SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | DPP v Alexander (a pseudonym) |
Citation: | [2024] ACTSC 161 |
Hearing Dates: | 17 and 24 May 2024 |
Decision Date: | 24 May 2024 |
Before: | Mossop J |
Decision: | See [79]-[80] |
Catchwords: | CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Bail – application for bail and review of bail decision from the Magistrates Court – [redacted] – where accused detained with convicted offenders, contrary to s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) – breach of human right amounts to “special or exceptional circumstances” for the purpose of s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) – consideration of s 22 factors – bail granted CRIMINAL LAW – STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Accused detained with convicted offenders, contrary to s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) – whether contravention amounts to “special or exceptional circumstances” for the purpose of s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) – consideration of relevant statutory provisions and Corrective Services policies – right contained in s 19(2) not limited by s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT) – purpose of s 44 is to implement rather than qualify the right contained in s 19(2) – special circumstances favouring the grant of bail established |
Legislation Cited: | Bail Act 1992 (ACT), ss 9D, 20B, 22, 43A Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT), ss 7, 9, 10, 14, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 52, 55, 62, 108, 115, 137, 140, 219 Crimes (Sentence Administration) Act 2005 (ACT), s 18 Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), ss 19, 28, 30, 34, 36, 40B, Pt 3 Legislation Act 2001 (ACT), ss 139, 140, 141, 142 [redacted] |
Cases Cited: | Davidson v Director-General, Justice and Community Safety Directorate [2022] ACTSC 83; 18 ACTLR 1 McIver v The King [2023] ACTCA 48; 20 ACTLR 303 |
Texts Cited: | ACT Corrective Services, Corrections Management (Remand Detainees) Policy 2019 (at 13 June 2019) ACT Corrective Services, Placement and Shared Cell Operating Procedure (at 21 September 2022) Explanatory Statement, Corrections Management Bill 2006 (ACT) |
Parties: | Director of Public Prosecutions William Alexander (a pseudonym) ( Accused) ACT Human Rights Commissioner (Intervener) |
Representation: | Counsel D Berents ( DPP) J Pappas ( Accused) S Fitzgerald (Intervener) |
| Solicitors Director of Public Prosecutions Andrew Byrnes Law Group ( Accused) ACT Human Rights Commission (Intervener) | |
File Numbers: | [redacted] |
MOSSOP J:
Introduction
1․This is an application for bail. The application is subject to s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). I ultimately conclude that the requirement for “special or exceptional circumstances” in s 9D of the Act has been satisfied and that the considerations in s 22 of the Act warrant a grant of bail.
Factual background
[paragraphs 2-12 redacted]
Current applications
[paragraphs 13-15 redacted]
Evidence
[paragraph 16 redacted]
Section 9D test
17․The submission that there were either special or exceptional circumstances established was based upon an aggregation of factors. [redacted]
18․There was some evidence or information that the accused was detained with convicted sex offenders. I raised…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Alexander (a pseudonym) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] ACTSC 161
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of sections 19 and 44 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), section 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT), and the policies of the Corrective Services. Specifically, the court had to determine if the segregation right under section 19(2) was limited by section 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT). The court held that section 44 was intended to implement the segregation right rather than limit it, thereby establishing "special circumstances" favouring bail.
In reaching its decision, the court examined the statutory provisions and policies to confirm that the segregation right was indeed a fundamental aspect of the accused's human rights. Given the breach of this right, the court found that "special or exceptional circumstances" had been established, warranting the grant of bail. The court considered various factors under section 22 of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) and concluded that bail should be granted to Alexander.
Orders
Orders of the court
See [79]-[80]
Background
Background to the litigation
Alexander asserts that his detention with convicted offenders is a direct violation of his human rights, which he argues should be considered when determining whether special or exceptional circumstances exist for the purposes of granting bail. In response, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) contends that Alexander's right under section 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) is not limited by section 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT). The DPP argues that section 44 is intended to implement rather than qualify the right contained in section 19(2). Despite the DPP's contention, Alexander maintains that the purpose of section 44 is to create an exception to the right, thereby justifying the grant of bail due to the established special circumstances.
The factual dispute hinges on whether the contravention of Alexander's human rights by being detained with convicted offenders constitutes special or exceptional circumstances for the purpose of bail under section 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). This issue is examined in the context of relevant statutory provisions and Corrective Services policies. Ultimately, the court must consider these factors in light of the broader statutory framework and policies governing detention conditions and the granting of bail.
