Darcy Blackwell v Naomi O'Donohue

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
[2022] FWC 1633

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.365—General protections

Darcy Blackwell

v

Naomi O’Donohue

(C2021/5321)

COMMISSIONER YILMAZ

MELBOURNE, 24 JUNE 2022

Application to deal with a contravention of the general protections’ provisions involving dismissal – jurisdictional objection – whether employee was dismissed.

Introduction

  1. Ms Darcy Blackwell filed a general protections dispute involving dismissal application under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) with the Fair Work Commission (Commission) on 31 August 2021. Ms Blackwell contends that Ms Naomi O’Donoghue contravened the general protections provisions in relation to her workplace rights and her temporary absence. She further contends that her termination of employment is an adverse action, and she is seeking payment of unpaid wages, superannuation and leave entitlements.

  1. Ms O’Donoghue contends that Ms Blackwell was engaged as a contractor by Enright Cleaning Services to specifically perform COVID 19-related cleaning duties for its principal client Metricon Homes in its training centre and display/design showroom Studio M. Ms O’Donoghue held a contract to deliver cleaning services to Metricon Homes, and she contends that Ms Blackwell agreed to deliver cleaning services according to her hours of availability. Ms O’Donoghue further states that at no time was Ms Blackwell engaged as an employee and the relationship was clear from the outset. Ms O’Donoghue states that the contract between Enright Cleaning Services and Metricon Homes ceased on 10 August 2021 and Ms Blackwell was not dismissed.

  1. Ms Blackwell contends that she was not a subcontractor but an employee and was dismissed when she took a period of absence. She alleges contravention of the following sections of the Fair Work Act 2009:

·   S.340 Protection of workplace rights

·   S.343 Coercion

·   S.344 Undue Influence or pressure

·   S.352 Temporary absence

  1. Conciliation conferences between the parties took place from October 2021 with a staff conciliator and they came to an end in late December 2021. In addition to the general protections application, Ms Blackwell lodged a complaint with the Fair Work Ombudsman.

  1. On referral to chambers, the parties agreed to further conciliation. At the first of two conferences it was obvious that there were jurisdictional matters to be determined. The Respondent contends that the Applicant was not an employee or dismissed, while the Applicant contends that the relationship was of employer and employee, and she was dismissed. In the course of the conferences, the Applicant’s mother contended that the contractor arrangement was a sham.

  1. I conducted two conferences with the parties with the view of resolving all matters in dispute. Ms O’Donoghue was open to resolving the dispute with Ms Blackwell on a commercial basis despite her being out of work and unwell. No resolution was reached, and the jurisdictional matters remained in dispute throughout the conferences and the hearing.

  1. Ms Blackwell was assisted by and often represented by her mother, who I am advised is a lawyer. Mrs Elisabeth Blackwell did not seek leave to appear.

  1. As the matter was not resolved at conciliation, the parties agreed that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Darcy Blackwell v Naomi O'Donohue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FWC 1633
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms Darcy Blackwell brought an application to the Fair Work Commission under s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009, alleging that Ms Naomi O’Donoghue contravened the general protections provisions in relation to her workplace rights and her temporary absence and that she was dismissed. Ms O’Donoghue contends that Ms Blackwell was engaged as a contractor and not dismissed. The Commissioner found that Ms Blackwell was not dismissed and that there was no contravention of the Act. The application was dismissed.

The key legal issue for the Commissioner was whether Ms Blackwell was dismissed within the meaning of s.365 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The Commissioner found that Ms Blackwell was not dismissed because she was not an employee. The Commissioner found that Ms Blackwell was a contractor and not an employee because she was engaged to work according to her availability, performed her work autonomously, exercised control over the activities she performed, and Ms O’Donoghue did not have the right to control Ms Blackwell’s activities except for compliance with cleaning requirements. The Commissioner also found that the arrangement was not a sham because there was no evidence of any purpose other than the agreed arrangement. The Commissioner found that Ms Blackwell was not dismissed because her services were no longer required due to the end of Ms O’Donoghue’s contract with Metricon Homes. The Commissioner found that Ms Blackwell’s refusal to communicate with Ms O’Donoghue led to the loss of her opportunity with Metricon, which was her own doing.