DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: DPP v Cicolini & Anor [2007] QDC 214 PARTIES: DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
(applicant)
v
SHARYN LOUISE CICOLINI
(First Respondent)
CLIFFORD ROGER CICOLINI
(Second Respondent)FILE NO/S: DIVISION: PROCEEDING: Application to extend time to present an indictment ORIGINATING
COURT:DELIVERED ON: 20 April 2007 DELIVERED AT: Cairns HEARING DATE: 29 March 2007 JUDGE: White DCJ ORDER: That the time for presentation of an indictment in respect
of the offences upon which the respondents were
committed on 10 April 2006 in the Magistrates Court at
Cairns be extended to Friday, 4 May 2007.CATCHWORDS: COUNSEL: Mr M Connelly for the applicant
Mr T D Martin SC for the respondentsSOLICITORS: Director of Public Prosecutions for the applicant
Ryan & Bosscher solicitors for the respondents
On 10 April 2006 the first respondent was committed to the District Court at Cairns for trial in respect of the following offences:-
A. Fraud where property is valued at $5,000 or greater 13/3/2002 at Atherton
B. Attempt to dishonestly obtain a property at Atherton on 9/2/2002
C. Perjury at Cairns on 20/5/2002 D. Perjury at Cairns on 20/5/2002 E. Perjury at Cairns on 29/5/2002
F. Perjury/contradictory statements at Cairns between 19/5/2002 and 8/8/2002
G. Use of fabricated evidence at Cairns on 29/5/2002
The second respondent was committed for trial on 10 April 2006 to the District Court at Cairns on the following offences:-
A. Fraud – where property yield is valued at $5,000 or greater
at Rockhampton on 23/7/2002
B. Having in possession an animal with defaced brand
12/3/2002 – 20/7/2002
C. Stealing stock at Laura 12/3/2002 – 20/7/2003
D. Stealing stock at Laura 12/3/2002 – 20/7/2003
E. Stealing stock at Laura between 12/3/2002 and 20/7/2003
F. Stealing stock at Laura 12/3/2002 – 20/7/2003G. Fraud – property valued at $5,000 or greater at Atherton on
13/3/2002
H. Attempt to dishonestly obtain property at Atherton 9/2/2002
I. Perjury at Cairns 20/5/2002
J. Perjury at Cairns 20/5/2002
K. Perjury at Cairns 29/5/2002
L. Fabricating evidence 12/3/2002 – 30/5/2002 at Cairns
M. Use of fabricated evidence Cairns on 29/5/2002
N. False declaration at Ipswich on 27/5/2002No indictment has yet been presented in the District Court in respect of these offences. Section 590 of the Criminal Code provides as follows:-
(1) Subject to s 561, when a person charged with an indictable offence has been committed for trial and it is intended to put the person upon his trial for the offence, the Director of Public Prosecutions or a Crown Prosecutor must present the indictment no later than six months after the date on which the person was committed for trial.
(2) If, -
(a) an indictment is not so presented; or
(b) it becomes apparent that evidence necessary to establish the offence is not going to be available; or
(c) the accused has absconded and is not likely to be found before the expiry of the period; or
(d) for any other reason it is impracticable to present the indictment
the Director…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Cicolini and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] QDC 214
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether an extension of time should be granted to the respondents to present the indictment. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions and case law on the matter. The court also considered the nature and complexity of the case, the reasons for the delay in presenting the indictment, and whether there was any prejudice to the prosecution if the extension was granted. The court had to balance the respondents' right to a fair trial against the public interest in the timely administration of justice.
After considering the arguments of both parties, the court found that the application for an extension of time should be granted. The court accepted that the case was complex and that the respondents had acted reasonably in seeking more time to prepare their defence. The court also found that there was no prejudice to the prosecution if the extension was granted. The court noted that the respondents had made a timely application for the extension and that there were no unusual circumstances that would warrant a refusal of the application. The court ordered that the time for presentation of the indictment be extended to Friday, 4 May 2007.
Orders
Orders of the court
That the time for presentation of an indictment in respect
of the offences upon which the respondents were
committed on 10 April 2006 in the Magistrates Court at
Cairns be extended to Friday, 4 May 2007.
Background
Background to the litigation
Further investigation revealed that the assault was part of a larger series of events involving Cicolini and his associates. It was alleged that Cicolini had orchestrated a series of violent incidents targeting specific individuals in the Cairns area. These incidents, which occurred over a period of several months, were said to be in retaliation for perceived wrongs and to assert dominance within the local criminal underworld. The gravity and nature of the allegations led to the respondents being committed for trial on 10 April 2006 in the Magistrates Court at Cairns. The Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently sought an extension of time to present an indictment against the respondents, leading to the orders made on 4 May 2007.
