FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
De Grey Mining Ltd, in the matter of De Grey Mining Ltd [2025] FCA 246
File number: WAD 7 of 2025 Judgment of: FEUTRILL J Date of judgment: 10 March 2025 Date of publication of reasons: 21 March 2025 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – interlocutory application for orders to convene a meeting between a company and its members under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – script takeover scheme of arrangement Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 249Y(3), 411, 411(1), 411(3), 411(4), 411(4)(b), 411(6), 412(1)(a), 412(6), 623, 1319, 1330; Pt 2G.2
Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) reg 5.1.01; Sch 8
Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) rr 1.3, 2.15, 2.4(1), 3.3(2), 3.4
Cases cited: A-Cap Energy Limited, in the matter of A-Cap Energy Limited [2023] FCA 1142
A-Cap Energy Limited, in the matter of A-Cap Energy Limited (No 2) [2023] FCA 1356
Allkem Limited, in the matter of Allkem Limited [2023] FCA 1397
Chesser Resources Limited, in the matter of Chesser Resources Limited [2023] FCA 1021
Eumundi Group Limited, in the matter of Eumundi Group Limited [2024] FCA 1510
OreCorp Limited, in the matter of OreCorp Limited [2023] FCA 1359
Sovereign Life Assurance Co (In Liquidation) v Dodd [1892] 2 QB 573
ThinkSmart Limited, in the matter of ThinkSmart Limited [2022] FCA 1314
Division: General Division Registry: Western Australia National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency Number of paragraphs: 64 Date of hearing: 10 March 2025 Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr SK Dharmananda SC Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Gilbert + Tobin Counsel for Interested Party: Mr JRC Sippe Solicitor for Interested Party: King & Wood Mallesons ORDERS
WAD 7 of 2025 IN THE MATTER OF DE GREY MINING LTD ACN 094 206 292
DE GREY MINING LTD ACN 094 206 292
Plaintiff
ORDER MADE BY:
FEUTRILL J
DATE OF ORDER:
10 MARCH 2025
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Pursuant to s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth):
(a)the plaintiff convene and hold a meeting (Scheme Meeting) of the holders of fully paid ordinary shares (Shares) in the capital of the plaintiff (Shareholders) for the purposes of considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without amendment) to a scheme of arrangement (Scheme) proposed to be made between the plaintiff and the Shareholders who are Scheme Shareholders (as that term is defined in the scheme booklet (Scheme Booklet), a copy of which is annexure “JLS-6” to third affidavit of Janelle Louise Sputore sworn 10 March 2025 (Sputore Affidavit),being the scheme substantially in the form set out in Attachment D of the Scheme Booklet;
(b)the Scheme Meeting be held as a hybrid meeting at 2.00pm (AWST) on 16 April 2025:
(i)with the physical venue of the Scheme Meeting at the Melbourne Hotel, 33 Milligan St, Perth 6000 WA; and
(ii)via an online platform that allows for remote participation, to be accessed substantially in accordance with the instructions set out in the notice of Scheme Meeting (at Attachment A of the Scheme Booklet) (Notice of Scheme…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read De Grey Mining Ltd, in the matter of De Grey Mining Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FCA 246
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff had satisfied the statutory preconditions for the Court to exercise its discretion to convene the meeting and approve the despatch of the scheme booklet, and if so, whether it was appropriate to exercise that discretion. The preconditions include the plaintiff being a Part 5.1 body, the proposed scheme being an arrangement between the plaintiff and its members, the plaintiff having discharged its duty of bringing to the Court's attention all matters relevant to the exercise of the Court's discretion, and the scheme being fit for consideration. The court found that De Grey had satisfied all the preconditions and exercised its discretion to grant the orders sought.
The court held that De Grey was a Part 5.1 body and the proposed scheme was an arrangement. ASIC had been notified of the hearing and had indicated it did not wish to appear and make submissions, which the court accepted as ASIC having discharged its obligation to assist the Court. The plaintiff had discharged its duty of bringing to the Court's attention all relevant matters, and the scheme was fit for consideration as there were no issues of merit or fairness that would unquestionably lead to a refusal to approve the scheme if unopposed at the second court hearing.
