Deayton and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

Deayton and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 3310 (16 September 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:2023/5367          

Re:Michael Deayton  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member K Parker

Date:16 September 2024

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits this matter to the Respondent with a direction that a new statement of participant supports (‘SOPS’) be approved for the Applicant, Mr Michael Deayton, which contains the following provisions:

1.a provision to specify that the new SOPS is to be reassessed by the Respondent 12 months after the date upon which it is approved (‘Reassessment Date’);

2.a provision to approve funding for Mr Deayton in respect of the following supports:

a.as a “Stated Support”, the cost of excessive electricity usage by Mr Deayton resulting from the use of equipment by reason of his disability, being an amount equivalent to the total monthly amounts charged to Mr Deayton (that is, after any Victorian-based concessions have been applied and deductions made, as recorded on those bills) over the previous 12-month period, in respect of the electricity usage in excess of 7.34 kWh per day, and minus any lump sum payment made to Mr Deayton by the Commonwealth for an Essential  Medical Equipment Payment;

b.as a “Stated Support”, funding for 56 hours of physiotherapy (which includes four hours to prepare a written progress report to be lodged with the NDIA before the Reassessment Date);

c.as a “Stated Support”, funding for 27 hours of remedial massage therapy (which includes one hour to prepare a written progress report to be lodged with the NDIA before the Reassessment Date);

d.as a “Stated Support”, funding for 28 hours of occupational therapy (which includes four hours to prepare a written progress report to be lodged with the NDIA before the Reassessment Date);

e.as a “Stated Support”, the cost per annum of providing Mr Deayton with access to Foxtel sports channels being an amount equivalent to 50% of the total amount Mr Deayton is currently charged by Foxtel for his current yearly “full package” Foxtel subscription;

f.as a “Stated Support”, $800 per annum to fund two economy return airfares for a support worker to accompany Mr Deayton as he travels to one Powerchair championship per annum (whether that be hockey or football), and to accompany him when he returns home after the event;

g.as a “Stated Support”, the following costs associated with providing a local support worker to assist Mr Deayton at his temporary accommodation while attending one Powerchair event per annum (likely to take place from a Thursday to a Monday inclusive, based on the previous programs for such events):

i.27 hours for one support worker at the daytime weekday rate to provide assistance to Mr Deayton in respect of the Thursday, Friday, and Monday;

ii.16 hours for one support worker at the daytime weekend rate to provide assistance in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deayton and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Deayton against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the provision of supports under his National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) plan. Mr Deayton, who lives with a progressive genetic muscle disorder causing significant physical impairments and limited mobility, sought funding for several supports, including excessive electricity usage, ongoing physiotherapy and massage therapy, a component of his Foxtel subscription for sporting events, and supports to enable his participation in interstate Powerchair events. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether these disputed supports met the criteria of "reasonable and necessary supports" as defined by the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth).

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the interpretation of "reasonable and necessary supports" under section 34(1) of the NDIS Act and relevant operational guidelines. It considered the specific circumstances of Mr Deayton's disability and how the requested supports related to his goals of maintaining independence, social connection, and participation in recreational and sporting activities. The Tribunal analysed whether certain costs, such as electricity usage and Foxtel subscription, were day-to-day living costs or directly attributable to his disability support needs, referencing principles from the *Warwick v National Disability Insurance Agency* decision regarding the distinction between general living expenses and disability-related costs.

Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter with directions to approve a new statement of supports for Mr Deayton. This new statement was to include funding for the disputed items, such as excessive electricity usage due to disability-related equipment, physiotherapy, massage therapy, occupational therapy, a portion of his Foxtel subscription for sports, and comprehensive supports for his participation in interstate Powerchair events, including travel, local assistance, and equipment hire. The Tribunal also directed that the plan be self-managed for a notional duration of 12 months, allowing for a review period of the new supports.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal considers that the four requested supports in dispute between the Parties, are “reasonable and necessary supports” for Mr Deayton and should be funded under the NDIS. There are two other supports, transport supports and the cost of the annual subscription to RACV Roadside Assist for a Wheelchair, which the Parties agree should be included in Mr Deayton’s NDIS plan, so they will be included in Mr Deayton’s next SOPS, as well as all other existing supports in his current SOPS, on a pro rata basis. The Tribunal is content for the funding to be “self-managed” and for the notional duration of Mr Deayton’s next NDIS plan to be 12 months. BACKGROUND Mr Deayton lives with a rare, genetic muscle disorder, nemaline myopathy. Congenital myopathy causes problems with muscle cells, affecting the tone and contraction of the muscle fibres.[1] This leads to weakness of skeletal muscles, which has happened in Mr Deayton’s case. [1] Mr Deayton’s Hearing Tender Bundle (‘Mr Deayton’s HTB’), document 61. As time passes, Mr Deayton’s condition has worsened. He used to be able to walk when he was younger. He is now 60 years of age.[2] He requires a wheelchair to assist him to mobilise. He lives alone in a public housing two bedroom unit in an outer suburb in Melbourne, Victoria, provided to him through Housing Vic.[3] [2] T-Documents, p.2.[3] Transcript, P-23. Housing Vic is now known as Homes Victoria. Mr Deayton also has a keen interest in AFL football and horse racing. He is a member of a horse racing syndicate. Mr Deayton gave evidence that he has several friendships and has developed social networks associated with horseracing. Mr Deayton gave evidence that he likes to be able to talk about the latest developments in horseracing and football, with his family, friends, and the other members of his horse racing syndicate. Mr Deayton has been involved in and would like to return to competitive sports. Previously, Mr Deayton has represented Victoria in electric wheelchair sports through Powerchair Victoria (specifically, in hockey and English-rules football). Mr Deayton’s current NDIS plan commenced on 9 September 2022 for a notional period of two years (‘Current NDIS Plan’).[4] Ms Deayton’s goals under his NDIS plan include:(a)to maintain his independent living arrangements, so he can continue to live on his own;(b)meet his ongoing support needs, so he can maintain his independence, dignity, and self-esteem;(c)maintain his current independent movement and transportation in and around his home and community, so he can see his family and friends;(d)maintain and enhance his social networks, have more opportunities to access community activities and participate in recreational and sporting activities; and(e)maintain his mobility, flexibility, and muscle strength, so he can maintain his independence.[4] The Tribunal presumes this is the current plan as it has not been provided with any subsequent plans by either party. The Tribunal notes the reassessment date of this plan is 8 September 2024.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the primary issues in this proceeding are:(a)whether each of the four Supports In Dispute are “reasonable and necessary supports” within the meaning of the NDIS Act and should be included in Mr Deayton’s SOPS forming part of his NDIS plan; (b)if a new SOPS is approved for Mr Deayton, to determine the date by which the NDIA must reassess the new plan under Division 4 of the NDIS Act (that is, the Reassessment Date); and(c)to determine how the funds in any new SOPS approved for Mr Deayton are to be managed.EVIDENCE, SUBMISSIONS AND HEARING The parties lodged the following written submissions with the Tribunal:(a)Mr Deayton’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (undated) lodged on 8 December 2023 (‘Mr Deayton’s SFIC’);(b)NDIA’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (2 February 2024) (‘NDIA’s SFIC);(c)Mr Deayton’s Reply to the NDIA’s SFIC (undated) lodged on 26 February 2024 (‘Mr Deayton’s Reply’);(d)Mr Deayton’s Further Submissions for the Hearing (undated) lodged on 11 March 2024 (‘Mr Deayton’s Further Submissions’);(e)NDIA’s Outline of Oral Argument (12 March 2024) (‘NDIA’s Outline’). The parties lodged the following documentary evidence with the Tribunal:(a)a set of documents lodged by the NDIA pursuant to its obligations under s 37 of the AAT Act on 10 August 2023 (‘T-Documents’) (223 pages);(b)Mr Deayton’s hearing tender bundle (‘Mr Deayton’s HTB’) (746 pages) comprising: (i)Documents 1 to 36 lodged on 8 December 2023; (ii)Documents 37 to 47 lodged on 26 February 2024; (iii)Documents 48 to 60 lodged on 11 March 2024; and (iv)Document 61 lodged on 13 March 2024.(c)NDIA’s hearing tender bundle lodged on 2 February 2024 (642 pages) (‘NDIA’s HTB’);(d)NDIA’s supplementary hearing tender bundle lodged on 1 March 2024 (‘NDIA’s Supplementary HTB’);(e)Publication entitled Victorian Concessions Guide to Discounts and Services lodged by the NDIA on 4 March 2024;(f)email from Ms Georgia McIntyre to Mr Deayton dated 14 September 2022 lodged with the Tribunal by Mr Deayton on 4 March 2024; Mr Deayton lodged a Statement of Lived Experience (undated) on 8 December 2023 (‘Mr Deayton’s SLE’).[8][8] Mr Deayton’s HTB, document 1. The substantive hearing of this matter took place over two days on 4 and 12 March 2024. Mr Deayton was self-represented in this proceeding and was accompanied by his support worker. The NDIA was represented by Mr Matthew Keneally of counsel and an external lawyer from Maddocks, Ms Jessica Summers. The NDIA case manager was also present. The parties lodged the following further evidence and submissions after the conclusion of the substantive hearing:(a)by email dated 14 March 2024, the NDIA’s Supplementary Submission (‘NDIA’s Supplementary Submission’);(b)by email dated 22 March 2024, the NDIA’s further submission;(c)by email and attached document dated 2 April 2024, Mr Deayton’s Reply to NDIA’s Supplementary Submission and Closing Statement (‘Mr Deayton’s Closing Statement’); and(d)by email dated 21 August 2024, Mr Deayton’s further submissions about his request for funding for the Powerchair Events Support; and(e)by email dated 12 September 2024, the NDIA’s response to Mr Deayton’s further submissions about his request for funding for the Powerchair Events Support.PRELIMINARY ISSUE – TRANSITION FROM STATE-BASED SCHEME TO NDIS

