de Waard and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

de Waard and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2021] AATA 316 (25 February 2021)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:2017/3717          

Re:Cornelius de Waard

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell

Date:25 February 2021

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the Veteran is entitled to be paid the special rate disability pension from 6 September 2019.

....................[SGD].................................................

Member D Mitchell

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – special rate pension – relevant assessment period – incapacity from service-caused conditions – prevented from being able to continue to undertake remunerative work that he was undertaking – alone test – loss of salary or wages – date of effect of decision where application for review was made outside the 3 month window – decision under review set aside and new decision substituted

LEGISLATION

Repatriation Act 1920 (Cth)

Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (Cth)

CASES

Banovich v Repatriation Commission (1986) 6AAR 113

Boxsell and Repatriation Commission [2007] AATA 1215

Clements and Repatriation Commission [1997] AATA 291

Flentjar v Repatriation Commission (1997) 48 ALD 1

Grundman v Repatriation Commission [2001] FCA 892

Morris and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2017] AATA 2165

Repatriation Commission v Hendy (2002) 76 ALD 47

Repatriation Commission v Maloney [1993] FCA 212

Repatriation Commission v Richmond [2014] FCAFC 124

Repatriation Commission v Watkins (2015) 228 FCR 573

Richmond v Repatriation Commission[2014] FCA 272

Roberts and Repatriation Commission [1992] AATA 76; (1992) 15 AAR 192; (1992) 26 ALD 611

Rose v Repatriation Commission [2001] FCA 245

Smith v Repatriation Commission [2014] FCAFC

Wright and Repatriation Commission (2005) 144 FCR 302

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Mitchell

25 February 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Cornelius de Waard (the Veteran) made an application for an increase in disability pension dated 10 November 2014. The Respondent received that application on 11 November 2014.[1]

    [1]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T53, pages 168-178, Application for Increase in Disability Pension for Previously            Accepted Disabilities.

  2. On 14 January 2015, the Respondent issued a decision increasing the Veteran’s disability pension from 50% to 60% of the General Rate, with effect from 11 November 2014.[2]

    [2]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T63, pages 214-221, Decision – Increasing the Applicant’s Disability Pension to 60% of the General Rate.

  3. The Veteran sought review of that decision.[3]

    [3]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T65, page 223, Application for Review of Decision dated 14 January 2015.

  4. The Veteran made a claim for disability in relation to clear cell renal cancer on 27 January 2016.[4]

    [4]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T90, pages 299-314, Claim for Disability Pension (Renal Cancer).

  5. On 16 March 2016, the Respondent accepted the Veteran’s claim for adenocarcinoma of the right kidney as being service related under the Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act) and deferred the assessment of the Veteran’s rate of disability pension.[5]

    [5]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T95, pages 328-333, Decision: Accepting the Applicant’s “Adenocarcinoma of the Right Kidney” as service Related under the Act and Deferring the Assessment of the Applicant’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read de Waard and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 316
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Veteran against a decision of the Repatriation Commission regarding his eligibility for a special rate pension. The Veteran, who had a distinguished naval career, sought to have his disability pension increased to the special rate, arguing that service-caused conditions prevented him from continuing in his maritime career. The core dispute revolved around the assessment period for his eligibility and the date from which any increased pension should be paid.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine several legal issues. These included identifying the relevant assessment period for the Veteran's claim, whether he met the preliminary criteria for a special rate pension under section 24 of the *Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth), and crucially, whether he was totally and permanently incapacitated due to service-caused conditions alone. Furthermore, the Tribunal had to ascertain if, by reason of such incapacity, the Veteran was prevented from continuing his remunerative work and if this prevention resulted in a loss of salary or wages that he would not have suffered had he been free of the incapacity. Finally, the AAT needed to determine the effective date for any special rate pension awarded.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on applying the criteria set out in section 24 of the Act to the evidence presented. It found that the Veteran met the requirements for the special rate pension during specific periods, notably between 11 November 2014 and August 2015, and again from 6 September 2019. The Tribunal considered the Veteran's loss of his Master's licence due to hearing impairment, which occurred in September 2014, and his inability to secure alternative onshore employment due to his specialised maritime career. The Tribunal also addressed the issue of the effective date of payment, noting that the Veteran's application for review was made outside the usual three-month window.

Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the previous decision and substituted a new decision. It found that the Veteran met the requirements of section 24(1)(c) of the Act from 11 November 2014 to August 2015 and again from 6 September 2019. In relation to the date of effect, the Tribunal determined that, by virtue of section 177(2)(b)(ii) of the Act, the earliest date for payment of the increased pension was the date on which the application for review was made, which was 21 June 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 3 July 2017, the Tribunal granted the Veteran’s application for an Extension of Time to Lodge an Application for Review of a Decision.[9][9] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T2, page 3, AAT Extension of Time Order.BACKGROUND The Veteran joined the Royal Australian Navy on 3 March 1968 as a Midshipman. The Veteran outlined his enlistment history as follows:[10][10] Exhibit 4, Statement of the Applicant dated 10 August 2018, pages 2-3, paragraphs 4-12.4.I joined the Royal Australian Navy on 3 March 1968 as a Midshipman. I spent two years training as a Midshipman serving on HMAS Cerberus, HMAS Watson, HMAS Nowra and on various fleet units such as HMAS Stuart, HMAS Sydney and HMAS Melbourne. At the end of my period of training, I had to appear before the Fleet Board which sat on board HMAS Melbourne to tender my qualifications to be given a full Commission.5. I passed the requirements of the Fleet Board which were rigorous. I was commissioned as an Acting Sub- Lieutenant. After 12 months, I achieved the full rank of Sub-Lieutenant. I was posted to HMAS Perth which was a Guided Missile Destroyer with a crew in excess of 300 about to be deployed to Vietnam.6.As a very junior Officer on HMAS Perth, my duties were very much to be the dogsbody. It was still a training berth for me learning seamanship skills such as watchkeeping. HMAS Perth was on the gun line off Vietnamese waters. My duties included gunnery duties, plotting coordinates and calculating bearings to ensure the greatest accuracy of the gunfire support provided by HMAS Perth. It was certainly a steep learning curve for me as these duties were performed under the pressure of real-time active service. I remained on HMAS Perth until February 1971.7.My next posting was to HMAS Penguin and then HMAS Brisbane for short periods of time. Then back on HMAS Perth for a further 4 months.8. In March 1971, I was posted to HMAS Queensborough in Sydney which was a training billet and allowed me to work towards the completion of a full bridge watchkeeping certificate. I then spent six months in HMAS Barbette, as it's First Lieutenant (2 I.C.) a patrol boat in Cairns. I was then posted to HMAS Sydney from August 1972 until July 1973 during which time I participated in three trips to Vung Tau, Vietnam. My duties in Sydney were Amphibious Warfare Officer and assistant Cargo Officer.9. I served in HMAS Torrens between July 1973 and March 1974 as assistant Anti­ Submarine Warfare Officer.10. In March 1974, I was posted to HMAS Cerberus as a training and divisional officer. My last posting was as the Commanding Officer of HMAS Betano which was a "Landing Craft Heavy".11. I discharged from the Australian Navy in August 1976. I remained In the Naval Reserves.12. During my naval career, I received a naval board commendation for my role in a sea rescue. A copy is attached to this Statement. After discharging from the Navy, the Veteran found work in the Australian maritime industry whilst remaining active in the Naval Reserves. In 1997, the Veteran upgraded his maritime skills by obtaining an “Advanced Diploma of Applied Science – Shipmaster” from the Australian Maritime College.[11][11] Exhibit 2, Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, page 2, paragraphs 8-9.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issue before the Tribunal is whether the Applicant is eligible for payment at the special rate of pension. This requires determining:(a)What is the assessment period?(b)Whether the Veteran:(i)made a valid application under section 15 of the Act for an increase in the rate of pension that he was receiving (section 24(1)(aa) of the Act); (ii)had not yet turned 65 when the application was made (section 24(1)(aab) of the Act); and(iii)was being paid the disability pension at a rate equal to or greater than 70% of the General rate of pension (section 24(1)(a)(i) of the Act). (c)If the answer to (b) is yes, whether the Veteran is totally and permanently incapacitated, that is unable to work more than eight hours a week, due to service-caused incapacity alone (section 24(1)(b) of the Act); and (d)If the answer to (c) is yes, whether the Veteran by reason of incapacity from his service-caused conditions, alone, is prevented from continuing to undertake remunerative work that he was undertaking; and(e)If the answer to (d) is yes, whether the Veteran, by reason of being prevented from continuing to undertake remunerative work, suffered a loss of salary or wages, or of earnings, that he would not be suffering if he was free of that incapacity.