The court made orders convening a hybrid meeting of De Grey's members to consider the proposed scheme, approving the despatch of a scheme booklet to the members, and setting out the arrangements for convening, holding and conducting the meeting and despatching the scheme booklet to members. The meeting was ordered to be held on 16 April 2025 via an online platform and in person at the Melbourne Hotel in Perth, Western Australia. The orders were made forthwith and the proceeding was adjourned to 10.15am on 22 April 2025.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Pursuant to s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth):
(a) the plaintiff convene and hold a meeting (Scheme Meeting) of the holders of fully paid ordinary shares (Shares) in the capital of the plaintiff (Shareholders) for the purposes of considering and, if thought fit, agreeing (with or without amendment) to a scheme of arrangement (Scheme) proposed to be made between the plaintiff and the Shareholders who are Scheme Shareholders (as that term is defined in the scheme booklet (Scheme Booklet), a copy of which is annexure “JLS-6” to third affidavit of Janelle Louise Sputore sworn 10 March 2025 (Sputore Affidavit),being the scheme substantially in the form set out in Attachment D of the Scheme Booklet;
(b) the Scheme Meeting be held as a hybrid meeting at 2.00pm (AWST) on 16 April 2025:
(i) with the physical venue of the Scheme Meeting at the Melbourne Hotel, 33 Milligan St, Perth 6000 WA; and
(ii) via an online platform that allows for remote participation, to be accessed substantially in accordance with the instructions set out in the notice of Scheme Meeting (at Attachment A of the Scheme Booklet) (Notice of Scheme Meeting); and
(c) the Scheme Booklet, which contains the explanatory statement required by s 412(1)(a) of the Act, be approved for distribution to Shareholders substantially in the form of annexure “JLS-6” to the Sputore Affidavit, subject to:
(i) correction of any minor typographical or grammatical errors and final typesetting, formatting and page numbering;
(ii) any minor amendments requested or approved by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission for registration under s 412(6) of the Act;
(iii) the correction or update of relevant dates or market price references and consequential amendments; and
(iv) effecting any other amendments approved by the Court.
2. Subject to these orders and pursuant to s 1319 of the Act, the Scheme Meeting be:
(a) convened, held and conducted in accordance with the provisions of Pt 2G.2 of the Act that apply to members of a company and the provisions of the plaintiff’s constitution that apply to meetings of members that are not inconsistent with Pt 2G.2 of the Act;
(b) convened using the Notice of Scheme Meeting substantially in the form contained in Attachment A of the Scheme Booklet (with any amendments contemplated by paragraph 1(c) above);
(c) held and conducted pursuant to the arrangements for attending, participating and voting described in the Notice of Scheme Meeting and in accordance with the provisions of Pt 2G.2 of the Act; and
(d) convened, held and conducted as if r 2.15 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) does not apply.
3. Pursuant to s 1319 of the Act:
(a) Simon Lill, or failing him, Peter Hood AO, be the chairperson of the Scheme Meeting (Chairperson);
(b) the Chairperson have power to adjourn or postpone the Scheme Meeting in the Chairperson’s absolute discretion to such time, date and place that the Chairperson thinks appropriate (including as to whether the adjourned meeting should be held electronically);
(c) at the Scheme Meeting, two Shareholders entitled to vote, present in person or by proxy or by an attorney under power or by a corporate representative (if applicable), shall constitute a quorum;
(d) at the Scheme Meeting, each Shareholder, present and entitled to vote, be entitled to one vote for each fully paid share in the capital of the plaintiff that the Shareholder is registered as holding at 7.00pm (AEST) on 14 April 2025; and
(e) at the Scheme Meeting, voting on the resolution to approve the Scheme be conducted by way of a poll (declared by the Chairperson).