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal considers it appropriate that the notional plan duration be 12 months. This will allow for a settling in period of the new suite of supports and the change of the plan management settings. It will also allow an opportunity for the NDIA to review the progress reports provided in relation to the physiotherapy, massage therapy and occupational therapy, once Mr Deayton re-engages with those interventions.CONCLUSION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits this matter to the NDIA with a direction that a new SOPS be approved for Mr Deayton, which contains the following provisions:(a)a provision to specify that the new SOPS is to be reassessed by the Respondent 12 months after the date upon which it is approved (‘Reassessment Date’);(b)a provision to approve funding for Mr Deayton in respect of the following supports:(i)as a “Stated Support”, the cost of excessive electricity usage by Mr Deayton resulting from the use of equipment by reason of his disability, being an amount equivalent to the total monthly amounts charged to Mr Deayton (that is, after any Victorian-based concessions have been applied and deductions made, as recorded on those bills) over the previous 12-month period, in respect of the electricity usage in excess of 7.34 kWh per day, and minus any lump sum payment made to Mr Deayton by the Commonwealth for an Essential Medical Equipment Payment;(ii)as a “Stated Support”, funding for 56 hours of physiotherapy (which includes four hours to prepare a written progress report to be lodged with the NDIA before the Reassessment Date);(iii)as a “Stated Support”, funding for 27 hours of remedial massage therapy (which includes one hour to prepare a written progress report to be lodged with the NDIA before the Reassessment Date);(iv)as a “Stated Support”, funding for 28 hours of occupational therapy (which includes four hours to prepare a written progress report to be lodged with the NDIA before the Reassessment Date);(v)as a “Stated Support”, the cost per annum of providing Mr Deayton with access to Foxtel sports channels being an amount equivalent to 50% of the total amount Mr Deayton is currently charged by Foxtel for his current yearly “full package” Foxtel subscription;(vi)as a “Stated Support”, $800 per annum to fund two economy return airfares for a support worker to accompany Mr Deayton as he travels to one Powerchair championship per annum (whether that be hockey or football), and to accompany him when he returns home after the event; (vii)as a “Stated Support”, the following costs associated with providing a local support worker to assist Mr Deayton at his temporary accommodation while attending one Powerchair event per annum (likely to take place from a Thursday to a Monday inclusive, based on the previous programs for such events):· 27 hours for one support worker at the daytime weekday rate to provide assistance to Mr Deayton in respect of the Thursday, Friday, and Monday;· 16 hours for one support worker at the daytime weekend rate to provide assistance in respect of the Saturday and Sunday;(viii)as a “Stated Support”, $350 for the cost of temporary hire of a hoist and commode including delivery and collection at the accommodation where Mr Deayton will be staying when attending one Powerchair event per annum;(ix)as a “Stated Support”, transport supports in the amount of $7,306 per annum to be paid to Mr Deayton on an ongoing fortnightly basis (as from 9 September 2022, as agreed between the Parties);(x)as a “Stated Support”, the cost of Mr Deayton’s annual subscription to RACV Roadside Assist for a Wheelchair being $25.50 per annum (as from 9 September 2022, as agreed between the Parties); and(xi)as a “Stated Support” (and subject to the NDIA obtaining a quote), the costs associated with the registration and attendance by Mr Deayton within the next three months, to attend a training course in respect of the self-management of a NDIS plan so that he may better understand a participant’s obligations under s 46 of the NDIS Act when doing so; and(xii)replication, on a pro-rata basis, of all other existing supports in Mr Deayton’s current SOPS (except for any one-off supports where the funding for such support has already been expended, and except for the previous funding approved for physiotherapy and “other professional” which has been replaced