Director of Public Prosecutions v Franklin (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Franklin (No 5)

Citation: 

[2024] ACTSC 196

Hearing Date: 

14 February 2024, 8 April 2024

Decision Date: 

24 June 2024

Before:

Baker J

Decision: 

(1)  The prosecution is permitted to adduce the evidence of the further 2019 incident as relationship or context evidence.

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – Application to adduce prior evidence of family violence in respect of family violence and sexual violence offending – s 74A of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT) – consideration of relationship and context evidence – application granted

Legislation Cited: 

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT), ss 27(3)(a), 28(2)(a), 34, 54(1)

Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), s 474(1)

Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT), s 74A

Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), ss 56, 137
Family Violence Act 2016 (ACT), ss 8, 9

Cases Cited: 

DPP v Mastalerz [2024] ACTSC 30

DS v The Queen [2022] NSWCCA 55

DPP v Franklin (No 4) [2024] ACTSC 35

Marshall v The King [2023] ACTCA 11

MM v The Queen [2012] ACTCA 44; 232 A Crim R 303

R v BC (No 3) [2020] ACTCA 49

R v Fordham (1997) 98 A Crim R 359

R v PAB [2006] QCA 212; 1 Qd R 184

R v Sadler [2008] VSCA 198; 20 VR 69

R v Toki (No 3) [2000] NSWSC 999; 116 A Crim R 536

Texts Cited:

Revised Explanatory Statement to the Sexual Assault Reform Legislation Amendment Bill 2022 (ACT)

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Crown)

Patrick Franklin ( Accused)

Representation: 

Counsel

S Jerome ( Crown)

K Ginges ( Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions

Hugo Law Group ( Accused)

File Numbers:

SCC 214 of 2022

SCC 215 of 2022

SCC 310 of 2023

BAKER J:      

Introduction

  1. The accused, Patrick Franklin, has been charged with the following nine offences in an indictment dated 18 January 2024:

    (a)Count 1 (CC2022/4895): choke/suffocate/strangle, contrary to s 28(2)(a) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (b)Count 2 (CC2022/7508): choke/suffocate/strangle, contrary to s 28(2)(a) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (c)Count 3 (CC2022/4896): choke render insensible, contrary to s 27(3)(a) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (d)Count 4 (CC2022/4898): forcible confinement, contrary to s 34 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (e)Count 5 (CC2022/4899): choke render insensible, contrary to s 27(3)(a) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (f)Count 6 (CC2022/4900): sexual intercourse without consent, contrary to s 54(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (g)Count 7 (CC2022/7513): sexual intercourse without consent, contrary to s 54(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (h)Count 8 (CC2023/9300): sexual intercourse without consent, contrary to s 54(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

    (i)Count 9 (CC2023/9301): sexual intercourse without consent, contrary to s 54(1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT).

  2. Counts 1 to 7 relate to an incident that is alleged to have occurred on 18 May 2022. Counts 8 and 9 relate to an incident that is alleged to have occurred on 2 November 2019.

  3. On 14 March 2024, the prosecution…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Franklin (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Franklin (No 5) involved a request by the prosecution to adduce evidence of a prior incident of family violence in relation to a case involving allegations of family violence and sexual violence. The application was heard by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The central legal issue before the court was whether the prosecution could present evidence of a 2019 incident of family violence, which occurred between the accused and the complainant, as relationship or context evidence in the current trial. This was in accordance with section 74A of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1991 (ACT).

The court examined the admissibility of the 2019 incident evidence under section 74A of the EMP Act, which permits the admissibility of relationship or context evidence that explains why a complainant responded to the alleged offending in a way that might otherwise seem unexpected or implausible. The court also considered the potential exclusion of this evidence under section 137 of the Evidence Act, which mandates the exclusion of evidence if its prejudicial effect outweighs its probative value. The court found that the evidence of the 2019 incident had sufficient probative value to be admitted as it explained the complainant's actions and reactions during the alleged offending, which aligned with the contemporary understanding of family violence as a pattern of behaviour. Furthermore, the court concluded that the prejudicial effect of the evidence did not outweigh its probative value, thus permitting its admission.

In light of the court's reasoning, it granted the prosecution's application to adduce the evidence of the further 2019 incident as relationship or context evidence. The court's decision was based on the recognition that the evidence was relevant to understanding the dynamics of the relationship between the accused and the complainant, and it was not deemed unfairly prejudicial. This decision allowed the prosecution to present a fuller picture of the relationship and the context in which the alleged offending occurred.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The prosecution is permitted to adduce the evidence of the further 2019 incident as relationship or context evidence.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Even where relationship or context evidence is admissible under s 74A of the EMP Act, such evidence may still be excluded under s 137 of the Evidence Act, which provides:137Exclusion of prejudicial evidence in criminal proceedingsIn a criminal proceeding, the court must refuse to admit evidence presented by the prosecutor if its probative value is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant. I recently summarised the principles relating to the admission of relationship or context in DPP v Mastalerz [2024] ACTSC 30 at [49] – [59]. In summary, evidence may be relevant as relationship or context evidence where it explains why a complainant responded to the alleged offending in a way that, without the broader context, might seem unexpected or implausible. In some cases, context or relationship evidence may also be relevant to draw inferences about an accused’s state of mind, or “their reason for acting in a particular way towards the complainant”: Mastalerz at [51]. For example, relationship or context evidence may be relevant to explain a complainant’s submission to sexual intercourse in circumstances where the complainant fears that the accused will become violent if they refuse, or as informing an inference that an accused must have known a complainant was not consenting in light of past acts of violence: Mastalerz at [52] – [53] citing DS v R [2022] NSWCCA 55 at [120]; R v Fordham (1997) 98 A Crim R 359 at 369 – 370; R v Toki (No 3) [2000] NSWSC 999; 116 A Crim R 536 at [24] – [28], [72]; R v PAB [2006] QCA 212; [2008] 1 Qd R 184 at [24] – [26]; R v Sadler [2008] VSCA 198; 20 VR 69; MM v The Queen [2012] ACTCA 44; 232 A Crim R 303 at [6] – [8]. The “cumulative effect” of family violence is explicitly recognised in s 74A of the EMP Act. This provision affirms the contemporary understanding of family violence, recognising that “a number of acts that form part of a pattern of behaviour may amount to family violence, even though some or all of the acts, when viewed in isolation, may appear to be minor or trivial”: Mastalerz at [55]; sub-ss 74A(2)b) and 74A(3)(b)(ii) of the EMP Act. The provision was intended to ensure that factfinders can properly “evaluate the true nature of relationships between the parties and why the victim survivor reacted the way as they did”: Revised Explanatory Statement to the Sexual Assault Reform Legislation Amendment Bill 2022 (ACT) (“Explanatory Statement to the 2023 Amending Legislation”) at 12 [2]. However, the admissibility of relationship or context evidence does not only depend on the probative value of the evidence. Where the prejudicial effect of relationship or context evidence outweighs its probative value in a criminal trial, the evidence must be excluded under s 137 of the Evidence Act: Explanatory Statement to the 2023 Amendment Legislation at 5. Evidence may be unfairly prejudicial if it is “liable to be misused by the jury in some way; divert the jury from its task; be evaluated by the jury through some illegitimate form of reasoning; or be used in a way which is irrational or illogical”: Franklin (No 4) at [39], citing Mastalerz at [42]; Hughes at 349 [17]; Bauer at 93 [73]; Marshall v The King [2023] ACTCA 11 at [53]; and R v BC (No 3) [2020] ACTCA 49 at [40]. Unfair prejudice will not arise simply because the evidence supports the prosecution case or inculpates an accused.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established