Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd v Cadbury Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Applications 1120614; 1120615; 1120621 in the name of Cadbury Limited and opposition to registration by Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd - proposed suspension of opposition proceedings

Delegate: Deirdre O'Brien
Representation: Opponent
Colin Golvan of senior counsel instructed by Middletons
Applicant
David Shavin of senior counsel, Warwick Rothnie of counsel instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Decision: 2008 ATMO 6
Reg 5.16 direction that opposition proceedings be suspended
No award of costs

Background

  1. Cadbury Ltd (‘Cadbury’) filed trade mark applications 1120614; 1120615; and 1120621 on 23 June 2006 (‘the priority date’). Each of these applications has been accepted for registration and advertised in the Official Journal of Trade Marks. The relevant trade mark details are:

Trade Mark No: 1120614
Owner: Cadbury Limited
Priority Date: 23 June 2006
Goods:            Block chocolate; boxed chocolate (Class 30)
Trade Mark: CO: ENDORSEMENT ONLY; PURPLE
Endorsements:            The trade mark is the colour PURPLE depicted in the representation attached to the application form being approximated by reference PMS 2685C in the Pantone Colour Formula Guide and used in relation to the designated goods.*
Provisions of subsection 41(6) applied.
Trade Mark No: 1120615
Owner: Cadbury Limited
Priority Date: 23 June 2006
Goods:            Block chocolate; boxed chocolate (Class 30)
Trade Mark: CO: ENDORSEMENT ONLY; PURPLE
Endorsements:           The trade mark is the colour PURPLE depicted in the representation attached to the application form (PMS 2685, which has an LAB value of L=33.07, A=34.13, B=-43.07, all such values +/- 10%) used in relation to the designated goods.*
Provisions of subsection 41(6) applied.
Trade Mark No: 1120621
Owner: Cadbury Limited
Priority Date: 23 June 2006
Goods:            Block chocolate; boxed chocolate (Class 30)
Trade Mark: CO: ENDORSEMENT ONLY; PURPLE
Endorsements:           The trade mark consists of the colour purple, depicted in the representation attached to the application form being approximated by reference PMS2685C in the Pantone Colour Formula Guide, used in relation to the nominated goods.*
Provisions of subsection 41(6) applied.
  1. Each of these trade mark applications has, in turn, been opposed by Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd (‘Darrell Lea’). The Notices of Opposition in relation to trade mark applications 1120614; 1120615; and 1120621 (collectively ‘the present oppositions’) were filed on 8 May 2007; 14 August 2007; and 8 May 2007 respectively. The grounds of opposition cited in each Notice of Opposition may be summarized as:

    Øthe opposed trade mark is not capable of distinguishing the applicant’s goods;

    Øthe applicant is not the owner of the opposed trade mark;

    Øthe opposed trade mark is substantially identical with or deceptively similar to registered trade mark 771390 having an earlier priority date in respect of similar goods or closely related services;

    Øthe applicant does not intend to use, or authorise the use of, the opposed trade mark in relation to the goods specified in the application;

    Øthe registration of the Trade Marks would prejudice the opponent and/or its licensees in the conduct of its and/or their business;

    Øthe…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd v Cadbury Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ATMO 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd to suspend trade mark oppositions it had filed against Cadbury Limited's applications. Darrell Lea argued that the outcome of a separate passing off proceeding before the Federal Court would be significant to the determination of factual distinctiveness in the present oppositions, and that suspending the oppositions would avoid the costly and time-consuming process of obtaining evidence that would be required in both proceedings.

The legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether the present trade mark oppositions should be suspended pending the outcome of the Federal Court passing off proceeding, and whether the balance of convenience favoured such a suspension. Cadbury contended that the passing off proceeding was not sufficiently relevant to justify suspension, highlighting that key findings of the primary judge in that proceeding had been overturned on appeal and pointing to differences in the nature of the proceedings, particularly the distinct questions of misrepresentation in passing off versus the function as a badge of origin in trade mark oppositions.

