Dawson v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dawson v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2021] FCA 1636   

File number: SAD 154 of 2019
Judgment of: WHITE J
Date of judgment: 13 December 2021
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – approval of settlement under s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – where the settlement negotiated is fair and reasonable and in the interests of group members as a whole – settlement approved.
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 33C, 33V, 37AF

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) of ss 9(1), 9(1A), 10

Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) s 606

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89

Camilleri v The Trust Co (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468

Dawson v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1354

Division: General Division
Registry: South Australia
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 53
Date of hearing: 13 December 2021
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Collett with Mr T Guthrie
Solicitor for the Applicants: Johnston Withers Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms K Eastman SC with Ms K Stewart
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

SAD 154 of 2019
BETWEEN:

BASIL JOSHUA DAWSON

First Applicant

KAMIS LEROY DAWSON

Second Applicant

KRESNA CAMERON (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

WHITE J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 DECEMBER 2021

BY CONSENT THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Confidentially

1.The Applicants file, but not serve, the affidavit of Kirsty Jane Bennett affirmed 10 December 2021, and any requirement for service of that affidavit is dispensed with.

2.Pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), and on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the opinion of counsel for the Applicants, which is confidential Annexure KJB1 to the affidavit of Kirsty Jane Bennett made 10 December 2021, remain confidential and not be accessed by any person except by direction of a Judge, with a view to it being treated in the same way as would be the case if it was placed in a sealed envelope marked "Not to be Opened Except by Direction of a Judge".

Extension of the Opt-Out

3.Order 5 of the Orders dated 29 October 2021, fixing the Opt-Out date pursuant to s 33J of the Act as 5 pm (ACDT) on 9 December 2021, be extended for two Group Members, Delissa West and Nathaniel Nelson, to 4.30 pm (ACDT) on 24 December 2021.

4.The Applicants use their best endeavours to make contact with Delissa West and Nathaniel Nelson by telephone to bring to their attention the content of Order 3 and that they may contact Damian McLean, in his capacity as Head Community Advisor, if they need any assistance with the Commencement/Opt-Out/Settlement Notice, including with exercising their right to opt out of the proceeding.

Settlement Approval

5.Pursuant to s 33V and s 33ZF of the Act, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dawson v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1636
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dawson v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) involved the Ngaanyatjarra Community in the Shire of Ngaanyatjarraku, Western Australia, alleging racial discrimination by the Commonwealth in the implementation of the Community Development Program (CDP). The applicants argued that the mutual obligation requirements for receiving income support payments under the Social Security Act 1991 were discriminatory due to the remoteness and socio-economic status of the community. The central legal issue was whether the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable in the interests of the group members as a whole under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976.

The court found that the settlement was forward-looking, aiming to address the underlying issues with the CDP rather than merely compensating for past wrongs. It highlighted that the settlement acknowledged the unique needs of job seekers in remote communities and empowered group members to participate in the design of policies affecting their lives. The court was satisfied that the settlement was fair and reasonable and in the best interests of the group members, considering the non-monetary benefits it offered. The court approved the settlement, emphasising its significance in providing sustained improved outcomes for the group members and the broader community.

