Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd v F Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd v F Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd [2006] FCA 915

DARWALLA MILLING COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 009 698 631) & ORS v F HOFFMANN-LA ROCHE LTD & ORS
VID 359 OF 1999

JESSUP J
18 JULY 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 359 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

DARWALLA MILLING CO. PTY LTD (ACN 009 698 631)
FIRST APPLICANT

LIENERT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 008 293 007)
SECOND APPLICANT

BRISBANE EXPORT CORPORATION PTY LTD
(ACN 010 345 150)
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

F. HOFFMANN-LA ROCHE LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

ROCHE PRODUCTS PTY LTD (ACN 000 132 865)
SECOND RESPONDENT

ROCHE VITAMINS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 000 991 793)
THIRD RESPONDENT

ROCHE VITAMINS ASIA PACIFIC PTY LTD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

AVENTIS SA
SIXTH RESPONDENT

AVENTIS ANIMAL NUTRITION PTY LTD
(ACN 009 718 245)
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

AVENTIS ANIMAL NUTRITION SA
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

AVENTIS ANIMAL NUTRITION ASIA PACIFIC PTY LTD
NINTH RESPONDENT

BASF AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT
TENTH RESPONDENT

BASF AUSTRALIA LTD (ACN 008 437 867)
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

BASF EAST ASIA REGIONAL HEADQUARTERS LIMITED
THIRTEENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

JESSUP J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JULY 2006

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The evidence contained in the confidential exhibits to the affidavit of Kim Elizabeth Parker affirmed on 11 July 2006, being the exhibits set out in the schedule to this order, not be published to any person without the order of the Court.

Schedule:

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-2”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-3”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-4”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-7”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-8”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-9

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-10

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-14”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-24”

·     Confidential Exhibit “KEP-25”

2.The confidential exhibits referred to in order 1 be sealed on the court file and not disclosed to any person without the order of the Court.

3.Pursuant to ss 33X and 33Y of the Federal Court of  Australia 1976, the form and content of the notice of application for approval of proposed settlement to group members set out in the schedule to this order be approved:

Schedule:

NOTICE OF PROPOSED SETTLEMENT

VITAMINS CLASS ACTION

In 1999 a class action was commenced in the Federal Court of Australia regarding an alleged cartel to fix the prices of animal-grade vitamins sold by the Roche, BASF and Rhone-Poulenc/Aventis groups of companies (“the Respondents”). 

The class action alleges that at various times between 1992 and 1999, the Respondents fixed prices for vitamins A, E, B1, B2, B5, C, Betacarotene, Canthaxanthin for animal nutrition or animal health (“the Class Vitamins”) and premix products containing Class Vitamins. 

The companies bringing the class action (“the Applicants”) seek damages and other orders, for themselves and for all persons who fall within the definition of “Group Members” in the class action.  The Group Members are defined to cover all persons who were:

a)     Manufacturers, distributors and suppliers of pre-mixes containing Class Vitamins; or

b)    Manufacturers, distributors and suppliers of stock feeds containing Class Vitamins; or

c)     Producers of livestock including…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd v F Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 915
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd and others v F Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd and others involved a class action proceeding in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiffs, who were seeking damages and other orders on behalf of a group of individuals and entities affected by an alleged cartel to fix the prices of animal-grade vitamins, had reached an agreement to settle the proceeding with the defendants. The court was required to determine whether the proposed settlement and the associated settlement scheme were fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class members. The court also had to decide on the disclosure of certain confidential documents and the form and content of the notice of application for approval of the proposed settlement.

The court found that the proposed settlement was fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class members. It approved the form and content of the notice of application for approval of the proposed settlement, and ordered that certain confidential documents not be disclosed to any person without the order of the Court. The court also approved the settlement scheme which established formulae for valuing the claims of Group Members for losses resulting from higher vitamin prices and lost profits on lost premix sales. The court ordered that the confidential exhibits be sealed on the court file and not disclosed to any person without the order of the Court.

The final orders of the court included the approval of the proposed settlement and the settlement scheme, the prohibition of the disclosure of certain confidential documents without the order of the Court, and the sealing of the confidential exhibits on the court file. The court also ordered that the applicants' solicitors send the notice of proposed settlement to each person who had registered as a group member with the solicitors and publish it in various newspapers. The applicants' and respondents' solicitors were granted leave to inspect the court file and copy any notices of objection filed by Group Members objecting to the settlement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The evidence contained in the confidential exhibits to the affidavit of Kim Elizabeth Parker affirmed on 11 July 2006, being the exhibits set out in the schedule to this order, not be published to any person without the order of the Court.

Schedule:

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-2”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-3”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-4”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-7”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-8”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-9

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-10

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-14”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-24”

· Confidential Exhibit “KEP-25”

2. The confidential exhibits referred to in order 1 be sealed on the court file and not disclosed to any person without the order of the Court.

3. Pursuant to ss 33X and 33Y of the Federal Court of Australia 1976, the form and content of the notice of application for approval of proposed settlement to group members set out in the schedule to this order be approved:

Schedule:

NOTICE OF PROPOSED SETTLEMENT

VITAMINS CLASS ACTION

In 1999 a class action was commenced in the Federal Court of Australia regarding an alleged cartel to fix the prices of animal-grade vitamins sold by the Roche, BASF and Rhone-Poulenc/Aventis groups of companies (“the Respondents”).

The class action alleges that at various times between 1992 and 1999, the Respondents fixed prices for vitamins A, E, B1, B2, B5, C, Betacarotene, Canthaxanthin for animal nutrition or animal health (“the Class Vitamins”) and premix products containing Class Vitamins.

