De Fry v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
17 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
De Fry v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 260
File number:
MLG 646 of 2019
Judgment of:
JUDGE BLAKE
Date of judgment:
27 February 2025
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application to review decision of the delegate where the delegate refused to waive visa condition 8503 – whether delegate was in error by failing to take account of claims and evidence or acting unreasonably, or applying the wrong test as to whether circumstances were ‘compelling’– no error established – application dismissed.
Legislation:
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) Sch 2.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
BETWEEN:
RALPH HERBERT DE FRY
First Applicant
SHERRYL FRANCISCA DE FRY Second Applicant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE BLAKE
DATE OF ORDER:
27 FEBRUARY 2025
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The name of the Respondent be amended to ‘Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs’.
2.The Application filed on 7 March 2019 be dismissed.
3.The Applicants pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding, fixed in the sum of $5,300.
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.
Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
JUDGE BLAKE:
INTRODUCTION
This is an application to review a decision made by a delegate of the Minister (‘delegate’) on 5 February 2019. In her decision, the delegate declined to waive visa condition 8503 in respect of the Visitor (Class FA) (Subclass 600) visas (‘visas’) held by the Applicants (Court Book (‘CB’) 78-80).
For the reasons that follow, I have decided to dismiss the application for review.
BACKGROUND
The Applicants are citizens of Sri Lanka. On 31 May 2017, the Applicants were granted the visas (CB 71).
The visas were subject to schedule 8, clause 8503 of theMigration Regulations 1994 (Cth). That provision…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read De Fry v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:
The applicants, citizens of Sri Lanka, sought a judicial review of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs’ decision to refuse their request to waive a visa condition 8503, which prohibited them from being granted a substantive visa while they remained in Australia. The applicants sought the waiver to allow them to stay in Australia and provide care and assistance to family members. The applicants appeared before the court unrepresented and did not file any amended application or outline of submissions. The Minister relied on his written outline of submissions and filed a Court Book.
The legal issues before the court were whether the delegate was in error by failing to take account of the claims and evidence or acting unreasonably, or applying the wrong test as to whether the circumstances were 'compelling'. The court considered the relevant legislation, including the Migration Act 1958 and the Migration Regulations 1994, and the decision of the delegate. The court noted that the term 'compelling' was not defined in the migration legislation and must be given its ordinary meaning. The court also noted that the circumstances must be sufficiently forceful to lead the decision-maker to make a decision to waive the condition.
The court found that the delegate had not erred in their decision. The court considered the information provided by the applicants and found that while the circumstances were compassionate, they were not compelling enough to warrant a waiver of the visa condition. The court found that the applicants' family members had other options available to them, such as entering into residential care or the applicants returning to Australia to visit them. The court concluded that the applicants had not established any error on the part of the delegate.
The court dismissed the application for review and the applicants' request for a waiver of visa condition 8503 was upheld. The court found that the delegate had not acted unreasonably or applied the wrong test in their decision. The court also noted that the applicants had not filed any amended application or outline of submissions despite being given the opportunity to do so.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
For the reasons that follow, I have decided to dismiss the application for review.BACKGROUND The Applicants are citizens of Sri Lanka. On 31 May 2017, the Applicants were granted the visas (CB 71). The visas were subject to schedule 8, clause 8503 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). That provision relevantly stated that ‘The holder will not, after entering Australia, be entitled to be granted a substantive visa, other than a protection visa, while the holder remains in Australia’. On 4 February 2019, the Applicants requested a waiver of visa condition 8503 as they wished to remain in Australia to provide care and assistance to family members (CB 70). On 5 February 2019, the delegate decided not to waive visa condition 8503 for the Applicants (CB 78-80). The Applicants filed their Application for review in this Court on 7 March 2019 (‘Application’). The Application was accompanied by an affidavit in support from their solicitor. The Applicants appeared before me unrepresented. They did not file any amended application or outline of submissions despite being given the opportunity to do so and relied simply on the Application and the affidavit of their previous solicitor. The Minster relied on his written outline of submissions. The Minister also filed a Court Book. THE DECISION OF THE DELEGATE The decision of the delegate is of reasonably short compass. It is reproduced below:The client’s claims In this decision record, the term ‘client’ refers to the person(s) requesting waiver of visa condition 8503.The clients have requested a waiver of the no further stay condition 8503 because they wish to remain in Australia to provide care and assistance to family members.Information and evidence consideredI am a delegated decision maker under subsection 41(2A) of the Migration Act 1958. In reaching my decision, I have considered the following:•relevant legislation contained in the Migration Act and Migration Regulations 1994•information contained in the Department's Procedures Advice Manual 3•documents and