Deayton and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Deayton and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 1506 (28 May 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2019/7510

Re:Michael Deayton

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

Date:28 May 2021

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

......[sgd]..................................................................

Dr Stewart Fenwick

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – applicant with nemaline myopathy – no disadvantage principle – whether day to day living costs – whether supports relate to disability – decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Australian Constitution

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013

Cases

Breavington v Godleman (1988) 169 CLR 41
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency (2017) 252 FCR 121
McLaughlin and National Disability Agency [2021] AATA 496
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 276 FCR 415

Red Energy Pty Ltd v Saxton [2019] FCCA 86

Secondary Materials

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disability, opened for signature 30 March 2007, 2515 UNTS 3 (entered into force 3 May 2008)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support for Participants) Rules 2013

Quick, John and Robert Rudolph Garran, The Annotated Constituted of the Australian Commonwealth (1901)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Stewart Fenwick, Senior Member

28 May 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Deayton applied on 18 November 2019 for review of an internal review decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) dated 29 April 2019 which, in effect, maintained his plan as previously approved without a number of specific supports which Mr Deayton had wanted to be included.

  2. The Applicant was accepted as a National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) participant on 9 February 2018. Mr Deayton’s first NDIS plan was approved on 9 November 2018, and he sought a review of the plan on 14 November 2018. Mr Deayton declined to access the supports funded in his plan and continued to question the plan’s content at the time of its first annual review in 2019. Mr Deayton’s concerns about his supports arise from his transition from a Victorian Disability Services funded Individual Support Package (ISP) to the NDIS in 2018.

  3. Mr Deayton represented himself at a hearing by telephone on 12 March 2021. He lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC), and a bundle of material was received at the hearing (Exhibit A1), marked H3–H23 in the Hearing Bundle lodged by the Respondent. This material includes a statement of lived experience from Mr Deayton, a number of witness statements, a range of documents relating to the supports not approved by NDIS, and several policy documents in relation to the NDIS.

  4. The Respondent lodged a SFIC and documents under s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T documents), and the Hearing Bundle, being a consolidated set of all material lodged. At my invitation, the Respondent lodged further material following the hearing being submissions and authorities relevant to the concept of ‘no disadvantage’, and the interpretation of day-to-day living expenses.

    LEGISLATION

  5. An NDIS plan takes effect under s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deayton and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1506
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Deayton against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). Mr Deayton, who has the rare genetic muscle disorder Nemaline Myopathy, sought to have certain supports included in his NDIS plan. The dispute centred on whether these supports constituted reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act), particularly in relation to day-to-day living costs and whether they related to his disability.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the NDIA's decision to exclude certain supports from Mr Deayton's NDIS plan was correct. Specifically, the court had to consider the application of the "no disadvantage principle," which Mr Deayton argued should have ensured continuity of supports previously funded under his previous Individual Support Plan (ISP). The Tribunal also had to assess whether the requested supports were for day-to-day living costs or were directly related to Mr Deayton's disability, and whether there was sufficient evidence to validate the need for these supports.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the NDIA, finding that the "no disadvantage principle," as referenced in intergovernmental agreements, did not supplant the statutory criteria for determining reasonable and necessary supports under the Act. The Tribunal noted that the concept of "no disadvantage" was not explicitly found in the Act and that decision-making must be consistent with the federal statutory framework. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that there was insufficient evidence to establish the nature of Mr Deayton's previous ISP supports or to adequately validate the underlying need for the requested supports. The Tribunal applied the principles from *McLaughlin and National Disability Agency* [2021] AATA 496, which held that the "no disadvantage principle" does not override the statutory criteria and that the nexus between a disability and a support must be clearly established by evidence.