The matter before the court is an application for bail and a review of the bail decision from the Magistrates Court. Alexander, the accused, was initially remanded in custody following charges being laid in the Magistrates Court. Upon the application of the accused for bail, the Magistrates Court conducted a hearing where it considered the application under the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). After weighing various factors, the Magistrates Court declined to grant bail to Alexander, a decision which he subsequently sought to have reviewed. The application for bail review was filed in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, where it was heard by [redacted]. The Supreme Court's review focused on whether the detention of Alexander with convicted offenders contravened section 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), and if such contravention constituted "special or exceptional circumstances" as contemplated by section 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). Throughout the process, the court examined relevant statutory provisions, including the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT), to determine the implications of these statutory rights on the bail decision. Ultimately, the Supreme Court found that the breach of the accused's human rights amounted to special or exceptional circumstances, warranting the grant of bail.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the detention of the accused with convicted offenders, contrary to s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), constitutes "special or exceptional circumstances" for the purpose of s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT).
2. How the contravention of s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) impacts the consideration of the factors under s 22 of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) in the context of a bail application.
3. Whether the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) is limited by s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT).
4. What purpose s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT) serves in relation to the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT).
5. Whether the special circumstances established by the contravention of the accused's rights under s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) favour the grant of bail under s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT).
Held
1. The court concluded that the detention of the accused with convicted offenders, contrary to s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), constitutes "special or exceptional circumstances" for the purpose of s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). The result was that these circumstances were considered in the bail decision.
2. The contravention of s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) impacted the consideration of the factors under s 22 of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) by adding weight to the special circumstances that favoured the grant of bail.
3. The court concluded that the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) is not limited by s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT). The result was that the right remained intact.
4. The purpose of s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT) was found to be to implement rather than qualify the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT). The result was that the right was upheld in its entirety.
5. The court determined that the special circumstances established by the contravention of the accused's rights under s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) did favour the grant of bail under s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). The result was that bail was granted.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the issue of whether the detention of the accused with convicted offenders, contrary to s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), constituted "special or exceptional circumstances" for the purpose of s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). The court examined the plain language of s 9D, which provides that bail may be refused if there are special or exceptional circumstances that make it appropriate to do so. The court held that a contravention of s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) could indeed amount to special or exceptional circumstances, given that it directly contravened a legislated human right, thereby triggering a consideration of the special or exceptional circumstances provision under the Bail Act 1992 (ACT).
Turning to the second issue, the court considered how the contravention of s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) impacts the consideration of the factors under s 22 of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) in the context of a bail application. Section 22(1) of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT) requires the court to consider all relevant circumstances, including the nature and seriousness of the offence, the accused's criminal history, and the likelihood of the accused appearing in court if released on bail. The court found that the contravention of the accused's rights under s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) should be factored into this consideration, potentially tipping the balance in favour of granting bail to remedy the violation of the accused's legislated human rights.
The third issue involved whether the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) was limited by s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT). The court meticulously analyzed both statutory provisions and concluded that s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT) did not limit the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT). Instead, s 44 was found to be an implementation provision that aimed to ensure the practical operation of the right contained in s 19(2). The court distinguished between limitations and implementation, holding that s 44 was not a limitation but rather a mechanism for fulfilling the legislated right.
The court then considered the purpose of s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT) in relation to the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT). The court held that s 44 served to implement the right contained in s 19(2), rather than to qualify it. This interpretation aligned with the principle that statutory provisions should be construed in a way that gives effect to legislated rights, rather than undermining them. The court's finding reinforced the idea that s 44 was intended to facilitate the operation of the right, rather than to impose restrictions on it.
Finally, the court addressed whether the special circumstances established by the contravention of the accused's rights under s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) favoured the grant of bail under s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT). Given the contravention of a legislated human right, the court held that the special circumstances did indeed favour the grant of bail. The court emphasised that the remedy of bail was particularly appropriate to address the breach of the accused's human rights, thereby aligning with the overarching principles of justice and human dignity enshrined in the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT). Consequently, the court granted bail to the accused, underscoring the importance of protecting legislated human rights and the role of bail in achieving this objective.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the contravention of s 19 of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), which mandates the segregation of accused persons from convicted offenders, constitutes special or exceptional circumstances under s 9D of the Bail Act 1992 (ACT), potentially favouring the grant of bail. The court distinguished the implementation nature of s 44 of the Corrections Management Act 2007 (ACT) from a limitation on the right contained in s 19(2) of the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT), thereby holding that such contravention can weigh significantly in the consideration of bail applications.