Digital Central Australia (Assets) Pty Ltd v Stefanovski (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Digital Central Australia (Assets) Pty Ltd v Stefanovski (No 2) [2017] FCA 1000

File number: QUD 865 of 2016
Judge: LOGAN J
Date of judgment: 25 August 2017
Catchwords:

EQUITY – confidential information – use of confidential information – scope of protection

CONTRACT – intellectual property – confidential information – where use of confidential information in breach of contract – restraint of trade – obligations of franchisee as to confidential information after termination of contract – effect of explicit contractual restraint – scope of protection – damages

EQUITY – injunctions – former franchisee of applicant created corporation to compete with applicant both during and following contractual relationship with applicant – former franchisee used confidential information in businesses run in competition with applicant – conduct of former franchisee in breach of equitable obligations owed to applicant and statutory duties – damages for breach of contract and equitable compensation inadequate to protect interests of party

EQUITY – equitable remedies – doctrines and principles – imposition of duty of confidence – necessary conditions

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct – unconscionable conduct – breach of statutory duty of good faith in franchise agreement – concealment of intention before and after termination and sale of franchise to cause company to engage in competition with franchise business – knowing assistance – injunction - damages  

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 80

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 131, 133

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A

Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No 2) 2010 (Cth) s 87

Australian Consumer Law s 232

Companies (New South Wales) Code 1981 (NSW) s 81

Cases cited:

Bay v Illawarra Stationery Supplies Pty Ltd (1986) 4 ACLC 429

B J McAdam Pty Limited v Jax Tyres Pty Limited (No 3) [2012] FCA 1438

Digital Central (Assets) Pty Ltd v Stefanovski [2017] FCA 738

Intelsec System Ltd v Grech-Cini [1999] 4 All ER 11

Kelner v Baxter (1866) LR 2 CP 174

O’Brien v Komesaroff (1982) 150 CLR 310

Pioneer Concrete Services Ltd v Galli [1985] VR 675

Streetscape Projects (Australia) Pty Ltd v City of Sydney (2013) 85 NSWLR 196

Summergreene v Parker (1950) 80 CLR 304

Zomojo Pty Ltd v Hurd (No 2) (2012) 299 ALR 621

Date of hearing: 1 August 2017
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Economic Regulator, Competition and Access
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 42
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J Sweeney
Solicitor for the Applicant: HRT Legal
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr S Couper QC with Mr P Afshar
Solicitor for the Respondents: KB Legals

ORDERS

QUD 865 of 2016
BETWEEN:

DIGITAL CENTRAL AUSTRALIA (ASSETS) PTY LTD ACN 114 113 709

Applicant

AND:

TOME STEFANOVSKI

First Respondent

KYLIE CLARK

Second Respondent

ANT PRINTING PTY LTD ACN 607 685 325 (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

LOGAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 AUGUST 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

First Respondent – Mr Stefanovski

1.From…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Digital Central Australia (Assets) Pty Ltd v Stefanovski (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1000
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Digital Central Australia (Assets) Pty Ltd sued Mr Stefanovski, Ms Clark, Ant Printing, TK Sign Installations, and a company trading as ARES. The dispute involved the misuse of confidential information and breach of contract by Mr Stefanovski and others. They were alleged to have used the applicant’s confidential information to compete with it after the termination of a franchise agreement. The court had to determine the scope of protection for confidential information under contract and equity, the enforceability of explicit contractual restraints, and the adequacy of damages for breach of contract and equitable obligations.

The court held that the confidentiality obligations under the franchise agreement were clear and enforceable. The use of confidential information to compete with the applicant constituted a breach of both contractual and equitable duties. The explicit contractual restraints were enforceable, and the scope of protection extended to the specific information and businesses identified. The court found that damages for breach of contract and equitable compensation were inadequate to protect the applicant’s interests. Therefore, injunctive relief was appropriate to prevent further misuse of confidential information and to restrain the respondents from competing with the applicant in certain areas.