The companies bringing the class action (“the Applicants”) seek damages and other orders, for themselves and for all persons who fall within the definition of “Group Members” in the class action. The Group Members are defined to cover all persons who were:

a) Manufacturers, distributors and suppliers of pre-mixes containing Class Vitamins; or

b) Manufacturers, distributors and suppliers of stock feeds containing Class Vitamins; or

c) Producers of livestock including poultry, pigs sheep and cattle, and dairy farmers, egg producers and aquaculturalists, who purchased stock feeds containing Class Vitamins; or

d) Manufacturers, distributors and suppliers of veterinary and performance enhancing preparations and supplements containing Class Vitamins; or

e) Manufacturers and distributors of pet food containing Class Vitamins;

and who ordinarily resided in or carried on business in Australia, and spent at least $2,000 for Class Vitamins or premixes or other products containing Class Vitamins, in the period 5 March 1992 to 31 December 1999.

If you are, or think you might be, a Group Member then you should read this notice carefully, as it may affect your rights.

PROPOSED SETTLEMENT OF THE CLASS ACTION

The Applicants have reached an agreement with the Respondents to settle the class action.

The proposed settlement requires approval by the Federal Court before it takes effect. If approval is granted then an amount of $30.5M paid by the Respondents will after payment therefrom of the sum of $419 758 to the Applicants and some nominated Group Members by way of reimbursement for their time, effort and out of pocket expenses associated with the class action, be distributed between the Applicants and those Group Members who lodge a claim in accordance with a Settlement Distribution Scheme (“Settlement Scheme”). In broad terms, the Settlement Scheme establishes formulae for valuing the claims of Group Members for losses resulting from higher vitamin prices paid by them for Class Vitamins or products containing Class Vitamins (“overcharge”). The settlement scheme also establishes formulae for valuing the claims of Group Members who are premix manufacturers (excluding the Respondents and their related companies) and who claim lost profits on lost premix sales resulting from the cartel (“lost market share”). Group Members will be required to lodge claims supported by business records as set out in a proof of claim form which can be viewed at the web site below. The Settlement Sum will be distributed in proportion to each Group Member’s claim.

The proposed settlement also requires the Respondents to pay $10.5m for the Applicants’ legal costs. The Applicants’ solicitors, Maurice Blackburn Cashman Pty Ltd (“MBC”) will not charge Group Members any costs in relation to the class action or for participating in the Settlement Scheme. If any Group Member wishes to engage separate solicitors then it will need to make a separate costs arrangement with those solicitors. If a Group Member is dissatisfied with the amount assessed for its claim under the Settlement Scheme then it may request a review by an independent barrister, who will charge the Group Member a fee.

The full terms of the proposed settlement and of the proposed Settlement Scheme may be by obtained by contacting MBC on 1800 810 812, or on their web site at http://www.vitaminssettlement.com.au.

COURT APPROVAL

The Applicants will seek the Court’s approval of the proposed settlement including the proposed Settlement Scheme at a hearing in Melbourne at 10.15 am on 31 August 2006.

If the Court grants approval then the settlement will be binding on every Group Member, and will be the only way for Group Members to recover compensation for the effects of the alleged cartel.

WHAT YOU MUST DO

If you are a Group Member and you are in favour of the settlement then there is nothing you need to do at this time. A further notice will be published in this newspaper if the settlement is approved, and it will tell you what you need to do then. In the meantime you are welcome to contact MBC to register as a Group Member, if you have not already done so. Please do not dispose of any documents you have regarding your purchases or sales of Class Vitamins or products containing Class Vitamins since 1992. Those documents might assist you in lodging a claim.

If you are a Group Member and you wish to object to the settlement or the Settlement Scheme then you must send a written notice to the Federal Court. It must have the heading shown below. It must be received by the Court before 24 August 2006. You will then be sent further information and might be required to attend the hearing on 31 August 2006. If so, you may wish to hire a lawyer to represent you.

If you have any questions, please visit the MBC web site at http://www.vitaminssettlement.com.au or telephone MBC on 1800 810 812, or seek your own legal advice.

NOTICE OF OBJECTION

“Vitamins Class Action”

Federal Court of Australia No.V359 of 1999

1. Addressed to: District Registrar, Federal Court of Australia, Commonwealth Law Courts, 305 William Street, Melbourne 3000.

2. Filed by: (Group Member name, address, telephone/e-mail contact details)

3. Reasons for Objection: (Set out brief written reasons)

4. Signed and dated:

4. On or before 28 July 2006 the solicitors for the applicants cause the Notice of Proposed Settlement to be:

(a) sent by e-mail or by prepaid post to the last known address of each person who has registered as a group member with the solicitors;

(b) published in each of the following newspapers:-

(i) Stock & land (VIC);

(ii) The Land (NSW);

(iii) Stock Journal (SA);

(iv) Farm Weekly (WA);

(v) North Queensland Register;

(vi) Queensland Country Life;

(vii) Adelaide Advertiser;

(viii) Brisbane Courier Mail;

(ix) Canberra Times;

(x) Hobart Mercury;

(xi) Melbourne Herald Sun;

(xii) Northern Territory News;

(xiii) West Australian;

(xiv) Sydney Daily Telegraph;

(xv) The Australian; and

(xvi) The Weekly Times

5. The applicants’ solicitors and the respondents’ solicitors have leave to inspect the court file (other than the confidential exhibits referred to in order 1) and to copy any notices of objection filed by Group Members objecting to the settlement.

6. The further hearing of this Notice of Motion be adjourned to 31 August 2006.

7. Costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JESSUP J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JESSUP J

Full text does not contain this section.