Denlay v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 89 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kevin Denlay v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 1434

Citation: Kevin Denlay v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 1434
Parties: KEVIN VINCENT DENLAY v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
File number: QUD 347 of 2010
Judge: LOGAN J
Date of judgment: 17 December 2010
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Application under s 39B(1) of the Judiciary Ac7t 1903 (Cth) – Whether purported assessments made by the Commissioner of Taxation were tainted with jurisdictional error due to the conscious maladministration of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) and Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (Taxation Acts) – Where Commissioner obtained information relating to the Applicants’ taxable income from a third party who according to foreign law stole that information – Where Commissioner received that information abroad – Whether Commissioner breached s 400.9 of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) in receiving the stolen information – Consideration of Commissioner of Taxation v Futuris Corporation Ltd (2008) 237 CLR 146

Held:  The Commissioner has a duty under the Taxation Acts to assess the income of taxpayers from “any other information in his possession, or from any one or more … sources” and is to enjoy “full and free: access for that purpose” – The Commissioner could not then be in breach of s 400.9 if the alleged breach was undertaken with a justification at law – s 10.5 of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) and s 166 and s 263 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) considered – No conscious maladministration present

Legislation: Constitution (Cth) ss 75(v), 128
Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15A
Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth)
Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2006 (Cth)
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
Income Tax Assessment Act 1914 (Cth) s 35
Income Tax Assessment Act 1922 (Cth) s 9
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 6, 166, 170,174, 175, 175A, 177, 263, 264
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 6-5, 15-15
Intelligence Services Act 2001 (Cth) s 11
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B
Public Service Act 1999 (Cth) s 13
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) ss 4, 4A, 5, 14ZZP, 14ZZQ
Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) ss 4, 100, 308C
Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) ss 10.5, 15.2, 139.1, 400.2, 400.9, 400.15, 476.1, 477, 477.1
Cases cited: A v Hayden (1984) 156 CLR 532 cited
Awad v Commissioner of Taxation (2000) 104 FCR 106 considered
Bropho v Western Australia (1990) 171 CLR 1 considered
Bunning v Cross (1978) 141 CLR 54 cited
Burdeau v McDowell 256 US 465 (1921) considered
Bundesverfassungsgericht [German Constitutional Court], 2 BvR 2101/09, 9 November 2010 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1977) 143 CLR 499 considered
Commissioner of Taxation v Clarke (1927) 40 CLR 246 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Futuris Corporation Ltd (2008) 237 CLR 146 considered
Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Mylecharane (2007) 177 A…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Denlay v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1434
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Denlay v Commissioner of Taxation concerned a challenge by the taxpayer to the validity of assessments made by the Commissioner of Taxation. The taxpayer argued that the assessments were flawed because the Commissioner had obtained information about his taxable income from a third party who had stolen the information abroad, potentially contravening s 400.9 of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth). The court had to decide whether the Commissioner's use of the stolen information constituted a jurisdictional error, rendering the assessments invalid.

The court examined whether the Commissioner's actions amounted to a "conscious maladministration" of the Taxation Acts, as required to invalidate an assessment under Commissioner of Taxation v Futuris Corporation Ltd. It held that the Commissioner had a duty under the Taxation Acts to assess income from any information in his possession and could not be in breach of s 400.9 if the information was lawfully obtained or if there was a legal justification for using it. The court found no evidence that the Commissioner acted in bad faith or was not entitled to use the information. It also noted that the Commissioner's reliance on the stolen information did not constitute an offence under s 10.5 of the Criminal Code, which allows for lawful actions under the Taxation Acts.

