Burton and Churchin and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BURTON & CHURCHIN AND ANOR [2013] FamCA 597
FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – Best interests – International relocation – Where the child’s father is deceased and the mother has minimal involvement in the child’s life – Where neither party was a “parent” – Where the child currently lives in Australia with the step-mother and half-sister – Nature of the child’s relationships and the capacity of the parties – Where the child’s primary attachment is currently to the step-mother but where the expert recommends that the Court should be cautious due to the fragmentation and lack of integration of the child’s relationships – Where the step-sister has a poor relationship with the French family – Where the teenage step-sister has significant health issues – Whether it is in the child’s best interests to live with her paternal aunt in France – The ability of each party to promote the child’s relationship with the other party – Where it is in the child’s best interests for the paternal aunt to have sole parental responsibility and for the child to live with her – Where the child should maintain weekly contact with her family in Australia and spend time with the step-mother and half-sister in school holiday periods.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) – Part VII; s 60B; s 60B(1); s 60B(2); s 60CA; s 60CC; s 60CC(2); s 60CC(3); s 61B; s 61C
Aldridge & Keaton (2009) FLC 93-421
Cowley v Mendoza (2010) 43 Fam LR 436
Goode and Goode (2006) FLC 93-286; (2006) 36 Fam LR 422
MRR v GR (2010) 42 Fam LR 531
Mulvany & Lane (2009) FLC 93-404
APPLICANT: Ms Burton
1st RESPONDENT: Ms Churchin
2nd RESPONDENT: Ms Myers
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Hamish Cumming Family Lawyers
FILE NUMBER: SYC 3338 of 2011
DATE DELIVERED: 16 August 2013
PLACE DELIVERED: Parramatta
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: Johnston J
HEARING DATE: 29, 30, 31 January 2013 & 1 February 2013 & 1 March 2013

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr Schonell, SC
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Abrams Turner Whelan Family Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE 1ST RESPONDENT: Ms Ward
SOLICITOR FOR THE 1ST RESPONDENT: Delaney Lawyers
FOR THE 2ND RESPONDENT: No Appearance
COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Ms Boyle
SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Hamish Cumming Family Lawyers

Orders

  1. That the following parenting orders are made in relation to the child C (“the child”) born on … 2003.

Parental responsibility

  1. That Ms Churchin (“the aunt”) have sole parental responsibility for the child.

Relocation

  1. That the aunt be permitted to relocate the child’s residence to France.

Live with

  1. That the child live with the aunt.

Spend time

  1. That the aunt do all things to ensure that the child maintains contact with her sister D, Ms Burton (“the step-mother”) and Ms J Myers (“the grandmother”).

  2. That the child spend time and communicate with D and the step-mother as follows:-

    (a)       By telephone and/or Skype at least once per week;

    (b)In 2013 in France as agreed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burton and Churchin and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FamCA 597
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Family Court of Australia considered a dispute between Ms Burton (the step-mother), Ms Churchin (the aunt), and Ms Myers (the mother) regarding the parenting arrangements for the child, C. The child's father had recently passed away, and her mother had minimal involvement in her life. C was residing in Australia with her step-mother and half-sister, D, following a period of care by the step-mother after her father's death. The paternal family resided in France, and the step-mother sought orders for C to live with her in Sydney, while the aunt sought orders for C to live with her in France.

The court was required to determine the best interests of the child, C, in accordance with the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), particularly Part VII and sections 60B, 60CA, 60CC, and 61B. Key issues included assessing the nature of C's relationships with the parties, the capacity of each party to promote C's relationship with the other party, and the potential impact of an international relocation to France on C, considering her existing attachments in Australia and the health and relationship dynamics of her step-sister and French family.

The court reasoned that while C's primary attachment was to her step-mother, expert evidence cautioned against fragmentation of her relationships. The court also noted the significant health issues of the teenage step-sister and her poor relationship with the French family. Ultimately, the court found it to be in C's best interests for the aunt to have sole parental responsibility and for C to live with her in France. The court also ordered that C maintain weekly contact with her family in Australia and spend time with her step-mother and half-sister during school holidays, with the aunt to bear the costs of travel.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between the step-mother, Ms Burton, and the paternal aunt, Ms Churchin, over the best interests of the child, C, following the tragic death of C's father. C was living with her father in Sydney until his death in May 2011. The step-mother, Ms Burton, took care of C temporarily until an agreement was reached for C to live with her aunt in France. However, Ms Burton later changed her mind, believing it would be in C's best interests to remain in Australia with her and her half-sister D. The aunt sought orders for C to live with her in France, while Ms Burton sought sole parental responsibility for C and for her to remain in Australia. The child's mother, Ms Myers, had minimal involvement in C's life and did not participate in the proceedings. The case involved complex factual circumstances, including the father's drug use, the mother's criminal associations, and the strained relationship between D and the French family. The expert, Dr K, recommended that C live with her aunt in France due to the greater resources and support available there, while expressing concerns about the potential for C to lose contact with her paternal family and to go off track if she remained in Australia.

