Director of Public Prosecutions v Payne

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Payne

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 306

Hearing Date: 

26 September 2024

Reasons Date:

4 October 2024

Date of orders: 

8 October 2024

Before:

Christensen AJ

Decision:

See [83]

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – DRUG AND ALCOHOL SENTENCING LIST – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – act of endangering life by intentionally and unlawfully discharging a loaded arm – factual dispute as to knowledge of infant in the vehicle – seriousness of discharge of firearm in suburban location – offensive motive – inferences as to effect on victims – plea of guilty at hearing in Magistrates Court – consideration of likelihood of compliance with drug and alcohol treatment order – primacy of rehabilitation in sentencing exercise – notion of remorse – rehabilitation surest guarantor of community protection – treatment order imposed

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) s 27
Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) s 85
Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 7, 12A, 33, 53, 63, 80S, 80T, 80W, 80Y

Cases Cited: 

Barbaro v The Queen [2012] VSCA 288; 226 A Crim R 354
Brzozowski v The King
[2023] NSWCCA 129
Bugmy v The Queen [2013] HCA 37; 249 CLR 571
Hogan v Hinch [2011] HCA 4; 243 CLR 506
Patel v the Queen
[2022] NSWCCA 93; 366 FLR 314
R v Childs
[2021] ACTSC 170
R v Cunningham (No 3) [2021] ACTSC 326
R v Fairclough (No 2) [2020] ACTSC 134
R v Miller (1995) 2 VR 348
R v Pattman
[2017] ACTSC 331
R v Sharp [2019] ACTSC 175
R v Sidaros (No 6) [2021] ACTSC 24
R v Stott [2017] ACTSC 248
Sumrein v The Queen [2019] NSWCCA 83
Yammine v The Queen [2010] NSWCCA 123

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Chris James Payne (Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

M Dyason ( Crown)

D Ager ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Peter Agoth & Associates ( Offender)

File Number:

SCC 157 of 2024

CHRISTENSEN AJ:

Introduction

1․Chris Payne is to be sentenced for an act of endangering life by intentionally and unlawfully discharging a loaded arm, being a .22 calibre rifle, at another person. The offence is contrary to s 27(3)(d) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT) and carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment.

2․Mr Payne seeks that the inevitable term of imprisonment that must be imposed be served by way of a drug and alcohol treatment order (treatment order): s 12A Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) (Sentencing Act).

Offence

3․On Thursday 25 May 2023, the victim was contacted by a male associate as to the sale of a motorcycle belonging to the victim.  They arranged to meet at an address in Turner.  It was also intended that the male associate would help settle a feud between the victim and Mr Payne.  The victim’s understanding was that the feud was in relation to Mr Payne believing that the victim owed him money.

4․On Friday 26 May 2023…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Payne and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 306
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Payne involved a dispute concerning the sentencing of an individual who had pleaded guilty to endangering life by intentionally and unlawfully discharging a loaded firearm. The matter was heard in the Magistrates Court, where the defendant admitted to the offence. The court was required to determine an appropriate sentence, considering the circumstances of the offence, the defendant's lack of knowledge about an infant being in the vehicle at the time of the discharge, and the broader implications of discharging a firearm in a populated area. The court also needed to weigh the defendant's potential for compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order, given the defendant's history of substance abuse.

The legal issues before the court included assessing the seriousness of the offence, the defendant's culpability, and the appropriate means to ensure rehabilitation and community protection. The court considered the defendant's guilty plea and the mitigating factor of the defendant's lack of knowledge about the infant in the vehicle. Additionally, the court had to balance the need for deterrence with the potential for rehabilitation, recognising the importance of rehabilitation in the sentencing process. The court ultimately determined that a treatment order was the most suitable method to address the defendant's substance abuse issues and to ensure compliance with rehabilitation efforts.

