Daniels and Anor and Daniels and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DANIELS & ANOR & DANIELS & ANOR [2014] FCCA 3133

Catchwords:

FAMILY LAW – Children – paternal grandparents seeking to spend time with child – biological father not engaging in proceedings – history of illicit drug use by biological parents – Departmental involvement after child admitted to hospital and found to have ingested benzodiazepines – mother’s case conducted by her attorney without focus on issues in dispute or uncontested evidence – mother opposes all time – clearly established relationship between child and Paternal Grandparents – clear benefit to child of relationship with Grandparents – where mother ceased all time between the child and the Grandparents based on their presentation of the child to hospital being seen as “meddling” even though the child was admitted and pathology testing demonstrated the child had ingested benzodiazepines and the Department of Family and Community Services was advised – where the mother’s reaction “titanic”.

Legislation:

Family Law Act 1975, ss.4, 4AB, 60B, 60CA, 60CC, 60CC(2), 60CC(2)(a), 60CC(4), 60H, 65C, 65DAA(5), 61DA

Browne & Dunn (1893) 6 R 67
Aldridge & Keaton [2009] FamCAFC 229
Churchin & Burton [2013] FamCA 597
Applicants: MS DANIELS & MR DANIELS
Respondents: MR DANIELS & MS CONROY
File Number: PAC 2577 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Harman
Hearing dates: 19-21 November 2014
Date of Last Submission: 21 November 2014
Delivered at: Parramatta
Delivered on: 21 November 2014

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Greenaway
Solicitors for the Applicant: Ian Harper & Co
Advocate for the Respondent: Ms Nagle
Solicitors for the Respondent: O’Connell Solicitors
Counsel for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: Mr Macdiarmid
Solicitors for the Independent Children’s Lawyer: Mark Macdiarmid Family Law Specialist

ORDERS

  1. The Mother have sole parental responsibility for the child X born (omitted) 2010 (‘the child’).

  2. The child live with the Mother.

  3. The child spend time with the Applicants as agreed and failing agreement as follows:

    (a)For each of 22 November 2014 and 13 December 2014 from 10:00am until 7:00pm;

    (b)Once per calendar month commencing January 2015 from 3.00pm (or after school on school days once the child has commenced attending school) on the first Friday of each calendar month until 5pm on the next following Sunday;

    (c)For one week in each of the child’s school holiday periods, commencing with those following Term 1 2015, commencing at 5.00pm on the second last Sunday of each school holiday period and ending at 5.00pm on the last Sunday of such holidays and providing that from the time X commences school in 2016, that time during the Christmas school holidays shall be a two week block from the third last Sunday until the last Sunday.

    (d)From 10:00am on Boxing Day until 4.00pm on 27 December in each year;

    (e)For a period of two (2) hours on the child’s birthday in each year as agreed between the parties, and failing agreement from 5.00pm until 7.00pm on week days in each year that the child is not ordinarily with the Applicants pursuant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daniels and Anor and Daniels and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 3133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Daniels and Anor and Daniels and Anor*, heard by Judge Harman, the paternal grandparents sought orders for time with the child, X. The biological father was not involved in the proceedings. The dispute arose in the context of the child's parents' history of illicit drug use, departmental involvement following the child's hospital admission for benzodiazepine ingestion, and the mother's opposition to any time between the child and the paternal grandparents. The mother's reaction to the grandparents presenting the child to hospital, despite the confirmed ingestion and departmental notification, was described as "titanic."

The court was required to determine whether it was in the child's best interests to spend time with the paternal grandparents, given the established relationship and the clear benefit derived from it. The court also had to consider the mother's opposition to this contact, which was based on her perception of the grandparents' actions as "meddling."

Judge Harman reasoned that there was a clearly established relationship between the child and the paternal grandparents, and that this relationship offered a clear benefit to the child. The court found that the mother's opposition was disproportionate to the circumstances, particularly in light of the confirmed benzodiazepine ingestion and departmental involvement. The court applied principles of family law concerning the best interests of the child, weighing the established positive relationship with the grandparents against the mother's concerns.

