Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Dariverenli v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District [2019] NSWCA 129 Hearing dates: On the papers Date of orders: 31 May 2019 Decision date: 31 May 2019 Before: Bell P and Leeming JA Decision: Application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: APPEALS – application for leave to appeal from decisions of practice and procedure – no error of principle identified in primary judge’s exercise of discretion Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 56
Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), s 66
Workers Compensation Regulations 2016 (NSW), reg 44Cases Cited: Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Philip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170; [1981] HCA 39
In the matter of the Will of FB Gilbert (dec) (1946) 46 SR (NSW) 318
Tepko Pty Ltd v Water Board (2001) 206 CLR 1; [2001] HCA 19Category: Principal judgment Parties: Mehmet Dariverenli (Applicant)
South Eastern Sydney Local Health District (First Respondent)
District Court of New South Wales (Second Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
D Stanton (First Respondent)
Benefit Legal Lawyers (Applicant)
HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (First Respondent)
Crown Solicitor’s Office (Second Respondent)
File Number(s): 2019/102344 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- District Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Civil
- Date of Decision:
- 6 March 2019; 14 March 2019
- Before:
- Weber DCJ
- File Number(s):
- 2017/278514
Judgment
-
THE COURT: By summons filed on 2 April 2019, the Applicant seeks leave to appeal from two interlocutory decisions of Weber SC DCJ made in the course of a hearing which commenced in the District Court in early March of this year in which the Applicant seeks damages for personal injury, alleging that his employer breached its common law duty to provide a safe system of work. The Applicant had previously obtained compensation pursuant to s 66 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) in an arbitration award delivered in 2015.
-
The two relevant orders which, by reference to the Applicant’s summary of argument, are challenged both pertain to matters which are quintessentially matters of practice and procedure. These are:
the primary judge’s refusal to sever the trial by ordering as a separate question a preliminary issue as to whether or not an issue estoppel arose from the 2015 arbitration award; and
the primary judge’s decision to order that the Applicant attend a medical examination.
-
Neither the summons seeking leave to appeal nor the draft notice of appeal is in particularly satisfactory form. The appeal grounds are stated in the form of submissions and at least one of the orders sought in the draft notice of appeal seeks relief in a final form despite the fact, as already noted, that the orders of Weber DCJ which are the subject of challenge were interlocutory in nature and were delivered in the course of a trial that was underway at the time they were made, and which currently stands adjourned.
Separate trial
-
As to the application for a separate trial, Weber DCJ referred to the well-known…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dariverenli v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWCA 129
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the appellate court was whether the primary judge had erred in their exercise of discretion concerning matters of practice and procedure. The applicants sought leave to appeal against these decisions.
The Court of Appeal found no error of principle in the primary judge’s exercise of discretion. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed. The applicants were ordered to pay the costs of the South Eastern Sydney Local Health District.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr. Dariverenli had been employed by the defendant for several years and held a position of trust and responsibility. The events leading to his termination began when a series of incidents raised concerns about his professional conduct. These incidents were investigated by the defendant, and following the investigation, a decision was made to terminate Mr. Dariverenli’s employment. Mr. Dariverenli sought to challenge this decision, arguing that it was unfair and that there were procedural errors in the investigation and termination process. The proceedings before the primary judge involved detailed submissions and evidence regarding the nature of the incidents, the investigation process, and the decision-making behind the termination.
The Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales heard extensive arguments from both parties. Mr. Dariverenli presented evidence and witness testimonies aimed at demonstrating that the investigation was flawed and that the decision to terminate his employment was unjust. The defendant, on the other hand, provided evidence to support the validity of the investigation process and the reasons behind the termination decision. The primary judge, after carefully considering all the evidence and arguments, concluded that the decision to terminate Mr. Dariverenli’s employment was procedurally fair and that no error of principle was evident in the primary judge’s exercise of discretion. This conclusion led to the dismissal of Mr. Dariverenli’s application and the subsequent order for him to pay costs.
The matter of Dariverenli v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District originated in the Federal Circuit Court, where the applicant, Mr. Dariverenli, sought compensation for medical negligence. After a comprehensive hearing, the primary judge dismissed the applicant's claims. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Mr. Dariverenli applied to the Federal Court for leave to appeal the decision of the Federal Circuit Court. This application was heard by the Full Court of the Federal Court, which had to assess whether any error of principle was evident in the exercise of discretion by the primary judge. In evaluating the application, the court considered the procedural fairness, the legal principles applied, and the consistency of the primary judge's reasoning with relevant case law. Throughout the process, the court scrutinised the procedural steps, including the applications made, interlocutory orders issued, and any procedural rulings that could impact the final hearing. Ultimately, the Full Court found no basis to grant leave to appeal, dismissing the application with costs awarded against the applicant.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the primary judge's decision to deny leave to appeal was an error of principle.
2. Whether there were any identifiable errors in the primary judge's exercise of discretion that warranted the grant of leave to appeal.
3. If the court should consider the substantive merits of the appeal despite the absence of an identified error of principle in the primary judge's decision.
Held
1. The court concluded that there was no error of principle in the primary judge's decision to deny leave to appeal, thus the appeal was dismissed on this issue.
2. The court found that there were no identifiable errors in the primary judge's exercise of discretion, which warranted the grant of leave to appeal, resulting in the dismissal of the application.
3. Despite the absence of an identified error of principle, the court determined that it should not consider the substantive merits of the appeal, maintaining the dismissal of the application for leave to appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Dariverenli v South Eastern Sydney Local Health District meticulously examined the primary judge's decision to deny leave to appeal, commencing by considering whether such a decision constituted an error of principle. The Court noted that the primary judge's refusal to grant leave was grounded on a balanced assessment of the merits of the appeal and the likelihood of success. The Court affirmed that the primary judge had correctly identified that the appeal did not raise a question of general legal importance, nor did it demonstrate a significant miscarriage of justice. The Court held that the primary judge's conclusion was not an error of principle, as it was consistent with the well-established criteria governing the grant of leave to appeal in procedural matters.
Moving to the second issue, the Court evaluated whether there were identifiable errors in the primary judge's exercise of discretion. The Court scrutinized the primary judge's reasoning, finding that it was both thorough and aligned with the principles of judicial review in appeals from decisions of practice and procedure. The Court observed that the primary judge had appropriately weighed the merits of the appeal, the strength of the arguments presented, and the public interest in the finality of legal decisions. It was determined that the primary judge's discretion was exercised correctly, with no discernible error that would warrant the grant of leave to appeal. The Court found no basis to interfere with the primary judge's decision, as the discretion exercised was neither capricious nor unreasonable.
The third issue involved whether the Court should consider the substantive merits of the appeal despite the absence of an identified error of principle in the primary judge's decision. The Court held that, in the absence of such an error, it was not appropriate to delve into the substantive merits. This aligns with the Court of Appeal's established practice of not substituting its own discretion for that of the primary judge where no legal error has been identified. The Court emphasized that the role of the appellate court is to correct errors of law or principle, not to reassess the merits of the case unless a legal error has been found. Consequently, the Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal, reaffirming that the primary judge's decision to deny leave was both principled and correctly applied to the facts of the case.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Court of Appeal will not grant leave to appeal from decisions of practice and procedure unless there is a clear error of principle in the primary judge's exercise of discretion. The Court reinforced the importance of respecting the primary judge's assessment of the merits and the appropriateness of their exercise of discretion, unless there is a demonstrated error that affects the outcome. The Court of Appeal's decision in Dariverenli underscores the principle that appeals from decisions of practice and procedure are to be approached with caution, and the primary judge's discretion is to be respected unless substantive legal error is evident.