Dexbay Pty Ltd v The Crown

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[1995] QLC 51

 
  LAND COURT

BRISBANE

29 JUNE 1995

Re:                Claim for Compensation -
  Land Act 1962 -
  A93-27.

Dexbay Pty Ltd
  v.
  The Crown

J U R I S D I C T I O N

This is a claim for compensation by Dexbay Pty Ltd (Dexbay) which company purports to hold an interest as sub-lessee of land leased under the Land Act 1962 (the Act) and resumed under the provisions of the Act in November 1991. On the matter being called for hearing, objection was taken by the Crown to the hearing of the claim on grounds that the claim was made out as if Dexbay had an interest in the land as sub-lessee of freehold land to which, it is submitted, the resumption provisions of the Land Act cannot apply.
           The claim arose following the issue of a Proclamation published in the Government Gazette of 30 November 1991 under which the Governor in Council, in pursuance of the provisions of s.306 of the Act, notified and declared that on and from that date the following land in the county of Stanley, parish of South Brisbane, was resumed:

"Lot 4 on plan SL11336, Lot 5 on plan SL12877 and Lot 414 on plan SL 11430 sheets 1 and 2, containing an area of about 4.91 hectares and being the whole of the land contained in Special Lease No 06/51507.  "

S.306 provides that the Governor in Council may resume the whole or any part of any holding and that on resumption the lessee is entitled to compensation as prescribed by Division XI of Part X of the Act.  "Holding" is defined as the land held from the Crown by any lessee and "lessee" is defined as the holder of a lease under the Act.
           At the date of resumption Special Lease 06/51507 (the lease) was held by World Expo Park Pty Ltd (WEP) as lessee for a term of 4 years 7 months and 23 days commencing on 8 May 1989 (expiring 31 December 1993).  The lease was granted under the provisions of s.203(a) of the Act for the purpose of "Business and Commercial (Amusement and Entertainment Park and Public Car Park)" subject to conditions, one of which (C.12) reads:

"The terms and conditions of the lease are subject to the provisions of the South Bank Corporation Act 1989. "

WEP, as lessee, duly pursued a claim for compensation under the relevant provisions of the Act.  The claim was heard by the Court and judgment given on 20 May 1994 (A93-26).  The Court held that

"the claimant company's interest in the lease as lessee had no market value at resumption date.  "

Compensation was determined at Nil.
           Under covering letter dated 24 December 1991, Dexbay, by its solicitors Stubbs Barbeler Grant,           served a claim for compensation upon the Crown as constructing authority in the sum of $761,486.  The claim states that the nature of the interest held by Dexbay in the lease is as sub-lessee of part of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dexbay Pty Ltd v The Crown and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] QLC 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dexbay Pty Ltd (Dexbay) sought compensation from the Crown for the resumption of a lease under the Land Act 1962. Dexbay claimed an interest as sub-lessee of land leased under the Act and resumed by the Crown in November 1991. The Crown objected to the claim, arguing that Dexbay's interest as sub-lessee was derived from freehold land, to which the resumption provisions of the Act could not apply. The Land Court was tasked with determining the nature of Dexbay's interest at the time of resumption and whether compensation was payable.

The court examined the historical context of the land's vesting in the Crown under the South Bank Corporation Act 1989 and subsequent leasing arrangements. Dexbay's sublease agreement with World Expo Park Pty Ltd (WEP), the primary lessee, was not formally approved by the Minister nor registered with the Department of Lands. The court found that Dexbay's interest was not a legal estate but rather an equitable interest, given the Crown's knowledge of the sublease and its lack of objection. However, the court also considered that Dexbay's interest was precarious due to WEP's financial difficulties and the lack of a term certain beyond the initial agreement, which ended in December 1991.

The court concluded that Dexbay's interest at the time of resumption was limited to the one-month period remaining under the option agreement. Given the minimal security of Dexbay's tenure and the absence of a claim for any other interest held at the resumption date, the court ruled that Dexbay was not entitled to compensation. The court noted that any claim for disturbance would face significant difficulties, as it would depend on the degree of security of the tenure.

The court ordered the matter to resume for further evidence and submissions on whether compensation was payable consequent upon the resumption.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established