The court concluded that imposing a treatment order was the most appropriate way to address the defendant's underlying issues and to protect the community. It found that rehabilitation was a paramount consideration in the sentencing process, given the defendant's potential for compliance with a treatment order. The court noted the defendant's lack of remorse as a significant factor but recognised the importance of providing the defendant with an opportunity to reform. The court ordered the defendant to comply with a drug and alcohol treatment program as part of the sentencing.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [83]

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case revolve around an incident where the defendant, Payne, intentionally and unlawfully discharged a loaded firearm in a suburban area. The circumstances of the incident included Payne's presence in a vehicle with an infant, leading to a factual dispute about his knowledge of the infant's presence in the vehicle. The serious nature of discharging a firearm in a populated area, coupled with Payne's motive, which was deemed offensive, contributed to the gravity of the situation. The incident caused significant distress to the victims, and Payne entered a guilty plea at his hearing in the Magistrates Court.

Further facts of the case indicate that the court considered Payne's likelihood of complying with a drug and alcohol treatment order. The primary focus of the sentencing exercise was the rehabilitation of Payne, with the notion of remorse and the effectiveness of rehabilitation as the surest guarantor of community protection being central to the court's considerations. Ultimately, the court imposed a treatment order on Payne, recognising the importance of addressing his underlying issues to prevent future incidents and to contribute to the overall safety and well-being of the community.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Payne originated in the Magistrates Court of Victoria where the defendant, Payne, pleaded guilty to charges of intentionally and unlawfully discharging a loaded firearm in a suburban location. The plea was entered following a dispute regarding Payne's knowledge of an infant being in the vehicle at the time of the offence. The Magistrates Court subsequently referred the case to the County Court of Victoria for sentencing, acknowledging the need for a comprehensive sentencing exercise under the Drug and Alcohol Sentencing List. Payne's plea and the circumstances surrounding the offence were pivotal in the referral. During the proceedings in the County Court, the prosecution emphasised the seriousness of the act, particularly given the potential for significant harm in a densely populated area, and the offensive motive behind Payne's actions. The court also considered Payne's likelihood of complying with a drug and alcohol treatment order, recognising the importance of rehabilitation in the sentencing process. The notion of remorse and the broader implications for community protection were also discussed. Ultimately, the County Court imposed a treatment order on Payne, underscoring rehabilitation as the surest means of protecting the community.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the accused person have the requisite knowledge of the infant being in the vehicle at the time of the offence?
2. What is the appropriate weight to be given to the seriousness of discharging a firearm in a suburban location?
3. Should the court consider the offensive motive behind the accused's actions in determining the sentence?
4. How should inferences about the effect on the victims be treated in the sentencing process?
5. In what manner should the likelihood of compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order be assessed in the sentencing context?
6. How should the court balance the principle of rehabilitation with other sentencing considerations?
7. What constitutes sufficient evidence of remorse for the purposes of sentencing?
8. Is rehabilitation the surest guarantor of community protection in this case?
9. What are the appropriate terms of the drug and alcohol treatment order to be imposed on the accused?

Held
1. Did the accused person have the requisite knowledge of the infant being in the vehicle at the time of the offence? The court concluded that the accused did not have knowledge of the infant being in the vehicle at the time of the offence.
2. What is the appropriate weight to be given to the seriousness of discharging a firearm in a suburban location? The court held that discharging a firearm in a suburban location is inherently serious due to the potential for widespread harm.
3. Should the court consider the offensive motive behind the accused's actions in determining the sentence? The court decided that the offensive motive behind the accused's actions should be considered in the sentencing process.
4. How should inferences about the effect on the victims be treated in the sentencing process? The court held that inferences about the effect on the victims should be treated with caution but remain relevant in the sentencing process.
5. In what manner should the likelihood of compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order be assessed in the sentencing context? The court concluded that the likelihood of compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order should be assessed based on the accused's history and current circumstances.
6. How should the court balance the principle of rehabilitation with other sentencing considerations? The court held that while rehabilitation is important, it must be balanced with other sentencing considerations, including community protection and deterrence.
7. What constitutes sufficient evidence of remorse for the purposes of sentencing? The court concluded that genuine remorse should be evidenced by the accused’s actions and statements, not merely expressed regret.
8. Is rehabilitation the surest guarantor of community protection in this case? The court held that rehabilitation is not the surest guarantor of community protection in this case.
9. What are the appropriate terms of the drug and alcohol treatment order to be imposed on the accused? The court imposed a drug and alcohol treatment order with specific terms as outlined in [83].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Director of Public Prosecutions v Payne, the court was tasked with determining the appropriate sentence for the accused who had intentionally and unlawfully discharged a loaded firearm in a suburban area. The court's reasoning addressed several complex issues, beginning with whether the accused had knowledge of an infant being in the vehicle at the time of the offence. The court resolved this issue by examining the evidence presented and concluded that there was insufficient evidence to establish the accused's knowledge with the requisite standard of proof. The court underscored the importance of the principle that the prosecution must prove each element of the offence beyond reasonable doubt, and given the lack of direct evidence, it could not be said that the accused had the requisite knowledge. This aspect of the reasoning established that in cases of factual disputes, the prosecution bears the onus of proving knowledge to a high standard.

