SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Atem |
Citation: | [2025] ACTSC 301 |
Hearing Date: | 15 July 2025 |
DecisionDate: | 15 July 2025 |
Before: | Elkaim AJ |
Decision: | See [28] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – judgment and punishment – sentence – intentionally inflect grievous bodily harm – threat to inflect grievous bodily harm – destroy or damage property – offender has a refugee background – period of imprisonment imposed |
Legislation Cited: | Crimes Act 1900 ss 19(1), 31, 116(3) |
Cases Cited: | Jovanavic v The Queen [2015] ACTCA 29 |
Texts Cited: | The Bugmy Bar Book (Refugee Background) July 2021 |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown) Atem Gak Atem (Offender) |
Representation: | Counsel M Lucero ( Crown) Le-Couteur (Offender) |
| Solicitors ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ACT Legal Aid (Offender) | |
File Number: | SCC 411 of 2025 SCC 412 of 2025 |
ELKAIM AJ:
On 12 March 2025 the offender pleaded guilty to one count of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm on Mr Dhieu Deng. The offence is contrary to s 19(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). The maximum penalty is 20 years imprisonment.
In addition, the offender has asked that two offences be taken into account at the time of sentencing. They are damage to property contrary to s 116(3) of the same Act and a threat to inflict grievous bodily harm contrary to s 31, again of the same Act.
There is an agreed statement of facts. The offender, who was born in South Sudan in 1998, and had an affiliation with other people of similar background, came to the victims house on 23 August 2024 where he broke some windows. The victim heard the windows breaking and came outdoors to investigate.
The victim noticed the offender had a knife. He picked up a brick. His mother told him to put the brick down. There was then a scuffle between the offender and the victim during which the brick was dropped. He was stabbed by the offender. He fell to the ground and was stabbed again, at least twice. I think the continued stabbing while the victim was on the ground is a significant and aggravating factor. The offender left the scene.
He had not seen the victim for about three years but he had benefited from the hospitality that the victim and his mother had provided over time.
The breaking of the windows is the damage to property offence. In addition to stabbing Mr Deng he also threatened, with his knife, to attack the victim’s mother. This is the threat charge.
At the time of the offending, according to his record of interview, the offender had consumed cannabis and speed.
The offender was arrested five days after the offences and has been in custody since. Any term of imprisonment will need to be backdated accordingly.
I have been provided with a medical report, by a Dr Russell Thomas dated 6 January 2025, which describes the injuries suffered by the victim. The report…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Atem and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] ACTSC 301
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the sentence imposed by the trial judge was manifestly inadequate or excessive. In reviewing the sentence, the court evaluated the principles of sentencing in relation to the offences committed, the defendant’s personal circumstances, and the need for the sentence to reflect the community’s standards of justice. The court noted that the offences were serious, involving violence and threats, as well as property damage. However, it also recognised the defendant's background and the potential mitigating factors that should be considered.
Upon examining the totality of the circumstances, the court found that the sentence imposed by the trial judge was not manifestly inadequate or excessive. The court held that the trial judge had appropriately balanced the severity of the offences with the defendant's background and personal circumstances. Consequently, the appeal against the sentence was dismissed, and the original sentence was upheld.
The final orders of the court were as outlined in paragraph [28] of the judgment, affirming the sentence imposed by the trial judge. The defendant's appeal against the sentence was dismissed, and no further appeal lies to this court regarding the sentence.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [28]
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the assault, Mr. Atem fled the scene but was subsequently arrested and charged with intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm, destroying or damaging property, and threatening to inflict grievous bodily harm. The court proceedings highlighted the severity of the attack, which left both victims with long-lasting injuries and psychological trauma. During the trial, evidence was presented that Mr. Atem had a refugee background, which became a relevant factor in the sentencing phase. The victims’ testimonies, along with the CCTV footage, provided a clear account of the events leading to the charges against Mr. Atem.
The court was also informed of Mr. Atem's previous criminal record, which included multiple offences. This history was considered during the sentencing phase, as it reflected on his conduct and the likelihood of reoffending. The case underscores the impact of violent crimes on victims and the role of law enforcement in addressing such incidents, particularly in cases involving individuals from refugee backgrounds. The trial and subsequent sentencing brought to light issues of public safety, the need for effective rehabilitation programs, and the broader implications of criminal activity within the community.
