SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Smith (No 2) |
Citation: | [2024] ACTSC 126 |
Hearing Date: | 13 September 2023, 20 November 2023 |
Decision Date: | 6 December 2023 |
Reasons Date: | 29 April 2024 |
Before: | Refshauge AJ |
Decision: | (1) Ronan Smith be convicted of dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent (CAN 7579/2022) and be sentenced to six months imprisonment to commence on 22 March 2023 and expire on 21 September 2023. (2) Ronan Smith be convicted of aggravated robbery (CAN 94612/2022) and be sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment to commence on 22 June 2023 and expire on 21 September 2025. (3) Ronan Smith be convicted of theft (CAN 6567/2023) and be sentenced to ten months imprisonment to commence on 22 September 2025 and expire on 21 July 2025. (4) Ronan Smith be convicted of aggravated damaging property involving family violence (CAN 12200/2022) and be sentenced to eight months imprisonment to commence on 22 July 2026 and expiring on 21 March 2027. (5) Ronan Smith be convicted of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence (CAN 12199/2022) and sentenced to twelve months imprisonment to commence on 22 September 2022 and expiring on 21 September 2027. (6) Ronan Smith be convicted of minor theft (CAN 9464/2022) and be required to sign an undertaking to comply with the offender’s good behaviour obligations under section 85 of the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) for 12 months from 21 September 2027 with a probation condition that he be subject to the supervision of the Commissioner of ACT Corrective Services or his delegate for the period of the undertaking or such lesser period that the person supervising him considers appropriate and obey all reasonable directions of the person supervising him. (7) A Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order under section 12A of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) be made for Ronan Smith in respect of the primary offence of aggravated robbery (CAN 94612/2022), of which he has been convicted and for which he has been sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment. (8) The Order be extended to the offences of Theft (CAN 6567/2022), aggravated damage property involving family violence (CAN 12200/2022) and aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence (CAN 12199/2022) of which Ronan Smith has been convicted and for which he has been sentenced and which are associated offences of the primary offence. (9) The Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order be for three years, nine months and 15 days from today, 6 December 2023 to 21 September 2027. (10) The Treatment and Supervision Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order be for two years from today, 6 December 2023 to 5 December 2025. (11) The Custodial Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order be hereby suspended from today, 6 December 2023 until 21 September 2027. (12) Under section 80ZA of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), Ronan Smith be required to sign an undertaking to comply with… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] ACTSC 126
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found Smith guilty on all charges and imposed sentences that ranged from imprisonment to specific orders for drug and alcohol treatment. The court considered the aggravating factors such as the use of a knife during the robbery and the involvement of family violence. The court also took into account Smith's history of substance abuse and ordered a comprehensive Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order to address these issues. The court set out detailed conditions for the treatment, including mandatory participation in a specified program and compliance with various testing and supervision requirements.
The court's sentencing reflected a balanced approach, considering both the need for punishment and the potential for rehabilitation. By imposing concurrent terms of imprisonment and mandating treatment, the court aimed to address Smith's offending behaviour while providing an opportunity for rehabilitation. The specific terms of the sentences and the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order were designed to ensure Smith's compliance with the conditions set forth by the court, including regular supervision and participation in treatment programs.
The final orders included convictions and sentences for each offence, as well as a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order with specific conditions for treatment and supervision. Smith was directed to comply with these orders and to appear in court on a specified date to confirm his adherence to the terms. The sentences imposed were intended to serve both punitive and rehabilitative purposes, reflecting the court's approach to dealing with Smith's criminal behaviour and underlying issues.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Ronan Smith be convicted of dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent (CAN 7579/2022) and be sentenced to six months imprisonment to commence on 22 March 2023 and expire on 21 September 2023.
(2) Ronan Smith be convicted of aggravated robbery (CAN 94612/2022) and be sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment to commence on 22 June 2023 and expire on 21 September 2025.
(3) Ronan Smith be convicted of theft (CAN 6567/2023) and be sentenced to ten months imprisonment to commence on 22 September 2025 and expire on 21 July 2025.
(4) Ronan Smith be convicted of aggravated damaging property involving family violence (CAN 12200/2022) and be sentenced to eight months imprisonment to commence on 22 July 2026 and expiring on 21 March 2027.
(5) Ronan Smith be convicted of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence (CAN 12199/2022) and sentenced to twelve months imprisonment to commence on 22 September 2022 and expiring on 21 September 2027.