The court ordered Mr Stefanovski, Ms Clark, and TK Sign Installations to pay damages and equitable compensation to the applicant. They were also restrained from using the applicant’s confidential information and from operating competing businesses in specified areas until certain dates. Ant Printing was ordered to pay damages and equitable compensation and was restrained from using confidential information. The application against the fourth respondent was dismissed. The court reserved costs pending further submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

First Respondent – Mr Stefanovski

1. From the date of this Order until 31 March 2018, the first respondent must not (personally or through employees, agents or in any other way) use, or disclose to any third party, and must not cause or permit the third or fifth respondents or any other person to use or disclose to any third party, any of the following information:

(a) the technique described in the Franchise Manual as to how successfully to apply (or remove) a vinyl print to a signboard; and

(b) any information derived from the password-protected part of the website realestate.digitalcentral.com.au which is pricing information concerning the Approved Products, customer product preferences or customer purchasing history.

2. Within 5 business days of the date of this Order, the first respondent is to deliver up to HRT Legal, the solicitors for the applicant, any original or copy document (in whatever form) in his possession, power or control, or in the possession, power or control of the fifth respondent which contains any of the information set out in Order 1 above.

3. Within 10 business days of the date of this Order or such further time as maybe agreed to in writing by the applicant or granted on application by the Court the first respondent is to make, file and serve on the applicant an affidavit deposing to his compliance with Orders 2 and 4.

4. From the date of this order until 10 August 2018, the first respondent:

(a) must not, directly or indirectly, own, or have a financial, legal or beneficial interest in, or manage, operate, conduct, be employed by or in connection with, or be involved in the operations of, any business:

(i) involving the retail sale (in the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order) of items similar to the Approved Products; or

(ii) similar to the Franchised Business (if that business operates from, or within, the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order);

(b) without derogating from Order 4(a), must not be directly or indirectly involved or interested in (whether as shareholder, director, employee agent or otherwise) the “ARES” business of the third respondent, to the extent that that the operation of that business has either or each of the characteristics described in that sub-paragraph.

5. The first respondent pay to the applicant the sum of $58,476 as equitable compensation and as damages caused by contraventions of section 51AD of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (CCA) and section 21 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), together with pre-judgment interest of $2475 pursuant to section 51A(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act);

6. The first respondent be jointly and severally liable with the second, third and fifth respondents to pay to the applicant the sum and the amount of interest thereon referred to in Order 5.

Second Respondent – Ms Clark

7. From the date of this order until 31 March 2018, the second respondent must not (personally or through employees, agents or in any other way) use, or disclose to any third party, and must not cause or permit the third or fifth respondents or any other person to use or disclose to any third party, any of the following information:

(a) the technique described in the Franchise Manual as to how successfully to apply (or remove) a vinyl print to a signboard; and

(b) any information derived from the password-protected part of the website realestate.digitalcentral.com.au which is pricing information concerning the Approved Products, customer product preferences or customer purchasing history.

8. Within 5 business days of the date of this Order, the second respondent is to deliver up to HRT Legal, the solicitors for the applicant, any original or copy document (in whatever form) in her possession, power or control, or in the possession, power or control of the third respondent which contains any of the information set out in Order 6 above.

9. From the date of this order until 10 August 2018, the second respondent:

(a) must not, directly or indirectly, own, or have a financial, legal or beneficial interest in, or manage, operate, conduct, be employed by or in connection with, or be involved in the operations of, any business:

(i) involving the retail sale (in the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this order) of items similar to the Approved Products;

(ii) similar to the Franchised Business (if that business operates from, or within, the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order);

(b) without derogating from Order 9(a), must not be directly or indirectly involved or interested in (whether as shareholder, director, employee, agent or otherwise) the “ARES” business of the third respondent, to the extent that the operation of that business has either or each of the characteristics described in that sub-paragraph.

