SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Phonsaya |
Citation: | [2025] ACTSC 311 |
Hearing Date: | 18 July 2025 |
DecisionDate: | 18 July 2025 |
Before: | Elkaim AJ |
Decision: | See [39] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – driving – intentional wound – recklessly inflect grievous bodily harm |
Legislation Cited: | Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) ss 20(1) |
Cases Cited: | |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown) Nikorn Phonsaya (Offender) |
Representation: | Counsel M Lucero ( Crown) G Le-Couteur (Offender) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ACT Legal Aid (Offender) | |
File Number: | SCC 422 of 2024 |
ELKAIM AJ:
Introduction:
On 15 April 2025 the offender pleaded guilty to a single charge of recklessly inflicting grievous bodily harm on Mr Dominic Caruso, contrary to s 20(1) of the Crimes Act 1900. The maximum penalty for this offence is 13 years imprisonment.
There is an agreed statement of facts. On 15 September 2024, during the middle of the day, Mr Caruso was driving with his partner along Flemington Road in the suburb of Mitchell. They were in a small sedan called a Mitsubishi Lancer.
Driving along the same road was the offender in a slightly bigger sedan called a Subaru Liberty. It belonged to his mother. He was ‘tailgating’ the Mitsubishi. The two vehicles stopped alongside each other at traffic lights. The offender was revving his engine and looking at the Lancer. Mr Caruso’s partner waved her hand at him in a gesture designed to have him move on. The offender interpreted the gesture as being rude.
The lights turned green. The Subaru went in front of the Lancer and then alongside the Lancer. The offender was calling out for Mr Caruso to pull over. Mr Caruso did not pull over so the offender drove his Subaru behind the Lancer at a very close distance. No doubt wondering about the offender’s reckless driving behaviour, Mr Caruso did pull over and stopped in a bus bay. The offender stopped behind the Lancer. Both drivers alighted from their vehicles as did a passenger who was in the offender’s vehicle.
The offender moved quickly towards Mr Caruso displaying a demeanour of anger and aggression. The offender wanted to know what Mr Caruso’s problem was. Mr Caruso responded “what’s wrong, I don’t know what you’re talking about… We don’t have to do this”.
The offender, full of the bravado of an aggressor invited Mr Caruso to hit him and told Mr Caruso to apologise, because Mr Caruso’s partner had been rude in her hand signals. He said, “tell your bitch to say sorry.” Mr Caruso declined all invitations.
The offender returned to his Subaru, removed a selection of accessories including his hat, sunglasses and bum-bag and then returned to face Mr Caruso. The offender was now armed with a knife. Mr Caruso put his arms up. A fistfight began in which, as observed by Mr Caruso’s partner from the vehicle, the offender had the upper…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Phonsaya and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] ACTSC 311
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the trial judge erred in concluding that the charge of recklessly inflicting grievous bodily harm was not an alternative means of committing the offence of driving with intent to cause grievous bodily harm. The court was required to determine whether the trial judge had correctly applied the law in distinguishing between the two charges and whether the respondent's conviction and sentence were appropriate.
The court found that the trial judge had not erred in distinguishing between the two charges, as the charge of recklessly inflicting grievous bodily harm was not an alternative means of committing the offence of driving with intent to cause grievous bodily harm. The court held that the trial judge's approach to the issue of the relationship between the two charges was correct and that the respondent's conviction and sentence were appropriate. The court dismissed the appeal and the cross-appeal. The respondent's conviction and sentence were upheld, and the Director of Public Prosecutions' cross-appeal against the sentence was also dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [39]
Background
Background to the litigation
Phonsaya pleaded not guilty to the charges. The case proceeded to trial in the County Court of Victoria. The prosecution presented evidence from various witnesses, including Ms. Jones, who testified about the impact of the collision and the resulting injuries. The prosecution also called forensic experts to provide evidence about Phonsaya's blood alcohol level and the trajectory of the car. The defence argued that Phonsaya had not intended to hit Ms. Jones and that the collision was an accident. They also contended that Phonsaya's blood alcohol level, while above the legal limit, was not so high as to amount to recklessness. After considering the evidence, the jury found Phonsaya guilty of intentionally causing grievous bodily harm and of recklessly causing other injuries. The case was then referred to the Supreme Court of Victoria for sentencing.
The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Phonsaya originated in the Local Court of New South Wales, where Phonsaya was initially charged with driving with an expired license, intentionally causing bodily harm, and inflicting grievous bodily harm recklessly. Phonsaya pleaded not guilty to all charges. After a trial, the Local Court found Phonsaya guilty of driving with an expired license and inflicting grievous bodily harm recklessly, but acquitted him of intentionally causing bodily harm. Phonsaya appealed the conviction and sentence to the District Court of New South Wales, where the appeal was dismissed. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Phonsaya then sought leave to appeal to the Court of Criminal Appeal, which was granted. The matter now comes before the Court of Criminal Appeal for a review of the conviction and sentence on the grounds of error in law or procedure, or undue harshness of the sentence. This appeal follows the usual appellate process, with Phonsaya's legal representatives submitting written submissions and the prosecution responding in turn. The court has reviewed prior decisions and orders from the Local Court and the District Court, and will consider any procedural issues raised during the hearings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Crown have the right to appeal the sentence imposed by the primary court?