The court's decision underscores the importance of considering the long-term interests and specific circumstances of Indigenous communities in resolving racial discrimination claims. The settlement's focus on empowering community members to shape their future aligns with human rights principles and addresses systemic issues within the CDP.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the reasons published on 3 November 2021 for the approval of the forms of notices to be given to the group members and concerning the manner of their provision (Dawson v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1354), I described the background to the proceedings briefly. It is convenient to repeat in these reasons some of what I then said, together with some further details.Background The first three applicants commenced the action on 22 July 2019. The fourth and fifth applicants were joined as applicants with effect from 29 April 2020. The applicants and the group members are members of the Ngaanyatjarra Community in the Shire of Ngaanyatjarraku in the Central Reserves Area of Western Australia. The eastern boundary of the Shire abuts the western boundaries of South Australia and the Northern Territory. There are 10 communities in the Shire of which Warburton is the largest. It is a remote community, being located 1,542 kms northeast of Perth, 750 kms northeast of Kalgoorlie, 560 kms northeast of Laverton and 1,050 kms southwest of Alice Springs. Approximately 40% of the group members reside in Warburton. The Ngaanyatjarra Council (Aboriginal Council) (the Ngaanyatjarra Council) was incorporated in March 1981. It represents the interests of around 2,000 Ngaanyatjarra, Pintupi and Pitjantjatjara Traditional Owners (Yarnangu) who reside in the Ngaanyatjarra Communities. It is directly involved in a variety of initiatives relating to health, education, training, employment, housing, law and justice matters, finance, land management and a variety of commercial enterprises. The Ngaanyatjarra Council is, also, contracted by the Commonwealth to deliver job services to jobseekers in the Shire on income support payments under the Community Development Program (CDP). The Commonwealth admits that, according to the 2016 Census, the Shire had a population of 1,606 persons of whom 86% were Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander. The majority of the residents are Ngaanyatjarra People (60.7% speak Ngaanyatjarra) but there are others from the Western Desert Cultural Bloc. The applicants’ Further Amended Statement of Claim (the FASC) alleges that the per capita income of residents in the Shire is the lowest on mainland Australia. The Commonwealth does not admit that allegation but does plead matters indicating that the Shire is an area of socio‑economic disadvantage. In particular, it pleads that, in the 2016 Australian Bureau of Statistics Socio‑economic Indexes for Local Government Areas in Australia, the Shire ranked in:(i)the second percentile in the Index of Relative Socio‑economic Disadvantage;(ii)the third percentile in the Index of Relative Socio-economic Advantage and Disadvantage;(iii)the fourth percentile in the Index of Economic Resources; and(iv)the ninth percentile in the Index of Education and Occupation. In the proceedings, the applicants allege that the Commonwealth discriminated against them and group members, in contravention of ss 9(1), 9(1A) and 10 of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) (the RD Act), by requiring them to participate in the CDP in order to receive income support payments under the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) (the SS Act). The discrimination alleged is said to be a consequence of the “mutual obligation requirements” imposed on NewStart Allowance recipients. Persons who do not comply with those requirements suffer penalties in the form of reduced payments of social security or the withdrawal of payments altogether. The applicants’ claim in substance is that the mutual obligation requirements which oblige social security recipients to engage in minimum periods of work per day, per week and per year and to make a minimum number of applications for work and which were applied in their cases, were, in the period between 1 July 2015 and 23 May 2019, discriminatory. This was so because they were more onerous than those imposed on other recipients of NewStart Allowances having regard, in particular, to the remoteness of their communities, their low levels of education and literacy, and other aspects of their socio‑economic status which made applications for, the obtaining of, and participation in, paid employment more difficult.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The central question for the Court’s consideration is whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable in the interests of group members considered as a whole. In Camilleri v The Trust Co (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468 at [5], Moshinsky J helpfully summarised many of the applicable principles. It is not necessary to repeat them in these reasons. I will address later particular matters bearing upon the application of the principles which are pertinent in this case. Evidence For the purposes of considering the application for approval, I have had regard to the eight affidavits of the applicants’ solicitor, Ms Bennett, affirmed 7 and 27 October 2021, 18 and 19 November 2021 and 9, 10 and 13 December 2021, two in the last case, and the affidavit of Mr Barker, a senior executive lawyer in the Australian Government Solicitor’s Office, affirmed 9 December 2021. Mr Barker has had the conduct of the proceedings on behalf of the Commonwealth. I will make an order pursuant to s 37AF of the FCA Act in respect of the opinion of counsel which is Annexure KJB‑11 to the affidavit of Ms Bennett made on 10 December 2021. In addition to the affidavits, I have also been assisted by the helpful submissions from both the applicant and the Commonwealth, as well as by their oral submissions today. Further background By way of further background, I add the following. Following the amendment of the proceedings pursuant to the Court’s orders of 29 October 2021, the claim group has comprised persons satisfying the following criteria:(a)resident of the Shire of Ngaanyatjarraku; and(b)between the ages of 22 and 54 (inclusive); and(c)participating in the Community Development Program; and(d)…(e)a party to a Job Plan that contained a term pursuant to s 606(1) of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) as it applied for the period 1 July 2015 to 23 March 2019 (which was approved by the Secretary under s 606(2) of that Act), to the effect that the person:(i)during the period 1 July 2015 to 1 March 2019, complete in any week the number of hours in Work for the Dole and/or another approved activity specified below:A.25 hours (if the person was aged 22 to 29 years), orB.any number of hours from 0 to 25 hours (if the person was aged 30 to 49 years), orC.any number of hours from 0 to 25 hours (if the person was aged 50 to 54 years), or(ii)during the period 1 March 2019 to 23 May 2019, complete in any week 20 hours in Work for the Dole and/or another approved activity; and(f)…(g)…(h)in receipt of activity tested income support known as NewStart Allowance. The description of persons in subpara (e) of the definition can be paraphrased as those who are party to a job plan which contained a term pursuant to s 606(1) of the SS Act (which was approved by the Secretary pursuant to s 606(2)) to the effect that the person complete a number of hours each week in Work for the Dole or in another approved activity, which (varied according to the person’s age). The terms pursuant to s 606 were known as “Activity Requirements” or as “Mutual Obligation Requirements”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept the following submissions of the applicants’ counsel:[90]This settlement is forward-looking and is premised on achieving a human rights based outcome. It is not concerned with trying to right alleged wrongs of the past with payment of a (relatively) small amount to the group members. That would do nothing to address the underlying problems the Communities (including the group members) have with the CDP and the vision they have for something that better meets the needs of the group members and other Ngaanyatjarra people.[91]The CDP is not delivering on its intended objectives in the Shire of Ngaanyatjarraku for the Ngaanyatjarra people. The Commonwealth has heard what the Applicants, other communities and stakeholders have said about the CDP and, in this settlement, acknowledges that job seekers in remote communities have unique needs and concerns. [92]At a very early stage of this proceeding, the Applicants, the Communities and the Commonwealth chose to put aside their differences on questions of liability and come together to develop the key elements of, and process to further design, something new that addresses the concerns, and meets the economic, social and cultural needs, of the group members and the broader Communities. The critical role that it is intended that the group members and other Ngaanyatjarra people will have in that design process … is a significant part of the settlement itself. The settlement empowers group members and other Ngaanyatjarra people to meaningfully participate in, and directly shape, the development of policy and practices that affect their lives.[93]This, together with the $2 million grant for the benefit of Communities, will provide the best possible chance for sustained improved outcomes for the group members and other Ngaanyatjarra people. For these reasons, a price cannot be placed on this settlement. The value and benefits to group members of the settlement (discussed above) are very real and significant but cannot (or cannot adequately) be measured in monetary terms.(Citations omitted)Summary and conclusion I repeat that this is an unusual Pt IVA action and the settlement proposed is unusual. It takes account of the particular circumstances and nature of the Ngaanyatjarra Community and the consideration of their long term interest. I am comfortably satisfied that the settlement negotiated in the extensive mediation is fair and reasonable and in the interests of group members considered as a whole and, accordingly, I will make the orders sought by the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.