10. Forthwith after the date of this Order and until 10 August 2018, the second respondent must cause the third respondent’s websites using the ANT Printing Domain Names to display (in a prominent position on the customer login page and in conjunction with a link to or copy of this Order) a notice that the third respondent has, until 10 August 2018, been restrained, by order of the Federal Court of Australia, from operating any business:

(i) involving the retail sale (in the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to the Court’s Order) of items similar to the Approved Products, as defined in the Court’s Order;

(ii) similar to the Franchised Business, as defined in the Court’s order (if that business operates from, or within, the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed the Schedule 1 to that Order);

11. Within 10 business days of the date of this Order or such further time as may be agreed to in writing by the applicant or granted on application by the Court, the second respondent is to make, file and serve on the applicant an affidavit deposing to her compliance with Orders 8 and 10.

12. The second respondent pay to the applicant the sum of $58,476 as equitable compensation and as damages caused by contraventions of section 51AD of the CCA and section 21 of the ACL, together with pre-judgment interest of $2,475 pursuant to section 51A(1)(a) of the FCA Act.

13. The second respondent be jointly and severally liable with the first, third and fifth respondents to pay to the applicant the sum and the amount of interest thereon referred to in Order 12.

Third Respondent – Ant Printing

14. From the date of this order until 31 March 2018, the third respondent must not (personally or through employees, agents or in any other way) use, or disclose to any third party, and must not cause or permit any person to use or disclose to any third party, any of the following information:

(a) the technique described in the applicant’s Franchise Manual as to how successfully to apply (or remove) a vinyl print to a signboard; and

(b) any information derived from the password-protected part of the website realestate.digitalcentral.com.au which is pricing information concerning the Approved Products, customer product preferences or customer purchasing history.

15. From the date of this Order until 10 August 2018, the third respondent:

(a) must not, directly or indirectly, own, or have a financial, legal or beneficial interest in, or manage, operate, conduct, be employed by or in connection with, or be involved in the operations of, any business:

(i) involving the retail sale (in the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order) of items similar to the Approved Products;

(ii) similar to the Franchised Business (if that business operates from, or within, the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order);

(b) without derogating from Order 15(a), must not operate or be directly or indirectly involved or interested in the “ARES” business, to the extent that the operation of that business has either or each of the characteristics described in that sub-paragraph.

16. The third respondent pay to the applicant the sum of $58,476 as equitable compensation and as damages caused by contraventions of section 51AD of the CCA and section 21 of the ACL, together with pre-judgment interest of $2,475 pursuant to section 51A (1)(a) of the FCA Act;

17. The third respondent be jointly and severally liable with the first, second and fifth respondents to pay to the applicant the sum and the amount of interest thereon referred to in Order 16.

Fourth Respondent

18. Insofar as it relates to the fourth respondent, the application be dismissed.

Fifth Respondent – TK Sign Installations

19. From the date of this order until 31 March 2018, the fifth respondent must not (personally or through employees, agents or in any other way) use, or disclose to any third party, and must not cause or permit any person to use or disclose to any third party, any of the following information:

(a) the technique described in the Franchise Manual as to how successfully to apply (or remove) a vinyl print to a signboard; and

(b) any information derived from the password-protected part of the website realestate.digitalcentral.com.au which is pricing information concerning the Approved Products, customer product preferences or customer purchasing history.

20. From the date of this order until 10 August 2018, the fifth respondent:

(a) must not, directly or indirectly, own, or have a financial, legal or beneficial interest in, or manage, operate, conduct, be employed by or in connection with, or be involved in the operations of, any business:

(i) involving the retail sale (in the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order) of items similar to the Approved Products;

(ii) similar to the Franchised Business (if that business operates from, or within, the suburbs listed in the postcodes listed in Schedule 1 to this Order);

(b) without derogating from Order 20(a), must not be directly or indirectly involved or interested in (whether as shareholder or otherwise) the “ARES” business of the third respondent to the extent that the operation of that business has either or each of the characteristics described in that sub-paragraph.

