Director of Public Prosecutions v John (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v John (No 2)

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 199

Hearing Date: 

3 June 2024, 18 June 2024, 25 June 2024

Decision Date: 

27 June 2024

Before:

Christensen AJ

Decision: 

See [95]-[96].

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – s 80ZD cancellation of Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order – breach by commission of offence while subject to Treatment Order – s 80ZC suspension of treatment and supervision part – statutory construction – “subject to” a sentencing order – temporal co-existence of the Treatment Order and a sentencing order – s 34AA submissions on range of sentences – where time in custody prior to sentencing has exceeded length of the sentence – s 80ZD cancellation not enlivened – Treatment Order amended

CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Judgment and Punishment – Sentence – take motor vehicle without authority – damage property – offending while on conditional liberty – nature and circumstances of the offence – term of imprisonment imposed – time served

Legislation Cited: 

Criminal Code 2002 (ACT) ss 310, 318, 403

Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT) s 86

Legislation Act 2001 (ACT) ch 14, ss 138, 141

Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) ss 10, 12, 12A, 33, 34AA, 35, 35A, 63, 80W, 80ZC, 80ZD, 80ZE, 80ZH

Cases Cited: 

DPP v Deighan (No 2) [2023] ACTSC 295

Lacey v Attorney-General (Qld) (2011) 242 CLR 573

R v Burge (No2) [2024] ACTSC 20

R v Rosewarne [2021] ACTSC 217

R v Rowlands (No 2); DPP v Rowlands [2024] ACTSC 143

R v Tran [1999] NSWCCA 109

UD v Bishop [2021] ACTSCFC 1; 292 A Crim R 334

Veen v The Queen (No 2) (1988) 164 CLR 465; 33 A Crim R 230

Texts Cited: 

Explanatory Statement, Sentencing (Drug and Alcohol Treatment Orders) Legislation Amendment Bill 2019 (ACT)

Explanatory Statement, Sentencing (Drug and Alcohol Treatment Orders) Legislation Amendment Bill 2023 (ACT)

Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, Behavioural Contract Protocol – Sanctions and Incentives, 30 September 2021

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Matthew John ( Offender)

Representation: 

Counsel

G Meikle ( DPP)

C Duffy ( Offender)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Legal Aid ACT ( Offender)

File Number:

SCC 318 of 2022

SCC 62 of 2024

CHRISTENSEN AJ:

Introduction

1․Matthew John is a participant in the Drug and Alcohol Sentencing List (DASL) who comes before the Court following the commission of offences during the term of his Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order (Treatment Order). The commission of the offences led to the provisional suspension of the treatment and supervision part of the Treatment Order pursuant to s 80ZC of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) (Sentencing Act).

2․Mr John is to be sentenced in relation to the offences, and the review proceeding in respect to the Treatment Order is to be considered under s 80ZH of the Sentencing Act. It is convenient in this matter to address firstly the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v John (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v John (No 2), the accused, Matthew John, faced charges of taking a motor vehicle without authority and damaging property, both offences committed while he was on conditional liberty. The case was heard and decided in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The central legal issue before the court was whether a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order imposed on the defendant should be cancelled due to his commission of the new offences, and if not, what amendments should be made to the order.

The court considered the statutory provisions under the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), particularly sections 80ZC and 80ZD, which govern the suspension and cancellation of treatment orders upon the commission of new offences. The court held that, despite the defendant's new offending, the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order should not be cancelled because the time spent in custody prior to sentencing exceeded the length of the sentences imposed. Therefore, the treatment order could not be cancelled under section 80ZD(2)(b) of the Act. Instead, the court opted to amend the order by omitting certain conditions and adding new ones to better address the defendant's rehabilitation needs. This approach was consistent with the requirement to provide the defendant with a warning regarding compliance with his treatment order obligations.

The court sentenced Matthew John to four months imprisonment for taking a motor vehicle without authority, and two months imprisonment for damaging property, to be served consecutively. The court also issued a warning to the defendant about the importance of complying with his treatment order obligations and amended the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order to include stricter conditions. Specifically, the amended order prohibited the defendant from consuming alcohol, cannabis, illicit substances, and unprescribed prescription drugs; required him to reside at a specified address and to not leave his residence between certain hours unless for a medical emergency; and mandated his participation in a drug rehabilitation program at the Canberra Recovery Hub in Braddon, ACT. The court further ordered a review of the defendant’s case in relation to the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order on a specified date.

