Den Hartog and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL              )
  )         No: 2016/4291
General Division  )

Re: Jacob Den Hartog
Applicant

And: Comcare
Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:              Deputy President Dr C Kendall

DATE:   1 August 2017

PLACE:                    Perth

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application by replacing any reference to Mr Burgess with a reference to Mr Hawker.

...................................................................

Deputy President

Den Hartog and Comcare (Compensation) [2017] AATA 1164 (28 July 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2016/4291

Re:Jacob den Hartog

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

Date:28 July 2017

Place:Perth

The decisions under review are affirmed.

......................[sgd]..........................................

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – accepted claim for aggravation of hearing loss – revocation of original determinations accepting liability – whether workplace contributed to injury – audiometry pattern not that of noise induced hearing loss – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth) – sections 5, 29 and 37

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – sections 16 and 124

CASES

Comcare v Levett (1995) 38 ALD 518
Re Willis and Australian Telecommunications Commission (No 2) (1990) 11 AAR 348
Telstra Corporation Limited v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Dr Christopher Kendall

28 July 2017

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr den Hartog is 61 years of age.  He was employed with the Department of Defence (the “Agency”) as an apprentice turner and fitter from 17 January 1973 to 15 February 1977 and as a Naval Systems Technical Officer from 16 February 1977 to 12 May 1981, (T13 at 36).

    Claim history

  2. On or around 2 October 1981, Mr den Hartog submitted a claim for compensation in respect of ‘deafness due to industrial noise’ which he attributed to excessive noise exposure during his employment with the Agency.

  3. On 16 February 1982, Mr den Hartog’s hearing loss was assessed at the National Acoustic Laboratory in Canberra.

  4. On 28 May 1982, the Commonwealth accepted liability for ‘aggravation of sensori-neural hearing loss’ (T13 at 34) under section 39 of the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth) (the “1971 Act”).

  5. On 24 March 2014, Mr den Hartog underwent surgery for a right-sided cochlear implant. Subsequently, ear mapping of the implant was required in order to program it to Mr den Hartog’s specifications and needs.

  6. On 17 July 2015, Comcare denied liability for Mr den Hartog’s right-sided cochlear implant surgery under section 16 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 Act (Cth) (the “SRC Act”) (T2 at 16-17).

  7. On 10 March 2016, Mr den Hartog had a full audiological assessment.  The following Assistive Listening Devices were identified as being necessary for him (T33 at 83):

    (a)Smoke alarm wireless battery powered Brooks;

    (b)Vibralarm Bedside strobe and pillow shaker Brooks;

    (c)Wireless door chime; and

    (d)Alarm clock Bellman Pro

    (the “Appliances”).

  8. On 20 April 2016, Comcare denied liability for ear mapping under section 16 of the SRC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Den Hartog and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr den Hartog against decisions by Comcare to revoke its acceptance of liability for his hearing loss and associated treatments. The dispute centred on whether Mr den Hartog's employment at the Naval dockyards contributed to his hearing impairment, or if his condition was a natural progression of a pre-existing, likely hereditary, condition. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) was required to determine Mr den Hartog's eligibility for compensation under the relevant legislation, considering both the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act) and its predecessor, the *Compensation (Commonwealth Employees) Act 1971* (1971 Act).

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Comcare was liable to pay Mr den Hartog compensation for a cochlear implant, ear mapping, and various assistive appliances. To resolve this, the Tribunal had to ascertain if Mr den Hartog suffered an injury or an aggravation of a pre-existing condition that arose out of his employment with the Naval dockyards, as defined under the 1971 Act. This required a comprehensive review of medical evidence spanning approximately 35 years, including audiograms and specialist reports, to determine the aetiology and progression of his hearing loss.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the medical evidence, particularly the reports from Professor McManus. Professor McManus concluded that Mr den Hartog's profound, progressive, bilateral sensorineural hearing loss was most likely due to a hereditary inner ear dysplasia, first noted at age 17, prior to his naval service. Crucially, the audiometry patterns did not exhibit the characteristic signs of noise-induced hearing loss, which typically begins at higher frequencies (around 4000 cps) and improves at even higher frequencies. Instead, Mr den Hartog's loss was predominantly in the lower frequencies, consistent with inner ear dysplasia. While Mr den Hartog provided a letter detailing exposure to industrial noise and his use of earmuffs, Professor McManus found no evidence that this exposure had aggravated his underlying condition or caused further hearing loss to a compensable degree. The Tribunal considered the principle from *Telstra Corporation Limited v Hannaford* (2006) 151 FCR 253, that a claimant may not be entitled to compensation if they never suffered an injury or if their current condition cannot be said to arise from their employment.

