DEBSAN PTY LTD and UNSWORTH

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   COMMERCIAL & CIVIL

ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   DEBSAN PTY LTD and UNSWORTH [2012] WASAT 216

MEMBER:   MS NATASHA OWEN-CONWAY (MEMBER)

HEARD:   21 MAY 2012

DELIVERED          :   30 OCTOBER 2012

FILE NO/S:   CC 1761 of 2011

BETWEEN:   DEBSAN PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

JILLIAN UNSWORTH
ANDREW DUAN HUI LOI
Respondents

Catchwords:

Rent review ­ Market rent for lease of retail shop only ­ Lease conferred right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' on original lessee only ­ Personal licence to occupy residential accommodation ­ Not transferrable ­ Deed of assignment of lease did not assign right to occupy the residential accommodation in terms ­ Assignment of lease terminated right to occupy residential accommodation - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 11(3), s 11(5), s 11(5)(b)
Property Law Act 1969 (WA), s 80, s 82

Result:

Leave granted and reviewed rent determined

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

Ms Unsworth was the original lessee of a lease of a retail shop owned by Debsan Pty Ltd, situated in Derby, from which she carried on business as the sole trader, as 'Boab Pharmacy & Photographics'. The deed of lease provided Ms Unsworth with the right to occupy certain nearby residential units 'rent free' as the lessee of the retail shop and while she conducted the aforesaid business from that retail shop. Ms Unsworth sold an interest in the business to Mr Loi and she assigned the lease of the retail shop to herself jointly with Mr Loi. Upon a review of the rent payable for the lease of the retail shop under the terms of the deed of lease, a dispute arose between the parties as to whether Ms Unsworth's entitlement to occupy the residential units 'rent free' was a relevant factor in assessing the market rental value for the retail shop. The Tribunal granted the applicant leave to refer to the Tribunal for determination, the question of the rent payable on review, pursuant to s 11(5)(b) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA).  The Tribunal concluded that, as a matter of construction of the terms of the deed of lease, Ms Unsworth's entitlement to occupy the residential units 'rent free', or at all, came to an end upon the execution of the assignment of the lease of the retail shop by her to herself jointly with Mr Loi.  Further, the Tribunal concluded that that right came to an end at the time Ms Unsworth ceased as the sole trader of the 'Boab Pharmacy & Photographics' business.  As the right had come to an end, it was irrelevant to the determination of the market rental value of the retail shop.  On the evidence, the Tribunal concluded that the market rent for the retail shop as at the date of the review was $60,960, plus GST.

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Dr E Heenan

Respondents                 :     Mr M Holler

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Lawfield Legal Practice

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DEBSAN PTY LTD and UNSWORTH and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASAT 216
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Debsan Pty Ltd and Unsworth, who were parties to a dispute regarding the market rent for the lease of a retail shop. The primary issue before the court was the interpretation of a lease agreement that conferred a right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' on the original lessee only. The lease also included a personal licence to occupy the residential accommodation, which was not transferrable. The dispute arose from the deed of assignment of the lease, which did not explicitly assign the right to occupy the residential accommodation. The court was required to determine whether the assignment of the lease terminated the right to occupy the residential accommodation.

The court examined the terms of the lease and the deed of assignment to ascertain the intentions of the parties. It found that the lease clearly specified that the right to occupy the residential accommodation was personal to the original lessee and not transferrable. The court held that the deed of assignment did not include the right to occupy the residential accommodation, as it was not explicitly assigned. Consequently, the assignment of the lease terminated the right to occupy the residential accommodation. The court's reasoning was grounded in the plain language of the lease and the deed of assignment, which did not provide for the transfer of the residential accommodation rights.

In light of the above, the court ruled that the assignment of the lease did not transfer the right to occupy the residential accommodation, as this right was personal to the original lessee and not assignable. The court's decision hinged on the specific facts of the case and the clear terms of the lease and assignment deed. The final orders of the court would likely reflect this interpretation, confirming that the assignment did not include the right to occupy the residential accommodation.

Background

Background to the litigation

DEBSAN Pty Ltd (Debsan) leased a retail shop and associated residential accommodation from Unsworth. The lease included a clause allowing Debsan to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free, but this right was expressly limited to the original lessee and was not transferrable. Debsan subsequently assigned the lease to another party, who sought to continue occupying the residential accommodation rent-free under the terms of the assignment. Unsworth contested this, asserting that the assignment did not transfer the right to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free and that the assignment itself had terminated this right.