information provided by the applicant(s)•relevant information held on Departmental files.Findings Based on the information before me, including the documents and information provided by the client in support of the waiver request, I find that the circumstances for waiver of no further stay condition 8503 are not met by the client.Reasons You have made a request for a condition 8503 waiver. I have assessed your request and the reasons for my decision are detailed below. The Minister cannot waive condition 8503 unless the relevant criteria in the Migration Act and the Migration Regulations are satisfied.The circumstances of subregulation 2.05(4) have not been met by the client on the date I made my decision. Subregulation 2.05(4) states that: 2.05(4):For subsection 41(2A) of the Act, the circumstances in which the Minister may waive a condition of a kind described in paragraph 41(2)(a) of the Act are that:(a)since the person was granted the visa that was subject to the condition, compelling and compassionate circumstances have developed:(i) over which the person had no control; and (ii) that resulted in a major change to the person’s circumstances; and(b)if the Minister has previously refused to waive the condition, the Minister is satisfied that the circumstances mentioned in paragraph (a) are substantially different from those considered previously; and (c) if the person asks the Minister to waive the condition, the request is in writing.I have addressed the requirements, as relevant to the case, in particular, addressing those that have not been met below.The circumstances must be compelling and compassionate ‘Compassionate’ circumstances (which are also not defined in the legislation and must be given their ordinary meaning) involve the concept of ‘compassion’ which is a feeling of sorrow or pity for the sufferings or misfortune of others, or sympathy. Compassionate circumstances give rise to these feelings. I acknowledge that the clients’ desire to remain in Australia and provide care to Mr De Fry’s sister and assistance to his niece is a compassionate circumstance.I must also consider whether the circumstances are compelling. The term ‘compelling’ is not defined in the migration legislation. It must be given its ordinary meaning. ‘Compelling’ means forceful or driving, especially to a course of action. The circumstances must be sufficiently forceful that they lead the decision-maker to make a decision to waive the condition.The request contains a statement which provides detailed information in regard to the clients’ current circumstances. It is stated that Mr De Fry’s sister, Mrs Vivekananda Rajah, has had a substantial increase in the need for care as a result of her medical conditions. I acknowledge medical documentation provided which confirms that Ms Rajah suffers from multiple medical conditions including cognitive impairment, depression and a risk of falls. Medical documentation provided further states that Ms Rajah requires 24 hour supervision to ensure her safety. Up until now it is stated that Ms Rajah’s daughter, Ms Ingrid Rudolph, was caring for her but Ms Rudolph is no longer able to do so as a result of having suffered two strokes, her ongoing work commitments and Ms Rajah’s increase in care requirements. It is stated that Ms Rudolph still maintains her full time employment, and that whilst strokes have not completely prevented her from working or providing some sort of care to her mother, it has increased her reliance of others, including the clients, to assist in looking after Ms Rajah. As a result of these circumstances the clients are seeking a waiver to allow them to remain in Australia to provide ongoing care to Ms Rajah, as her doctors are of the opinion that the condition of her health will not improve in the future.Based on the information provided I accept that Ms Rajah requires a significant level of care. It is stated that Ms Rudolph and her husband are employed full time and therefore unable to stay home and look after Ms Rajah. It is further stated that they are unable to afford to place Ms Rajah in a nursing home, nor does anyone, including Ms Rajah want to proceed with the residential care option. In addition to this, it is stated that Ms Rajah is strongly refusing to go into an aged care facility. I have considered this information and I acknowledge that it is not the preference for Ms Rajah or her family to enter into residential care. However, I have considered that this is nonetheless an option which is available to the family. I acknowledge claims that this would isolate Ms Rajah from her family who she is used to seeing every day. However, whilst I acknowledge that time spent with family may be reduced, I have considered that it is open to Ms Rajah’s daughter and son-in-law in Australia to consider maintaining a substantial level of contact with Ms Rajah in the event that her residence may change. I have further considered that the clients also have the option to consider returning to Australia to visit Ms Rajah until such time that they consider any permanent visa pathways which may be available to them. Having considered the circumstances entirely I am not satisfied the circumstances are sufficiently forceful to waive the condition.In considering all the information the client has provided to support the request to waive condition 8503, I have assessed these claims against the criteria in Regulation 2.05(4). I am not satisfied the circumstances are circumstances that meet all the criteria set out in the Regulations and therefore the condition 8503 has not been waived under sub-section 41(2A) of the Act.Decision As I find that the circumstances in subregulation 2.05(4) and 2.05(4AA) are not met by the client, I therefore refuse the request by the client for a waiver of condition 8503. THE APPLICATION