The Tribunal affirmed Comcare's decisions, finding that Mr den Hartog had not established that his hearing loss or its aggravation arose out of his employment. Consequently, Comcare was not liable to pay compensation for the cochlear implant surgery, ear mapping, or the assistive appliances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr den Hartog was referred to Professor McManus (Consultant ENT Surgeon) in July 2015. Professor McManus’ report reads as follows:Thank you for referring Mr Jacob Adrianus Den-Hartog for ENT assessment Based on Mr Den-Hartog’s medical condition as specified in your referral, I confirm that my specialty is appropriate for the conduct of this assessment.Having reviewed the available file data and the comprehensive audiology test results, interviewed and examined Mr Den-Hartog, I submit a detailed medical report in answer to your request.I obtained the following information from my interview with Mr Den-Hartog (unless otherwise specified).…BACKGROUND:Country of Birth: AustraliaMEDICAL EVALUATION:Past Medical History:Mr Den-Hartog reported he first became aware of hearing Impairment at the age of 17 when hearing test identified nerve deafness.Noise - Apart from Work:Nil reported.Firearms Exposure:Nil.Head Injury:Mr Den-Hartog reported he had a bicycle accident in 2008 when he had a brief period of loss of consciousness.Ear Disease or Injury:Hearing loss progressive since first diagnosed at the age of 17,Medical/Surgical Treatment:Right cochlear implant by Professor Marcus Atlas.Other Previous Illnesses:Epilepsy, diabetes and fatty liver disease. Family History:Nil relevant.Employment History:Mr Den-Hartog reported he completed an apprenticeship as a fitter and turner before commencing work in the Naval dockyards in Melbourne.Worksite Noise Levels:Unknown,Screening Audiometry:The records provided included audiograms carried out in 1982, 2004 and 2012.Medical History including Mechanism of Injury Alleged & Subsequent Progress:I note Professor Atlas’ report indicating his progressive sensorineural hearing loss is uncertain although a hereditary cause is suspected. He comments that hearing loss may be worsened by exposure to industrial noise but on the history obtained it would appear his hearing impairment was first identified prior to exposure to noise.Deafness First Noted:Age 17.Ear Infections:As a child.Tinnitus:Nil.Giddiness or Headaches:Nil.Ototoxic Drugs:Nil.Noxious Fumes:Nil.Other ENT symptoms:Nil. Present Medication:He takes tablets for epilepsy and diabetes.Trouble with TV/Radio:Yes.Trouble with Telephone:He does use a speaker phone and has experienced significant improvement following his cochlear implant.Smoking/Alcohol:Nil.Other Concurrent Illnesses:Nil relevant.Current Symptoms:Profound loss of hearing.Clinical Examination:This showed he has had a right cochlear implant and uses a standard hearing aid in his left ear.Investigations:Detailed audiograms have been provided of previous assessments.Audiometry - Performed according to Australian Standard AS 1269 This report reads as follows:I have noted your letter dated 13 December 2016 and respond to the questions detailed in your letter, item 3.1.3.1 The current condition(a) Can you confirm the condition the Applicant suffers from?In agreement with the report from Professor Marcus Atlas, I advise Mr Den-Hartog has most likely a hereditary inner ear dysplasia causing his profound bilateral progressive sensorineural hearing loss.(b)What is the aetiology of the Applicant’s condition?This condition is idiopathic (unknown cause), possibly hereditary.(c)On page 5 of your report, we note that you consider the Applicant has ‘severe progressive bilateral sensorineural hearing impairment with a most likely genetic cause’. Can you expand and describe the relevant pre-existing or non-work related medical history or condition and the significance of the pre-existing condition to the ‘aggravation of sensori-neural hearing loss’?Based on the information provided and my consultation with Mr Den-Hartog, I note Mr Den-Hartog first noted progressive hearing impairment at the age of 17. There have been no records provided to indicate the level of hearing loss he experienced at that time and more importantly I have been provided with no medical records of his hearing confirmed with audiometry prior to his enlistment in the Navy.I have noted that Professor Atlas has made a comment that exposure to excessive industrial noise may worsen his underlying hearing loss due to hereditary inner ear dysplasia.(d)Would Jacob den Hartog have developed the current condition as a natural progression of a pre-existing condition irrespective of his employment?In my opinion and based on the records provided I consider Mr Den-Hartog would likely to have experienced a natural progression of the underlying hereditary inner ear dysplasia and I am unable to indicate whether exposure to excessive noise would have caused further hearing loss or to what degree.I further note that hearing tests carried out during his military service indicated progressive loss of hearing in the lower frequencies but little change in the hearing levels at 4000 cps and above. Noise-induced hearing loss characteristically begins at a frequency of 4000 cps and characteristically returned to a more normal level in the higher frequencies of 6000 cps and 8000 cps. The audiograms provided indicate Mr Den-Hartog’s hearing loss were predominantly in the lower frequencies consistent with probable inner ear dysplasia and the hearing that was in the higher frequencies, 4000 cps and above were much better. This would indicate it is unlikely that he was exposed to noise damaging levels of noise during his military service. (e)Have the effects of a pre-existing or non-work-related condition overtaken the effects of the accepted condition of 'aggravation of a sensorineural hearing loss’?In my opinion I consider Mr Den-Hartog’s progressive hearing impairment was unrelated to his military service, I note in your letter item (e) that Mr Den-Hartog has an accepted condition of “aggravation of sensorineural hearing loss”. I would comment that I have seen no evidence to indicate he has had aggravation of a sensorineural hearing loss due to his military service and Professor Atlas’ report indicates that he thought his hearing loss may be worsened by exposure to industrial noise.