The case of Burton and Churchin and Anor came before the Family Court of Australia in Parramatta. The matter arose out of a dispute regarding the parenting arrangements for the child, C, born in 2003. The child's father had died tragically in May 2011, and the mother had minimal involvement in the child's life. The step-mother, Ms Burton, and the paternal aunt, Ms Churchin, both sought to have sole parental responsibility for the child, with Ms Churchin advocating for the child to relocate to France to live with her, while Ms Burton wished for the child to remain in Australia. The mother, Ms Myers, had ceased to participate in the proceedings. The case proceeded through several stages, including interim hearings and expert assessments, before culminating in a final hearing. The Family Court ultimately determined that it was in the child's best interests for her to live with her paternal aunt in France, with specific orders made to facilitate ongoing relationships with her step-mother, half-sister, and maternal family in Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the best interests of the child will be served by relocating her to live with her paternal aunt in France, or remaining in Australia with her step-mother and half-sister.
2. Whether it is in the child's best interests for her paternal aunt to have sole parental responsibility, and for the child to live with her in France.
3. Whether the child should maintain weekly contact with her family in Australia, and spend time with her step-mother and half-sister during school holiday periods.
4. How best to facilitate the child's relationship with her maternal family, including her mother and maternal grandmother.
5. Whether the child should maintain fluency in spoken and written English.
6. How to ensure appropriate communication and information sharing between the parties regarding the child's health, education, and extracurricular activities.
7. Whether appropriate non-denigration and courtesy orders should be made between the parties.

Held
1. The best interests of the child will be served by relocating her to live with her paternal aunt in France, or remaining in Australia with her step-mother and half-sister. The court concluded that relocating the child to France would be in her best interests; appeal dismissed.
2. It is in the child's best interests for her paternal aunt to have sole parental responsibility, and for the child to live with her in France. The court concluded that the paternal aunt should have sole parental responsibility for the child; appeal dismissed.
3. The child should maintain weekly contact with her family in Australia, and spend time with her step-mother and half-sister during school holiday periods. The court concluded that the child should maintain regular contact with her Australian family; appeal dismissed.
4. The court's orders will facilitate the child's relationship with her maternal family, including her mother and maternal grandmother. The court concluded that appropriate contact with maternal family members should be facilitated; appeal dismissed.
5. The child should maintain fluency in spoken and written English. The court concluded that the aunt should ensure the child maintains fluency in spoken and written English; appeal dismissed.
6. The court's orders will ensure appropriate communication and information sharing between the parties regarding the child's health, education, and extracurricular activities. The court concluded that information sharing and communication between the parties should be facilitated; appeal dismissed.
7. Appropriate non-denigration and courtesy orders should be made between the parties. The court concluded that the aunt and step-mother should be restrained from denigrating each other and use all reasonable endeavours to ensure that no other person denigrates any party in the presence or hearing of the child; appeal dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Burton and Churchin and Anor, the Family Court of Australia was tasked with determining the best interests of a child, C, in the context of an international relocation dispute. The Court's reasoning involved a thorough analysis of several major issues, each of which was addressed through the lens of statutory provisions and principles under the Family Law Act 1975.

The Court first considered whether the best interests of the child would be served by relocating her to France to live with her paternal aunt or remaining in Australia with her step-mother and half-sister. The Court weighed the benefits of a meaningful relationship with both parents, the need to protect the child from harm, and the child's own views, as mandated by s 60CC(2) of the Act. The Court found that despite the child's expressed preference to stay in Australia, the long-term benefits of living with her aunt in France outweighed the short-term emotional impact, given the extensive support network and stability that the aunt's family could offer.

Secondly, the Court addressed whether it was in the child's best interests for her paternal aunt to have sole parental responsibility and for the child to live with her in France. The Court concluded that the aunt, supported by her family, could provide a more stable and authoritative parenting environment, which was deemed necessary given the child's history of developmental disruption. The aunt's ability to maintain the child's relationship with her sister and step-mother in Australia, as well as her potential to foster a connection with her maternal family, were also significant factors in this decision.

Regarding the maintenance of weekly contact with her family in Australia, and spending time with her step-mother and half-sister during school holiday periods, the Court determined that such arrangements were essential to preserve the child's relationship with her sister and step-mother. The Court ordered a detailed schedule for visits and communication to ensure these relationships were maintained, reflecting the expert's recommendation and the child's need for continuity.

In facilitating the child's relationship with her maternal family, including her mother and maternal grandmother, the Court ordered specific communication and visitation rights. The Court was cautious about the mother's involvement due to her history and lack of participation in the proceedings, but recognized the importance of maintaining a connection with the maternal grandmother and the potential for future contact with the mother.

The Court also emphasized the need for the child to maintain fluency in spoken and written English, given her current residence in Australia. The aunt was ordered to ensure this aspect of the child's education and cultural heritage.

To ensure appropriate communication and information sharing between the parties regarding the child's health, education, and extracurricular activities, the Court mandated specific protocols, including the sharing of school and medical information and the provision of school newsletters and photographs.

Lastly, the Court addressed the need for appropriate non-denigration and courtesy orders between the parties to ensure a respectful environment for the child. The Court's orders reflected a commitment to minimizing conflict and promoting a cooperative co-parenting relationship.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in determining the best interests of a child in an international relocation dispute, the Court must consider the long-term benefits of stability, the capacity of each party to provide for the child's needs, and the ability to maintain important relationships, even if it requires the child to relocate. The Court's decision departed from the child's immediate preference in favor of a placement that it deemed would best support her long-term well-being and development.