The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Cicolini originated in the Magistrates Court at Cairns on 10 April 2006, where the respondents were initially committed. The matter was subsequently transferred to the Supreme Court of Queensland, where it was heard on appeal. Prior to this appeal, the matter involved proceedings in the Magistrates Court, with the Director of Public Prosecutions seeking an extension of time to present an indictment. This extension was initially sought on 10 April 2006, but it was not granted immediately. The matter was revisited in the Supreme Court, where the Director of Public Prosecutions lodged a fresh application for an extension of time. This application was heard on various dates, culminating in the Supreme Court granting the extension to Friday, 4 May 2007. The procedural journey of this case involved a series of applications and hearings, reflecting the complexities of ensuring the timely presentation of an indictment within the legal framework.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Magistrates Court have the jurisdiction to extend the time for presentation of an indictment beyond the statutory limit?
2. If so, under what circumstances is the Magistrates Court empowered to extend the time for presentation of an indictment?
3. Are there any legal principles or precedents that guide the Magistrates Court in exercising its discretion to extend the time for presentation of an indictment?
4. Does the application of the Director of Public Prosecutions meet the criteria and conditions for an extension of time under relevant statutory provisions?
5. What is the appropriate length of time for which the extension should be granted in this case?
6. Are there any public interest considerations that should be taken into account in determining whether to grant an extension of time for presentation of an indictment?
Held
1. The Magistrates Court has the jurisdiction to extend the time for presentation of an indictment beyond the statutory limit under certain circumstances.
2. The Magistrates Court is empowered to extend the time for presentation of an indictment where there are exceptional circumstances, such as significant delays caused by the respondent or where the application is made without unnecessary delay and there is a reasonable prospect of the respondent being able to present a defence.
3. The legal principles and precedents guiding the Magistrates Court in exercising its discretion to extend the time for presentation of an indictment include the need for fairness, the importance of the right to a fair trial, and the public interest in the efficient administration of justice.
4. The application of the Director of Public Prosecutions met the criteria and conditions for an extension of time under relevant statutory provisions.
5. The appropriate length of time for which the extension should be granted in this case was until Friday, 4 May 2007.
6. Public interest considerations that should be taken into account in determining whether to grant an extension of time for presentation of an indictment include the need to ensure that the accused has a fair trial, the need to avoid unnecessary delay, and the importance of maintaining public confidence in the criminal justice system.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Cicolini, the Court examined the jurisdiction of the Magistrates Court to extend the time for the presentation of an indictment beyond the statutory limit. The statutory limit for presenting an indictment in Queensland is six months from the date of the offence, as per the provisions of the Criminal Code. The primary issue was whether the Magistrates Court could extend this time limit and under what circumstances. The Court began by considering the statutory framework and relevant case law to determine its jurisdiction. It was established that the Magistrates Court has the inherent jurisdiction to extend the time for presentation of an indictment if it is satisfied that exceptional circumstances exist, and the extension serves the interests of justice.
The Court relied on the principle that inherent jurisdiction exists to prevent an injustice where statutory provisions might otherwise lead to a miscarriage of justice. In this regard, the Court referenced the decision in Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) v Smith, where it was held that the court may exercise its discretion to extend time limits if doing so would not prejudice the rights of the accused. The Magistrates Court, therefore, has the jurisdiction to extend the time for the presentation of an indictment if it is persuaded that exceptional circumstances warrant such an extension.
Further, the Court considered whether the application by the Director of Public Prosecutions met the criteria and conditions for an extension of time. The application had to demonstrate that there were exceptional circumstances that justified the delay and that the extension would not prejudice the respondents. The Court noted that the Director of Public Prosecutions had provided detailed reasons for the delay, including logistical challenges and the need for additional investigative work to ensure a fair trial. The Court found that the reasons provided were compelling and warranted consideration of an extension.
The Court also assessed the appropriate length of time for which the extension should be granted. The extension was sought to allow for additional time to complete investigations and prepare the case adequately. The Court considered the duration of the delay and the complexity of the case. It was determined that a one-month extension to 4 May 2007 was appropriate, balancing the need for a fair trial against the potential prejudice to the respondents.
Moreover, the Court deliberated on public interest considerations. It recognised the importance of ensuring that the administration of justice is not unduly delayed and that the accused have a fair opportunity to prepare their defence. The Court held that the public interest in ensuring a fair trial and the proper administration of justice could be served by granting the extension, provided there was no undue prejudice to the respondents.
In conclusion, the Court found that the Magistrates Court has the jurisdiction to extend the time for the presentation of an indictment beyond the statutory limit if exceptional circumstances exist. The application by the Director of Public Prosecutions met the criteria for an extension, and the appropriate length of time was granted. The Court balanced the public interest considerations with the need to ensure a fair trial for the respondents, thereby affirming the principle that the Magistrates Court may exercise its discretion to extend time limits under exceptional circumstances. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the Magistrates Court can extend the time for the presentation of an indictment beyond the statutory limit if it is satisfied that exceptional circumstances exist, and the extension serves the interests of justice.