The Hearing Officer considered the submissions of both parties, including supplementary submissions on the relevance of the passing off proceeding. Despite Cadbury's arguments regarding the differences between the proceedings, the Hearing Officer found that the balance of convenience favoured suspension. This decision was influenced by the potential for the Federal Court's findings to impact the determination of factual distinctiveness in the oppositions, and the evidentiary concerns raised by Darrell Lea.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer directed that the trade mark oppositions be suspended until the Federal Court decision in the passing off proceeding was handed down. The oppositions would then be lifted from suspension, unless an appeal was lodged, and proceed through the evidence stages. Each party was directed to bear its own costs in relation to the suspension application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On these bases I am satisfied the balance of convenience favours a suspension of the present oppositions pending the outcome of the passing off proceedings. Decision I direct that the present oppositions be suspended until the Federal Court decision in the passing off proceeding is handed down. If there is no appeal from that decision, the present oppositions shall be lifted from suspension, and further directions given such that the opposition will continue through the evidence stages in accordance with normal practice and procedure. Costs Both parties sought their costs in relation to this matter. Darrell Lea has succeeded in its application, but only in relation to the passing off proceeding. Having noted the late stage at which Cadbury was informed of the relevance of this proceeding, I am not satisfied it is reasonable to award costs against Cadbury. Accordingly, I direct that each party bear its own costs in relation to this matter. Deirdre O'BrienHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings15 January 2008

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Darrell Lea also pursued an argument based upon the Federal Court opposition in relation to application 779336. If the court finds the application may be registered in its original form, it would, in Darrell Lea’s submission, render the present oppositions pointless. It was further submitted that findings of fact made at trial would be of significance to the determination of factual distinctiveness in the present oppositions. Darrell Lea contends that the present oppositions should be suspended pending the outcome of the Federal Court opposition. Additional Considerations: Darrell Lea drew my attention to several additional factors which may assist the determination of this suspension application. Briefly summarised, these are:ØEvidentiary concerns: Physical evidence tendered in relation to both Federal Court proceedings would be required to conduct the oppositions. Obtaining this evidence would be a costly and time-consuming process.ØThird party interests: It was submitted that while no third parties would be adversely affected by a suspension of the present oppositions, several third party manufacturers may benefit from a suspension. These parties would not be required to give evidence in a multitude of proceedings. Cadbury Cadbury’s submissions in relation to the passing off proceedings at the time of the hearing were limited by the failure of Darrell Lea to give Cadbury sufficient notice that it would be relying on those proceedings. I therefore gave both parties the option of making additional written submissions on the relevance of those proceedings. The supplementary submissions of both parties have been considered in this decision, and as such I regard any procedural unfairness upon Cadbury to have been mitigated. The Passing Off Proceeding: In its additional submissions, Cadbury argued that the passing off proceeding was not sufficiently relevant to the present oppositions to justify their suspension. Cadbury noted that the findings of Heerey J, specifically that extracted previously, were overturned by the Full Court on appeal. Of specific relevance is the conclusion of the Full Court that ‘[i]t is not possible … to conclude that there was no miscarriage of justice by reason’ of Heerey J’s exclusion of certain expert evidence at trial.[3][3] Cadbury Schweppes Pty Ltd v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Ltd (2007) 72 IPR 261, 287 (Black CJ, Emmett and Middleton JJ). Cadbury also drew my attention to differences in the nature of each proceeding. The most significant being: Øthe passing off proceeding involves liability only where Darrell Lea’s conduct misrepresented ‘sponsorship, endorsement or association of some sort with the plaintiff [who I note to be a separate, but related company].’ The question in the present oppositions being whether Cadbury has established factual distinctiveness in relation to trade mark applications 1120614, 1120615 and 1120621.ØSurrounding factors, namely whether Cadbury uses the colour purple in isolation as an indicium of trade, are relevant to questions of misrepresentation. The question relevant to section 41(6) of the Trade Marks Act is whether a sign is taken by the public to be functioning as a badge of origin.