(f)If the answer to (e) is yes, from what date should the Veteran be paid the special rate pension?EVIDENCEApplicant’s Evidence The Applicant provided a statement dated 28 February 2018[53] firstly outlining his service history (as provided above) and secondly outlining his post discharge maritime career. In relation to the events leading up to when he ceased work, the Applicant provided:[54]22.My last position as a Ship's Master terminated in May 2014 when I delivered a ship to Singapore and decided that I needed a break despite being offered further work by both Pacific Marine Towing, International Marine Services (IMS) and Great Lakes Dredging Co. In September 2014 I was ready to go back to work and after a being offered employment by Great Lakes Co I agreed to make myself available for the next period duty. As my annual Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) medical was due I - during this period I undertook my medical with Dr Houghton where I failed my hearing test thus invalidating my Master's licence and any prospect of further work as a Ship's Master or deck officer. At the time that I lost that qualification due to my hearing, I was earning in the vicinity of AU$250,ooo per year.23.At the time that I lost my Certificate as a Ship's Master, I had been offered employment from a number of different large companies such as Pacific Tugs, Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Company ( the largest dredging and land reclamation company in United States) and International Marine Shipping which was also an international dredging company. Throughout my working career I have rarely had to solicit for work. The nature of the industry is that one relies on one's reputation to be offered work.24. Ships Masters rarely·retire at 65 years of age. Most work well into their 70s. Most of my peers are still working and are well past 65 years of age. It was my intention to continue to work well into my 70s. My opportunities for employment are limited to seagoing positions because that was a career choice taken by me many years ago. Accordingly, I have not developed any skills that could be used onshore in other capacities. Some of my contemporaries did choose to go that way but I did not.[53] Exhibit 4, Statement of the Applicant dated 28 February 2018, pages 1-8.[54] Exhibit 4, Statement of the Applicant dated 28 February 2018, page 6, paragraphs 22-24.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is satisfied that the Veteran satisfied the requirements of section 24(1)(c) of the Act at the time of his claim for an increase of disability pension and at various times throughout the assessment period. Specifically, between the period of 11 November 2014 and August 2015 and then again from 6 September 2019.Conclusion in relation to section 24 of the Act Based on the evidence before it and as outlined in the above consideration the Tribunal finds that the Veteran:(a)Met the requirements of section 24(1)(aa) of the Act from 11 November 2014.(b)Met the requirements of section 24(1)(aab) of the Act from 11 November 2014.(c)Met the requirements of section 24(1)(a) of the Act from 4 October 2015.(d)Met the requirements of section 24(1)(b) of the Act from 11 November 2014.(e)Met the requirements of section 24(1)(c) of the Act from 11 November 2014 to August 2015 and again from 6 September 2019. From what Date should the Veteran be Paid the Special Rate of Pension? The Respondent in its written closing submissions submitted that by virtue of section 177(2)(b)(ii) of the Act, should the Tribunal increase the rate of the Veteran’s disability pension, that the earliest any such increase could take effect was 21 June 2017.[128][128] Respondent’s Submissions dated 3 April 2020, pages 13-14, paragraphs 89-90. Relevantly, section 177 provides:Effective dates of certain determinations relating to payment of pension or seniors health card(1)This section is in addition to, and not in substitution for, any of the provisions of section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Act 1975 in their application to proceedings for a review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of a reviewable decision.(2)Where the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, upon application made under subsection 175(1) for a review of a decision of the Commission that has been affirmed or varied by a decision of the Board or a decision of the Board made in substitution for a decision of the Commission, grants a pension (not being a service pension or income support supplement) or attendant allowance, or increases the rate at which a pension (not being a service pension or income support supplement) is to be paid, the Tribunal may approve payment of the pension or of attendant allowance, or payment of the pension at the increased rate, as the case may be:(a) if the application is made within 3 months after service on the applicant of a document setting out the terms of that decision of the Board--from a date not earlier than the earliest date as from which the Board could, if it had granted a pension or attendant allowance or increased the rate of the pension, have approved payment of the pension or attendant allowance, or payment of the pension at an increased rate, as the case may be; or(b) in any other case:…..(ii) if the review relates to an application in accordance with section 15, or to an application for attendance allowance—from the date on which the application under subsection 175(1) was made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.