Unsworth v Debsan Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   UNSWORTH -v- DEBSAN PTY LTD [2014] WASC 46

CORAM:   LE MIERE J

HEARD:   20 MAY 2013

DELIVERED          :   25 FEBRUARY 2014

FILE NO/S:   GDA 18 of 2012

BETWEEN:   JILLIAN UNSWORTH

First Appellant

ANDREW DUAN HUI LOI
Second Appellant

AND

DEBSAN PTY LTD
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :MEMBER N OWEN-CONWAY

Citation  :DEBSAN PTY LTD and UNSWORTH [2012] WASAT 216

File No  :CC 1761 of 2011

Catchwords:

Appeal - Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA) - Lease conferred right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' on original lessee only - Personal licence to occupy residential accommodation - Non-transferable - Deed of assignment of lease did not assign right to occupy the residential accommodation - No statutory right to assign the right to occupy the units

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA), s 3, s 10, s 11(5)(b)

Result:

Dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Appellant              :     Mr M F Holler

Second Appellant          :     Mr M F Holler

Respondent:     Mr E M Heenan

Solicitors:

First Appellant              :     AustAsia Legal Pty Ltd

Second Appellant          :     AustAsia Legal Pty Ltd

Respondent:     Lawfield Legal Practice

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

AIB Group (UK) Ltd v Martin [2002] 1 WLR 94

City of Rockingham v PMR Quarries Pty Ltd [2001] WASCA 317

Lewis v Bell (1985) 1 NSWLR 731

Radaich v Smith (1959) 101 CLR 209

  1. LE MIERE J:  Ms Unsworth was the original lessee of a retail shop owned by Debsan Pty Ltd in Derby, from which she carried on business as a sole trader under the name 'Boab Pharmacy & Photographics'.  The lease instrument (the Lease) entitled Ms Unsworth to occupy rent free two residential units at the rear of the shop for the term of the lease and any extensions of it, provided that only the lessee and not any assignee of the lessee shall be entitled to occupy the units.  Ms Unsworth sold an interest in the business to Mr Loi and with the consent of Debsan assigned the lease of the shop to herself jointly with Mr Loi.

  2. Upon a review of the rent payable for the lease of the shop under the terms of the Lease a dispute arose between the parties as to whether Ms Unsworth's entitlement to occupy the residential units 'rent free' was a relevant factor in assessing the market rental value for the shop.  The State Administrative Tribunal granted Debsan leave to refer to the Tribunal for determination the question of the rent payable on review pursuant to s 11(5)(b) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA) (the Commercial Tenancy Act).  The Tribunal concluded that, as a matter of construction of the terms of the Lease, Ms Unsworth's entitlement to occupy the residential units 'rent free', or at all, came to an end upon the execution of the assignment of the lease of the shop by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Unsworth v Debsan Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] WASC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Unsworth v Debsan Pty Ltd was heard by the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute involved an original lease agreement where the lessee had the right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free', a right that was expressly limited to the original lessee only. Upon the original lessee assigning the lease to a new party, a dispute arose over whether the right to occupy the residential accommodation was also assigned. The new lessee argued that the assignment of the lease should include the right to occupy the residential accommodation, whereas the landlord contended that this right was personal and non-transferable.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the assignment of the lease included the right to occupy the residential accommodation 'rent free', or if this right was confined to the original lessee alone. The court had to determine the interpretation of the lease agreement, specifically focusing on whether the assignment deed transferred all rights, including the right to occupy the residential accommodation, or if the right to occupy was personal and non-transferable. Additionally, the court needed to consider whether the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA) provided any statutory rights to assign such a right.

The court found that the right to occupy the residential accommodation 'rent free' was personal to the original lessee and not assignable under the terms of the lease. The assignment deed did not explicitly transfer this right, and the court held that the right to occupy was not included in the assignment. The court also noted that there was no statutory right to assign the right to occupy the residential accommodation under the relevant legislation. Consequently, the new lessee was not entitled to the benefit of occupying the residential accommodation 'rent free'.

The Supreme Court dismissed the new lessee's claim, affirming that the right to occupy the residential accommodation 'rent free' remained with the original lessee. The court's decision was based on the clear terms of the lease agreement and the statutory framework governing the assignment of commercial leases. The court held that the assignment deed did not confer the right to occupy the residential accommodation on the new lessee, and thus, the new lessee was not entitled to any such benefit.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Unsworth v Debsan Pty Ltd concerns a dispute arising from the interpretation of a Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA). The original lease granted to the first lessee, Unsworth, included a right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free'. This right was personal to Unsworth and non-transferable under the terms of the lease agreement. Subsequently, Unsworth assigned his lease to Debsan Pty Ltd through a Deed of Assignment. Debsan Pty Ltd argued that the right to occupy the residential accommodation was assignable and should transfer with the lease. Unsworth contested this, asserting that the right to occupy the residential accommodation was not assignable and remained with the original lessee. The dispute escalated to the court to determine the validity of Debsan Pty Ltd's claim to the right to occupy the residential accommodation.

This matter came before the court as an appeal from a lower court decision. Initially, the dispute was heard in the lower court where the primary judge ruled in favour of Debsan Pty Ltd, finding that the right to occupy the residential accommodation was indeed assignable. Unsworth appealed this decision to the higher court, challenging the lower court's interpretation of the lease agreement and the applicable statutory provisions. The appeal process involved submissions on the written records and arguments from both parties. The higher court was tasked with reviewing the lower court's decision and determining whether the right to occupy the residential accommodation was indeed assignable under the terms of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' is assignable under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA).
2. Whether the Deed of Assignment effectively transferred the right to occupy the residential accommodation to Debsan Pty Ltd.
3. Whether the statutory provisions confer a personal, non-transferable right to occupy the residential accommodation to the original lessee only.

Held
1. The court held that the right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' under the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA) is not assignable.
2. The court held that the Deed of Assignment did not effectively transfer the right to occupy the residential accommodation to Debsan Pty Ltd.
3. The court held that the statutory provisions confer a personal, non-transferable right to occupy the residential accommodation to the original lessee only.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the statutory language of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreement Act 1985 (WA). It noted that the legislation conferred a right to occupy residential accommodation 'rent free' upon the original lessee, but did not provide any express authority for the assignment of this right. The court emphasised that the right to occupy the residential accommodation was a personal licence, which is inherently non-transferable, as it pertains to the original lessee's personal entitlement to occupy the premises without incurring a rental charge. The court rejected the argument that the Deed of Assignment could have any effect on the non-assignable personal right to occupy, as the deed itself did not include any provision or condition that would alter the statutory scheme. In reaching its conclusion, the court relied on established legal principles that personal licences cannot be assigned without express statutory provision to the contrary. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the statutory provisions confer a personal, non-transferable right to occupy the residential accommodation to the original lessee only, and that this right cannot be assigned by means of a Deed of Assignment.