Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Chaouk

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT

CITATION:
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Chaouk and Anor [2010] NSWSC 1418

JURISDICTION:

FILE NUMBER(S):
2010/12426

HEARING DATE(S):
26 November 2010

JUDGMENT DATE:
8 December 2010

PARTIES:
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) (Plaintiff)
Basame Chaouk (First Defendant)
Local Court of New South Wales (Second Defendant)

JUDGMENT OF:
Johnson J      

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Local Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
1066/09

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Magistrate George

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
7 October 2009

COUNSEL:
Mr I Bourke (Plaintiff)
Mr B Chaouk (First Defendant - In Person)

SOLICITORS:
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) (Plaintiff)
Mr B Chaouk (First Defendant - In Person)
Local Court of New South Wales (Second Defendant - Submitting Appearance)

CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW
claim for prerogative relief
summary hearing
charges of affray and being armed with intent to commit indictable offence
failure by police to comply with brief of evidence requirements
brief included ERISP of witness and not witness statement
prosecution application to dispense with brief requirements and for adjournment
defence opposed dispensation application but consented to adjournment
refusal by Magistrate of both prosecution applications
charges dismissed
held that refusal of adjournment constituted denial of procedural fairness
relief granted

LEGISLATION CITED:
Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001
Crimes Act 1900
Criminal Procedure Act 1986
Supreme Court Act 1970
Suitors’ Fund Act 1951
Justices Act 1902
Local Court Rules 2009

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Director of Public Prosecutions v West [2000] NSWCA 103; 48 NSWLR 647
Blazevski v Judges of the District Court (1992) 29 ALD 197
Nitiva v Director of Public Prosecutions [1999] NSWCA 332
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Ozakca [2006] NSWSC 1245; 68 NSWLR 325
McRae v Redmond (Smart J, 7 May 1987) 8 Petty Sessions Review 3534
Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Fungavaka [2010] NSWSC 917
Director of Public Prosecutions v Cassell (1995) 80 A Crim R 160
The Queen v Lewis [1988] HCA 24; 165 CLR 12
Watson v Watson (1968) 70 SR(NSW) 203
Bell v Imrie (Yeldham J, 24 February 1989) 8 Petty Sessions Review 3905

TEXTS CITED:

DECISION:
1.  An order is made calling up the record of the Parramatta Local Court relating to the First Defendant on 7 October 2009.
2.  An order is made in the nature of certiorari quashing the decision of the Parramatta Local Court on 7 October 2009 refusing the prosecution’s application for adjournment.
3.  An order is made quashing the order of dismissal made by the Parramatta Local Court on 7 October 2009 with respect to the charges brought against the First Defendant.
4.  An order is made that the proceedings be remitted to the Parramatta Local Court to be heard and determined according to law.
5.  No order is made as to costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION

Johnson J

8 December 2010

2010/12426         Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Basame Chaouk and Anor

JUDGMENT

  1. JOHNSON J:  By an Amended Summons filed 2 September 2010,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v Chaouk and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 1418
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a prosecution brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) against the First Defendant, Chaouk, on charges of affray and being armed with intent to commit an indictable offence. The matter was initially heard in the Local Court of New South Wales and subsequently came before the District Court of New South Wales. The First Defendant was unrepresented during the proceedings.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the prosecution had complied with the requirements of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 in serving a brief of evidence, and if not, whether the court should grant a dispensation to allow the evidence to be admitted. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the refusal to grant an adjournment constituted a denial of procedural fairness to the defendant.

The court found that the prosecution had failed to comply with the requirements of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 by serving a brief of evidence that included an ERISP of a witness rather than a written witness statement. Despite this, the prosecution sought to have the brief dispensed with and for the matter to be adjourned. The defence opposed the prosecution’s application for dispensation but consented to an adjournment. The Magistrate refused both applications, resulting in the charges being dismissed. The court held that the refusal to grant an adjournment constituted a denial of procedural fairness to the First Defendant, and thus granted the relief sought by the prosecution.