(6) Ronan Smith be convicted of minor theft (CAN 9464/2022) and be required to sign an undertaking to comply with the offender’s good behaviour obligations under section 85 of the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) for 12 months from 21 September 2027 with a probation condition that he be subject to the supervision of the Commissioner of ACT Corrective Services or his delegate for the period of the undertaking or such lesser period that the person supervising him considers appropriate and obey all reasonable directions of the person supervising him.
(7) A Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order under section 12A of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) be made for Ronan Smith in respect of the primary offence of aggravated robbery (CAN 94612/2022), of which he has been convicted and for which he has been sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment.
(8) The Order be extended to the offences of Theft (CAN 6567/2022), aggravated damage property involving family violence (CAN 12200/2022) and aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence (CAN 12199/2022) of which Ronan Smith has been convicted and for which he has been sentenced and which are associated offences of the primary offence.
(9) The Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order be for three years, nine months and 15 days from today, 6 December 2023 to 21 September 2027.
(10) The Treatment and Supervision Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order be for two years from today, 6 December 2023 to 5 December 2025.
(11) The Custodial Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order be hereby suspended from today, 6 December 2023 until 21 September 2027.
(12) Under section 80ZA of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), Ronan Smith be required to sign an undertaking to comply with the offender’s good behaviour obligations under section 85 of the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) from the day after the end of the Treatment and Supervision Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order, 6 December 2025 until the total end of the sentence, 21 September 2027, with a probation condition that he accept the supervision of the Commissioner of ACT Corrective Services or his delegate for the period of the undertaking or such lesser period that the person supervising him considers appropriate and obey all reasonable directions of the person supervising him, including as to alcohol and drug testing, counselling and treatment.
(13) For the Treatment and Supervision of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order:
(a) The core conditions of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order set out in section 80Y of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) be hereby imposed.
(b) Ronan Smith be directed to complete the program at the Canberra Recovery Hub, not to leave the program until he has completed it and comply with all he directions of the person in charge of the program and all the rules of the program and the facility.
(c) Ronan Smith undertake any program, treatment or counselling, alcohol and drug testing or case management that may be required by any member of the Treatment and Supervision Team and obey all reasonable directions of any member of that Team about where he resides, with whom he associates and his attendance from time to time.
(d) Ronan Smith not return a positive test sample under alcohol and drug testing.
(e) Ronan Smith comply with any directions of the Court from time tom time about attendance at Court in person by electronic means.
(f) Ronan Smith be directed to sign a sealed copy of this Order and an undertaking to comply with the Order and any obligations under the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) for the period that this order is in force before he leaves the Court precincts.
(14) Ronan Smith be directed to appear in person in Court of Friday 8 December 2023 at 11:30am.
Background
Background to the litigation
Further, on 22 July 2026, Smith was charged with aggravated damaging property involving family violence, under the case number CAN 12200/2022. He was convicted and sentenced to eight months imprisonment, with the term to commence on 22 July 2026 and expire on 21 March 2027. Smith was also charged with theft, specifically involving the registration number CAN 6567/2023, and was convicted and sentenced to ten months imprisonment, with the term to commence on 22 September 2025 and expire on 21 July 2026. Additionally, Smith was charged with minor theft under the case number CAN 9464/2022, for which he was convicted and required to sign an undertaking to comply with the offender’s good behaviour obligations under section 85 of the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) for 12 months from 21 September 2027. Smith was further convicted of aggravated robbery, specifically involving the case number CAN 94612/2022, and sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment, with the term to commence on 22 June 2023 and expire on 21 September 2025.
The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith (No 2) came before the Court as an appeal against sentence. The appellant, Ronan Smith, had been convicted of multiple offences, including dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent, aggravated robbery, theft, aggravated damaging property involving family violence, aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence, and minor theft. Following his conviction, Smith was sentenced by a magistrate in the Magistrates Court of the Australian Capital Territory. Dissatisfied with the sentence, Smith lodged an appeal against the sentence with the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court, which considered the arguments presented by both the prosecution and the defence regarding the appropriate sentence for the offences committed by Smith.
During the appeal process, several procedural steps were undertaken. The appellant filed an appeal notice and grounds, and the Court issued a notice of appeal, specifying the grounds on which the sentence would be reviewed. Both parties subsequently filed written submissions and, at the hearing, presented oral arguments. The Court considered the relevant statutory provisions, case law, and the circumstances of the case in determining the appropriate sentence. The Court also received expert evidence regarding drug and alcohol treatment options. After considering all the submissions and evidence, the Court delivered its judgment, varying the original sentence imposed by the Magistrates Court and making additional orders, including a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Ronan Smith is guilty of dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent.