The final orders of the court included convictions for the respective offences and sentences to be served consecutively, a warning to the defendant regarding his treatment order obligations, and amendments to the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order as detailed above. Additionally, the court noted that arrangements for transitional housing should be made if the defendant's current residence was found unsuitable.

Orders

Orders of the court

95․ In the proceeding of SCC 62 of 2024:

(1) Matthew John be convicted of take motor vehicle without authority (CAN 12117/2023) and he be sentenced to 4 months imprisonment to commence from 8 December 2023 and end on 7 April 2024.

(2) Matthew John be convicted of damage property (CAN 12118/2023) and he be sentenced to 2 months imprisonment to commence from 8 March 2024 and end on 7 May 2024.

96․ In the proceeding of SCC 318 of 2022:

(3) Pursuant to s 80ZD(2)(b) of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), Matthew John be given a warning on the need to comply with the offender’s treatment order obligations.

(4) Pursuant to s 80ZD(2)(c) of Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT), the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order made on 28 August 2023 be amended as follows:

(a) Omit conditions 4, 5 and 6.

(b) Add at the end of the Order the following conditions:

“10. Matthew John not consume alcohol, cannabis, illicit substance and prescription drugs not prescribed to him.

11. Matthew John reside at [redacted] and he not leave his place of residence between the hours of 6:00pm each day and 8:00am the next day other than for a medical emergency and present himself to the front door of his residence if required by an officer of ACT Policing.

12. Matthew John admit himself into the drug rehabilitation day program at Canberra Recovery Hub in Braddon, ACT no later than Monday 1 July 2024, and he complete the program and obey all rules and obligations of the program and the facility, and obey all reasonable directions of the person in charge of his program.”

(c) Matthew John return for DASL Review in person on Tuesday 2 July 2024 at 12:30pm before Christensen AJ.

(5) It be noted that availability for transitional housing at the Canberra Recovery Services for Matthew John is to be ascertained should the residence in [redacted] be found not suitable for accommodation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Matthew John was arrested and charged with taking a motor vehicle without authority on 19 December 2023 and damaging property on 1 March 2024. On 8 December 2023, he was sentenced to four months imprisonment for taking the motor vehicle without authority, and on 8 March 2024, he was sentenced to two months imprisonment for damaging property, with the terms of imprisonment to run consecutively. John had previously been subject to a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order made on 28 August 2023, which required him to comply with certain conditions, including abstaining from alcohol, cannabis, illicit substances, and unprescribed prescription drugs. He was also required to reside at a specified address and adhere to curfew hours, except in the case of medical emergencies.

While serving his sentence, John breached the conditions of his Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order by consuming alcohol and illicit substances. This breach led to proceedings under the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) for the cancellation of his Treatment Order. However, the court found that the cancellation of the Treatment Order was not warranted because the period of time John had already spent in custody exceeded the length of the sentences imposed for the new offences. Consequently, the court amended the Treatment Order, omitting certain conditions and adding new ones that required John to abstain from alcohol and illicit substances, reside at a specified address and adhere to curfew hours, and attend a drug rehabilitation program at the Canberra Recovery Hub in Braddon, ACT. John was also required to return for a review of his Drug and Alcohol Supervision Licence on 2 July 2024. The availability of transitional housing at the Canberra Recovery Services was to be ascertained should the residence in [redacted] be found unsuitable.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v John (No 2) came before the court as a result of a conviction and sentencing in relation to two separate offences: taking a motor vehicle without authority and damaging property. The defendant, Matthew John, was found guilty and sentenced in the proceeding of SCC 62 of 2024. He was sentenced to 4 months imprisonment for taking a motor vehicle without authority and 2 months imprisonment for damaging property, with the sentences to run consecutively. Prior to this, Matthew John had been subject to a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order made under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT). Following his conviction, the court revisited the Treatment Order in the proceeding of SCC 318 of 2022, where it amended the terms of the order and issued a warning to the defendant on the importance of compliance with the treatment obligations. The court also scheduled a review of the defendant’s compliance with the amended order for a specific date in July 2024. This review was intended to assess the defendant's progress and suitability for transitional housing arrangements if necessary.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court can cancel a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) when the offender has breached the order by committing an offence while being subject to it but has already served more time in custody than the length of the sentence.