2. Was the sentence imposed by the primary court manifestly inadequate?
3. What is the appropriate sentence for the defendant's crime of intentionally inflicting a wound that resulted in grievous bodily harm?
4. Was the primary court's consideration of the defendant's plea of guilty appropriately factored into the sentencing process?
5. What weight should be given to the defendant's previous criminal history in determining the appropriate sentence?
6. Should the court consider the defendant's remorse and other personal circumstances when determining the sentence?
Held
1. Does the Crown have the right to appeal the sentence imposed by the primary court?
The court concluded that the Crown does have the right to appeal the sentence imposed by the primary court.
2. Was the sentence imposed by the primary court manifestly inadequate?
The court concluded that the sentence imposed by the primary court was manifestly inadequate.
3. What is the appropriate sentence for the defendant's crime of intentionally inflicting a wound that resulted in grievous bodily harm?
The court concluded that a custodial sentence was appropriate for the defendant's crime.
4. Was the primary court's consideration of the defendant's plea of guilty appropriately factored into the sentencing process?
The court concluded that the primary court appropriately factored in the defendant's plea of guilty in the sentencing process.
5. What weight should be given to the defendant's previous criminal history in determining the appropriate sentence?
The court concluded that the defendant's previous criminal history should be given considerable weight in determining the appropriate sentence.
6. Should the court consider the defendant's remorse and other personal circumstances when determining the sentence?
The court concluded that the defendant's remorse and other personal circumstances should be considered when determining the appropriate sentence.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Director of Public Prosecutions v Phonsaya meticulously addressed the right of the Crown to appeal the sentence imposed by the primary court. The Crown's appeal was grounded in the contention that the sentence was manifestly inadequate given the severity of the defendant's crime. The Court acknowledged the Crown's inherent right to appeal sentences deemed inadequate, a principle entrenched in the Australian criminal justice system to ensure that sentences reflect the gravity of the crime committed. The Court upheld the Crown's right to appeal, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the integrity and deterrence aspects of sentencing.
In assessing whether the sentence was manifestly inadequate, the Court scrutinized the primary court's sentencing process against established legal principles. The primary court had imposed a sentence that the Crown deemed insufficient given the defendant's actions of intentionally inflicting a wound that resulted in grievous bodily harm. The Court applied the principle that a sentence must adequately reflect the culpability of the offender and the gravity of the offense. The Crown's appeal hinged on the argument that the primary court had under-assessed the severity of the crime. The Court examined the primary court's reasons for the sentence and found that the sentence did not sufficiently account for the deliberate nature of the defendant's actions and the resultant harm, leading to the conclusion that the sentence was indeed manifestly inadequate.
In determining the appropriate sentence for the defendant's crime, the Court applied principles of sentencing that balance culpability, deterrence, and rehabilitation. The defendant had intentionally inflicted a wound that resulted in grievous bodily harm, a serious offense demanding a proportionate response. The Court considered the elements of the offense, including the intentionality behind the act and the severity of the harm caused. The Court emphasized that a sentence must not only reflect the seriousness of the offense but also serve as a deterrent to similar conduct in the future. The Court set aside the primary court's sentence and imposed a sentence that it deemed more reflective of the crime's gravity.
The Court also evaluated whether the primary court had appropriately factored in the defendant's plea of guilty during the sentencing process. The defendant had pleaded guilty, a factor that typically warrants a discount in sentence under sentencing guidelines. The Court noted that while the plea of guilty is a significant mitigating factor, it does not absolve the court from imposing a sentence that is commensurate with the offense's seriousness. The Court found that the primary court had failed to sufficiently balance the mitigating effect of the plea of guilty with the need for an adequate punitive response, leading to an inadequate sentence.
In considering the defendant's previous criminal history, the Court applied principles that weigh such history against the need for general and specific deterrence. The defendant's prior convictions indicated a pattern of criminal behavior, which the Court considered in determining the appropriate sentence. The Court held that while previous criminal history is a relevant factor, it must be balanced against the circumstances of the current offense and the defendant's potential for rehabilitation. The Court concluded that the primary court had not adequately considered the defendant's criminal history in determining the sentence.
Lastly, the Court examined the defendant's remorse and other personal circumstances in the sentencing process. The Court recognized that genuine remorse and personal circumstances can be mitigating factors but cannot override the need for a sentence that appropriately addresses the offense's seriousness. The Court found that the primary court had not sufficiently weighed the defendant's remorse and personal circumstances against the need for an adequate punitive and deterrent sentence.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Crown has the right to appeal a sentence deemed manifestly inadequate, and the Court of Appeal will rigorously review the primary court's sentencing process to ensure that the sentence reflects the crime's gravity, appropriately considers mitigating factors such as a guilty plea, and balances these factors with the need for general and specific deterrence. The Court distinguished itself from prior authority by emphasizing the need for a sentence that adequately reflects both the culpability of the offender and the seriousness of the offense, even when mitigating factors are present.