FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Diawara v National Australia Bank Limited [2023] FCA 1048
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Diawara v National Australia Bank Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 1048
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court meticulously examined the nature and content of the "Cultural Review Report" and the circumstances surrounding its creation. It found that the report was commissioned by NAB's legal representatives, Herbert Smith Freehills (HSF), from a third party, WWS, to assist in providing legal advice to NAB regarding its legal obligations in the substantive proceedings. The report was intended to be used exclusively for this legal advice and was prepared under strict protocols to maintain its privileged status. The court considered the letter of engagement between HSF and WWS, which outlined the confidential and privileged nature of the report and the conditions for its preparation and handling. The court concluded that the dominant purpose of the report was indeed for legal advice, and thus, it was subject to legal professional privilege. The respondent's conduct, including its refusal to disclose the report to the media and its adherence to the stipulated protocols, further supported the claim of privilege. Therefore, the court granted the respondent's application and excused it from producing the "Cultural Review Report."
The court's final orders included excusing the respondent from complying with the notice to produce the "Cultural Review Report" and directing the applicant to pay the respondent's costs of the application. These orders underscore the importance of maintaining legal professional privilege in protecting the confidentiality of legal advice and ensuring the proper functioning of the legal process.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The respondent be excused from complying with category 1 of the notice to produce dated 12 April 2023 issued by the applicant to the respondent pursuant to rule 30.28(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).
2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of this application, to be agreed or assessed.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The applicant opposed the conclusion that the Cultural Review Report was the subject of legal professional privilege on a number of bases. First, it was contended that Mr Gonski is not the person whose purpose is to be examined, as he was a “mere conduit” through whom the outcome desired by the client was achieved. On the applicant’s submission, the relevant purpose to be examined is the respondent’s, and there is no direct admissible evidence of that purpose. It was also noted that there is nothing in the evidence that even discloses the identity of the person(s) who gave the instructions to procure the Cultural Review Report (whose mind can be taken to be the controlling mind of the corporation for the purposes of this particular transaction). Second, the applicant considered that the asserted dominant purpose of the Cultural Review Report was called into question by the fact that WWS was undertaking a factual investigation into two further matters (ascertained from the letter of engagement). Third, the applicant contended that the Court has not received any detailed evidence of the sequence of events that led to the procuring of the Cultural Review Report from which safe inferences about the dominant purpose of the Cultural Review Report could be drawn (comparing DBCT). Fourth, the applicant submitted that Mr Gonski’s bald assertion that the Cultural Review Report was procured for the “sole” purpose of HSF providing the Advice to the respondent is unsupported by evidence of the way in which the instructions to engage WWS came about. As a statement of Mr Gonski’s/HSF’s purpose, it is little more than a “verbal formula”: cf Grant v Downs at 689. It was also submitted that the invitation to view the Cultural Review Report should be rejected. This submission was made on the bases that no “good reason” had been identified to do so; and that doing so may operate an unfairness on the applicant by virtue of the fact that the evidence in support of the privilege claim, on which the applicant could make submissions, was slight: TerraCom v ASIC [2022] FCA 208; (2022) 401 ALR 143 at [74] (TerraCom).Consideration I am satisfied that on the evidence, properly read, the respondent has established that the dominant purpose for the creation of the Cultural Review Report was for it to be utilised by HSF in providing the Advice to the respondent in respect of the substantive proceedings. Contrary to the applicant’s submission, the respondent is not relying on a mere verbal formula. Rather, Mr Gonski’s assertion as to the “sole” purpose for which the Cultural Review Report was created must be considered with the other evidence, which includes the letter of engagement. The claim by Mr Gonski is not unsupported by evidence sufficient to enable the Court to consider and make an informed decision: cf NCA v S at 212. The letter of engagement clearly sets out the basis upon which the Cultural Review Report was sought, which includes, inter alia, its use in providing the Advice sought by the respondent. WWS was provided, inter alia, with the documents filed in the proceedings and Ms Diawara’s Australian Human Rights Commission complaint to assist in conducting the review. Protocols were set out for conducting interviews and contacting interviewees, and the respondent’s staff. The letter of engagement provided that any communications with others in the course of the investigation must include in the heading the words “Privileged and Confidential”. Protocols and conditions for the handling of the material used to compile the Cultural Review Report were detailed. The Cultural Review Report and anything associated with its preparation are repeatedly referred to in the letter of engagement as confidential and privileged. The letter of engagement emphasises that “[i]t is critical that these protocols be followed to ensure that your report remains privileged and to avoid any confusion about your instructions”.