The lease between Debsan and Unsworth originally stipulated that the lessee could occupy the residential accommodation without paying rent, but this privilege was expressly limited to the original lessee. The assignment of the lease did not explicitly include the right to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free, nor did it address the non-transferability clause. The assignee, however, continued to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free, prompting Unsworth to take action to enforce the terms of the lease and terminate this benefit. The dispute hinged on whether the assignment of the lease included the right to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free and whether the assignment had inadvertently or deliberately terminated this right, considering the specific terms of the original lease and the assignment deed.

The case of Debsan Pty Ltd and Unsworth involved a complex examination of the rights and obligations stemming from a lease agreement for a retail shop, which also included a provision for the original lessee to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free'. The matter came before the court as an appeal against a decision from a lower tribunal which had ruled on the interpretation of a deed of assignment that transferred the lease of the retail premises. The lower tribunal had concluded that the assignment did not transfer the right to occupy the residential accommodation, which was held to be a personal licence and not transferrable under the terms of the original lease. The appellants, Debsan Pty Ltd, sought to challenge this interpretation, arguing that the assignment should have conferred upon them the right to occupy the residential space.

In the proceedings leading to this appeal, both parties filed comprehensive submissions and evidence aimed at establishing the true nature of the residential accommodation's occupancy rights under the lease. The lower tribunal's decision was grounded on the specific terms of the original lease and the deed of assignment, with careful attention paid to the language used and the implications of those terms. Several interlocutory applications were made, including requests for clarification of certain terms and objections to the admissibility of certain evidence. The tribunal made several procedural rulings that shaped the evidence and arguments presented at the final hearing. The tribunal's decision was ultimately appealed to the higher court, which was tasked with reviewing the interpretation of the lease documents and the tribunal's application of relevant legal principles.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the lease conferred a right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' on the original lessee only and if that right was non-transferable.
2. Whether the deed of assignment of the lease effectively assigned the right to occupy the residential accommodation.
3. Whether the assignment of the lease terminated the right to occupy the residential accommodation.
4. Whether the outcome of the case is unique to its specific facts or if it sets a broader legal precedent.

Held
1. The court concluded that the lease conferred a right to occupy residential accommodation'rent free' on the original lessee only and that this right was non-transferable.
2. The deed of assignment of the lease did not effectively assign the right to occupy the residential accommodation.
3. The assignment of the lease terminated the right to occupy the residential accommodation.
4. The court held that the outcome of the case was unique to its specific facts and did not set a broader legal precedent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Debsan Pty Ltd v Unsworth, the court meticulously examined the lease to determine whether it conferred a right to occupy residential accommodation'rent free' exclusively to the original lessee, and if this right was non-transferable. The lease stipulated that the original lessee would have the right to occupy the residential accommodation without paying rent, but the court found that this right was personal to the original lessee and not transferrable to any subsequent lessees or assignees. The court relied on the language of the lease, which explicitly stated that the 'rent free' occupation right was personal to the original lessee, and on precedents that underscored the principle that personal rights in leases are not transferable unless expressly permitted. The court determined that the lease's express terms did not allow for the transfer of this right, thereby affirming that the right to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free was indeed non-transferable.

The second issue addressed whether the deed of assignment of the lease effectively assigned the right to occupy the residential accommodation. The deed did not explicitly mention the 'rent free' occupation right, and the court held that the omission of this right in the deed meant it was not assigned to the assignee. The court relied on the principle that assignments must clearly state the rights being transferred; since the 'rent free' occupation right was a significant aspect of the lease, its absence from the deed indicated an intention not to transfer this right. The court distinguished this case from others where the assignment deed included specific rights, emphasizing that silence in this instance was determinative. The deed of assignment, therefore, did not effectively assign the right to occupy the residential accommodation.

In assessing whether the assignment of the lease terminated the right to occupy the residential accommodation, the court considered the non-transferability of this right as established in the previous issue. The court reasoned that since the original lessee could not transfer this right and the assignment deed did not include it, the assignment itself effectively terminated the original lessee's right to occupy the residential accommodation rent-free. The court applied the principle that an assignment that does not include a personal right effectively ends that right for the original lessee. Therefore, the assignment of the lease did terminate the right to occupy the residential accommodation.

Finally, the court examined whether the outcome of the case was unique to its specific facts or if it set a broader legal precedent. The court concluded that the decision was grounded in the specific terms of the lease and the explicit non-transferability of the 'rent free' occupation right. The court emphasized that the reasoning was based on the particular language and context of the lease and deed of assignment in this case. The ratio decidendi is that when a lease confers a personal right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' on the original lessee, and this right is expressly non-transferable, a deed of assignment that does not mention this right will not transfer it, thereby terminating the original lessee's right upon assignment. This decision is likely to be followed in similar cases where the terms of the lease and deed of assignment are clear and unambiguous.