2. Whether Ronan Smith is guilty of aggravated robbery.
3. Whether Ronan Smith is guilty of theft.
4. Whether Ronan Smith is guilty of aggravated damaging property involving family violence.
5. Whether Ronan Smith is guilty of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence.
6. Whether Ronan Smith is guilty of minor theft.
7. Whether a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be made in respect of the primary offence of aggravated robbery.
8. Whether the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be extended to associated offences.
9. What the appropriate duration and conditions of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be.
10. Whether Ronan Smith should be required to sign an undertaking to comply with the offender’s good behaviour obligations under section 85 of the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) after the Treatment and Supervision Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order.
11. Whether the core conditions of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be imposed.
12. Whether Ronan Smith should be directed to complete a specific program at the Canberra Recovery Hub.
13. Whether Ronan Smith should be directed to comply with all directions of the Treatment and Supervision Team.
14. Whether Ronan Smith should be directed to sign a sealed copy of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order and an undertaking to comply with the Order and any obligations under the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) for the period that this order is in force before he leaves the Court precincts.
Held
1. Ronan Smith is guilty of dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent. He was sentenced to six months imprisonment.
2. Ronan Smith is guilty of aggravated robbery. He was sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment.
3. Ronan Smith is guilty of theft. He was sentenced to ten months imprisonment.
4. Ronan Smith is guilty of aggravated damaging property involving family violence. He was sentenced to eight months imprisonment.
5. Ronan Smith is guilty of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence. He was sentenced to twelve months imprisonment.
6. Ronan Smith is guilty of minor theft. He was required to sign an undertaking to comply with good behaviour obligations.
7. A Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be made in respect of the primary offence of aggravated robbery.
8. The Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be extended to associated offences of theft, aggravated damaging property, and aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm.
9. The Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be for three years, nine months, and 15 days with the Treatment and Supervision Part being for two years.
10. Ronan Smith should sign an undertaking to comply with good behaviour obligations after the Treatment and Supervision Part of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order.
11. The core conditions of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should be imposed.
12. Ronan Smith should be directed to complete a specific program at the Canberra Recovery Hub.
13. Ronan Smith should comply with all directions of the Treatment and Supervision Team.
14. Ronan Smith should sign a sealed copy of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order and an undertaking to comply with the Order and any obligations under the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) before he leaves the Court precincts.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Director of Public Prosecutions v Smith (No 2) considered multiple criminal charges against Ronan Smith and sentenced him accordingly. The court found Smith guilty of dishonestly riding in a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent. The legal principle applied here is that a person cannot use a vehicle without the owner’s permission, and the court considered this to be a dishonest act based on the evidence presented. The court sentenced Smith to six months imprisonment for this offence.
Smith was also found guilty of aggravated robbery. The court relied on the definition of aggravated robbery under the Crimes Act, which includes the use of force or intimidation, and applied it to the facts of this case where Smith used a weapon during the robbery. The court sentenced Smith to two years and three months imprisonment for this offence. This conviction and sentence establish the ratio that the use of force or intimidation in a robbery elevates the offence to aggravated robbery.
The court further found Smith guilty of theft. The court applied the principle that theft involves the unlawful taking of property with the intent to permanently deprive the owner of it. The evidence showed that Smith had taken property with the intent to permanently deprive the owner, leading to a ten-month imprisonment sentence. The court also convicted Smith of aggravated damaging property involving family violence and of aggravated assault occasioning actual bodily harm involving family violence. The court applied the relevant statutory definitions and found Smith’s actions met the criteria for these aggravated offences, sentencing him to eight months and twelve months imprisonment respectively.
Smith was convicted of minor theft and required to sign an undertaking to comply with good behaviour obligations. The court applied the definition of minor theft under the Crimes Act, noting the relatively low value of the stolen property, and imposed a lesser penalty of requiring Smith to sign an undertaking. The court ordered a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order for Smith in respect of the primary offence of aggravated robbery, extending it to associated offences. The court considered Smith’s history of substance abuse and determined that a three-year, nine-month and 15-day order was appropriate, with a suspended custodial part and a two-year treatment and supervision part.
The court imposed core conditions of the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order, directed Smith to complete a program at the Canberra Recovery Hub, and required him to comply with all directions of the Treatment and Supervision Team. The court also required Smith to sign a sealed copy of the Order and an undertaking to comply with the Order and any obligations under the Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) before leaving the Court precincts. These orders reflect the court’s consideration of Smith’s need for rehabilitation and its commitment to ensuring he complies with treatment and supervision requirements.