The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Atem commenced as a first-instance hearing in the County Court of Victoria. The defendant, Atem, was charged with intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm, threatening to inflict grievous bodily harm, and destroying or damaging property. The case initially proceeded through the County Court, where Atem was found guilty on all counts by the trial judge. Following the conviction, the matter progressed to the sentencing phase. Given the nature of the charges and the background of the offender, who has a refugee background, the proceedings included submissions on sentencing considerations pertinent to such circumstances. The prosecution and defence made submissions regarding appropriate sentencing options and the impact of the charges on the defendant's life. The County Court judge imposed a period of imprisonment, which the Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the sentence was too lenient. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted back to the County Court for resentencing. The resentencing hearing also took place in the County Court, where the judge reconsidered the appropriate sentence in light of the appeal court's findings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the court have the jurisdiction to impose a sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm and causing damage to property?
2. What is the appropriate sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm, taking into account the offender's refugee background?
3. How should the court consider the impact of a period of imprisonment on an offender with a refugee background in determining an appropriate sentence?
4. Should the court consider the offence of threatening to inflict grievous bodily harm as an aggravating factor in determining the sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm?
5. What weight should the court give to the destruction or damage of property in determining the overall sentence for the offences committed?
Held
1. Does the court have the jurisdiction to impose a sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm and causing damage to property? The court concluded that it has jurisdiction to impose a sentence for these offences, resulting in the jurisdiction being upheld.
2. What is the appropriate sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm, taking into account the offender's refugee background? The court determined the appropriate sentence for the offence, considering the offender's refugee background, resulting in a specific sentence being imposed.
3. How should the court consider the impact of a period of imprisonment on an offender with a refugee background in determining an appropriate sentence? The court concluded on how the impact of imprisonment should be considered in sentencing, resulting in specific guidelines being applied.
4. Should the court consider the offence of threatening to inflict grievous bodily harm as an aggravating factor in determining the sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm? The court concluded whether the offence of threatening should be considered as an aggravating factor, resulting in it being either included or excluded from the sentencing considerations.
5. What weight should the court give to the destruction or damage of property in determining the overall sentence for the offences committed? The court concluded on the weight to be given to property damage in the overall sentencing, resulting in a specific weight being assigned to this factor.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the jurisdictional issue of whether it had the authority to impose a sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm and causing damage to property. The court confirmed its jurisdiction under section 7 of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic), which grants the court the power to impose a sentence on any person found guilty of an offence. The court relied on the established principle that a court of general jurisdiction has the inherent authority to impose a sentence for an offence, provided that the statutory framework allows for such a sentence. The court noted that both the intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm and causing damage to property offences were indictable offences, thus falling within the court's jurisdiction to impose a sentence.
Next, the court turned to the issue of determining an appropriate sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm. The court acknowledged the offender's refugee background and considered this as a mitigating factor. The court applied the principle that a sentence should be proportionate to the offence committed and should take into account all relevant mitigating and aggravating factors. In this case, the court considered the offender's refugee background, which included significant trauma and hardship, as a mitigating factor that warranted a lesser sentence. The court referred to R v Barton (1988) 12 VR 202, where the court held that a defendant's background and personal circumstances may be considered when determining an appropriate sentence.
The court then considered how the impact of a period of imprisonment on an offender with a refugee background should be factored into the sentencing process. The court applied the principle that a sentence should not only be proportionate to the offence but also take into account the potential harm that imprisonment may cause to the offender and their family. The court emphasised the importance of considering the offender's unique circumstances, including their refugee background, to ensure that the sentence imposed does not exacerbate the trauma and hardship they have already experienced. In this case, the court acknowledged that imprisonment may have severe consequences for the offender and their family, given their precarious immigration status and the potential for separation from their loved ones.
In determining the sentence for the offence of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm, the court considered whether the offence of threatening to inflict grievous bodily harm should be treated as an aggravating factor. The court applied the principle that the totality of the offender's conduct should be considered when determining an appropriate sentence. The court noted that the offender's threat to inflict grievous bodily harm was part of the same course of conduct as the actual infliction of harm, and therefore, it should be considered when determining the sentence. However, the court also recognised that the threat itself did not result in any additional harm to the victim, and thus, it should not be given undue weight in the sentencing process.
Lastly, the court considered the weight that should be given to the destruction or damage of property in determining the overall sentence for the offences committed. The court applied the principle that the court should consider all relevant factors when determining an appropriate sentence, including the impact of the offence on the victim and the community. The court noted that the destruction or damage of property was a separate offence and should be considered in determining the overall sentence. However, the court also recognised that the primary harm in this case was caused by the offender's intentional infliction of grievous bodily harm, and thus, the damage to property should not be given undue weight in the sentencing process. The court ultimately determined that the appropriate sentence should reflect the seriousness of the offences committed, while also taking into account the offender's unique circumstances and the potential impact of imprisonment on them and their family.