The court concluded that the Commissioner was entitled to use the information obtained from the LGT documents to make the assessments, and there was no conscious maladministration. Therefore, the application was dismissed, and the taxpayer was ordered to pay the Commissioner's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application, to be taxed if not agreed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Such direct and derivative use of information in the LGT documents is evident in the following excerpt from the Commissioner’s reasons for making the amended assessments:MATERIAL FACTS AND EVIDENCE8.The subject of this audit is the Australian resident taxpayer Kevin Vincent Denlay, TFN9.You were born in Australia on 3 March 1951.10.During the 1970s and 1980s you lived and worked extensively in the Kathmandu Valley of Nepal. You have been a resident of Australia for tax purposes since you returned to Australia to live permanently in 1984 or 1985.11.Your current residential address is 36 Glengarrie Road, Glengarrie, NSW. You are the sole owner of this 7.17Ha property. This property was acquired by you on 2 April 1987.12.You currently reside with your spouse, Mirja Helena Denlay.13.You were married to Mirja Pykalainen on 27th January 1989.14.You are an experience ‘technical diver’. You have an extensive global profile in the areas of undersea wreck discovery/exploration, undersea photography, and ‘mixed gas’ dive instruction.15.In the past, you have operated a business in Australia as a sole trader. The business has been marketed under the names of “Alternative Diving Services”/”Altdive”/”Action Unlimited Photographics”.16.The Commissioner is investigating arrangements and services provided by the LGT Bank in Liechtenstein (LGT) to Australian resident taxpayers.17.The Commissioner has been provided with documents (the LGT documents) concerning client accounts of LGT.18.The documentation links various individuals (with Australian addresses) to offshore companies and foundations managed by the LGT.19.“Kevin Vincent Denlay” is one name appearing on the LGT documents.20.…25.You were required to furnish information and documents to a named officer of the Commissioner by 20 December 2007 pursuant to section 264 of the ITAA 1936 and you complied with this request.26.You were also required to attend and give evidence under oath pursuant to section 264(1)(b) of the ITAA 1936. You were interviewed by Counsel assisting the Commissioner on 12th and 17th March 2008 and 21st May 2008. At this time you were examined with reference to the material obtained at your residential premises, your responses provided to the section 264 notice (which was due 20 December 2007), the LGT documents, and information ascertained by the Commissioner from Tax Office systems and public sources. Nyst Lawyers, your legal representatives, have been provided with transcripts of the section 264 interview.27.To date, you have not sought to review or alter your comments made under oath.LGT28.The LGT documents in the possession of the Tax Office indicate the following:ŸThe founding date of an entity called the Dorje Foundation was 23 November 1992.ŸKevin Vincent Denlay, address Glengarrie Road, Glengarrie NSW Australia 2486, date of birth 03.03.1951, is the beneficial owner of the funds in the Dorje Foundation bank account/s number 014 6778.ŸMarja[sic] Helena Pykalainen, address Glengarrie Road, Glengarrie NSW Australia 2486, date of birth 02.08.1953, is the beneficial owner of the funds in the Dorje Foundation bank account/s 024 5858.ŸIn respect of Mirja Denlay’s account, Robin Higham had a Power of Administration from 21 October 1998. The Power of Administration was revoked on 4 January 2000.ŸAs at 31 December 2001, Kevin Denlay’s account had a balance of $682 859.23 USD.ŸSonya Sprenger or Dagmar Gachter (of LGT) held a ‘client meeting’ in Hong Kong on 27 February 2002.ŸFunds of the Dorje Foundation appear to have ‘exited’ to the Prasidial Anstalt on or about 18 March 2002.ŸThe ‘origin of funds’ in the Dorje Foundation is said to be “Property sale in Australia, income from business activity in Australia – owing [sic] a deep sea diving center (exploration, pipeline laying/maintenance, treasure hunt)29.The Commissioner has sought and found evidence that corroborates the information of the LGT documents.With respect to Robin Higham, a figure named on the LGT documents30.Email correspondence between rhigham@ibm.net and altdive@iaccess.com.au (Kevin Denlay’s email account) dated 10 October 1998 and between robin.higham@dial.pipex.com. and robin_d_higham@hotmail.com dated 18 January 1999 was obtained by the Commissioner on 30 May 2007 under section 263 of the ITAA 1936. The email of 10 October 1998 contains the phrase “Very nice seeing you both again”. The Commissioner infers that this is a reference to a face-to-face meeting recently (with reference to the date of the email) held between you, your spouse Mirja and Robin Higham. The email goes on to provide financial advice to you. This October 1998 visit to Robin Higham corresponds with his appointment as Power of Administration over Mirja Denlay’s account within the Dorja Foundation.31.At interview, you admitted that you had met with Robin Higham as recently as the late 1990s.With respect to the client visit on 27 February 2002:32.The LGT document containing the date of a client visit on 27 February 2002 makes reference to the Dorje Foundation, and “LGT Investment