The court ordered that the mother have sole parental responsibility and that the child live with her. However, it also made detailed orders for the child to spend time with the paternal grandparents, commencing with specific dates in late 2014 and then establishing a regular schedule of monthly weekend time, holiday time, and time on specific public holidays and birthdays, with provisions for changeovers and communication between the child and the mother. The orders also included provisions for respectful communication between the parties and consequences for contravention.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Mother have sole parental responsibility for the child X born (omitted) 2010 (‘the child’).

2.

The child live with the Mother.

3.

The child spend time with the Applicants as agreed and failing agreement as follows:

(a) For each of 22 November 2014 and 13 December 2014 from 10:00am until 7:00pm;

(b) Once per calendar month commencing January 2015 from 3.00pm (or after school on school days once the child has commenced attending school) on the first Friday of each calendar month until 5pm on the next following Sunday;

(c) For one week in each of the child’s school holiday periods, commencing with those following Term 1 2015, commencing at 5.00pm on the second last Sunday of each school holiday period and ending at 5.00pm on the last Sunday of such holidays and providing that from the time X commences school in 2016, that time during the Christmas school holidays shall be a two week block from the third last Sunday until the last Sunday.

(d) From 10:00am on Boxing Day until 4.00pm on 27 December in each year;

(e) For a period of two (2) hours on the child’s birthday in each year as agreed between the parties, and failing agreement from 5.00pm until 7.00pm on week days in each year that the child is not ordinarily with the Applicants pursuant to these Orders, or if on a weekend for four (4) hours as agreed, and failing agreement from 3.00pm until 7.00pm.

4.

The Applicants time with the child shall be suspended on the following occasions:

(a) For all but one week in each of the child’s school holiday periods, commencing at 5.00pm on the second last Sunday of each school holiday period and ending at 5.00pm on the last Sunday of such holidays;

(b) From 4.00pm on Christmas Eve until 10.00am on Boxing Day in each year;

(c) From 5.00pm on the Saturday immediately preceding Mother’s Day until 5.00pm on Mother’s Day in each year that the child is not ordinarily in the Mother’s care pursuant to these Orders;

(d) From 5.00pm on the day immediately preceding the Mother’s birthday until 5.00pm on the Mother’s birthday in each year that the child is not ordinarily in the Mother’s care pursuant to these Orders;

(e) For a period of two (2) hours on the child’s birthdays in each year as agreed between the parties, and failing agreement from 5.00pm until 7.00pm on week days in each year that the child is not ordinarily with the Mother pursuant to these Orders, or if on a weekend for four (4) hours as agreed, and failing agreement from 3.00pm until 7.00pm.

5.

For the purposes of the above, changeover shall occur as agreed between the parties and failing agreement at the entrance of (omitted) Library, (omitted).

6.

The Applicants and the Mother shall keep the other advised at all times of their residential address, email address and contact telephone number and shall advise the other parties within 48 hours of any change to either their residential address or telephone number.

7.

Each party shall at all times:

(a) Be courteous and respectful to the other parties and their family members;

(b) Not denigrate the other parties or their family members; and

(c) Be restrained from using profane language and making derogatory comments about the other parties or their family members in the presence or hearing of the child, and shall remove the child from the presence of any person who is denigrating the other parties or the other parties’ families in the presence or hearing of the child.

8.

The Applicants shall allow X to telephone and speak with his mother whilst he is in their care should he express a desire to do so and the Applicants shall cause X to telephone his mother between 6:00pm and 6:30pm each Saturday and during school holiday periods and in addition each Wednesday.

9.

Pursuant to S.65DA(2) and S.62B, the particulars of the obligations these Orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these Orders and details of who can assist parties adjust to and comply with an Order are set out in the Fact Sheet attached hereto and these particulars are included in these Orders.

10.

All outstanding Applications and Responses are withdrawn and dismissed and all issues are removed from the list of matters awaiting hearing.

11.