The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The objects of the Act are found in s 3(1) and include support for the independence and social and economic participation of people with disability, the provision of reasonable and necessary supports, and enabling people with disability to exercise choice in the pursuit of their goals. EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS Support Plan Mr Deayton’s first approved plan (8 November 2018 to 8 November 2019) (T7) has total funded supports of $52,581.65 and states the following:(a)he lives independently in a two bedroom wheelchair accessible unit. He has family in the neighbourhood who assist him at times, as do friends and neighbours;(b)he has the rare, genetic muscle disorder Nemaline Myopathy. On good days he can get out of bed and look to his daily needs. On bad days he is unable to get out of bed except for basic needs;(c)he has a keen interest in horse racing and is a member of a syndicate, and has friendships and good social networks in the sport;(d)he enjoys AFL and movies which he watches on Foxtel and he once participated in competitive wheelchair sports, which he would like to return to; and(e)he spends a large part of his day online and socialising via Facebook. Mr Deayton’s plan identified the following short-term goals: to maintain independent living; and, to meet his ongoing disability support needs, to maintain independence, dignity and self-esteem. The plan identified the following medium or long-term goals: maintain current independent movement and transportation in and around home and community to see friends and family; maintain and enhance social networks and have more opportunities to access community activities and participate in sporting and recreational activities; and maintain mobility, flexibility and muscle strength. The core funded supports in Mr Deayton’s plan included: funding for personal care and community access; funding for assistive technology; and transport costs. Capacity building supports included: funding to assist in identifying assistive technology needs; and funding for allied health professional or therapists, including personalised training. Capital supports included powered wheelchair and bed and associated items. The NDIA appear to have approved a revision of this plan (T8) by letter dated 8 October 2019 (T8, p 53), increasing the total funded supports to $59,280.15. According to the Respondent’s SFIC ([15]) on 4 November 2020, the plan review date was extended to 24 April 2020 and the total funded supports was increased to $143,038.65. The core supports relevant to the issues in this matter are described as follows (T7, p 48; and T8, p 60):(a)‘Support to explore and participate in community based activities of interest and to develop, build and maintain friendships, for example, a person to support you to participate in social and community activities including attending recreational camps’ (together with other domestic supports, the funding allocated is $46,524.21) (T8, p 60);(b)‘Transport - $1,784.00. This funding is a contribution towards any transport related costs you incur during the plan period. This amount will be paid fortnightly into your nominated bank account on a pro-rata basis’ (T8, p 60).

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider that key information, data and evidence is important not only to quantify particular support requests, but to validate the underlying need. Without such material, it is difficult to develop an adequate understanding of the burden an applicant is seeking to address. This, indeed, is only the starting point for the inquiries established in the framework provided by the Act. In this instance, Mr Deayton’s direct evidence was helpful, and credible, however the absence of a robust evidence base overall has left important matters unable to be resolved to an appropriate standard of satisfaction.DECISION For the reasons given above, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In submissions provided following the hearing, the Respondent cited a number of decisions. I consider the decision in McLaughlin and National Disability Agency [2021] AATA 496 (McLaughlin) (handed down on the day of the hearing in this matter) particularly relevant. It is cited for the finding made that the no disadvantage principle does not supplant the statutory criteria for determining reasonable and necessary supports (at [128]–[130]). It is also cited for its findings in relation to the issue of day-to-day living costs, noting that the Tribunal in that decision found in favour of one support, and against another, based on the interpretation of evidence in respect of the nexus between the person’s disability and the support in question. The Tribunal found in favour of additional running costs of a private vehicle which it found fell within the ‘carve-out’ provision in Rule 5.2(a) of the Rules (at [125]). CONSIDERATIONS It is appropriate to first address Mr Deayton’s more fundamental submissions which centre upon his argument that supports previously funded under his ISP should have been included in his NDIS plan. The Intergovernmental Agreement includes as Annex A (H6, pp 48–52) the text of ‘high-level’ principles released by the Council of Australian Governments following the release of the Productivity Commission report on Disability Care and Support. Here it is stated in Principle 1 (at point (l)) that the NDIS should recognise best practice at the State and Territory level to ‘[p]rovide continuity of support to people with disability currently receiving services to ensure they are not disadvantaged in the transition …’. I also accept that there is reference in s 118 of the Act to best endeavours with respect to any intergovernmental agreement. However, as noted in the Operational Guidelines, the concept of no disadvantage is not found in the IGA, and I am unable to accept that the IGA itself should guide decision making in the way contended by Mr Deayton. This is a consequence of the nature of administrative decision making in the context of the NDIS, where a decision must be made consistent with the federal statutory framework. As a matter of practical reality, it must also be acknowledged that the participant needs and support options may change from plan to plan, within the NDIS, let alone across different schemes. Perhaps more importantly, and in the specific context of this matter, I must note that the evidence before me does not provide any real certainty as to what was previously funded. I do not discount Mr Deayton’s evidence and submissions on this point, but I am not satisfied that I have adequate evidence of the nature of his ISP prior to transition to the NDIS to base any relevant consideration or finding. Mr Deayton cited the Constitution in support of a proposition, broadly, that discussions or outcomes of some form apparently in relation to a VCAT proceeding should have weight in the Tribunal. The Constitution also was cited in support of the need to recognise Mr Deayton’s previous ISP support. The provision relied upon is found in Chapter V dealing with the States and s 118 provides: ‘[f]ull faith and credit shall be given, throughout the Commonwealth, to the laws, the public Acts and records, and the judicial proceedings of any State’.