Dimitrov v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2018 0107

PETER MICHAEL DIMITROV & ORS (according to the Schedule) Applicants
v
BENDIGO & ADELAIDE BANK LTD (ACN 068 049 178) & ORS (according to the Schedule) Respondents

---

JUDGES: WHELAN AP, HARGRAVE AND EMERTON JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
HOW OBTAINED: On the papers
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 13 March 2019
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: Dimitrov & Ors v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd & Ors [No 2]
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2019] VSCA 51
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2014] VSC 516 (Croft J)

---

COSTS – Application for extension of time for leave to appeal – application dismissed – ordinary costs consequences of unsuccessful application – applicants pay costs of eleventh to thirteenth respondents.

---

WHELAN AP
HARGRAVE JA
EMERTON JA:

  1. On 6 March 2019 we delivered judgment on an application by the applicants for an extension of time in which to seek leave to appeal from orders approving a settlement of group proceedings.[1]  The application for an extension of time for leave to appeal was dismissed.  The first to fourth respondents sought to have their costs reserved, foreshadowing an application for indemnity costs once certain related proceedings were determined.  The eleventh to thirteenth respondents (‘the directors’) sought costs on the standard basis.  Counsel for the applicants sought an opportunity to read the Reasons and, if so advised, file and serve a brief written submission.  Directions were made for the filing and service of a submission by the applicants on the application for costs by the directors and for a written submission in response. 

    [1][2019] VSCA 41 (‘the Reasons’). These reasons assume knowledge of the contents of the Reasons.

  1. The applicants filed a written submission resisting the costs order sought on behalf of the directors.  They resisted the order on the following basis:

(1)The applicants had only ever sought orders affecting their own particular situation in relation to the first respondent, Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited (‘BABL’).  The applicants had never sought orders that would ‘change the rights of the directors’.  They were only concerned to preserve their ability to pursue defences and cross-claims against BABL.  In the circumstances, the directors had been acting much like an ‘intervener’ and the principles which apply to interveners should be applied to them.  The directors had no interest which was not in common with BABL. 

(2)The application made was a ‘test case’ which was focused on significant legal issues and was of likely benefit to a considerable number of people otherwise left in doubt as to their legal position.  In such test cases the general approach to costs is not, and should not, be followed.

  1. In the alternative, the applicants sought an order staying any order as to costs until certain related matters concerning two of the applicants (Cairncross and Laszczuk) were determined.

  1. In response, the directors submitted:

(1)The directors were not ‘interveners’.  They were joined as respondents by the applicants.  The relief sought by the applicants included an order vacating the orders…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dimitrov v Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] VSCA 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Dimitrov and others, sought an extension of time to appeal against orders approving a settlement of group proceedings. The respondents, Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd and others, opposed the extension and sought costs on the standard basis, while the directors of the respondents sought to have their costs reserved for potential indemnity costs. The applicants argued that the directors were akin to interveners and that the application was a test case, thus not warranting a costs order. The directors contended that they were not interveners and that the application was not a test case, and they sought an order for costs according to the ordinary rule and against a stay.

The court examined whether the directors should be considered interveners and whether the application was a test case. The court found that the directors were not interveners, as they were joined as respondents by the applicants and had a real interest in the outcome of the application. The court also found that the application was not a test case, as the determinative factors of the application, delay and prejudice, did not concern the legal issues raised. Therefore, the ordinary cost consequences of an unsuccessful application should follow.

The court ordered that the applicants pay the costs of the directors of the application for an extension of time. The court also considered that there was no ground for a stay, as the directors were not parties to the related applications, and the outcome of those applications could not affect the assessment of the directors' position in relation to the application for an extension of time.

The final orders were that the applicants pay the costs of the eleventh to thirteenth respondents of the application for extension of time. The applicants were also ordered to pay the costs of the directors of the application for an extension of time.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by the applicants, Peter Michael Dimitrov, Mark Simon Laszczuk, and Tiffany Michelle Cairncross, for an extension of time to seek leave to appeal from orders approving a settlement of group proceedings. The respondents include Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited (BABL) and other parties. The applicants sought to vacate the orders approving the settlement, arguing they had not been properly served and had not received proper legal advice. The eleventh to thirteenth respondents, who are directors of BABL, sought costs on the standard basis.

The case originated from the Supreme Court of Victoria and was appealed to the Court of Appeal. On 6 March 2019, the Court of Appeal delivered judgment on the application for an extension of time to seek leave to appeal, dismissing the application. The first to fourth respondents sought to have their costs reserved, with an intention to apply for indemnity costs in related proceedings. The eleventh to thirteenth respondents sought costs on the standard basis. The applicants filed a written submission resisting the costs order sought by the directors, arguing that the directors should be treated as interveners and that the application was a test case. The directors submitted that they were not interveners and that the application was not a test case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the directors are to be treated as 'interveners' in the context of the application for an extension of time.
2. Whether the application for an extension of time can be considered a 'test case' and if the principles applicable to such cases should apply.
3. Whether the ordinary cost consequences of an unsuccessful application should follow.
4. Whether there should be a stay of the order as to costs until certain related matters are determined.

Held
1. The directors are not to be treated as 'interveners' in the context of the application for an extension of time. The court concluded that the directors had a real interest in the outcome of the application as parties to the deed of settlement and their submissions did not simply replicate those of other respondents.
2. The application for an extension of time cannot be considered a 'test case'. The court held that the application was not sufficiently analogous to a test case to warrant the application of the principles applicable to such cases.
3. The ordinary cost consequences of an unsuccessful application should follow. The court determined that costs should be awarded to the directors on the standard basis.
4. There should be no stay of the order as to costs until certain related matters are determined. The court found that there was no ground for a stay as the outcome on those applications could not affect the assessment of the directors' position in relation to the application for an extension of time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the arguments presented by both the applicants and the directors regarding the costs of the application for an extension of time. The Court concluded that the directors were not 'interveners', as they were joined as respondents by the applicants and had a real interest in the outcome of the application as parties to the deed of settlement. The Court found that the application for an extension of time was not a test case, as the legal issues of delay and prejudice did not concern the significant legal issues raised in the application.

The Court then turned to the question of whether the ordinary cost consequences of an unsuccessful application should follow. The Court held that, in this case, the ordinary cost consequences should apply and that the applicants should pay the costs of the directors on the standard basis. Finally, the Court rejected the applicants' request for a stay of the order as to costs until certain related matters were determined, finding that there was no ground for a stay as the outcome on those applications could not affect the assessment of the directors' position in relation to the application for an extension of time. The Court's reasoning demonstrates its adherence to the established legal principles concerning interveners, test cases, and the ordinary cost consequences of an unsuccessful application, as well as its consideration of the unique circumstances of the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the ordinary cost consequences of an unsuccessful application should follow, and that the principles concerning interveners and test cases do not apply in this case.