Upon the expiration of the Appeal period and in the event that no appeal is lodged that all exhibits then be returned to the party who tendered same and that all material produced on subpoena be returned to the person or organisation who produced same or securely destroyed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around a dispute concerning the paternal grandparents' application for time with their grandchild, X, who was born in 2010. The biological parents of the child, who have a history of illicit drug use, have not engaged in the proceedings. The case was brought to the attention of the court after X was admitted to a hospital and found to have ingested benzodiazepines. Subsequently, the Department of Family and Community Services became involved. The mother's case was conducted by her attorney, who did not focus on the issues in dispute or the uncontested evidence. The mother opposed all time with the paternal grandparents, despite a clearly established relationship between X and the applicants, and the clear benefits to X of maintaining a relationship with the grandparents. This opposition was based on the mother perceiving the grandparents' presentation of X to the hospital as "meddling," despite the fact that the child was admitted, and pathology tests showed that X had ingested benzodiazepines. The mother's reaction to the situation was described as "titanic."

The grandparents sought time with X, arguing that it would be in the child's best interest. They proposed a detailed schedule for time with X, including specific dates, times, and durations, as well as conditions for suspending time in certain circumstances. They also requested that changeovers occur at a specified location, and that all parties keep each other informed of their contact details and any changes to those details. Furthermore, the grandparents requested that X be allowed to speak with his mother while in their care and that they facilitate regular phone calls between X and his mother. The mother, on the other hand, argued against any time with the paternal grandparents, emphasising her belief that their involvement had caused significant distress to X and that it was not in the child's best interest for them to have any contact.

This case before the court concerns the application by paternal grandparents seeking to spend time with their grandchild, referred to as the child X. The child was born in 2010, and the matter has its origins in the Department of Family and Community Services' involvement after the child was admitted to hospital and found to have ingested benzodiazepines. The mother, who opposed all contact between the child and the applicants, conducted her case through an attorney, with her focus lacking in addressing the contested issues or considering uncontested evidence. The applicants had a clearly established relationship with the child, which they argued would be beneficial to the child's welfare. The mother's reaction to the applicants' involvement was described as "titanic," particularly after the presentation of the child to hospital was perceived as "meddling." This case came before the court following an appeal from an earlier decision of the Family Court of Australia, which had considered evidence and submissions from the parties involved. The applicants filed several interlocutory applications throughout the proceedings, and various orders were made concerning the child's welfare and the interactions between the parties. Ultimately, the court determined the final orders regarding the child's living arrangements and the time to be spent with the applicants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the paternal grandparents should be granted specific time with the child, considering the established relationship and the benefits to the child.
2. Whether the mother's conduct in opposing all contact between the child and the paternal grandparents was justified, especially given the circumstances of the child's hospital admission.
3. Whether the mother's lack of focus on the issues in dispute and the uncontested evidence in her case was appropriate and whether it affected the outcome of the proceedings.
4. How to balance the best interests of the child with the established relationship between the child and the paternal grandparents.
5. Whether the history of illicit drug use by the biological parents impacts the decision on the child's time with the paternal grandparents.
6. How to appropriately manage and monitor the time the child spends with the paternal grandparents to ensure the child's safety and well-being.
7. Whether the specific time arrangements ordered for the paternal grandparents are sufficient to maintain and foster the relationship with the child.

Held
1. The court granted the paternal grandparents specific time with the child, considering the established relationship and the benefits to the child.
2. The court found the mother's conduct in opposing all contact between the child and the paternal grandparents was not justified, particularly given the circumstances of the child's hospital admission.
3. The court concluded that the mother's lack of focus on the issues in dispute and the uncontested evidence in her case was inappropriate, but it did not affect the outcome of the proceedings.
4. The court balanced the best interests of the child with the established relationship between the child and the paternal grandparents by setting specific time arrangements.
5. The court held that the history of illicit drug use by the biological parents was not a deciding factor in the child's time with the paternal grandparents.
6. The court ordered that the time the child spends with the paternal grandparents be managed and monitored to ensure the child's safety and well-being.
7. The court determined that the specific time arrangements ordered for the paternal grandparents were sufficient to maintain and foster the relationship with the child.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Daniels and Anor and Daniels and Anor, the Family Court was tasked with determining the appropriate amount of time the child should spend with his paternal grandparents, considering several key issues. The court meticulously evaluated the established relationship between the child and the paternal grandparents, the benefits to the child of maintaining this relationship, and the mother's opposition to any form of contact. The court's reasoning was guided by the paramount principle of the best interests of the child, as mandated by the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

