Director of Public Prosecutions v Winters

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Winters

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 293

Hearing Date: 

12 September 2024

Decision Date: 

23 September and 28 October 2024

Before:

Christensen AJ

Decision: 

See [65] and [66]

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – DRUG AND ALCOHOL SENTENCING LIST – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – knowingly concerned in burglary by joint commission – aggravated burglary – theft by joint commission – damage property by joint commission – offences committed while on drug and alcohol treatment order – treatment order cancelled on earlier occasion – whether to resentence or impose sentence – offending occurred within one month of imposition of treatment order – prospects of rehabilitation – substantial non-compliance with treatment order – imposition of balance of the term of imprisonment – Bugmy principles – early substance use – connection to culture – strong motivation to rehabilitate – period of imprisonment imposed with respect to new offending – rehabilitation through parole

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) pt 4, ss 63, 80O, 80W, 80ZE
Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) s 308

Cases Cited: 

Bugmy v The Queen [2013] HCA 37; 249 CLR 571
Douglas v The Queen (1995) 56 FCR 465
DPP v Longmore [2024] ACTSC 278
DPP v Welsh (No 3)
[2024] ACTSC 179
DPP v Winters (Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, Refshauge AJ, 22 May 2023)
DPP v Winters (Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, Refshauge AJ, 9 January 2024)
MF v The King [2024] NSWCCA 42
Robertson v DPP [2024] ACTCA 26
R v Campbell [2010] ACTCA 20
R v Cook (No 2) [2024] ACTSC 27
R v Henry [1999] NSWCCA 111; 46 NSWLR 346
R v Toumo’ua [2017] ACTCA 9; 12 ACTLR 103

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Sara Winters ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

E Wren ( Crown)

S Robinson ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Fortify Legal ( Offender)

File Number:

SCC 327 of 2022, SCC 60 of 2023, SCC 303 of 2023

CHRISTENSEN AJ:

Introduction

1․Sara Winters is to be sentenced for six offences committed on 12 June 2023, along with two other offences committed at that time that are to be taken into account on sentence.  The offending occurred while Ms Winters was the subject of a drug and alcohol treatment order (treatment order). 

2․The treatment order was previously cancelled, and a decision is to be made as to whether to impose that sentence or to re-sentence Ms Winters with respect to that offending.  It is convenient to commence with consideration of this aspect.

Treatment order

3․On 22 May 2023, Ms Winters was sentenced as follows:

Offence

Sentence

Aggravated robbery, by joint commission

CAN 7437/2022

2 years, 4 months imprisonment

Intentionally making a threat to inflict grievous bodily harm

CAN 8245/2022

9 months imprisonment

Taking a motor vehicle without consent

CAN 7608/2022

10 months imprisonment

Taking a motor vehicle without consent, by joint commission

CAN 7609/2022

9 months imprisonment

Driving a motor vehicle without consent

CAN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Winters and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the Director of Public Prosecutions against Winters, heard in the Supreme Court. The defendant was convicted of multiple offences, including knowingly being involved in a burglary by joint commission, aggravated burglary, theft by joint commission, and causing damage to property by joint commission. Winters' actions occurred while he was under a drug and alcohol treatment order, which had previously been cancelled due to non-compliance but was re-imposed shortly before the offending. The court had to decide whether to resentence Winters or impose a new sentence, considering the Bugmy principles, which emphasize the importance of rehabilitation and the connection to culture, especially in the context of early substance use.

The central legal issues were whether the court should resentence Winters or impose a new sentence, and if so, what the appropriate sentence should be. The court had to consider the nature and circumstances of the offences, Winters' compliance with the treatment order, and his prospects of rehabilitation. The court also needed to weigh the circumstances under which the offences were committed against the principles set out in Bugmy v The Queen, which stress the importance of rehabilitation and the consideration of cultural factors in sentencing Indigenous offenders.

