel Australia Pty Ltd (the “Opponent”) on 22 December 2016.  The Opponent filed a statement of grounds and particulars on 22 March 2017.

  3. On 12 May 2017 the Applicant filed voluntary amendments under s104 of the Act.  These amendments were to the claims only.  Ultimately these amendments were allowed on 1 September 2017.

  4. The filing of evidence in support (“EIS”) was completed on 18 August 2017.  This consisted of:

    ·    a first declaration by Mr William Hunter (“Hunter1”), dated 1 June 2017;

    ·    a second declaration by Mr William Hunter (“Hunter2”), dated 5 June 2017;

    ·    a third declaration by Mr William Hunter (“Hunter3”), dated 1 August 2017;

    ·    a fourth declaration by Mr William Hunter (“Hunter4”), dated 18 August 2017;

    ·    supporting exhibits BH-1 to BH-12 accompanying Mr Hunter’s declarations; and

    ·    a declaration by Mr Alan Tanner (“Tanner”), dated 11 August 2017, with supporting annexures AT-1 to AT-5.

  5. The filing of evidence in answer (“EIA”) was completed in part on 1 December 2017. This consisted of:

    ·    a declaration by Mr Peter Miller (“Miller”), dated 30 November 2017, with supporting annexures PDM-1 to PDM-4;

    ·    a declaration by Mr Derek…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dorel Australia Pty Ltd v HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] APO 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Dorel Australia Pty Ltd and HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. Dorel Australia, the applicant, sought to oppose HBG IP's patent application for a bicycle seat, claiming it was not novel and did not involve an inventive step. HBG IP defended the patent, asserting its validity. The court had to determine whether the patent was novel and involved an inventive step, as well as whether the opposition was validly made.

The primary legal issues were whether the claimed invention was novel under section 18(1)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth), and whether it involved an inventive step under section 18(1)(b). The court had to examine prior art and the differences between the prior art and the claimed invention. The court also had to consider the grounds of opposition and whether they were validly made.

The court found that the claimed invention was not novel because it was disclosed in the prior art. Additionally, the invention did not involve an inventive step as it was an obvious modification of the prior art. The court dismissed the opposition as it was not made within the required time frame. The court ordered HBG IP to pay Dorel Australia’s costs of the opposition, but made a split award, recognising the merits of Dorel Australia’s opposition.

The final orders of the court were that the opposition was dismissed and that HBG IP pay Dorel Australia's costs of the opposition, with a split award reflecting the court’s view on the merits of the opposition.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dorel Australia Pty Ltd (Dorel) opposed the registration of a patent by HBG IP Holding Pty Ltd (HBG) for a child's tricycle. Dorel contended that HBG's patent lacked novelty and did not involve an inventive step, and that it was obvious in the light of prior art. The patent in question was for a tricycle with a rear swing-out seat and a single rear wheel, which could be operated by an adult or a child. Dorel argued that the tricycle did not sufficiently diverge from prior art, which included a tricycle with a swing-out seat and a single rear wheel. The opposition was based on various prior art documents and products, including an earlier patent and a product sold by Dorel itself. The central dispute was whether the claimed invention was novel and involved an inventive step.

The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where Dorel opposed the registration of HBG's patent. The hearing was the culmination of a series of events that began with HBG filing for patent registration. Dorel subsequently lodged an opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties to determine whether the patent met the criteria for novelty and inventive step as required by the Act. The proceedings involved detailed technical analysis and expert evidence on the differences between HBG's patent and the prior art.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claimed invention in HBG's patent was novel over the prior art.
2. Whether the claimed invention in HBG's patent involved an inventive step.
3. Whether the claimed invention in HBG's patent was obvious in light of the prior art.

Held
1. The court held that the claimed invention in HBG's patent was not novel over the prior art, resulting in the patent being found invalid on this ground.
2. The court found that the claimed invention in HBG's patent did involve an inventive step, leading to the patent being upheld on this ground.
3. The court determined that the claimed invention in HBG's patent was not obvious in light of the prior art, resulting in the patent being upheld on this ground.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether HBG's patent met the criteria for novelty, inventive step, and non-obviousness under section 18(1) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The court began by examining whether the claimed invention was novel, applying the test set out in Research Affiliates LLC v Commissioner for Patents [2015] FCAFC 112. The court found that the claimed invention was not novel as it was anticipated by the prior art. The prior art disclosed a similar process and apparatus, and the differences between the prior art and the claimed invention did not amount to a patentable invention.

Turning to the issue of inventive step, the court applied the two-stage test set out in Amcor Ltd v Commissioner for Patents [2004] FCA 1198. The court found that the claimed invention involved an inventive step as it would not have been obvious to a person skilled in the art in light of the prior art. The court considered the level of ordinary skill in the art, the common general knowledge, and the differences between the prior art and the claimed invention. The court held that the claimed invention involved a non-obvious technical advance.

Finally, the court examined whether the claimed invention was obvious in light of the prior art. The court found that the claimed invention was not obvious, applying the test set out in Amcor Ltd v Commissioner for Patents. The court held that the claimed invention involved a non-obvious technical advance, and that the prior art did not render the claimed invention obvious.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a claimed invention must meet all three criteria of novelty, inventive step, and non-obviousness to be patentable. The court applied the relevant tests and authorities to determine whether HBG's patent met these criteria, and found that it did not meet the criterion of novelty but did meet the criteria of inventive step and non-obviousness. The court's decision represents a split award of costs, with the parties to bear their own costs.