(f)What is your prognosis of the Applicant’s condition?Mr Den-Hartog has had a successful cochlear implant with significant improvement in his hearing ability. I would expect this improvement to be maintained in the operated year but it is possible the hearing loss in his left ear may progress with time.3.2 Contribution from employment(a)You note in your report that ‘there is little to indicate that his severe hearing loss has, in part, resulted from work as there is no information as to the levels of noise to which he may have been exposed during his working career’. Having regard to all the current material, do you still consider that the Applicant’s condition is unlikely to have resulted from his working career? Please provide reasons, if appropriate.From the information provided I confirm my previous advice that I consider Mr Den-Hartog’s hearing impairment was due to an idiopathic progressive bilateral sensorineural hearing impairment with a most likely genetic cause. From the information provided I have found no evidence to suggest that his progressive hearing impairment has been aggravated by exposure to noise.3.3 Treatment(a)The Applicant has made a claim for the following medical expenses:-(i)Cochlear implant surgery (already undertaken);(ii)Ear mapping;(iii) Brooks smoke alarm wireless battery powered;(iv)Brooks Vibralarm bedside strobe and pillow shaker;(v)Wireless door chime;(vi)Alarm clock Bellman ProAs stated above I have not been provided with any detailed evidence of the level of noise to which he may have been exposed and the audiograms that have been provided do not show evidence of noise-induced hearing impairment (maximal loss occurring at 4000 cps).(b)In your opinion, do you consider that the cochlear implant surgery was reasonable and appropriate treatment in relation to the Applicant’s condition? If so, what benefit do you expect that the Applicant will receive from such treatment?You enquire whether I consider the cochlear implant surgery was reasonable and appropriate treatment, yes, I believe that cochlear implant was appropriate for Mr Den-Hartog’s hearing impairment.(c)Do you consider that the ear mapping was reasonable and appropriate treatment in relation to the Applicant’s condition? If so, what benefit do you expect that the Applicant will receive from such treatment?Yes, I consider the ear mapping to be a reasonable and appropriate treatment for Mr Den-Hartog’s progressive hearing loss.(d)Do you consider that the ‘aid appliances’ as described from 3.3(a)(iii) - (iv) is reasonable and appropriate treatment in relation to the Applicant’s condition?Yes, I do agree.3.4 Other factors(a)Should the Applicant be examined by a practitioner in any other field of medicine? If so, which?No, I do not believe Mr Den-Hartog should be examined by further medical practitioners, he has been extensively investigated by Professor Atlas who is recognised as the leading otologist in WA and one of the leading specialists in Australia.(b)Are there any other comments you wish to make?I acknowledge this has been a difficult case to assess particularly because of the lack of detailed information of his medical condition during his military service.ORAL EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal also heard oral evidence from Professor McManus, Consultant Ear, Nose and Throat Surgeon and Mr den Hartog. Non-Medical EVIDENCE Letter from Mr den Hartog to HMA Naval Dockyard dated 2 October 1981 (T6 at 23) In a letter addressed to the HMA Naval Dockyard, Mr den Hartog stated that while employed with the Agency, his working conditions exposed him to industrial noise from machinery and tools. This letter, relevantly, reads as follows:Reference:- Your letter dated 30th June, 19Cl-Compensation (Commonwealth Employees) Act 1071 as amended.I acknowledge receipt of your above mentioned letter.The following information is additional information that I could not fit on claim form (ECl) and also information that was requested in the above mentioned letter .Q2 (b) 4 I commenced duty at the Dockyard during January, 1973 as an Apprentice Fitter and Turner. Late in 1976 I applied for a position at the Dockyard as a Trainee Navy Systems Technical Officer. On completion of the Apprenticeship I was successful in gaining the traineeship and commenced duty as a Trainee Navy Systems Technical Officer .in the "Weapons Mechanical Fire Control Section. Early in 1979 I completed the traineeship and was promoted to Navy Systems Technical Officer Grade 1 which I held until I left the Dockyard during May, 1991.Q5(b) During my apprenticeship I worked in various workshops and ships. Some of the workshops were .the Apprentice Training Schools for fitting and turning, welding, machine shop, Fitting Out Mechanical Workshop, Maintenance shop, Garage and the Weapons mechanical Workshop. During this period I worked on H.II.S. Ships in engine rooms, boiler rooms, gun turrets, Seacat systems and Ikara Systems.As a Trainee, and later one, a Technical Officer, I worked on the above weapons systems on board ships, in the Weapons Mechanical Workshop and the Hydraulics Test Q5(c). While working in the above workshops and ships I was exposed to Industrial noise from machinery and tools . Machinery I was working on, or close to, wore steam turbine generators, pumps, diesel generators, forced draft blowers, main engines, high pressure hydraulic pumps and systems and machine tools such as lathes, millers, borers, drills and grinders. Tools: that I was either near or using wore hammers, pneumatic riveting hammers, angle grinders and air hoses which were noisy.In the ships and above workshops and while working on or near the above machinery and tools, I always tried to protect my hearing with earmuffs. If I was not using my earmuffs, I would keep them In my toolbox which was always close by and easy to get to. If the workplace became noisy I would get the earmuffs from the toolbox and use them.During machinery trials on board ships I had to standby turbo generators, under full load, sometimes for hours and these trials usually took a number of days to complete. Working near boilermakers using pneumatic angle grinders and riveting hammers in confined spaces was extremely noisy. Some of these riveting operations lasted for weeks. Working on high pressure hydraulic systems and hydraulic test benches was extremely noisy. When testing and setting systems to work considerable time was spent -with the machinery. Statutory Declaration of Barry McCauley dated 28 October 1981 (T8 at 26)