Management Hong Kong”. The inference drawn by this document is that a meeting, relating to the Dorje Foundation, held on 27 February 2002 took place in Hong Kong.33.According to Department of Immigration and Citizenship (DIAC) records, you and Mirja Denlay travelled to Hong Kong between 24 February 2002 and 3 March 2002, coinciding with the ‘client visit’ reported on the LGT documents.34.At interview, you could not recall any specific knowledge of this trip.With respect to the ownership and origin of funds in the Dorje Foundation:35.At interview, on the 17 March 2008, you answered that to your knowledge, there are not other persons named “Kevin Denlay” working in the field of diving and photographics. The Commissioner cannot identify any other individuals of the same name in this occupation.36.You have in the past, and currently operate a business as a sole trader in Australia marketed as either “Alt Dive” or “Alternative Diving Services.” This activity utilizes your specialist skills as a “Nitrox” diver, allowing you to dive to greater depth than SCUBA divers. During the 1990s, you were one of a very few resident Australians with these skills. This occupation as a deep sea diver is also reference in the LGT documents.37.The Commissioner considers that the personal details (which are highly specific and difficult to replicate) provided on the LGT documents, including full name, date of birth, address, occupation and spouse, correctly identify you as the owner of account 014 6778 within the Dorje Foundation. Furthermore, the information contained on the LGT documents provided to the Commissioner identifies you as the beneficial owner of a quantum of funds housed in the LGT Bank at 31 December 2001.38.The Commissioner’s view is that the series of transactions evidence in the LGT documents, i.e., the birth of the Dorje Foundation in Nov 1992 ® the account balances at 31 December 2001 ® the exit to the Prasidial Anstalt in March 2002, on the balance of probabilities, relate to the income earning activities of you while a resident of Australia.39.Throughout the course of the interview under oath, you claimed that you had no knowledge of any LGT Bank accounts or the Dorje Foundation. When presented with copies of the LGT documents, you failed to provide any meaningful explanation of their contents. Given time for reflection on the matter between interviews, you could offer no input as to why your name and your personal details appear on the LGT documents.Vajrapani40.As part of an audit into your affairs, a comprehensive analysis of international funds transfers relating to you was conducted using data collected by the Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC).41.AUSTRAC data indicates that you were the beneficial customer of an incoming International fund transfer of USD $427 000 on 10 October 2006. The ordering customer is reported as being Richard Olsen, with a reported address of 5151 Bonny Doon Rd, Santa Cruz, CA. USA.42.Email correspondence dated 7 September 2006 between you and propheasants@cs.com (Richard Olsen’s email address) indicates that this transfer represents the proceeds of sale of a circa 12th century Nepalese statute called a Vajrapani (the Vajrapani). (The sale was concluded in October 2006)43.Email correspondence spanning the period October 2005 to October 2006 indicates that the strategy used to sell the Vajrapani was determined between you and Richard Olsen.44.In an email from Kevin Denlay to Richard Olsen dated 22 October 2005, you likened the Vajrapani to ‘other investments’.45.At interview, you answered that Richard Olsen is an old friend and a “very famous art dealer”, dealing in high end art.46.At interview, you stated that Olsen sold the Vajrapani on your behalf, received the funds and remitted them to you from his bank in California.47.At interview you admitted that you fabricated a document which purported to be a Bill of Sale from Kevin Denlay to Enoch Denlay (your son) of an “Antique 18th Century Nepalese Vajrapani bronze statue sold to Enoch Denlay on 31st December, 1999 for the sum of $12000 USD”.48.At interview, you stated it was a document “we made up for my son to carry the statue to the USA” and was false in each detail.49.At interview on 17 March 2008, you sought to clarify what you had said on the purposes of fabricating the documents in the following way:“You showed me a couple of invoices that were, basically, not exactly correct invoices for that statue and you implied that I made them up to evade taxes or duty in the US. Well that’s not the case because there’s no duty or taxes taking that item into the United States. There is on selling it and that was paid in California when it was sold. So I just wanted to clarify that I didn’t make those up to avoid any taxes or duties. I made them up specifically so my son could take – take the item and it would look like his because that would have just made it a lot easier. There still was no duty or anything involved, or tax, but it would have been a lot easier if he could say it was his as he – and the value – because he had to carry it and we were afraid, because it weighed so much and the box it was in was a little bit big, that they would want to make him put it in the hold of an aeroplane and that’s certainty what we didn’t want to do.”50.You stated in interview that from about 1976/1977 until mid 1984, you had been involved in buying and selling statues.51.At interview, you said that in