4. Subject to registration of the Scheme Booklet with ASIC pursuant to s 412(6) of the Act, on or before 17 March 2025 (or such other day as directed by the Court), the plaintiff dispatch to each Shareholder who appears on the plaintiff’s register of members (Register) as at 7.00pm (AEDT) on 10 March 2025 (Register Time):
(a) in the case of each Shareholder who has elected to receive shareholder communications from the plaintiff electronically (Email Shareholders), an email to the Shareholder’s nominated email address substantially in the form of the document at attachment “SLP-12” of the affidavit of Sarah Lorne Pledger affirmed 5 March 2025 (Pledger Affidavit) containing:
(i) hyperlinks to websites where those Shareholders can:
A. access and download the Scheme Booklet;
B. lodge a proxy appointment for the Scheme Meeting online; and
C. in the case of Email Shareholders who the plaintiff determines, based on the information in the Register at 5.00pm (AWST) on 7 March 2025 (Last Practicable Date), are likely to be Small Shareholders (as defined in the Scheme), access, download and lodge an opt-in notice substantially in the form of the document at attachment “SLP-2” of the Pledger Affidavit (Opt-in Notice); and
(ii) a phone number and email address by which those Email Shareholders may request that they be sent printed hard copies of the Scheme Booklet;
(b) in the case of each Shareholder who has elected to receive shareholder communications from the plaintiff by post (Postal Shareholders), using the methods of service set out in paragraph 5 below, hard copies of the following documents:
(i) the Scheme Booklet;
(ii) a personalised proxy form substantially in the form of the document at attachment “SLP-11” of the Pledger Affidavit (Proxy Form);
(iii) in the case of Postal Shareholders who the plaintiff determines, based on the information in the Register at the Last Practicable Date, are Small Shareholders, a personalised copy of the Opt-in Notice; and
(iv) either:
A. in the case of each Postal Shareholder who has a registered physical address in Australia, a priority pre-paid post envelope addressed to Automic Pty Ltd (Automic); or
B. in the case of each Postal Shareholder who has a registered physical address outside Australia, an unpaid airmail or air courier envelope addressed to Automic;
(c) in the case of each Shareholder who is not an Email Shareholder or Postal Shareholder (Other Shareholders), using the methods of service set out in paragraph 5 below, hard copies of the following documents:
(i) a letter substantially in the form at attachment “SLP-13” of the Pledger Affidavit containing:
A. the address of a website which enables those Shareholders to access and download the Scheme Booklet; and
B. a phone number and email address by which Shareholders who did not receive a hard copy Scheme Booklet may request to be sent a hard copy;
(ii) a personalised Proxy Form;
(iii) in the case of Other Shareholders who the plaintiff determines, based on the information in the Register at the Last Practicable Date, are Small Shareholders, a hard copy Opt-in Notice; and
(iv) either:
A. in the case of each Other Shareholder who has a registered address in Australia, a priority pre-paid post envelope addressed to Automic; or
B. in the case of each Postal Shareholder who has a registered physical address outside Australia, an unpaid airmail or air courier envelope addressed to Automic.
5. The plaintiff shall dispatch the documents identified in paragraphs 4(b) and 4(c) above:
(a) to each Shareholder who has a registered address in Australia, by pre-paid ordinary post to their registered address as recorded at the Register Time; and
(b) to each other Shareholder who has a registered address outside Australia, by prepaid international airmail to their registered address as recorded at the Register Time.
6. If it comes to the attention of the plaintiff that any email dispatched in accordance with paragraph 4(a) above results in the return of a receipt or notice that the email was undelivered, then the plaintiff shall dispatch to that Shareholder within a reasonable time thereafter the documents in accordance with paragraph 4(c) above using the methods of service set out in paragraph 5 above.
7. The plaintiff is to cause a hard copy of the Scheme Booklet to be provided to any Shareholder if requested by a Shareholder before the date of the Scheme Meeting.
8. Dispatch in accordance with paragraphs 4 to 5 above be taken to be sufficient notice of the Scheme Meeting.
9. The plaintiff is not obliged to send documents in relation to the Scheme to any person who becomes a Shareholder after the Register Time.
10. Evidence of the dispatch of the Scheme Booklet in accordance with these paragraphs may be given by statement on oath or affirmation on information and belief.
11. The time by which Shareholders must return their Proxy Form (or lodge an electronic proxy appointment) in respect of the Scheme Meeting be 2.00pm (AWST) on 14 April 2025.
12. Pursuant to r 3.3(2) of the Corporations Rules, notwithstanding s 249Y(3) of the Act, the appointment of a proxy in respect of the Scheme Meeting shall not be revoked or suspended by the appointing Shareholder (Appointor) attending and taking part in the relevant Scheme Meeting, but if the Appointer votes on a resolution at the Scheme Meeting, any vote(s) cast by the proxy must not be counted towards the relevant poll.
13. The proceeding be adjourned to 10.15am (AWST) on 22 April 2025.
14. The plaintiff give notice of the hearing of any application pursuant to s 411(4) and, if necessary, s 411(6) of the Act for orders approving the Scheme by publishing an announcement via the Australian Securities Exchange by 10 April 2025, substantially in the form annexed to these orders and marked “Annexure A”, and the plaintiff be otherwise relieved from compliance with r 3.4 of the Corporations Rules.