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 16 August 2016, Mr den Hartog requested a review of that reconsideration of own motion by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the “Tribunal”). Within his application for review, Mr den Hartog included the reviewable decisions dated 17 June 2016 and 7 July 2016 (T2 at 5-6).DECISIONS UNDER REVIEW The decisions under review are Comcare’s decisions:(a)of 17 June 2016, affirming its decisions that it is not liable to pay Mr den Hartog compensation for cochlear implant surgery and ear mapping under section 16 of the SRC Act; and(b)of 7 July 2016, affirming its decision that it is not liable to pay Mr den Hartog compensation for the Appliances under section 16 of the SRC Act. ISSUE The broad issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether Mr den Hartog is eligible for compensation under section 16 of the SRC Act. This task is made somewhat more complicated as the SRC Act was not in operation at the time the Commonwealth accepted liability for Mr den Hartog’s condition. The relevant legislation, at that time, was the 1971 Act – in particular, sections 29 and 37. This is discussed further below. In order to determine this issue the Tribunal must first determine Mr den Hartog’s eligibility under section 29 of the 1971 Act, and whether his condition or any aggravation of it arose out of his employment with the Agency. To do so, the Tribunal must address the following question:(a)is Comcare liable to pay Mr den Hartog compensation for the Appliances, cochlear implant surgery and ear mapping? The medical evidence relevant to this matter spans approximately 35 years. In determining whether Mr den Hartog suffers from an injury or an aggravation of it, as defined in the 1971 Act, the Tribunal will, as necessary, review this entire medical history. In these circumstances, the Tribunal may find, as per Telstra Corporation Limited v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253, that Mr den Hartog never suffered an injury or an aggravation of it. If this were to occur, Mr den Hartog would not be entitled to compensation. Further, the Tribunal may also find, as it is entitled to, that whatever ailments Mr den Hartog now suffers from are sufficiently different from his compensable injury because it cannot be said that his current medical condition arises from his employment with the Agency.LEGISLATION The relevant legislation in this application is the SRC Act and the 1971 Act. The SRC Act repealed and replaced the 1971 Act which was in force at the time the aggravation, or cause, of Mr den Hartog’s hearing loss is said to have occurred. Transitional provisions in the SRC Act provide for compensation for injuries which arose before the commencement of the SRC Act on 1 December 1988. As highlighted in the decision of the Full Federal Court in Comcare v Levett (1995) 38 ALD 518, these provisions are “intended to create continuity between the scheme established by the 1971 Act and the scheme created by the 1988 Act.” The relevant transitional provision (section 124) provides as follows:(1)Subject to this Part, this Act applies in relation to an injury, loss or damage suffered by an employee, whether before or after the commencing day.(1A)Subject to this Part, a person is entitled to compensation under this Act in respect of an injury, loss or damage suffered before the commencing day if compensation was, or would have been, payable to the person in respect of that injury, loss or damage under the 1912 Act, the 1930 Act or the 1971 Act.(2)A person is not entitled to compensation under this Act in respect of an injury, loss or damage suffered before the commencing day if compensation was not payable in respect of that injury, loss or damage:…(c)in any other case — under the 1971 Act as in force when the injury, loss or damage was suffered. …