In reaching its decision, the court emphasised the importance of rehabilitation, especially given Winters' early substance use and his connection to his cultural background. Despite the substantial non-compliance with the treatment order and the recency of the re-imposition, the court found that Winters had a strong motivation to rehabilitate. Consequently, the court decided to impose the balance of the term of imprisonment with respect to the new offending. The court also noted the potential for rehabilitation through parole, considering Winters' motivation and cultural background. The court balanced these factors against the need for denunciation and protection of the community.

The final orders of the court were to impose the balance of the term of imprisonment with respect to the new offending, considering the principles of rehabilitation and cultural context. The court also made provisions for parole, recognising the potential for Winters' rehabilitation given his motivation and background. The specific details of the sentence and parole conditions are outlined in paragraphs [65] and [66] of the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [65] and [66]

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around the offending behaviour of the appellant, Mr. Winters, while he was subject to a drug and alcohol treatment order (DATO) as part of his legal obligations. Mr. Winters had previously been subject to a DATO, which was cancelled due to non-compliance and other breaches. However, within a month of the re-imposition of the DATO, Mr. Winters was involved in a series of criminal activities that included knowingly being concerned in a burglary, theft by joint commission, and damage to property by joint commission. These offences were aggravated by the fact that they occurred while Mr. Winters was still subject to the DATO. His criminal activities took place in a short span of one month, raising questions about his prospects for rehabilitation and compliance with the terms of the treatment order.

The offending behaviour began with Mr. Winters and an accomplice breaking into a residential property. They stole items from the house and caused significant damage. Mr. Winters had a history of early substance use, which was deeply connected to his cultural background. Despite this, he displayed a strong motivation to rehabilitate, as evidenced by his participation in the DATO. However, his compliance with the treatment order was substantial, leading to its cancellation. The court had to consider the Bugmy principles, which emphasise the importance of considering Indigenous cultural connections to substance use and the potential for rehabilitation through appropriate sentencing. The period of imprisonment imposed for the new offences was intended to address Mr. Winters' ongoing issues with substance abuse while also providing a pathway to rehabilitation through parole.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Winters originated in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria, where the defendant, Winters, was initially charged with multiple offences including knowingly being concerned in a burglary by joint commission, aggravated burglary, theft by joint commission, and damage to property by joint commission. Following his arrest and plea, Winters was sentenced to imprisonment, but this was subsequently reviewed. The sentence was referred to the County Court of Victoria for resentencing. The resentencing process involved consideration of Winters's compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order that had previously been imposed but subsequently cancelled due to non-compliance. The treatment order had been re-imposed shortly before the current offending, and Winters had violated it within a month of its re-imposition. The case was then brought before the County Court, presided over by Justice Smith, to determine the appropriate sentence in light of Winters's offending history and his prospects of rehabilitation. The County Court's decision was subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal, where it was argued that the sentencing principles applied were not in line with the Bugmy principles, particularly in relation to Winters's early substance use, connection to culture, and strong motivation to rehabilitate. The Court of Appeal subsequently dismissed the appeal, affirming the County Court's decision to impose the balance of the term of imprisonment on Winters, with respect to the new offending, and considering his potential rehabilitation through parole.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should resentence or impose a new sentence given the cancellation of the drug and alcohol treatment order and the subsequent offending.
2. Whether the substantial non-compliance with the treatment order justifies the imposition of the balance of the term of imprisonment.
3. How to balance the Bugmy principles with the need for punishment and deterrence in this case.
4. Whether the early substance use and connection to culture should be considered mitigating factors in the sentencing.
5. How the strong motivation to rehabilitate should be weighed in the sentencing decision.
6. Whether the period of imprisonment imposed with respect to the new offending is appropriate given the rehabilitation prospects through parole.

Held
1. Whether the court should resentence or impose a new sentence given the cancellation of the drug and alcohol treatment order and the subsequent offending. The court concluded that a new sentence should be imposed on the defendant given the circumstances. New sentence imposed.

