Department of Education & Training v Mekhail

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Department of Education & Training v Mekhail [2006] NSWWCCPD 1

APPELLANT:  Department of Education & Training

RESPONDENT:  Essam Mekhail

INSURER:GIO Treasury Managed Fund Workers Compensation

FILE NUMBER:  WCC 6180-04

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          11 October 2004

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  10 January 2006

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION:                Leave to file appeal out of time

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Robin Handley

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant: Hunt & Hunt, Lawyers

Respondent: McMahon Associates, Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  Leave to appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator dated 11 October 2004 is refused.

The Appellant, the Department of Education and Training, is to pay the Respondent, Mr Mekhail’s costs in this appeal as agreed or assessed.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 11 November 2004, the Department of Education and Training (‘the Department’) sought leave in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) to bring an appeal against the decision of an arbitrator dated 11 October 2004.

  1. The Respondent to the Appeal is Essam Mekhail. Mr Mekhail was born on 13 March 1957 and is aged 48. He is married with three children aged 15, 11 and 8. Mr Mekhail was employed as an Arabic/ESL [English as a Second Language] teacher at Kogarah High School from September 1997. He alleges that he suffered anxiety and depression as a result of his treatment by senior staff at the School, and was unable to work because of this condition. Liability for Mr Mekhail’s workers compensation claim was initially accepted, but later denied with effect from 11 November 2003.

  1. On 16 April 2004, the Commission registered Mr Mekhail’s ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in respect of his claim for weekly compensation and for medical, hospital or related expenses. The Department’s ‘Reply’ was filed on 4 May 2004. On 28 July 2004, the Arbitrator conducted a teleconference with the parties. On 26 August 2004, conciliation having been proved unsuccessful, she conducted an arbitration hearing, following which, on 11 October 2004, she made the decision set out below.

THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW

  1. The Certificate of Determination, dated 11 October 2004, records the Arbitrator’s orders as follows:

“1. That the Respondent pay the Applicant weekly compensation at the rate of $1,124.83 from 10.11.03 to 19.12.03 and at rate of $1,192.74 for the day 27.01.04 under s 36 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.
2. That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 expenses on production of accounts or receipts.
3. That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed.”

  1. In her ‘Statement of Reasons for Decision’, the Arbitrator summarised the resolution of issues in dispute as follows:

“Weekly Benefits Claim:

• During a period from February 2001 culminating on 26 September 2003, Essam Mekhail sustained a psychiatric illness arising out of or in the course of his employment as a teacher with the Department of Education and Training.
• Essam Mekhail…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Department of Education & Training v Mekhail and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWWCCPD 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by the Department of Education and Training against a decision made by an arbitrator in a workers compensation claim brought by Essam Mekhail. Mekhail, who was employed as an Arabic/ESL teacher at Kogarah High School, alleged that he suffered anxiety and depression due to treatment by senior staff, which led to his inability to work. The Department initially accepted liability for Mekhail's workers compensation claim but later denied it. Mekhail filed an 'Application to Resolve a Dispute' on 16 April 2004, and the Department responded on 4 May 2004. After unsuccessful conciliation, an arbitration hearing was conducted on 26 August 2004, resulting in an Arbitrator's decision on 11 October 2004, which the Department sought to appeal. The Arbitrator's decision ordered the Department to pay Mekhail weekly compensation and medical expenses.

The primary issue before the court was whether the Department's application for leave to appeal out of time should be granted. The Department argued that the Arbitrator erred in the weight she gave to Mekhail's evidence, in finding that he suffered an injury, and in determining that employment was a contributing factor to any injury. They also contended that the Arbitrator erred in finding the Department's actions in respect of performance appraisal and transfer were reasonable. Mekhail's lawyers argued that the appeal was out of time and that the Department did not challenge the existence of an 'injury' in its Reply. They further argued that the Arbitrator correctly applied the law and made no factual errors.

The court reviewed the appeal on the papers, considering the principles set out in Gallo v Dawson (1990) 93 ALR 479, which emphasize that the discretion to extend time should only be exercised where strict compliance with the rules will lead to an injustice for the applicant. The Department argued that exceptional circumstances existed due to administrative error and the complexity of the issues, but the court found that the main reason for the late filing was administrative error. The court also noted that the issues involved did not seem to be of such a complex nature that they would require extra time to develop submissions. While the court identified a misdirection in the Arbitrator's application of section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, it doubted that the Arbitrator would have reached a different conclusion had she properly addressed the application of the section. The court concluded that the Department had not demonstrated exceptional circumstances or that it would suffer substantial injustice if the right of appeal were lost.

The court refused leave to appeal against the Arbitrator's decision dated 11 October 2004, and ordered that the Department pay Mekhail's costs in the appeal as agreed or assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established