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Applicants appeared before me unrepresented. They did not file any amended application or outline of submissions despite being given the opportunity to do so and relied simply on the Application and the affidavit of their previous solicitor. The Minster relied on his written outline of submissions. The Minister also filed a Court Book. THE DECISION OF THE DELEGATE The decision of the delegate is of reasonably short compass. It is reproduced below:The client’s claims In this decision record, the term ‘client’ refers to the person(s) requesting waiver of visa condition 8503.The clients have requested a waiver of the no further stay condition 8503 because they wish to remain in Australia to provide care and assistance to family members.Information and evidence consideredI am a delegated decision maker under subsection 41(2A) of the Migration Act 1958. In reaching my decision, I have considered the following:•relevant legislation contained in the Migration Act and Migration Regulations 1994•information contained in the Department's Procedures Advice Manual 3•documents and information provided by the applicant(s)•relevant information held on Departmental files.Findings Based on the information before me, including the documents and information provided by the client in support of the waiver request, I find that the circumstances for waiver of no further stay condition 8503 are not met by the client.Reasons You have made a request for a condition 8503 waiver. I have assessed your request and the reasons for my decision are detailed below. The Minister cannot waive condition 8503 unless the relevant criteria in the Migration Act and the Migration Regulations are satisfied.The circumstances of subregulation 2.05(4) have not been met by the client on the date I made my decision. Subregulation 2.05(4) states that: 2.05(4):For subsection 41(2A) of the Act, the circumstances in which the Minister may waive a condition of a kind described in paragraph 41(2)(a) of the Act are that:(a)since the person was granted the visa that was subject to the condition, compelling and compassionate circumstances have developed:(i) over which the person had no control; and (ii) that resulted in a major change to the person’s circumstances; and(b)if the Minister has previously refused to waive the condition, the Minister is satisfied that the circumstances mentioned in paragraph (a) are substantially different from those considered previously; and (c) if the person asks the Minister to waive the condition, the request is in writing.I have addressed the requirements, as relevant to the case, in particular, addressing those that have not been met below.The circumstances must be compelling and compassionate ‘Compassionate’ circumstances (which are also not defined in the legislation and must be given their ordinary meaning) involve the concept of ‘compassion’ which is a feeling of sorrow or pity for the sufferings or misfortune of others, or sympathy. Compassionate circumstances give rise to these feelings. I acknowledge that the clients’ desire to remain in Australia and provide care to Mr De Fry’s sister and assistance to his niece is a compassionate circumstance.I must also consider whether the circumstances are compelling. The term ‘compelling’ is not defined in the migration legislation. It must be given its ordinary meaning. ‘Compelling’ means forceful or driving, especially to a course of action. The circumstances must be sufficiently forceful that they lead the decision-maker to make a decision to waive the condition.The request contains a statement which provides detailed information in regard to the clients’ current circumstances. It is stated that Mr De Fry’s sister, Mrs Vivekananda Rajah, has had a substantial increase in the need for care as a result of her medical conditions. I acknowledge medical documentation provided which confirms that Ms Rajah suffers from multiple medical conditions including cognitive impairment, depression and a risk of falls. Medical documentation provided further states that Ms Rajah requires 24 hour supervision to ensure her safety. Up until now it is stated that Ms Rajah’s daughter, Ms Ingrid Rudolph, was caring for her but Ms Rudolph is no longer able to do so as a result of having suffered two strokes, her ongoing work commitments and Ms Rajah’s increase in care requirements. It is stated that Ms Rudolph still maintains her full time employment, and that whilst strokes have not completely prevented her from working or providing some sort of care to her mother, it has increased her reliance of others, including the clients, to assist in looking after Ms Rajah. As a result of these circumstances the clients are seeking a waiver to allow them to remain in Australia to provide ongoing care to Ms Rajah, as her doctors are of the opinion that the condition of her health will not improve in the future.Based on the information provided I accept that Ms Rajah requires a significant level of care. It is stated that Ms Rudolph and her husband are employed full time and therefore unable to stay home and look after Ms Rajah. It is further stated that they are unable to afford to place Ms Rajah in a nursing home, nor does anyone, including Ms Rajah want to proceed with the residential care option. In addition to this, it is stated that Ms Rajah is strongly refusing to go into an aged care facility. I have considered this information and I acknowledge that it is not the preference for Ms Rajah or her family to enter into residential care. However, I have considered that this is nonetheless an option which is available to the family. I acknowledge claims that this would isolate Ms Rajah from her family who she is used to seeing every day. However, whilst I acknowledge that time spent with family may be reduced, I have considered that it is open to Ms Rajah’s daughter and son-in-law in Australia to consider maintaining a substantial level of contact with Ms Rajah in the event that her residence may change. I have further considered that the clients also have the option to consider returning to Australia to visit Ms Rajah until such time that they consider any permanent visa pathways which may be available to them. Having considered the circumstances entirely I am not satisfied the circumstances are sufficiently forceful to waive the condition.In considering all the information the client has provided to support the request to waive condition 8503, I have assessed these claims against the criteria in Regulation 2.05(4). I am not satisfied the circumstances are circumstances that meet all the criteria set out in the Regulations and therefore the condition 8503 has not been waived under sub-section 41(2A) of the Act.Decision As I find that the circumstances in subregulation 2.05(4) and 2.05(4AA) are not met by the client, I therefore refuse the request by the client for a waiver of condition 8503. THE APPLICATION