The final orders included the dismissal of the charges due to the procedural unfairness experienced by the First Defendant, and the granting of relief to the prosecution on the basis of the procedural error identified.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing of the Amended Summons on 26 November 2010, Mr Bourke of counsel appeared for the Plaintiff. The First Defendant appeared unrepresented. A submitting appearance had been filed on behalf of the Second Defendant, the Local Court of New South Wales. The First Defendant had been unrepresented when the matter came before Price J for hearing on 6 August 2010, with an adjournment being granted to him to seek legal representation. On 26 November 2010, the First Defendant was still unrepresented and the matter proceeded to hearing.Factual BackgroundThe Incident on 16 January 2009 As at January 2009, the First Defendant and Shane Towney had been neighbours for approximately two years, residing in a street in Granville. Mr Towney lived directly across the road from the First Defendant. The relationship between them was characterised by much animosity. About 11.40 am on 16 January 2009, the First Defendant arrived home. At the time, Mr Towney was placing his council bin at the front of his premises across the road. It is alleged that the First Defendant looked at Mr Towney and said words to the effect of “What are you doing, fat boy?” An argument then ensued with both hurling abuse at one another. Both remained on opposing sides of the street. However, the argument became increasingly heated, with the First Defendant yelling “I’m gunna fix you”. It is alleged that the First Defendant went inside his house for a short time and Mr Towney remained on the other side of the street. The First Defendant then returned, brandishing a silver knife with a 15 centimetre fold-out blade, which he was carrying in his right hand. It is alleged that he stormed across the street towards Mr Towney, who saw the knife upon approach, but stood his ground. The First Defendant is alleged to have approached Mr Towney, raised his right hand and jabbed Mr Towney to the upper-left cheek with the knife in hand. This action caused Mr Towney immediate pain and opened an eight centimetre abrasion to his upper-left cheek. It is alleged that Mr Towney then said to one of his young children, who was present throughout, “Go and get me a knife”. It is alleged that the First Defendant then retreated across the street to his front yard. Both men continued to hurl abuse at each other from opposite sides of the street. Mr Towney is alleged to have said words to the effect “If you want a fight, we’ll go at it in the street like men. Anyone can use a knife”. It is alleged that one of Mr Towney’s sons then returned with what is described as a butcher’s knife. He gave it to Mr Towney, who then charged into the middle of the street yelling “If you want to fight, come over here” whilst waving the knife, described as having a black handle and a silver blade and being about 20-30 centimetres in length. The First Defendant is then said to have retreated further to the front porch of his home, whilst Mr Towney moved onto the front driveway of the First Defendant’s home, continuing to entice him into a further confrontation. At that point, an independent witness and Mr Towney’s wife both contacted the police. It is alleged that, upon hearing that the arrival of police was imminent, Mr Towney gave the knife back to his son and advised him to return it to its kept place.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

No election was made for trial on indictment. Accordingly, the hearing of these matters in the Local Court on 7 October 2009 was to proceed as a summary hearing, thereby attracting pretrial procedures contained in ss.182-189 Criminal Procedure Act 1986. In particular, it is important to observe that ss.183, 186, 187 and 188 Criminal Procedure Act 1986 applied to these proceedings. Those provisions state:“183 Brief of evidence to be served on accused person where not guilty plea(1)If an accused person pleads not guilty to an offence, the prosecutor must, subject to section 187, serve or cause to be served on the accused person a copy of the brief of evidence relating to the offence.(2)The brief of evidence is, unless the regulations otherwise provide, to consist of documents regarding the evidence that the prosecutor intends to adduce in order to prove the commission of the offence and is to include:(a) written statements taken from the persons the prosecutor intends to call to give evidence in proceedings for the offence, and(b)copies of any document or any other thing, identified in such a written statement as a proposed exhibit.(3)The copy of the brief of evidence is to be served at least 14 days before the hearing of the evidence for the prosecution.(4)The Magistrate may set a later date for service with the consent of the accused person or if of the opinion that the circumstances of the case require it. …186 Form of copy of brief of evidence(1)The copy of the brief of evidence is to comply with any requirement applicable to it prescribed by the rules.(2)A written statement contained in the brief of evidence is to comply with this Act and any requirement applicable to it prescribed by the rules.187 When brief of evidence need not be served(1)The court may order that all or part of the copy of the brief of evidence need not be served if it is satisfied:(a)that there are compelling reasons for not requiring service, or(b)that it could not reasonably be served on the accused person.(2)The court may make an order under this section on its own initiative or on the application of any party.(3)An order may be made subject to any conditions that the court thinks fit.(4)Without limiting any other power to adjourn proceedings, the court may grant one or more adjournments, if it appears to it to be just and reasonable to do so, if the copy of the brief of evidence is not served in accordance with this Division. For that purpose, the court may extend the time for service of the brief of evidence.(5)A prosecutor is not required to serve a brief of evidence in proceedings for an offence of a kind, or proceedings of a kind, prescribed by the regulations.188 Evidence not to be admitted(1)The court must refuse to admit evidence sought to be adduced by the prosecutor in respect of an offence if, in relation to that evidence, this Division or any rules made under this Division have not been complied with by the prosecutor.(2)The court may, and on the application of or with the consent of the accused person must, dispense with the requirements of subsection (1) on such terms and conditions as appear just and reasonable.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the refusal of the adjournment by the Magistrate constituted a denial of procedural fairness.
2. Whether the Magistrate should have granted the prosecution's application to dispense with the brief of evidence requirements.

Held
1. The refusal of the adjournment by the Magistrate constituted a denial of procedural fairness.
2. The Magistrate should not have granted the prosecution's application to dispense with the brief of evidence requirements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the procedural fairness and the requirement of a brief of evidence in the context of the case against the First Defendant. In relation to the adjournment, the Court held that the Magistrate's refusal to adjourn the proceedings despite the absence of legal representation for the First Defendant and the lack of a brief of evidence from the prosecution amounted to a denial of procedural fairness. This was due to the First Defendant being prejudiced in his ability to effectively prepare and present his defence. Consequently, the Court granted the relief sought by the First Defendant.

On the issue of the brief of evidence, the Court held that the Magistrate should not have granted the prosecution's application to dispense with the brief of evidence requirements. The Court observed that the brief of evidence included the Evidence at Rest Interview Summary Protocol (ERISP) of a witness instead of the witness statement, which was not compliant with the statutory requirements. The Court held that the Magistrate should not have made an order dispensing with the requirements of the brief of evidence without the consent of the First Defendant, as mandated by s 188 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986. The Court noted that the Magistrate did not consider the impact of the non-compliance on the First Defendant's ability to adequately prepare a defence, which was a significant factor in determining whether the application should be granted.