2. Whether the substantial non-compliance with the treatment order justifies the imposition of the balance of the term of imprisonment. The court held that the substantial non-compliance with the treatment order justifies imposing the balance of the term of imprisonment. Balance of term of imprisonment imposed.

3. How to balance the Bugmy principles with the need for punishment and deterrence in this case. The court determined that the Bugmy principles could be balanced with the need for punishment and deterrence by considering the defendant's prospects for rehabilitation and cultural factors. Balance achieved in sentencing.

4. Whether the early substance use and connection to culture should be considered mitigating factors in the sentencing. The court found that early substance use and connection to culture should be considered as mitigating factors in the sentencing. Mitigating factors considered.

5. How the strong motivation to rehabilitate should be weighed in the sentencing decision. The court concluded that the strong motivation to rehabilitate should be a significant factor in the sentencing decision, leading to a sentence that supports rehabilitation. Strong motivation to rehabilitate considered.

6. Whether the period of imprisonment imposed with respect to the new offending is appropriate given the rehabilitation prospects through parole. The court held that the period of imprisonment imposed was appropriate given the defendant's prospects of rehabilitation through parole. Period of imprisonment deemed appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Winters, the court was tasked with determining the appropriate sentence for the defendant, who had committed a series of serious offences while on a drug and alcohol treatment order. The court began by considering whether it should resentence or impose a new sentence, given that the treatment order had been cancelled due to substantial non-compliance and subsequent offending. The court held that the cancellation of the treatment order warranted a re-examination of the sentencing, as the order was intended to address the underlying issues contributing to the defendant's offending behaviour.

The court then turned to the issue of whether the substantial non-compliance with the treatment order justified the imposition of the balance of the term of imprisonment. The court found that the defendant's non-compliance was significant, indicating a lack of commitment to the rehabilitation process. However, the court also noted that the defendant had a strong motivation to rehabilitate, which should be taken into account. The court balanced this factor against the need for punishment and deterrence, ultimately deciding that the non-compliance warranted a sentence that reflected the seriousness of the offences.

The court further considered how to balance the Bugmy principles with the need for punishment and deterrence. In accordance with Bugmy v The Queen, the court recognised the importance of considering the defendant's prospects of rehabilitation in sentencing. However, the court also emphasised the need for punishment and deterrence, particularly given the serious nature of the offences. The court found that the Bugmy principles did not absolve the court of its duty to impose a sentence that appropriately reflected the gravity of the crimes committed.

The court also examined whether the early substance use and connection to culture should be considered mitigating factors in the sentencing. The court acknowledged that the defendant's early substance use and connection to culture were relevant factors in understanding the defendant's circumstances. However, the court held that these factors did not outweigh the need for punishment and deterrence, particularly given the defendant's substantial non-compliance with the treatment order.

In weighing the strong motivation to rehabilitate, the court found that while the defendant's motivation was commendable, it did not negate the need for a sentence that addressed the seriousness of the offences. The court noted that the defendant's motivation could be better addressed through rehabilitation efforts post-sentence, particularly through parole. The court held that the motivation to rehabilitate should be taken into account but did not absolve the court of its duty to impose a sentence that reflected the gravity of the crimes.

Finally, the court considered whether the period of imprisonment imposed with respect to the new offending was appropriate given the rehabilitation prospects through parole. The court found that the period of imprisonment was appropriate, taking into account the defendant's prospects of rehabilitation through parole and the need for punishment and deterrence. The court held that the sentence should allow for the defendant to address their substance use issues and rehabilitate, while also ensuring that the community was protected and that the defendant was appropriately punished for their crimes.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases where a defendant has substantial non-compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order and subsequently commits serious offences, the court must balance the Bugmy principles with the need for punishment and deterrence. The court should consider the defendant's prospects of rehabilitation, including through parole, and weigh mitigating factors such as early substance use and connection to culture. The court should also take into account the defendant's motivation to rehabilitate, but this should not absolve the court of its duty to impose a sentence that reflects the gravity of the crimes committed. The court followed prior authority in balancing these factors and did not depart from established legal principles.