21. The fifth respondent pay to the applicant the sum of $58,476 as damages for breach of the Franchise Agreement, equitable compensation and as damages caused by contraventions of section 51AD of the CCA and section 21 of the ACL, together with pre-judgment interest of $2,475 pursuant to section 51A(1)(a) of the FCA Act;

22. The fifth respondent be jointly and severally liable with the first, second and third respondents to pay to the applicant the sum and the amount of interest thereon referred to in Order 21.

Costs

23. Costs be reserved.

24. As to the costs of the proceedings, including reserved costs:

(a) the applicant file and serve any submission as to costs, being not more than 10 pages, not later than close of business on 6 September 2017;

(b) the respondents file and serve any submission as to costs, being not more than 10 pages, not later than close of business on 15 September 2017;

(c) the applicant file and serve any submission in reply, being not more than 7 pages, or alternatively signify in writing to the Registrar and to the respondents that no submission in reply will be filed not later than 22 September 2017;

(d) upon the filing of the applicant’s submission in reply or, as the case may be, signification to the Registrar and the respondents, judgement as to costs shall stand reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Sections 131 and 133 of the Corporations Act, each within Pt 2B.3 of that Act, entitled, “Contracts Before Registration”, respectively provide:131 Contracts before registration (1)If a person enters into, or purports to enter into, a contract on behalf of, or for the benefit of, a company before it is registered, the company becomes bound by the contract and entitled to its benefit if the company, or a company that is reasonably identifiable with it, is registered and ratifies the contract: (a) within the time agreed to by the parties to the contract; or (b)if there is no agreed time--within a reasonable time after the contract is entered into. (2)The person is liable to pay damages to each other party to the pre-registration contract if the company is not registered, or the company is registered but does not ratify the contract or enter into a substitute for it: (a) within the time agreed to by the parties to the contract; or (b)if there is no agreed time--within a reasonable time after the contract is entered into. The amount that the person is liable to pay to a party is the amount the company would be liable to pay to the party if the company had ratified the contract and then did not perform it at all. (3)If proceedings are brought to recover damages under subsection (2) because the company is registered but does not ratify the pre-registration contract or enter into a substitute for it, the court may do anything that it considers appropriate in the circumstances, including ordering the company to do 1 or more of the following: (a) pay all or part of the damages that the person is liable to pay; (b)transfer property that the company received because of the contract to a party to the contract; (c) pay an amount to a party to the contract. (4)If the company ratifies the pre--registration contract but fails to perform all or part of it, the court may order the person to pay all or part of the damages that the company is ordered to pay.133 This Part replaces other rights and liabilities This Part replaces any rights or liabilities anyone would otherwise have on the pre--registration contract. The correct position in relation to s 131 is, with respect, well summarised by Perram J in B J McAdam Pty Limited v Jax Tyres Pty Limited (No 3) [2012] FCA 1438, at [21] to [22] (B J McAdam v Jax Tyres):21… At common law, it was not possible for a party to ratify acts of an alleged agent which occurred prior to the party’s existence: Kelner v Baxter (1866) LR 2 CP 174; North Sydney Investment and Tramway Company Limited v Higgins [1899] AC 263 at 271-272 per Lord Davey; Natal Land and Colonization Co Ltd v Pauline Colliery and Development Syndicate Ltd [1904] AC 120 at 126 per Lord Davey; Dudley Buildings Pty Ltd v Rose (1933) 49 CLR 84 at 94 per Starke J; Vickery v Woods (1952) 85 CLR 336 at 348 per Williams J.22Upon the introduction of the uniform companies laws in 1981 (including the Companies Act 1981 (Cth) and the Companies (New South Wales) Code 1981 (NSW)), the common law position was changed in relation to pre-incorporation contracts by s 81 of the Companies Code. This followed the Victoria Law Reform Commissioner’s eighth report, Pre-Incorporation Contracts, Report No 8 [1979] VicLRCmr 8. The present version of that provision is now found in s 131 of the Corporations Act …