The court then considered the seriousness of discharging a firearm in a suburban location, an issue of substantial weight in the sentencing process. The court relied on prior case law to emphasize the inherent danger posed by such actions, particularly in a densely populated area. The authorities cited underscored the potential for indiscriminate harm and the significant risk to public safety. The court applied these principles to the facts, noting the proximity of the shooting to residential properties and the potential for causing injury or death. This reasoning highlighted the court's commitment to ensuring that the seriousness of the offence is appropriately reflected in the sentence.

Turning to the offensive motive behind the accused's actions, the court deliberated on whether this factor should influence the sentence. The court held that while the motive might be relevant in assessing the culpability of the accused, it should not be the sole determinant in the sentencing process. The court referenced established sentencing principles that emphasize proportionality and the need to consider the broader impact of the offence on the community. By adopting this approach, the court balanced the need to account for the accused's motive with the imperative to ensure a just and proportionate sentence.

The court also addressed the inferences about the effect on the victims, considering whether these should be treated as a significant factor in the sentencing process. The court acknowledged the profound impact of such incidents on victims but determined that the primary focus should remain on the objective circumstances of the offence and the need for deterrence and protection of the community. The reasoning reflected the principle that while the court must consider the harm caused, it must also ensure that the sentence serves broader justice objectives. This consideration underscored the court's approach to balancing individual victim impact with wider societal concerns.

In assessing the likelihood of compliance with a drug and alcohol treatment order, the court engaged in a detailed analysis of the accused's history and prospects for rehabilitation. The court emphasized the importance of individualised sentencing that takes into account the specific circumstances of the offender. The reasoning demonstrated a nuanced understanding of the need to tailor sentences to the unique profiles of offenders while also ensuring that the orders imposed are likely to be effective. This aspect of the decision established that in sentencing, courts should thoroughly evaluate the likelihood of compliance with treatment orders based on the individual's history and prospects.

The court also balanced the principle of rehabilitation with other sentencing considerations, such as deterrence and community protection. The court underscored that while rehabilitation is a primary goal of sentencing, it must be balanced against the need to deter future offending and protect the community. The authorities cited supported the notion that rehabilitation should be a significant consideration but not the sole determinant. This reasoning highlighted the court's commitment to a holistic approach to sentencing that considers multiple objectives.

Regarding the notion of remorse, the court examined the evidence to determine whether the accused had demonstrated sufficient remorse for the purposes of sentencing. The court found that while the accused had expressed remorse, it was not of a kind or degree that would significantly mitigate the sentence. This reasoning reinforced the principle that remorse, while a relevant factor, must be substantial and genuine to have a meaningful impact on the sentence. The court's approach ensured that the sentencing process remained objective and grounded in the circumstances of the offence.

The court also deliberated on whether rehabilitation was the surest guarantor of community protection in this case. The reasoning indicated that while rehabilitation is an important consideration, it must be supported by other measures that ensure community safety. The court's conclusion underscored the need for a balanced approach that recognises the potential for rehabilitation while also addressing immediate risks to the community. This aspect of the decision established that rehabilitation should be a key, but not exclusive, consideration in sentencing.

Finally, the court imposed an appropriate drug and alcohol treatment order, considering the accused's history and prospects for rehabilitation. The court's reasoning demonstrated a careful consideration of the individual circumstances, ensuring that the order was likely to be effective and proportionate. This decision underscored the importance of tailoring treatment orders to the specific needs of the offender, reflecting a commitment to both rehabilitation and community protection. The terms of the order reflected a balanced approach that aimed to address the underlying issues contributing to the offending behaviour while also ensuring public safety.