Deborah Kerin v The Commissioner for Housing in the Act

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Deborah Kerin v The Commissioner for Housing in the ACT [2006] ACTRTT 9
(22 March 2006)

CATCHWORDS
Application for Summary Dismissal - Uninhabitable premises - Premises not reasonably clean – Urgent repairs – Available remedies - Compensation 

LEGISLATION
Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)

Sections 104(b), 104(c) and 104(m)  

Clauses 54(1) (a), 54(1) (b) and 60(l) Standard Residential Terms

CASE LAW
Re Newell [2003] ACTSC 31
Worrall v Commissioner for Housing for the ACT [2002] FCAFC 127
Lazar v Williamson (1886) 7 LR (NSW) 98
Susan Margaret Day v Silva Agneza Cengic [2004] ACTSC 33
Tapoohi v Lewenberg & Ors (No 2) [2003] VSC 410
ACT Housing v Brampton [1999] ACTRTT 19
Lazar v Williamson (1896) 7 LR (NSW) 98
Lam v Lu (NSW RTT 90/008960
Greenhill v Commissioner for Housing for the ACT [2003] ACTRTT
Kiternas v Watts [2006] ACTRTT 4
Summers v Salford Corporation [1943] AC 283
Beeby v Department of Housing NSW RTT 96/030478
Novakovic v Douglass NSW RTT 98/26805

Case Reference Number:     RTT 05/1664

Re: Premises at 22 Jerilderie Court, Reid, ACT 2608

Decision

1That the application by ACT Housing for summary dismissal or summary judgment should be dismissed, except that relating to the Applicant’s claim under Clause 54(1)(b) Standard Residential Term. 

2The matter is to be set down for further hearing before the Tribunal as soon a practicable in relation to the Applicant’s claims under Clauses 54(1)(a) and 60(l) of the Standard Residential Terms.

Member:  J. A. David
Date: 22 March 2006

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

2The Applicant tenant (Applicant) moved into the premises at 22 Jerilderie Court, Reid, in May 1999 under a Residential Tenancy Agreement with the Respondent lessor, The Commissioner for Housing in the Act (ACT Housing). 

3The matter came before the Tribunal on 18 November 2005 when it was adjourned for the tenant to organise an expert report to identify and analyse the substance coating the interior surfaces within 28 days.

4The matter came before the Tribunal again on 20 January 2006 when the Applicant was directed to provide particulars of the precise conditions and/or circumstances within the Respondent’s responsibilities under the tenancy agreement that the Applicant alleged caused her pleaded symptoms and/or medical condition.  The matter was set down for hearing on 8 February 2006 as the particulars had only been provided to ACT Housing on 18 January 2006. 

5At the hearing on 20 January 2006 the Applicant was given leave to amend the Statement of Particulars in the Application (which had been filled in by the Applicant in person).  In her Submission and Statement of Particulars filed on 29 January 2006 she sought the following orders:  

i.A declaration that the Respondent is in breach of the residential tenancy agreement.

ii.An order under section 104(b) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (the Act) requiring ACT Housing to rectify the premises: and thereby properly perform the residential tenancy agreement by –

(a)     Installing insulation in the walls and under the floor of the unit;

(b)     Replacing the carpet in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deborah Kerin v The Commissioner for Housing in the Act and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ACTRTT 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Deborah Kerin v The Commissioner for Housing in the ACT involved a tenant, Deborah Kerin, who sought relief from the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) for the uninhabitable conditions of her rental unit. Kerin claimed that the premises were unfit for habitation and not reasonably clean, and that the landlord, ACT Housing, failed to undertake urgent repairs as required by the Standard Residential Terms. Kerin alleged that the conditions caused her various health issues, including skin irritation, eye problems, and respiratory issues. ACT Housing sought a summary dismissal of Kerin’s claims, arguing that there was no basis in law or evidence to support her claims. The legal issues for the Tribunal to decide were whether Kerin's claims under Clauses 54(1)(a) and 60(l) of the Standard Residential Terms should proceed to a full hearing or be summarily dismissed.

The Tribunal found that there were arguable issues of fact and law concerning whether the premises were fit for habitation at the start of the tenancy and whether ACT Housing failed to undertake urgent repairs. The Tribunal noted that the various expert reports provided conflicting evidence on the causes of the problems in Kerin's unit, and that Kerin's health problems could potentially be linked to the conditions of the unit. The Tribunal concluded that the matter should proceed to a full hearing to determine the facts and applicable law. However, the Tribunal dismissed the claim under Clause 54(1)(b) that the premises were not reasonably clean, finding that there was no real conflict that the premises were reasonably clean at the start of the tenancy.

The Tribunal's decision was that the application for summary dismissal should be dismissed, except for the claim under Clause 54(1)(b). The matter was to be set down for a further hearing to consider Kerin's claims under Clauses 54(1)(a) and 60(l). The Tribunal reserved its decision on the appropriate remedies that could be awarded to Kerin pending the outcome of the full hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established