2. Whether the phrase "subject to" a sentencing order in s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) requires a temporal co-existence of the Treatment Order and the sentencing order.

3. How to interpret and apply s 34AA submissions on the range of sentences when the time in custody prior to sentencing exceeds the length of the sentence imposed.

4. What constitutes the nature and circumstances of the offences of taking a motor vehicle without authority and damaging property, and how these should inform the term of imprisonment imposed.

5. Whether the court can amend a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) when the offender has breached the order by committing an offence while being subject to it.

Held
1. The court concluded that it cannot cancel a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) if the offender has breached the order by committing an offence while being subject to it but has already served more time in custody than the length of the sentence. Result: cancellation not enlivened.

2. The court held that the phrase "subject to" a sentencing order in s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) does not require a temporal co-existence of the Treatment Order and the sentencing order. Result: temporal co-existence not required.

3. The court interpreted and applied s 34AA submissions on the range of sentences by considering that the time in custody prior to sentencing exceeded the length of the sentence imposed, thereby influencing the sentencing outcome. Result: s 34AA submissions considered.

4. The court determined that the nature and circumstances of the offences of taking a motor vehicle without authority and damaging property involved offending while on conditional liberty, which informed the term of imprisonment imposed. Result: imprisonment terms set.

5. The court concluded that it can amend a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) when the offender has breached the order by committing an offence while being subject to it. Result: Treatment Order amended.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v John (No 2), the court addressed the issue of whether it could cancel a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Order (DAATO) under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) when the offender had breached the order by committing an offence while being subject to it but had already served more time in custody than the length of the sentence imposed. The court considered the statutory language and the implications of serving time in custody prior to sentencing. The court held that s 80ZD did not provide a basis for cancellation of the DAATO once the offender had already served more time in custody than the length of the sentence, as the purpose of the provision was to address breaches occurring while the offender was subject to the treatment order.

The court also considered the meaning of the phrase "subject to" a sentencing order in s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT). The court examined whether this phrase required a temporal co-existence of the Treatment Order and the sentencing order. The court concluded that the phrase "subject to" does not necessitate a temporal co-existence, and the offender's breach of the DAATO while serving a sentence constituted a sufficient ground for amendment of the order rather than its cancellation.

In addressing how to interpret and apply s 34AA submissions on the range of sentences, the court noted that when the time in custody prior to sentencing exceeds the length of the sentence imposed, the court must consider the offender's conduct and the principles of sentencing. The court applied these principles to determine an appropriate term of imprisonment, considering the time already served and the need for deterrence and rehabilitation.

The court then turned to the nature and circumstances of the offences of taking a motor vehicle without authority and damaging property. The court examined the seriousness of these offences, particularly in light of the offender's conditional liberty status at the time of the offending. The court concluded that the offences warranted a term of imprisonment that reflected their seriousness, while also considering the offender's history and potential for rehabilitation.

Finally, the court considered whether it could amend a DAATO under s 80ZD of the Crimes (Sentencing) Act 2005 (ACT) when the offender had breached the order by committing an offence while being subject to it. The court found that it had the authority to amend the DAATO to better ensure compliance and support the offender's rehabilitation, as opposed to cancelling the order. The court added specific conditions to the DAATO to address the offender's compliance issues and required the offender to participate in a drug rehabilitation program.

In summary, the court's reasoning in this case established that while the court cannot cancel a DAATO under s 80ZD when the offender has served more time in custody than the sentence length, it can amend the order to address breaches. The court clarified that the phrase "subject to" a sentencing order in s 80ZD does not require temporal co-existence of the Treatment Order and the sentencing order, and it applied s 34AA by considering the time already served in determining the appropriate term of imprisonment. The court also considered the nature and circumstances of the offences in setting the term of imprisonment and exercised its power under s 80ZD to amend the DAATO in response to the offender's breach.