by the funding under paragraphs 229(b)(ii) to (iv) above), minus his current funding for support worker assistance for a period of five days as this will not be required during the five-day period when Mr Deayton will be in attendance at one Powerchair championship per annum, at which time he will have access to the supports referred to in paragraph [229(b)(vii)] above;(c)a provision specifying that the funding in this NDIS plan is to be “self-managed”; and(d)a provision specifying that it will be open to the NDIA to request invoices from Mr Deayton over the duration of this NDIS plan, to audit the expenditure by him to ensure it aligns with his NDIS plan. If there are found to be any irregularities or that funds are spent on supports, which are not identified in the new SOPS or which the NDIA has advised Mr Deayton are not “reasonable and necessary supports”, it will be open to the NDIA to undertake an unscheduled plan review under s 48 of the NDIS Act and to approve a new SOPS for Mr Deayton which may change the specifications in relation to being “plan-managed” or “Agency-managed”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal has considered the following Operational Guidelines published by the NDIA on its website:(a)NDIA Operational Guidelines entitled “Principles we follow to create your plan” (updated on 25 September 2023);(b)NDIA Operational Guidelines entitled “Reasonable and necessary supports” (updated on 6 October 2023) (‘NDIA R&N Guidelines’); and(c)NDIA Operational Guidelines entitled “Assistive Technology” (updated on 20 December 2023) (‘NDIA AT Guidelines’).CONSIDERATION OF REQUEST FOR ELECTRICITY SUPPORT Electricity usage in the home is generally regarded as a day-to-day living cost. Rule 5.1 of the Support Rules expressly excludes a support from being funded or provided under the NDIS if it “relates to a day-to-day living cost” (such as “utility fees”), “that are not attributable to a participant’s disability support needs” (see Rule 5.1(d)). On 12 September 2024, the NDIA made the following submission to the Tribunal about the Federal Court of Australia decision (currently on appeal to the Full Federal Court) in Warwick v National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] FCA 616:This decision considered the application of r5.1(d) and the exception to this rule under r5.2 of the Rules. When considering the operation of r5.1(d), his Honour Justice Perram stated at [14]:Paragraph 5.1(d) is contained in a legislative instrument. The expression ‘day-to-day living costs’ is not defined in that instrument, nor does it bear a technical meaning. Thus, it bears its ordinary meaning. According to the Macquarie Dictionary, the ordinary meaning of ‘day-to-day’ is ‘ordinary; happening every day’. Perhaps the word ‘everyday’ captures these two concepts. The ordinary meaning of ‘living costs’ is those expenses which are incurred in the course of living for the purpose of living. Thus ‘day-to-day living costs’ are those everyday expenses which are incurred in the course of living for the purpose of living. This meaning is confirmed by the examples which appear in brackets in paragraph 5.1(d) – ‘rent, groceries and utility fees’ – which are canonical examples of day-to-day living costs.In relation to r5.2(a), his Honour stated at [19]: The point of paragraph 5.2(a) is to permit recovery of everyday costs where those costs relate solely to disability support needs. Thus the telephone bill is out, but transport costs for a person unable to drive or to utilise public transport because of a disability are in. Expenses which are disability-related but which would be incurred anyway even if the person did not have a disability are not recoverable. Thus the fact that a telephone is used for purposes which relate to disability does not make them recoverable if it is used for other non-disability-related purposes too. Rule 5.2 elaborates further. It provides that the day-to-day living costs referred to in Rule 5.1(d) do not include the following (which may be funded under the NDIA if they relate to reasonable and necessary supports):(a) additional living costs that are incurred by a participant solely and directly as a result of their disability support needs;(b) costs that are ancillary to another support that is funded or provided under the participant’s plan, and which the participant would not otherwise incur.