the time you lived in Nepal, you and Richard Olsen engaged in the business of selling art. You acted as the middle-man. Sometimes you bought items so as to then resell them.52.You have been aware of the value of the item since as early as 1991, when you had it appraised at Sotheby’s Australia.53.At interview, you said that the Vajrapani was purchased with the purpose of selling it at a profit relatively soon after buying it, but that did not transpire because there was some doubt about its authenticity. When you sold it, the market was good, but in keeping with how you thought a statue of that quality would appreciate, you thought it was better to sell it privately, because if it didn’t sell at auction, that could “sort of taint the piece somewhat.”54.You did not declare any income in your 2007 income tax assessment that can be attributed to the profits from the sale of the Vajrapani.Your financial position when returning to Australia55.You returned to Australia to live permanently in 1984 or 1985 and you have been a resident for tax purposes from that time.56.When asked at interview what your assets were when you returned to Australia to live permanently, you provided the following:ŸYou said that you had some Asian art – maybe 10 or a dozen pieces. You could not give an estimate of the value of the art. You said that you did not have them valued. You could not say whether it was in the range of hundreds of dollars, tens of thousands of dollars, hundreds of thousands of dollars or millions. You said to put them somewhere within those ranges, would be guessing/speculating.ŸYou also had somewhere between 10 and 50 Tibetan and Nepalese carpets. You still have them. You do not know their value.ŸYou could not recall what cash reserves you had. You could not recall if it was hundreds of dollars, tens of thousands of dollars or hundreds of thousands of dollars.ŸYou could not recall if the property you purchased used funding drawn from cash reserves when you came back to Australia.ŸYou do not think any had debts/liabilities, but you can’t recall any more on that issue.CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN LIECHTENSTEIN AGAINST MR KIEBER

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In summary, the Commissioner’s submissions were as follows:(a)Before it could be concluded that an assessment was not made bona fide, it must be sown that there was either “conscious maladministration” of the assessment process for which the ITAA36 provides or some deliberate failure to administer that Act according to its terms: Futuris at [22], [52] and [55]; and Marijancevic v Mann, A Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 73 ATR 709 at [13]. Read in context, the reference to “the law” in [55] of the majority judgment in Futuris was submitted to be the ITAA36.(b)By analogy with what was said as to the position in New Zealand in Westpac Banking Corporation v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2009] 2 NZLR 99 at [92], so far as an allegation of conscious maladministration in the process of making an assessment is concerned, the focus must be on whether the officer who made the assessment acted in good faith and in the belief that he was entitled so to do.(c)On the evidence, all of the officers of the ATO, be they those who interviewed Mr Kieber, were later involved in investigating his taxation affairs in the course of Project Jade or who made the amended assessments were seeking to administer the ITAA36 (and to the extent relevant to assessment of taxation liability, ITAA97) according to its terms. The information provided by Mr Kieber was relevant to this end.(d)Having regard, in particular, to ss 166, 263 and 264 of the ITAA36, what the Commissioner may take into account is not to be read down by reference to how the material was obtained either at all or at least where the Commissioner did not cause to be taken illegally the source material from which the information was given to him. Reference was made by analogy to what was said to be the like position of the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS): Burdeau v McDowell 256 US 465 (1921); United States v Janis 428 US 433 (1976).(e)The evidence did not support a conclusion that any ATO officer knew or believed that he or she was not entitled to use the information in the LGT documents including, especially, use the information for the purpose of making the amended assessments.(f)Nor could it be suggested that the officers knew or believed that they were committing an offence against s 400.9 of the Criminal Code either in the way alleged by Mr Denlay or otherwise (even assuming, which was denied, that the elements of s 400.9 were present).(g)Further, the allegation of the commission of an offence against that provision, at a substantive level, ignored the operation of s 10.5 of the Criminal Code in respect of actions authorised by law (relevantly, the ITAA36) and, at a procedural level, did not meet the standard of proof dictated by s 140(2) of the Evidence Act in relation to the proof of conduct of such alleged gravity.(h)In any event, it would be incongruous if material illegally obtained could, depending on the exercise of a judicial discretion which took into account competing public interests: Bunning v Cross (1978) 141 CLR 54, be used in the exercise of the judicial power of the Commonwealth yet be unusable at all in the exercise of the executive power of the Commonwealth.CONSIDERATION