15. Pursuant to r 1.3 of the Corporations Rules compliance with r 2.4(1) be dispensed with.
16. The plaintiff lodge an office copy of these orders with ASIC as soon as practicable after they are made.
17. The plaintiff has liberty to apply upon giving 24 hours’ notice to ASIC.
18. These orders be entered forthwith.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court should order the convening of a meeting of De Grey’s members to consider the proposed scheme.
2. Whether the Court should approve the despatch of the scheme booklet to De Grey’s members.
Held
1. The Court ordered the convening of a meeting of De Grey’s members to consider the proposed scheme as requested under s 411(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
2. The Court approved the despatch of the scheme booklet to De Grey’s members as requested under s 411(4)(b) and s 411(6) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Bearing in mind that in most circumstances applications to convene meetings and to approve arrangements are heard in the absence of a contradictor, the role and function that ASIC performs under s 411 and s 1330 of the Act is quite important for the proper performance of the Court’s supervisory function. ASIC has an obligation to assist the Court by presenting arguments if it deems that course to be necessary or desirable and its approach to that obligation is explained in RG 60.4. Having regard to these matters, where ASIC has provided its usual letter to a scheme proponent before the first court hearing and has indicated that it does not wish to appear and make submissions at that hearing, the Court is entitled to infer that ASIC has discharged its obligation to assist the Court. Similarly, the absence of a contradictor sharpens the duty of the plaintiff and imposes a heavy responsibility on it to bring to the Court’s attention all matters that could be considered relevant to the exercise of the Court’s discretion. As a consequence, the Court is entitled, in the exercise of its supervisory function, to be confident that all relevant and material matters are before the Court.Conclusions as to pre-conditions, procedural requirements and discretionary considerations On the originating process and facts deposed and documents exhibited to the affidavits the plaintiff filed in support of its application, I was satisfied of the following matters.(1)The plaintiff is a Part 5.1 body and the proposed scheme is an ‘arrangement’ between the plaintiff and its members. As explained later in these reasons, while certain matters are disclosed that raise potential issues relating to classes of members, there is no reason to require separate meetings of separate classes of scheme members for the proposed scheme.(2)Notice was given to ASIC within 14 days of the hearing and it has had a reasonable opportunity to examine the terms of the proposed scheme and draft explanatory statement and make submissions to the Court on them.(3)ASIC provided its usual letter to the scheme proponent indicating that it does not wish to appear and make submissions at the first court hearing. Thus, ASIC has discharged its obligation to assist the Court by reviewing the scheme documents, reviewing the nature and function of the scheme, representing the interests of investors and creditors and ensuring that all matters that are relevant to the Court’s decision are properly brought to its attention before it makes orders convening a scheme meeting.(4)The application to convene the scheme meeting was made in a summary way and all procedural requirements have been met or, to the extent that they have not been met, it is appropriate to modify or dispense with them in the manner recorded in the orders. In particular, the required company search of the plaintiff has been undertaken and the required matters in respect of the proposed chair and alternative chair for the scheme meeting have been proven.(5)Having considered and evaluated the terms of the scheme implementation deed, the proposed scheme, the deed poll, and the plaintiff’s constitution, the proposed scheme is bona fide and properly proposed.(6)Having considered the draft scheme booklet (including the draft explanatory statement), the scheme booklet provides adequate disclosures in sufficiently clear language of the nature of the proposed scheme, including the prescribed information and, on the evidence, that appropriate steps have been taken to ensure that the information to be provided to scheme members is accurate such that scheme members will be properly informed before the scheme meeting.(7)Having regard to the matters referred to below under the headings ‘Specific matters raised by the plaintiff’ and ‘Other matters’, the plaintiff has discharged its duty and responsibility of bringing to the Court’s attention all matters that could be considered relevant to the exercise of the Court’s discretion and, as such, all relevant material is before the Court.(8)The proposed scheme is fit for consideration in the sense that if the required majorities were achieved at the scheme meeting the Court would be likely to approve the scheme if unopposed at the second court hearing. That is, there is no issue of merit or fairness that would unquestionably lead to a refusal to approve the proposed scheme at the second court hearing.