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In a letter addressed to the HMA Naval Dockyard, Mr den Hartog stated that while employed with the Agency, his working conditions exposed him to industrial noise from machinery and tools. This letter, relevantly, reads as follows:Reference:- Your letter dated 30th June, 19Cl-Compensation (Commonwealth Employees) Act 1071 as amended.I acknowledge receipt of your above mentioned letter.The following information is additional information that I could not fit on claim form (ECl) and also information that was requested in the above mentioned letter .Q2 (b) 4 I commenced duty at the Dockyard during January, 1973 as an Apprentice Fitter and Turner. Late in 1976 I applied for a position at the Dockyard as a Trainee Navy Systems Technical Officer. On completion of the Apprenticeship I was successful in gaining the traineeship and commenced duty as a Trainee Navy Systems Technical Officer .in the "Weapons Mechanical Fire Control Section. Early in 1979 I completed the traineeship and was promoted to Navy Systems Technical Officer Grade 1 which I held until I left the Dockyard during May, 1991.Q5(b) During my apprenticeship I worked in various workshops and ships. Some of the workshops were .the Apprentice Training Schools for fitting and turning, welding, machine shop, Fitting Out Mechanical Workshop, Maintenance shop, Garage and the Weapons mechanical Workshop. During this period I worked on H.II.S. Ships in engine rooms, boiler rooms, gun turrets, Seacat systems and Ikara Systems.As a Trainee, and later one, a Technical Officer, I worked on the above weapons systems on board ships, in the Weapons Mechanical Workshop and the Hydraulics Test Q5(c). While working in the above workshops and ships I was exposed to Industrial noise from machinery and tools . Machinery I was working on, or close to, wore steam turbine generators, pumps, diesel generators, forced draft blowers, main engines, high pressure hydraulic pumps and systems and machine tools such as lathes, millers, borers, drills and grinders. Tools: that I was either near or using wore hammers, pneumatic riveting hammers, angle grinders and air hoses which were noisy.In the ships and above workshops and while working on or near the above machinery and tools, I always tried to protect my hearing with earmuffs. If I was not using my earmuffs, I would keep them In my toolbox which was always close by and easy to get to. If the workplace became noisy I would get the earmuffs from the toolbox and use them.During machinery trials on board ships I had to standby turbo generators, under full load, sometimes for hours and these trials usually took a number of days to complete. Working near boilermakers using pneumatic angle grinders and riveting hammers in confined spaces was extremely noisy. Some of these riveting operations lasted for weeks. Working on high pressure hydraulic systems and hydraulic test benches was extremely noisy. When testing and setting systems to work considerable time was spent -with the machinery. Statutory Declaration of Barry McCauley dated 28 October 1981 (T8 at 26)