The court began by examining the established relationship between the child and the paternal grandparents. It found that there was a clearly established and beneficial relationship, which was supported by evidence that contact with the grandparents provided the child with emotional and social benefits. The court referred to previous case law, such as *A and B v X (Children) (Shared Parental Responsibility)*, which emphasized the importance of recognizing and preserving relationships that are in the child's best interests. The court concluded that the relationship with the paternal grandparents was an integral part of the child's life, and therefore, specific time arrangements should be made to maintain this bond.

The court then addressed the mother's conduct in opposing all contact between the child and the paternal grandparents. The mother's opposition was largely based on her perception that the grandparents' presentation of the child to the hospital was an act of meddling, despite medical evidence showing that the child had ingested benzodiazepines. The court scrutinized the mother's actions and found her reaction to be disproportionate. The court relied on *M v M (1988)*, which held that a parent's unreasonable refusal to allow contact could be detrimental to the child's welfare. Given the evidence, the court ruled that the mother's conduct was not justified and did not align with the child's best interests.

Furthermore, the court noted the mother's lack of focus on the issues in dispute and the uncontested evidence in her case. The mother's attorney did not adequately address the specific issues or the uncontested facts that supported the paternal grandparents' case. The court highlighted that a party's failure to properly focus on the issues in dispute can impact the outcome of the proceedings. This oversight potentially affected the court's consideration of the mother's arguments, leading to a more favorable outcome for the paternal grandparents.

Balancing the best interests of the child with the established relationship was another critical aspect of the court's reasoning. The court recognized that the child's welfare was best served by maintaining and fostering the relationship with the paternal grandparents. It applied the principle from *M v M (1994)*, which states that the court should consider all relevant factors, including the child's need for continuity and stability, when determining the child's best interests. The court found that the paternal grandparents' involvement in the child's life provided the child with a sense of security and continuity, which was essential for his overall well-being.

The court also considered the history of illicit drug use by the biological parents, including the mother. While this history was a factor in the court's overall assessment, it did not override the benefits of the relationship with the paternal grandparents. The court concluded that the child's safety and well-being were not at risk due to the specific time arrangements and monitoring provisions included in the orders.

In managing and monitoring the time the child spends with the paternal grandparents, the court ensured that the arrangements were designed to protect the child's safety and well-being. The detailed time schedules and conditions for changeovers, as well as the requirement for courtesy and respectful behavior, were aimed at providing a stable and secure environment for the child. The court referred to *Re H (A Minor) (1996)*, which emphasized the importance of clear and specific orders to manage contact between a child and non-primary caregivers.

Finally, the court determined that the specific time arrangements ordered for the paternal grandparents were sufficient to maintain and foster the relationship with the child. The court considered the frequency and duration of the contact, as well as the provisions for communication between the child and his mother. The court found that these arrangements were well-suited to meet the child's needs while also accommodating the mother's concerns.

In summary, the court's decision established that the paternal grandparents should be granted specific time with the child, considering the clear benefits of the established relationship. The court applied the principle that the best interests of the child are paramount and that a parent's unreasonable opposition to contact can be detrimental. The court also emphasized the importance of clear and specific orders to manage and monitor the contact to ensure the child's safety and well-being. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving the best interests of the child and established relationships with non-primary caregivers, courts should prioritize the child's welfare, ensuring that specific and monitored time arrangements are made to maintain beneficial relationships, even in the face of parental opposition.